Jovanni was so nice and helpful! They have really good ice cream too! Must try! We will be back.read more

Disappointed to see Hershey's ice cream and not homemade. Is this Tallahassee's best?read more

That's a great comparison. It makes total sense that you'd prefer the setup at Jeremiah's--having…read morestaff scoop the treats behind a counter is definitely more reassuring than the self-serve topping bins where people might be a bit messy. And you are right about those Jelati Cakes! At around $30, they are a total steal for a celebration compared to a lot of other custom dessert shops. Here is a review draft for the Bannerman location that highlights your favorite parts: Much Better Than the Competition! We've tried a few different spots in town, but we like Jeremiah's in Bannerman a lot better than places like Sweet Frog. Why we prefer Jeremiah's: * Hygiene: At other self-serve spots, I've seen people putting their hands in the topping bowls, which is really unhygienic. At Jeremiah's, everything is handled professionally behind the counter. * The Value: We love that they make Italian Ice cakes! They are amazing and very budget-friendly. It's our new go-to for celebrations. * Family Favorite: My cousins absolutely love making their own Italian Ice combos. The staff is always great, and it's a much cleaner, more comfortable experience. Highly recommend! Since your cousins love making their own combos, what's the best flavor combination you've tried there so far?

I love the drive thru option and it's super convenient in comparison to my house. Jeremiah's…read moreItalian Ice has some of the smoothest and creamiest Italian ice you will ever taste. The combination of Italian ice and their soft serve is the best combo you can get, called the gelati. They have a great rewards program and specials often. You'll be notified via email for upcoming specials and deadlines on rewards you'll have and will need to cash in on. I hope one day they will have dairy alternative options, but until then, I'll keep my Lactaid on hand to enjoy the delicious treats.

This was so good!! The spicy pickles and ranch dressing were amazing! The brisket was tender and…read moretasty. My husband liked the French fries- they had a crispy batter on them. We finished with homemade ice cream which was delicious. We will definitely come back!

If I could rate zero I would. If you want racism served to your kids this is the place to purchase…read moretheir bland ice cream. The bbq tasted like burnt leather the last time I went so if this is what you're seeking have at it. Enjoy!

Out of town and wanted something sweet . Yogurt was delicious plenty of options. Customer service…read morewas very cold, distant and not friendly at all, but I would recommend to try their flavors.

Solid price, good topping selection and great yogurt selection. Why ask for a tip though when all…read moreyou did was put my dessert on the scale and then tell me how much it costs, I made the dang thing!!

Went to a place next door for lunch and noticed this jewel. After we ate our food, we came to…read moreJeremiah's for a cool treat. I wanted a little ice crem and a little Italian ice - and this is exactly what I got! My portion was just right to top off the meal I had just eaten. I ordered vanilla soft serve with sugar free Italian ice, which was very good (jelati). My daughter ordered the Orea mud pie jelati. We both enjoyed our treats and will plan to return. Of note, there was a bit of a wait because only one person was working the counter and there was a line. But we weren't in a rush, so it was not a problem.

ICE ICE BABY | Restaurants and shops have come and go over the decades at Village Square but I was…read moresuper excited to see Jeremiah's had moved in. It's the perfect hangout spot in the 'burbs of northeast Tallahassee and we grabbed a quick sweet treat after dinner. I don't know if it's just me but I found the menu super confusing as a first time Jeremiah's customer. I pieced together the menu and the various combo/layer-in options to finally order the small Scoop Froggy Frog (mint chocolate chip) gelati swirl with mini chocolate chips. It was a lot bigger than I expected for a small - which was a pleasant surprise. We brought our dogs so we sat at one of a few tables outside while munching on our treats. Will definitely be back to try the Italian Ices next time!

4.5/5 stars. Decreasing the rating because when we checked in they asked if we were celebrating…read moreanything, to which we said yes my sister's graduation. The host was so excited and when a restaurant asks that you expect something fun for the graduation but nothing happened. Not a fun dessert, a fun plate with writing, a card, nothing. Highly disappointed fora white tablecloth restaurant. I would not recommend coming to celebrate here for that reason alone. Drinks took a while to come out. We were on the patio and our server was all over the place due to the table next to us being rude and picky to him. Delicious food though! My first time here even though I lived in Tallahassee for 4 years. The cornbread that was with the burnt ends... the best cornbread I've had in my life. Incredible. The barrington (ribs with corn) was delicious as well. Overall great food, okay atmosphere, okay service.

I've been here a number of times throughout the years, the quality of the food never really…read moredisappoints. The ingredients are fresh, and even some of their signature items have been updated and upgraded here and there with no complaints. However, I ordered a cinnamon roll for the first time in a while thinking it would be the same size as before and it has shrunk by more than half. It's a little disappointing to see the portion size be so drastically different than what I remembered. Taste wise it's still great, but I only got it thinking that it would be the huge cinnamon roll that I was used to. I was better off going to Cinnabon in the mall. Also, the prices are not updated on the website.

Hidden gem! My sweet tooth was calling me and I happened upon the establishment. It was pretty…read moreclose to my hotel so I was sold. My friend ordered 2 scoops of cookies and cream on a waffle cone. I ordered 2 scoops of chocolate with specialty dark chocolate on a waffle cone. The young lady assisting us behind the counter highly recommended it. When I tell you we sat in silence until we nearly inhaled our ice cream. It was so delicious. The richness in the flavors was definitely memorable. The portion sizes of the scoops were consistent and worth the value (around $11 for both). I would return whenever I'm in town.

Great little strip mall ice cream shop! We celebrated the last day of school with a kids cup of…read morebirthday cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and a turtle sundae. Both were great! The young man running the shop was friendly and helpful. You'll find a couple tables inside and a few more in the covered outside area. Not much atmosphere, but some damned good ice cream!!!

Nice, bright, friendly store with a solid selection of ice cream to choose from. The staff was very…read morefriendly and helpful as we asked for advice on flavors and bowls. The ice cream scoops were standard in size and the flavors were quite good. Everyone enjoyed their scoops. Only downside to this visit was the smell of the store. It smelled strongly of antiseptic and nothing else. While I do love things to be clean, it would be great to get smells of cones and other smells that represent the business to entice purchases!

The absolute nicest owners!! They are so sweet and support the community. Ice cream is delicious…read moreand store is always clean and tidy. Raspberry truffle is my favorite!