If you looking for number one pie in the Keys, this will be the place. They have been the winner of Key Lime Pie for many year. I think the secret is the crush and sweetness of the key lime. The crush is tasty and crunchy. The key lime in fill is soft and sweet. They also has ice cream. Unfortunately they did not have the key lime pie on the stick. However they do have many flavor to choose from. It has sugar free and gluten free ice cream. Feel not so guilty on guiltless sweet. Other that ice cream, they are actually a bakery. You can order the cake or cup cake you like. I can see the island people celebrating their special occasion many from this store. They also have the room next door is larger enough for any party. Sweet treat include brownies, milkshake, float and more. read more

See all

My cheesecake was frozen :( I was told it only needed to sit out for 5 minutes at room temperature. Probably needed an hour. read more

The key lime pie here is spectacular! Big hit with my family. The entire thing was gone in 2 days!

While visiting Marathon, we got ice cream here a few times and ordered an ice cream cake for my son's birthday. Service was great, ice cream and cake were delicious! Cute trinkets and gift items too! read more

Huge array of flavors. Something for everyone. We loved it My daughter had a lemon sorbet milkshake made and she swears by it. We will have to go back and get more read more

10 points for creativity very nice place very inviting friendly staff attentive The ice cream isn't bad it's not made locally which is a bit of a bummer ice cream is imported from Homestead Florida but in retrospect they do offer this cookie bowl which is a bowl with ice cream made out of a cookie and it's embedded with M&Ms truly delicious read more

See all

Get the chocolate covered key lime pie! You won't regret it! One of a kind and so good

I loved this place and would for sure come back!!!!! The food was great and so was the atmosphere!!

Best ice cream and cookies! There is usually a line and they are definitely worth the wait!

We loved this wonderful little shop and visited twice during our time in Marathon. The ice cream was delicious and we really enjoyed visiting with the owner! read more

We ordered a Key Lime pie and every part of it was perfect! The actual pie, the whipped topping, and the crust were 10/10.

I love your Cotton candy ice cream it's so delicious and I love your candy and toys is the best. I just love Sweet Savannah's.

This place has some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Generous portions is one thing that's nice, but the quality and flavors are what make it great. Nice, super clean, cute shop, seating area. Highly recommend if you are looking for an ice cream stop in the area. They also have key lime pie and cupcakes, which I didn't try, but I suspect would be very good. read more

Great service and a great key lime ice cream. Very convenient home town ice cream parlor

Yummy ice creams. Other sweets that are also scrumptious Cute store for tourists and unusual cute nick backs

We come to the Keys every February and having sampled key lime pie from Key Largo to Key West and Sweet Savannah's version stands out clearly as the best by far. We were more than a little amazed in reading a review of the supposed top 10 pies in the Keys that totally excluded this business - tremendous failure of reporting. As well, we ordered a specialty birthday cake for someone visiting us for a few days and it was stunningly beautiful and quite tasty. If you want the best the Keys have to offer in terms of key lime pie, visit Sweet Savannah's in Marathon. read more

Sweet Savannah's is a really cute bakery and ice cream shop in Marathon. The interior is nicely decorated and has an adorable "secret garden" room that looks like a relaxing place to hang out for a bit, although we took our goodies to go. After much indecision because everything looked so good, we ordered 3 cupcakes and a key lime bar. It was all delicious, but - and I can't believe I'm saying this - the cupcakes had too much frosting. Normally I'm all about the frosting, but it was just too much, especially because the cupcakes were also filled. The cake to frosting ratio was off. The cupcakes would still have been good with just half the amount of frosting. It's nice that Sweet Savannah's is open daily from 11am-9pm. A lot of bakeries close early, so it's great to be able to get a cupcake fix even into the evening. If you have a sweet tooth, definitely give Sweet Savannah's a try. read more

Neat place. Clean. Good service. We found the ice cream to be meh. Good selection of flavor but neither of us was very impressed with the ice cream itself. read more

This is the best place in Marathon for ice cream & to satisfy your sweet tooth. Give it a try , you won't be sorry.

Probably the best bread pudding I ever had. White chocolate bread pudding. They asked if we wanted it warmed up, so we did.. and we asked them to top it with a scoop of salted caramel ice cream.. and oooo weeeeeee... was it delicious! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Bread pudding - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

A wide variety of sweets and treats and for once some actual cute things to buy instead of crappy roadside tourist junk.

I had the peanut butter sundae with chocolate peanut butter ice cream. It was really delicious.

No... go down the road to the gourmet popsicles. We tried to get some treats here on 9/17 around 430... three kids were behind the counter and it was as if we interrupted a play date. The male named Derrick was microwaving a lava cake for another customer and the two females were just giggling at his antics. He put his finger in it and stuck it back into the microwave. When it was done, he took it out and literally, I'm not kidding, shoved it into my face, then my teenagers faces, each time saying "lava cake?" "lave cake?" We said no, and after 4 tries, the customer that ordered the lava cake came forward to claim it. Pure chaos and pretty gross. No one acknowledged us up until this point, except "lava cake?" So after 10 minutes we left... read more

If you're looking for a whole key lime pie that isn't outrageously expensive in the Keys, this is your place. Cost about $20 for the whole thing. They have all kinds of tasty homemade treats, and the girls behind the counter were very friendly. read more

Quaint little ice cream shoppe. Novel in their approach with hand scooped flavors, fresh baked cookies, salt water taffy and key lime pie. We sampled the Coconut Joy and Key Lime ice cream scoops. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Key lime lime was tasteless, service had no idea what was going on. Coffee is served reheated in a microwave instead of fresh brewed. I'm giving an extra star because they have free video games. read more

Good ice cream!!! love it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So good! We go there every single time we come to our Florida house and they are so nice my favorite ice cream is coconut joy! read more

Wow great sundae. The cupcakes, cake and pies look incredible. Can't wait to get back

This place is very cute. Brought my daughter here for a cupcake, but she wanted ice cream instead. Asked for a small scoop and got a pretty big one (portions are big). Had to try the key lime pie (which is actually a small slice) and it was amazing! So light and just the right tartness. Got the key lime ice cream which was also good but nothing like the pie. The service was great too. It is really a must if you are passing through marathon. read more

The staff was very friendly with us even through there was a small line. They do offer gluten and dairy free desserts. We all had ice cream, and while it tasted okay, it was definitely not special. There is a small store inside with the desserts if you're looking for gifts. Yes, it is overpriced, but so is all of the Keys. read more

I knew Sweet Savannah's would be a great dessert spot as soon as I saw their line out the door. They have delicious cupcakes, ice cream, and sundaes. I ordered a mocha latte cupcake which was a vanilla cake filled with chocolate ganache and topped with coffee flavored buttercream. I wish I had a picture but I ate it pretty quickly. Sweet Savannah's has a lot of gluten free treat as well as some dairy free ice cream/sorbet flavors. Once you get your ice cream they have a little shop and a cute seating area with free games. This is our new after dinner spot in Marathon. read more

Not a good experience! I went to buy a couple a dozen cupcakes for several clients. When I got there no one else was in there. I walked in and asked what they had left since it was slim pickings at the end of the day. But neither of the employees bother to wait on me first. Two of their employees decided to take care of the other two people who walked in later as I was still talking with one of the employees. I thought that's rude! I always make up my mind fast, so I was shocked that they both flippantly ignored a good customer. (I usually send a lot of money in order to impress my clients). Instead, they both decided to be rude and filled the other guy's orders first. So of course, the guy behind me bought up the cupcakes I was going to buy. Since I had to wait for their rather bad customer service, I noticed several flies crawling all over the icing of their cupcakes. Yuck!!! Thank God for their bad customer service or I wouldn't have noticed their cupcakes in Savannah's come with a distinct taste of FLY! LOL I left really quick telling them they lost all of my business and without their nasty fly cupcakes! Bob and Liz read more

Love their daily special cupcakes and delicious Key Lime Pie. Always a stop when we are there.

Ohhhhkay. Maybe it's the pregnancy hormones but wow was this ice cream amazing. All I have to say is get the banana praline and prepare for your life to be changed. I wish I could ship this home to Chicago. So so good. Super cute on the inside too with a little gift shop. If you are in the area you MUST stop here for a sweet treat. read more

Great sweets! They got cupcakes, ice creams, cakes and cookies!!!! Definitely worth a try!

kids got birthday cake idea cream, it was amazing Key lime pie is the best I've ever had anywhere!!! Perfect mix of tart and sweet just as it should be! Fun gift shop too read more

Um....the girls here are not friendly at all. I love getting a Sweet Savannah but the last few times the girl used a refrigerated cup cake and the frosting was hard and almost stale. As someone who has been in food service I forgive a lot, I would never go to an establishment right before close. I went in with my husband around 8:20-8:30 ish and they were complaining in ear shot about people coming in late and how they have to be there and they just want to close. Really? Not really interested in going back. read more

Key lime pie was spot on! Next time I'll try the chocolate covered key lime pie for sure! Yum!

If you cannot make it to KW and go to Mattheessen's, then try the Key Lime pie here.

Absolutely love this place! A little pricey, but great selection of gluten free options, cute gifts are, delicious ice cream abd great customer service! Highly recommend read more