I consider myself a pizza connoisseur (like every New Yorker :-) and I think Nick's delivers on taste and crust that is different than the typical NYC pizzas. It is my go to when I want something a little different. read more

I normally eat here for dinner. I really love this place because everything I've had is good. The pizzas are awesome. Specifically, I love the MVP pizza. I love the vongole. I tried the wings, which were special tonight, and I love the wine. You can't go wrong, really, at Nick's. Everything is good. I've recently started eating here for lunch, and I just saw that brunch is on offer, so that's my next thing. I have taken everyone here: clients, my mom, friends. They have a private room, which is great if you want to host a special lunch, birthday or baby shower. It looks like it could seat 30 to 50 people or something, so if I have a special occasion, this will be my go-to. The service is great, the food is awesome, and it's a really nice ambience. It really works for basically every occasion. Five stars all around. read more

Had another great pizza dinner at Nick's. This time we had a big group and tried the hot honey pizza and prosciutto and arugula pizza alongside our standard margarita pizza. All were delicious and service was great and friendly as usual! read more

Went there to celebrate my Mother-in-Law's birthday with dear husband. She loves Italian food. Her and her extended family including my family have gone there for years. We were always satisfied with there delicious family size portions. They updated the place since than. The food is still as good as I remembered it. Some things have changed for the better. The layout is more open with a grand bar. We are always greated by a welcoming staff member, some new with some familiar faces. If you want a nice intimate Italian restaurant to celebrate any occasion this is the place to be. read more

See all

We attended a bridal shower here with a large group of people. The service was very attentive. The pizza and the salad were both delicious but the chicken parm and meatballs were both dry and a bit cold. I understand that they we're trying to feed about 75 people so I'll still give them 4,stars for the good parts read more

We ordered take out from Nick's during lunch and ordered the Chicken parm on ciabatta and the Nonna's fried eggplant also on a ciabatta. The take out was quick and our order was packed and ready to go when we arrived (earlier than the time that was estimated). When selecting either sandwich, I would definitely get the Chicken parm again. It had a good tomato sauce and melted cheese. However, the Nonna's fried eggplant really was not up to me expectations. While the eggplant was good, it was only two thin slices, with roasted peppers and cheese. The Mozzarella was not even melted. The eggplant slices was warm but the other toppings made the sandwich cold. Additionally, I had higher expectations for ciabatta bread. I thought it would be crispy and warm, however it was a very soft, hero like bread. And there was no sauce whatsoever, so it was also very dry. Overall, enjoyed the chicken parm but would definitely skip the Nonna's fried eggplant sandwich. Perhaps get the Nonna's fried eggplant with tomato sauce, which is a better taste. read more

See all

Nicks! One of my fav Italian spots to order from! I've had it delivered and dined in. Always good! read more

See all

Will say this was the best pizza and salad combo I've had in a while. The crust was crispy but the pizza it self just captured all the best elements of a good Italian pizza; sauce cheese and bread. As usual, I asked them for Italian chili oil (a must have for any Italian pizza spot) and it wasn't too spicy but definitely had a kick. Caesar salad was creamy and the croutons were seasoned with a little bit of a kick to it. The entire restaurant took me to Italy with the woodfire ovens, lemon decor and cozy atmosphere and definitely the place I recommend if you're on the UES looking for a semi-casual bite. Our wait staff was generous and incredibly speedy as well which helped greatly. read more

See all

Love the dough- typical thin slice brick oven. Haven't had anything other than the pizza. May be hit and miss at times. Have had a few times where it's just lacking sauce and the pie seems closer to dried out. Vodka and standard both do this place justice when they make it properly. read more

Great Yorkville neighborhood restaurant for Italian food. The staff was very friendly and the food came out quickly. I really enjoyed the margherita pizza and the penne vodka pasta. They have reservations on Resy but you can also walk in but might expect a small wait. I'll be back! read more

Made a reservation for a Monday night after I saw a pic on Instagram of their chicken franchese and wanted to try it. The redecoration along with the Christmas decorations were nice. There were about 3 other tables seated when we arrived at 7pm. The menu had a variety of pizza salads and classic Italian dishes. All of the portions were large. I liked that they had single and family style options. The chicken in every dish was so tender and thin; it was delicious. Most entrees were $20-$30. I didn't like how the way charged an additional $5 for pasta. For dessert, we had the brownie sundae with ice cream (which was extra)! Definitely skip this. The brownie was terrible, overcooked. Another table got the cannoli and the tiramisu which looked delicious but also pricey at $14 each. I would return and definitely split the family style. It would be a great deal between 2 people. I'd like to try their pizza next time! read more

See all

This place is delicious and has fast friendly service. We ordered. Got the pizza in 7ish minutes. Excellent

Ordered chicken Parm hero. The chicken parm itself was pretty good, but the bread was a terrible choice. Lots of flour on the outside and not toasted. The lasagna was good, just a bit on the salty side. I would not get the chicken parm hero again, unless they changed the bread. read more

Nick's Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Pizzas are amazing always willing to put extra sauce on if you ask. Service is also top tier

Was not expecting the food to be as good as it was. Pizza was very good and the pastas and parms (eggplant and chicken) were excellent. Good, friendly service too. Not cheap, but recommended. read more

So...This one's a tricky case. Get a pizza with just one topping? Absolute win -- fantastic pizza, solid value, I'd fight for that slice. But add anything else, and suddenly you're entering the realm of disappointment. The eggplant Parmesan? Flat. Flat as a pancake. Tiny portion for the $20 you drop like it's golden ticket to flavor town -- spoiler: it's not. Ordered a salad with shrimp... no shrimp. Just wilted greens sulking in their bowl like they gave up on life. Management told me they'd give me a refund, three days later, no refund. Honestly, this place is solid for pizza. Everything else? Treat it as optional background noise. Go for the pizza, savor it, and ignore the rest -- unless you enjoy paying $20 to be mildly let down.It's read more

Still can't just order a slice here but it's a nice sit down experience to enjoy a full pie with friends. Or, by yourself if you're really hungry! Any size pizza can be a personal pizza if you have the will! read more

See all

AMAZING - ordered takeout the other Friday night and it arrived in exactly 20 minutes. The pizza was delicious, will definitely try again read more

Nick's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

What happen to the quality of food? Ordered take out and was not anything like expected. Not to mention always included rolls, this time no rolls. read more

I came here with a party of 4 on a Monday. It's wasn't very busy but we were seated immediately. I ordered the chicken francese. The chicken was very thin and tender. I ordered it with pasta. The dish overall was very good. Someone else got the bolognese which was very tasty but salty. We finished the meal with the brownie and ice cream (ice cream was $2/scoop extra). The brownie was warmed but overcooked and dry. Do not get the brownie dessert. The service was quick and allowed us to sit and talk which was nice. During the winter everytime the door would open it would get a bit chilly inside. Overall I enjoyed the meal and would return to try other dishes. read more

Nick's Pizza - F Chicken Francese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Very good NY style pizza for the UES. The space seems newly renovated as well. I shared the spicy soppresseta with hot honey pizza and it was very solid. A little soggy but crust and flavors were still excellent. We also shared the fried calamari which had a great batter and the red sauce to dip was superb. The brussel sprouts were just ok. read more

I can't speak to the pizza but I can attest to the honesty and integrity of the management. I erroneously ordered a large pizza with toppings at this location when I meant to order from the same name establishment in Forest Hills. Even though the pie was already made, I was credited the amount immediately without a discussion. Class act. I will be going there very soon to eat in person. read more

I had dinner at Nick's last night with two friends. The restaurant was warm and inviting with a great ambiance. We started off with a round of drinks (the Second Avenue spritz was light and refreshing), followed by an unreal vodka pizza, harvest salad (light yet filling), local burrata with honey (delish), chicken Francese and then finished off the meal with some homemade tiramisu! The service was excellent and the food delicious with generous portions. I will definitely be coming back! read more

So happy we discovered this neighborhood gem! Ambiance: - Went on a Friday night around 8:30pm and it was not busy at all. Maybe 15 people, so we were sat right away. - They have indoor and outdoor seating. Service: - Fast and friendly! Food: - Calamari (3/5) - just okay. Portion was enough for two, but flavor was bland. Not bad but did not standout. - Salad (4/5) - Salad was good, but felt a bit warm/ soggy. It was a hot day, but salad could have still come out a bit more fresh. - Pizza (5/5) - Honestly really good. Will definitely come back for the pizza. read more

Nick's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great Woodford Old Fashioneds. The MVP pizza was very good. Great ambiance. Amazing service. Tom behind the bar is personable and great service! Stop by for local experience but with great cocktails. read more

Nick's Pizza - Great Woodford Old Fashion - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Really loved this spot. The sausage and broccoli rabe pasta was so good. I think the renovation will be well worth it. read more

Nick's Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here for anniversary dinner. Been wanting to check out this place for a while. The food was sooooo yummy and service was quick. No complaints on anything we ate. Portion sizes were pretty large for NYC standards. read more

See all

I came here with some coworkers after work for an early dinner. The interior had a classic old style to it with wood furnishings. We ordered a few dishes and shared them. We ended up getting the Fried Calamari, Pepperoni Pizza, Shrimp Asparagus Pasta, and Caesar Salad. I loved the Calamari, which was perfectly crispy and light, with tasty seasoning. The pizza was also quite yummy, with melty cheese, plenty of fresh, juicy pepperoni, as well as basil. Pasta was cooked al dente with a decent amount of tender shrimp, but I wasn't a huge fan of the asparagus and it was lacking flavorful sauce. Caesar salad had a ton of Parmesan shavings, croutons and powdered cheese, but I'm not really into this type of salad. Service was pretty good. I'm not sure I would return because the food was just okay. read more

See all

I really loved this place! The wood-fired pizza was excellent, and I loved that you can order family-style or individual portions of all the entrees. The staff was really friendly, the atmosphere was great, and everything just felt easy and welcoming. The owner even walked around and talked to each table - he is the next generation of this family run spot since 2002. All around a place that I will definitely come back to! read more

We arrived a little before 6:00PM last night without a reservation. The guy came to us immediately & told us "Let me check it" with a big smile. Then he came back to us in a second & gave us a table. His warm attitude was good enough for us to feel comfortable, already. We ordered a Mediterranean salad, meatball spaghetti & seafood linguine. We especially loved their seafood linguine because its taste was perfect for us. They used a good amount of garlic & all the seafood in it was full of flavor. Everything was generously portioned & satisfying, too. Of course, the service was nice as well. Since it was a Friday night, the place was packed & bustling, which was pretty good but next time we'd like to come back to enjoy lunch during the daytime hours. So happy to find a cozy spot with great food on the UES, finally. Thank you! read more

Service is great, food is good, atmosphere ia great. Very child friendly. Love the decor. Great addition to the neighborhood.

I hosted a private lunchtime event at Nick's, and everything was fantastic ! From start to finish, the experience was seamless. The managers and staff were incredibly kind, accommodating, and easy to work with. The food was absolutely delicious and timed perfectly for such a large gathering. Our guests couldn't stop raving. If you're looking for a warm, authentic Italian spot on the UES--whether for a great italian meal, fantastic brick-oven pizza, or a perfect private room for an event--I can't recommend Nick's enough! read more

The brunch at Nick's restaurant was delicious. We really enjoyed all of our main courses- Nova Pie, Eggs in Purgatory, Countryside Eggs, and the Pancakes. We loved our Bellini and Martini Blanc drinks. We finished with the Bambino Doughnuts which were delicious and perfectly portioned. The restaurant staff were outstanding and we will definitely be back. Thank you to Nick's for delivering on their excellent new brunch menu and service. read more

Great pizza, really nice ambiance. The pizza was the highlight on the menu. Our server was nice as well read more

Nick's Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food is fresh and delicious, with nice portions and attentive service. An Upper East Side gem! read more

Nick's Pizza - Fettuccine shrimp primavera and a glass of happy hour house white wine at the bar - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Great neighborhood Family owned traditional Italialian restaurant on the upper east side. just renovated with the addition of a nice bar for dining . read more

See all

Very good pasta, pizza and salads. First and only place I've seen with option for pasta "al dente" in online order form which is fantastic. Quick delivery. Underrated on this app read more

Woke up Sunday morning with a craving for pancakes. Never thought Nick's Pizza, known of course for their great lunch and dinner menu, would have the most delicious pancakes I've ever had. They recently added a brunch menu. Sharing the good news with my Upper East Side neighbors. I'm so happy my husband and I decided to try them for pancakes! read more

It's been a few years since I've eaten here, I live out of town. Came back and they have remodeled, looks great. Now for the good news, the pizza is just as delicious as previously. If you haven't tried eating here I highly recommend you should give it a try. I had a pepperoni well done and it was perfect. Ate the whole pie myself! read more

Nick's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Solid place. It's a step above a typical pizzeria, but below the typical UES Italian restaurant experience. The staff were earnest. Salads were OK. Pizza was good, Neapolitan style. If you want pizza in a more civilized environment, this is a good call. read more

Nick's Pizza - Leaning tower of pizza. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York