It's probably important to note that I haven't been to Sy Thai since about August of 2008. The fall of '08 seems to be around the time that a lot of reviewers here got sick from their food and apparently the restaurant faced some health violations. The reason I haven't been back to Sy Thai has solely to do with its distance from me but now I'm kind of glad that I haven't been back there, considering what I've read on Yelp. That said, all I can do is review my past experiences with Sy Thai - and those experiences were quite good, hence the 4/5 star rating.
To be honest, I haven't even sampled much on the Sy Thai menu. Every time I went there, I would order the Egg Noodles (with tofu). What a treasure trove of flavor and delight that noodle dish is. When it was made just right - not too spicy, but not dripping wet with brown sauce either - it was heavenly to eat. Every time I made the 45 minute trip to Birmingham to sample them, I never regretted it.
Most times I went to Sy Thai, the service would either be laid back but attentive or I'd be borderline ignored. I can't really say I was ever treated poorly, though. Oftentimes the place is hopping and it can be difficult to get a booth, but I'd never felt that the wait wasn't worth it. As I said, those Egg Noodles are so...freakin'...good.
I've also had the spring rolls as an appetizer and they were among the best I've had, though sometimes they could feel a bit greasy/fried for a spring roll. They do come with a very sweet and zesty sauce you can put on them. Speaking of sweet and zesty, I always thought that Sy Thai was a nice place to take a date. Despite its Birmingham location you never have to deal with too many squirrel-y teenage girls in there. Unlike at some of the restaurants in town, Sy Thai patrons are just looking for good food and conversation - not to hold a Twilight convention.
What can I say? Apparently Sy Thai has turned into something of a health crisis, and I'd now think twice about returning there after reading some of the reviews on Yelp. However, based on my experiences from around 2002-2008, I'd have to rate it as one of my favorite Thai places. Then again, I've had food poisoning once in my life and I can wholly sympathize with anyone who has experienced it - so take this recommendation of Sy Thai with a hint of caution. read more