So may years of coming here and still very tasty. Here's what worked. We had filet of sole oreganata. That was really fresh and tasty and came with a few lemon potatoes. This I could eat often. The pasta limone is also a favorite. Here's the few dishes that were not my style. The Caesar salad had Dijon mustard mixed into the dressing which made it a tad spicier than it should be and changed the flavor. I won't order it again with that dressings. Dijon is better as a French vinegarette. Also... the tiramisu is fabulous! read more

See all

Cozy spot for great Italian classics - intimate for smaller parties but also able to accommodate for larger parties in the back space. Menu is varied with daily specials, but you can get classic dishes too. The Cacio e Pepe was a bit more funkier than other pastas I've had, and the Limone was also sweeter than expected. Note cash only! read more

Supper - Spaghetti Cacio e Pepe - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food was amazing! I had the lemon spaghetti and I wasn't expecting to love it. The service was good, the food was brought in a timely manner, and drinks were always kept up with. We sat at the bar and got to watch the food being prepared, that was entertaining. The place is very small but cute in the decor. read more

Supper - lemon pasta dish - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Wow. This place is incredible. At midnight after quite some drinks this felt like a Michelin star. Pretty expensive but fuck it I'll come back. Open kitchen concept rlly added to the experience and the staff/ service was on point. Sorry for the lack of pics but here's the food after we CLEANED the plates. ENTREES: lemon pasta, lamb bolognese, and chicken parm. Chicken parm stole the show for me, I'll be thinking about it for a while, the cheese was on point and the spaghetti w it was pretty standard but a nice touch. The lemon pasta was good but you have to add pile of Parmesan on top. The Parmesan was so fresh. I think I'd have liked the lemon pasta more if I'd gotten more light n lemony things with it but I was eating it with a side of heart burn n acid reflux so it didn't quite fit in. Lamb bolognese was also delicious. APPETIZERS: burrata and tomato so damn fresh and the basil rlly added to the experience. The bread with the beans- at first I was suspicious but when I realized the beans were spicy it was over. I don't know why I enjoyed this so much. Octopus was pretty chewy, I liked it but didn't love it. read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had 11 am brunch reservation, no wait, no problem. Most New Yorkers don't brunch this early which was in our favor. We sat outside. Was not rushed. Food was fabulous. Tasty and delish. Dessert and house made wine was spot on amazing! Service was prompt, polite and attentive. Would highly recommend! Secretly we went to check out the place as our daughter and her fiancé wanted to do their rehearsal dinner here. All I can say is yes! Yes! And oh yeah yes! See you in December with 25 peeps! Can't wait! read more

Great food, great service, tiny space- even for manhattan. Definitely worth a go. FYI they are a cash only business.

Amazing food - horrible experience. Let's start with a good because I genuinely think that this restaurant is very good and everything we had was delicious. My seafood risotto was absolutely divine and I legitimately have zero complaints. The Caesar salad is basic, but good and everyone else enjoyed their mains such as the chicken Parm and other pastas. Now let me explain the bad. We were placed in a back room, at a long table with a random party of probably about 10 younger adults who had a speaker with them and spent the entire dinner, blasting music and screaming completely ruining our experience. I have no idea why we were placed at this table in this back room with them, but it couldn't have been worse. Not only did this ruin the experience, but because we were in the back room we were left by our waiter to the point where we had to get up and go up to the host and multiple times to ask where our waiter was for our food, water and drinks. The ambience of the rest of the restaurant seems lovely and I genuinely think this would've been a four or five star review had our experience not been the way it was as the food was great and the restaurant itself seems very nice. I will definitely come back to supper to try it again as long as we're not put in a back room again. read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I went on a Saturday, specifically for the osso buco special. It didn't disappoint. The portion was generous, something that easily could be divided between two people. The sauce is rich and flavorful and it complimented the risotto Milanese perfectly. It was a LITTLE less tender than I'd like, for that I took off a star. Most of the veal was tender but there were some more rough bites. I also had the burrata salad which was huge and again something that easily could be divided between two people. The complimentary bread with olive oil and beans dipping sauce were awesome. Service was efficient and accommodating. This is a great date night or group gathering spot. It's ok for solo diners too of course but just know that you will be eating only half of what you're being served, maybe more than that! read more

Supper - Burrata Salad - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Staff was amazing - really nice and made our experience great. Pasta was good! (Don't get the steak though). read more

Supper - Homemade Iced Tea and the best waiters! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I used to live above this place which almost became a flex because it had such a good reputation. I've eaten there numerous times. It's super solid Italian. While I don't think it's the best in the city by any means, it makes more a wonderful dinner with friends or a good date spot. read more

Had dinner on Saturday night and we all loved it! We had a perfect meal from start to finish. Service and food quality was top notch. The chopped kale salad (the most simple but perfect starter) and pasta limone are perfection. read more

Came here for a get together with my wife and daughter recently. I was told the restaurant had been around for many years with a consistent menu. I found the overall experience to be mediocre at best. The pasta dishes we had were very expensive for what they were. We ordered a prosciutto and fruit dish as a starter. It was extremely basic, small, and cheese looked like deli cheese from a slicer. We had a panna cotta dessert that we shared which was OK. The waiter was very nice but really underdressed and didn't give me clean vibes. On top of this, they only take cash. Sorry but I think you can get a much better quality of food and a better experience for your money elsewhere. read more

My friend put me on to Supper when I was asking where a good Italian spot was in the city. He gave me the heads up that it's cash only (thankfully!) and I went solo. Upon arrival, it gave a homey vibe that I often see in Italian spots. I sat at the bar to watch the chefs cook each meal. The blood orange margarita was ok being too sweet for me. I was given bread with a bean/olive oil dip and it was unique and tasty. A very yummy roasted garlic taste. My chicken parm with a side a sautéed kale was really good as well. The chicken parm was cooked well and came out nice and warm. The spaghetti was pretty good. I wish there was a sprinkle of basil on the cheese to deepen the flavor profile. The sautéed kale was really good; perfectly salted with yummy garlic shavings. The entree portion was big enough to share. I took the tiramisu to go and it's really good! Price-wise, it's expensive but I'll pay for good food and experience anytime. read more

See all

This is an interesting place. Super cramped, impossible to walk in without bumping people in their seats, but it's actually a very pleasant and cozy atmosphere if you get sat at the right table. Wasn't a fan of the lychee martini (too sweet, needs more acidity) or the kale salad (no clue why there were jalapeños on top), but the spaghetti al limone and the salmon were both very, very good. Cash only but there's an ATM inside. Overall really enjoyed, think this is a great local spot read more

See all

Cash only spot. It took way too long for the food to come out-- luckily the complimentary bread and dip was bomb. Otherwise, we ordered the seafood risotto and their signature pasta with added sausage. Food was painfully mid, like it bums me out that I paid that much for it. It was bland... We got their Priest pasta, apparently their signature dish, but nothing about it felt special. read more

Truly do not understand how this place only has 3.9 stars? The food, the service and the atmosphere were all impeccable. We shared the risotto of the day (pear Gorgonzola), spaghetti pomodoro and basil, and the cacio e Pepe. 10/10 for all three dishes. The tiramisu was also one of the best I've had. I will definitely be coming back! read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came for a last minute brunch awhile ago and forgot to post. The beans and bread is unique but not my fave. Reasonably priced but missing the flavors I would like. read more

See all

This has been on my list to try. I'm not sure what took so long. It is cash only! There is an ATM at the premise. We really liked the starter! I've only had bread with either olive oil, butter and/or balsamic vinegar. This was so good. The cannellini beans were perfectly soft and tasted like they were soaked in garlic. We shared the meatballs, which were so soft and tiny. The chicken parm was a classic and the fish was interesting. The tiramisu was good too! Overall, great vibes! Good food with great portions! Come for the cannellini beans. read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've been coming here for many years for both brunch and dinner and it never disappoints! Great ambience and service; limited but good wine list; excellent pasta (including white truffles when in season!); and I can never get enough of those free garlicky beans! Today they were one of the few restaurants that dared to stay open as we got 11+ inches of snow. I finally got to try the eggs alla parmigiana with eggplant added. Yum! Worth the 14-degree, snowy, windy walk. read more

Supper - Eggs alla parmigiana with eggplant added. Yum!! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This place! This spot changed my life when it comes to Italian food. The first time I tried years ago y got the lemon pasta. That is my go to and while I live in California it's a place I miss. We had a watermelon salad with balsamic (special) which was divine. As for cocktails, this is my favorite place to get an espresso martini. I'm not a huge espresso martini fan in general but here they just do it right. So it's my go to. This place is always packed. Make reservations , high energy and loud. Perfect place for a night out with friends. Service wavers. It's busy so it's understandable why it's not as attentive but they try. Overall- must try. Especially if you are like me who says "meh, I'm not big on Italian food" . This place will change your mind. read more

I was at Supper for a friend's birthday. We made a reservation for 7 people, and the check-in process was very seamless. As soon as we arrived, they showed us right to our table. The table was in the back of the restaurant in what looked like a wine tasting room. It was very cozy and perfect for groups and occasions. The room had a long communal table and its own bathroom. The waiter was very sweet and attentive. He was joking around with us and also gave us food and wine recommendations. The restaurant is known for its Spaghetti Al Limone and its Spaghetti Cacio e Pepe. I ordered the Spaghetti Al Limone, and it was excellent. It was creamy, and the lemon flavor brightened the dish. For wine, we ordered the Montepulciano and the Pinot Grigio. Both were great! The room we were in did get a little loud since it was small and had a bunch of people in it, but it didn't negatively affect our experience. Overall, I was very happy with this meal and would go back! read more

Supper - Spaghetti al Limone - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Love love this place for dinner. It's beautiful to sit outside and enjoy a nice plate of pasta or a perfectly cooked piece of salmon with a glass of wine. I came here for brunch with my brother when he was in town and were searching for something with good vegetarian options. I will say that the regular brunch menu is pretty meh, but their specials hit. We got a polenta cake that was grilled covered in a mushroom sauce with different types of cooked mushrooms - DELICIOUS. I can still feel the tastes and textures of the meal, and I am craving it again. It was hearty and almost meaty (?) for being a vegetarian meal. We also got the eggplant parmesan, which was good in the fact that they don't fry the eggplant, but it was insanely cheesy and a huge portion even between the two of us. Love the complimentary bread, butter, and oil they provide at the end. It is a little bit of a pain that it's cash only but they have an ATM on site to make things easier. read more

It pains me to downgrade my rating of Supper after so many years of loyalty. My husband and I have dined here every time we've visited NYC (2-3 times per year) since 2017. It was our favorite Frank Prisinzano restaurant, serving the best pasta al Limone we'd ever had. Sadly, the quality of food has recently declined. Our recent dinner was not bad, but the same dishes were a shadow of what they once were. The Spaghetti al Limone's buttery sauce lacked the bright acidity we had grown to love, and the Gnocchi Castelmagno was incredibly one note, even with the winter truffle supplement. The Shaved Fennel salad was fresh and nicely composed, albeit over salted. The complimentary bread with cannellini bean dip, wine selection, and service were wonderful as usual. But sadly, I believe this was our last visit to Supper. read more

See all

Great food at supper. Ambiance was cute and cozy. Wish they turned up the music a little. Took a bit for the food to come out but the waiter was really nice. Service was good. We were just really hungry after long travel day! I'd recommend. read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It exudes an authentic old-world charm. This establishment is cash-only. I visited on a busy Friday evening and, regrettably, was seated near the walkway to the bathroom entrance. This resulted in several inadvertent brushes with waitstaff and customers as they walked past my table. The ambiance was otherwise reminiscent of NYC in the Godfather's era, with framed depictions of 'The Last Supper'. The kale gnocchi was an absolute revelation--a blend of red sauce, kale, and cheese that I would highly recommend. The chicken parmigiana was also delicious and evidently a staple dish. While the desserts, including a sundae and chocolate cake, were delightful, they didn't overshadow the main courses. read more

See all

Absolutely loved my experience at Supper on 2nd Avenue! The **3 for $15 brunch deal** I is a total steal and such a fun way to try a variety of dishes. Exciting news--they're rolling out a new menu with more drink options and upgrading their specials list, which makes me even more eager to go back. The atmosphere, service, and food all hit the mark. Highly recommend--this place is a must go. Celebrity siting an added bonus ! read more

Came here with some friends and had a lovely time, however, not sure if I would return. The food was pretty tasty, however, I don't think the food is worth the price. One thing to note before coming here is that they are cash only. Normally, when places are cash only I feel like the prices are a bit cheaper, but Supper still had relatively high prices at about $28 per entree depending on what you order. Another reason why I think it wasn't the best experience is where we were seated. The restaurant was rather empty with most of the front available and some seating in the back of the restaurant opened. However, they seated me and my two friends in a tiny booth right next to the kitchen which made our environment rather hectic and squished. I got to try their version on garlic bread, some cheese appetizer, their take on bolognese and a dessert. My favorite dish of the night was the bolognese as it was one of the best I have tasted, but everything else was average. Overall, this wasn't one of those places I left feeling satisfied and would want to return to, but it wasn't bad. read more

Very nice service, cute restaurant with a cozy vibe. Great for a romantic date. I got the lemon spaghetti, which was good but I honestly think the food here is overpriced for what you're getting. Especially like $9 extra for something like sausage or $13 extra for cheese. I would come back but only for a specific event, I think there's other Italian restaurants that are just as good and more affordable. read more

Supper - Spaghetti al Limone - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Yes Yes Yes I recommend! I wanted to go to all of Frank Prisinzanos's restaurants in Manhattan and this was the last for me to get to. We were seated across from the kitchen and these were by far the BEST seats in the house. It was a tight squeeze for 4 of us in the booth but we felt like we were the luckiest to watch the hard working kitchen in action. It was so much fun to watch the pasta go into the pot and come out a short bit later onto plates with sauce or cheese added. Busy busy workers all hustling fast and all working so well together. The food was GREAT as we expected. Good, down home Italian food! I recommend reservations and it is cash only. read more

See all

A cute CASH ONLY Italian restaurant with a cute homey interior! We came by and ordered the Black Salt Caesar Salad, Spaghetti al Limone, and Priest Stranglers. The caesar salad was solid, but we didn't feel that the black salt added a ton to the dish. The Spaghetti al Limone was light and refreshing - almost dessert-y, not in a bad way. The Priest Stranglers had some interesting depth of flavour in the sauce, but while some of the pasta was a perfect al dente, some was a little undercooked. We went on a weekend but later at night. Service was a bit slow considering there were only about three other tables in the restaurant. Overall, while I might not make a trip just to come here, Supper is a solid spot to come for some pasta if you're in the area! read more

See all

Very NYC- tight seating, walk through the kitchen to the back rooms to your table. Ambiance is a bit seedy. Floor grimy. Tables so close the waiters butt was in our faces as he'd bend over to talk to the table next door- which was frequent. Food was fair. Salmon tasteless on a bed of spinach with a dolly of lentils on top. More lentils would have been nice. Specialty Lemon pasta was tasty. Not a place I'd return to with so many better options in NY. read more

I came here with the bf one weekday as I've had my eye on it for a while. First thing is that the ambience of this place is simply stunning. It has a bit of a rustic feel to it. Additionally the staff is kind and attentive. They have an option to open a bottle of wine and they charge you for the amount you drink. The starter bread was really good, like top 10 I've had, so we were excited for our main dishes. As for food, he chose the tagliatelle al ragu and I chose the lasagna. My lasagna was pretty good; however I and my bf felt that the tagliatelle felt like it was a bit underwhelming. Hoping this is a one off-time for the restaurant, and would like to give it a try sometime soon. Oh! Bring cash! They don't accept cards. read more

Supper - Outside seating - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing service and people that work here they really make you feel welcome and at home. Probably one of the best restaurants I've been to in terms of service. The pasta wasn't for me. Had a late night craving for pasta and only got one dish which was the kale gnocchi. I may give it a shot again regardless one not liking the dish at all and try the spaghetti limone solely due to the amazing service. read more

Supper - Kale Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Lemon spaghetti is great! Tiramisu is good! The complimentary beans and bread are a bit disappointing. (I didn't even take pictures of them.) The beans are very garlicky and there is way too much of it. And the bread is not even focaccia. Some kind of hard-crusted sour-doughy type of bread. Not the best. Overall, the bean + bread don't add much to the experience. I just peck on them out of guilt and sense of duty. I'd rather have nothing. They only take cash. (No credit card) read more

Raul and Gustavo was so amazing. Would come back just for him. The food and drink was also so good! Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!

Fantastic service, and food. Ordered the Pasta Bolognese, pasta al limon, burrata, bread, and the most amazing Tiramisu. The kitchen is always in view so you can watch the chefs hard work. The chefs are also very nice, and skilled at cooking. Also, the pasta's homemade! Otherwise, this place is a fantastic place for dinner, and I recommend it to anyone looking for a bite for some Italian. read more

Supper - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've now been to all three restaurants by Frank and truly I loved them all. Loves: + Delicious pasta and very much enjoyed priest stranglers ($27) and spaghetti al ragu bolognese ($27) + Cute ambiance + More spacious than Frank but less than Lil Frankie's + Daily specials Not so love: - Cash only (like the other two) - Not enough restrooms; if you're lucky they'll let yo sneak into the restroom for private parties - Saturday Special Risotto was hella cheesy and I love cheese Overall, this was a good dinner with good company. I can't wait to be back! :) read more

Supper - Tagliatelle al Ragu Bolognese (top left), The Timely Priest Stranglers Pasta (bottom left), and Risotto Milanese (center right) - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Food was outstanding and the service was excellent. There are also many specials that aren't shown on their posted menu

I've seen all the hype about this place so was curious to see if it would live up. For starters we got the stracchino, which was pretty good but way over priced. For my main dish I got the spaghetti al limone, which the waiter said they were known for. It was certainly unique and had a very good taste. However, the portions were not very big and I ended up leaving hungry. It seemed to me like the noodles weren't fresh either and a big rubbery. I'm not sure if they make their noodles in-house or out of a package after eating them. I will say that the outside seating area was quite nice and our server made frequent stops to our table throughout our meal. Would I come back? I'm not sure. read more

Supper - Spaghetti al Limone - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Got the bolognese pasta, was okay. Service wasn't good. Restaurant has potential. Also cash only is very inconvenient. Food is over priced, shouldn't have to pay more to get cash from ATM. Will not be back read more