Did a search for key lime shakes in the keys and found this. Really cute and homey shop. Nice seating area. They also have many gluten free options. They make the ice cream into a shake for you. It was a really good shake but I missed the key lime tartness. We also ordered several cake balls and they were delicious. Highly recommend. read more

See all

I'm pretty spoiled when it comes to ice cream. My hometown has some of the best in house made ice cream in the state. We came in here to give theirs a try but we were disappointed when we saw they used Breyers. The sundaes were decent but definitely nothing to sing on the rooftops about. The line was out the door on a Thursday night and I commend the staff for politely telling uneducated customers that they must leave their mask on and not eat in line. Thank you! The actual restaurant itself is super cute. It's even got a little store full of knickknacks for purchase. Definitely come and check it out for yourself. read more

Baked goods frozen...expensive and dried out... never again this was their fourth chance...

Was fantastic. My husband had a banana split and I had two cookies with a hot chai. We both loved what we got. Cute little shop too. (Corrected, I realized my review said "hated two cookies" instead of "had to cookie", sorry Sweet Savannah's) read more

Sweet Savannah's is a charming desserts spot that will perfectly cure your sweet tooth needs! I come here whenever I'm in the keys. They offer a variety of desserts (including chocolate dipped key lime pie), but their primary focus is all things ice cream. And...big selling point, they don't skimp out on their portions! The decor makes it feel like you're walking into a secret garden. They have a huge indoor seating area for large groups and a kid's store with toys and trinkets to entertain you while your gobbling up that delicious ice cream. Sometimes they can have a line, but that's because they're so focused on providing the best service for each and every customer. I always make it a point to stop by here when I'm in the area. read more

Amazing chocolate covered key lime pie, cookie butter cupcake, and red velvet cupcake! Fast and friendly service! If you go at night it will be packed! This place is good! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Chocolate covered key lime pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Best key lime pie I have ever eaten. We go several times when we are in the Keys. It's cool and creamy with a delicious crust. It's wonderful plain or covered in chocolate. read more

Best cake ever!!! My family ordered a custom cake to celebrate a birthday while traveling to Marathon Key. The cake was outstanding, everyone in our group said it was the best cake they ever had! I had an amazing experience working with the bakery and couldn't recommend it enough!! The lemon blueberry cake does not disappoint. Thank you Margot & team! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

The best pie in the keys. Worth the drive from wherever you are. Had this pie in 2015 and had to go back!

We stopped here on our way from Marathon to Key Largo. I had their peanut butter and chocolate ice cream. Delicious!! My husband had the bread pudding and key lime pie. Excellent!! Cute place to stop for a sweet treat! read more

Not sure why reviews are complaining about the prices: Three custom made desserts and two bottled waters at $15 is actually quite good! Best cupcake I've had in a long time and the 2nd or 3rd best Key Lime Pie. Extremely pleasant service from a younger girl behind the counter today. Nice quiet spot to sit and relax as well. read more

Stopped by after hearing it was voted "best key lime pie" in the area. Pie slice was quite small. It had a delicious tangy taste. The texture was more pudding like than I'd expected. The cappuccino was excellent. The service was fair. Two people were behind the counter when we entered. I had to interrupt them to ask for service. I'd hope for more attentive staff. I'm on a Quest for the best key lime pie in the keys. This was good, but not the best. read more

The key lime pie, cookies and cupcakes we picked up while staying in Marathon were AMAZING! Highly recommend getting dessert here.

Stopped here real quick for dessert after dinner. Decided to pick up a whole Key Lime pie. Priced at $15, it seemed like a better deal than paying almost $5 per slice. It was well worth it. Staff were friendly and there were many other options to choose from such as ice cream, cookies, cupcakes and more. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Key Lime Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Sweet Savannah's is a local ice cream and dessert shop near Marathon. They have a wide variety of ice creams and cupcakes, with an emphasis on local, tropical flavors. We got an ice cream trio with birthday cake (the best flavor in my opinion), their signature key lime, and mango guava. All were excellent. The shop has a few tables on the patio for outdoor dining. It was hard to resist the cupcakes, especially the key lime cooler (always an excuse for a return trip though!) read more

Love the new location. Selection of ice creams is amazing, of course pistachio is still my favorite. Ice cream still as great as ever. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Delish!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

It was recommended by a friend and was our first time visiting. When we walked in we thought it was a really cute place. We saw people at the cash register so we stood in line. I walked over to look at the ice cream flavors while a young employee was cleaning the glass. When we were next up at the register the young lady asked my husband "you want something "? He said we wanted to order icecream. She then said we had to do that over in front of the ice-cream(2steps to our left). There's no signs to say where you order and mind you I was standing in front of the icecream while an employee was there and never asked if I wanted to order. There were three young employees there and none asked to help us. I ordered the guava cheesecake which had ice crystals in it. The ice cream was flavorful but the crystals took the enjoyment out of eating it. Ice cream is supposed to be creamy! So rating this 2 stars 1st due to lack of hospitality and 2nd ice crystals in the ice cream! read more

We go here every year while visiting during lobster season. We all were extremely disappointed with the staff and their lack of friendliness or enthusiasm. Literally like they were being forced to work there. I guess Marathon businesses are hurting for employees right now. There's definitely a lot cheaper places to go for ice cream. All it takes is a visit like this to ruin a tradition.....That's my wife's review below from 4 years ago. read more

A local small business you must stop in and support while you're in town, caters to any kind of sweet tooth you have. Any carries cookie mister ice cream, a rare ice cream that's hard to find! read more

We had the key lime pie it is the best in Marathon Key. We are down here from Naples, fl. Delicious pie. We stopped at Island fish company and we can't make up our minds which is better. Can you? read more

Sweet Savannah's - KeyLime Pie. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Oh my oh my. What a hidden place to get your sweet creamy key lime pie. Loved loved it. They also served ice cream and other kids stuffs or gifts. Forgot to take a picture of the pie it was gone once I realized it. Hahaha read more

Another popular spot! Seems theres always some sort of line but its not bad. And if you dont plan of devouring a lot of ice cream soon get your cone in a cup or stick to the 1 scoop! Lol 2 scoops is a lot and its hot out so it melts fast! read more

Sweet Savannah's - 1 scoop of cookies and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

We went here on the way back from key west. The shop had a variety of treats. We wanted to try a little bit of everything. We tried the cupcake it was ok. The cookies were also ok. The snickerdoodle cookie was nice and fluffy. The m&m was average. The ice cream was the best! We would go back and get just the ice cream. read more

Awesome offerings! The cupcakes and cookies are so moist and the options are plentiful. I made the mistake of taking some to several offices I call on and everytime I see them they ask for more! Smart folks. The ice cream selections are so great as well and they have many unique gifts and items for your canine kids. I understand the owner contributes generously to the community and as a local we appreciate that so much. Keep up the awesome work! read more

The best place for Key Lime Pie in The Keys! During my week long visit to The Keys I stopped at several different places to try their pie. I always came back to Sweet Savannah's. There is ice cream as well to enjoy. A small selection of household items and or souvenirs to buy as well. Stop in and check it out, you won't regret it! read more

Not much of a dine in type setting, but got their Keylime pie to go and it was absolutely fantastic! Five stars for the Keylime pie, three-ish For the dine in experience read more

Best ice cream in town!! Service was quick, flavors were numerous and tables are available to sit and enjoy your delights. We will be back!

The Cookie Butter cupcake was one of the most delicious desserts I've ever eaten - and I've eaten a LOOOOOOT of desserts. Our second fave was the chocolate Half-Baked. We weren't impressed with the Red Velvet - the icing was fluffy vs creamy and lacked a strong cream cheese texture/flavor. The Key Lime Pie was realllly good, too! I liked the taste combination of the chocolate Key Lime pie, but the chocolate was hardened which made it difficult to eat without squishing the pie filling. Tasty all the same! The whole place was cute and family friendly. read more

Sweet Savannah's is awesome. We've been coming to the keys for years and always stop by a couple of times. They have great shakes and vanilla malts too. read more

Such a cute little ice cream shop in Marathon. And the ice cream is amazing with lots of flavors to pick from

While visiting Marathon, we got ice cream here a few times and ordered an ice cream cake for my son's birthday. Service was great, ice cream and cake were delicious! Cute trinkets and gift items too! read more

The key lime pie here is spectacular! Big hit with my family. The entire thing was gone in 2 days!

Delicious key lime pie!! It is so smooth snd silky with a great fresh key lime flavor and the crust is great as well - you definitely can tell it's homemade. The key lime pie cookie was good as well. Overall, one of the best pies I've had in the keys! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Key lime pie - so delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Went twice for ice cream, just ok both times. Wife did love the key lime pie and their coconut ice cream. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Cookie bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

If you looking for number one pie in the Keys, this will be the place. They have been the winner of Key Lime Pie for many year. I think the secret is the crush and sweetness of the key lime. The crush is tasty and crunchy. The key lime in fill is soft and sweet. They also has ice cream. Unfortunately they did not have the key lime pie on the stick. However they do have many flavor to choose from. It has sugar free and gluten free ice cream. Feel not so guilty on guiltless sweet. Other that ice cream, they are actually a bakery. You can order the cake or cup cake you like. I can see the island people celebrating their special occasion many from this store. They also have the room next door is larger enough for any party. Sweet treat include brownies, milkshake, float and more. read more

See all

My cheesecake was frozen :( I was told it only needed to sit out for 5 minutes at room temperature. Probably needed an hour. read more

Get the chocolate covered key lime pie! You won't regret it! One of a kind and so good

Huge array of flavors. Something for everyone. We loved it My daughter had a lemon sorbet milkshake made and she swears by it. We will have to go back and get more read more

I loved this place and would for sure come back!!!!! The food was great and so was the atmosphere!!

Best ice cream and cookies! There is usually a line and they are definitely worth the wait!