If you want genuine delicious Mexican food, this is the spot. Small little hole in wall building with big flavor. Friendly service. But the food was phenomenal. Tasty. Large serving and genuinely surprised and would definitely stop by again. read more

Amazing authentic food. Delish! Carnitas tacos are a favorite. Outdoor seating is available. Don't pass it up because it is small.

Best taco place in the Hamptons! I drive from East Hampton to Hampton bays just for their food. Good sazon

It's getting up there in price but food's still good. I enjoy everything I get here. At least it's consistent in flavor. Nice folks run it. read more

See all

Amazing food, really bad service. Not attentive on the phone got the wrong order, still happy about it though.

Best Mexican food on Long Island / in the Hamptons without a doubt. Went here right when coronavirus started and it was the perfect retreat from all the madness. Planning to attend many more times even though they will do pickup only, like most restaurants. The staff is amazing and so lovely and so dope. The food is fire. Chilaquiles really stood out (nachos too) but it's all heat. I hope this place continues to kill it despite the crisis right now. I'm looking forward to many more drop-ins at la mejor !!!!! Uno amor!! read more

Taqueria Mi Pueblito - the interior of a restaurant - Mexican Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

No frills, down home, deliciously great Mexican eats right in the heart of HB! Oh and pro tip DO NOT pass up on their Horchata!! It's a must MUST get! We've had a gamut of items from their extensive menu but my fave is their regular tostada (beans, oaxaca stringy cheese, lettuce and topped with the additive crema) ; both the Mexican and traditional qeusadilla options, and the tacos are lovely too. Al pastor, chorizo, chicken and carnitas are our go to meat options for every dish. Service has always been friendly both when making a pick up order over the phone or in person. Love that they are open late nights as well. Seating is VERY limited here, so suggest you order ahead and pick up and go to your fave spot in town or by the water, weather permitting, and chow down! read more

See all

Best chicken quesadillas! Nachos and tacos are delish as well. I usually call for pick up and my order is ready in 15-20 minutes. Thank you ! read more

Yes, dinner in a deli on the highway.. a few other diners and lots of take out. Really like this cute place on the south side of Montauk Hwy in Hampton Bays. Super tiny unique eatery/ deli. Phone orders coming in. Popular among locals. People were super nice, food was fresh. 3 1/2 for fun Mexican food cooked to order, so chill out a few minutes and have a Jarritos lime soda or a bottled beer. Lol You order at the counter, go get a soda out of the case and tell the guy at the counter, he nods or makes a note and you wait for your order. They bring it out. Fun place. Not a fan of flour chips or the odd tomato pureed red orangy salsa.. but all else were good! On this visit a young man at the next table got up and handed me a cap remover... as they saw me try to open my soda to no success with a twist. The place and people are so likable in their unassuming way yet spicing up lunch or dinner nicely. So yeah.. head on over and have some traditional tacos, burritos, enchiladas etc. Sigh ok.. editing now.. adding a star.. why? because my vegetarian companion liked the effort to make good tacos with lots of flavor. So an extra star for the vegetarians that can be accommodated. read more

See all

This was probably the best, most authentic tasting Mexican cuisine we've had sicne we moved to the East Coast. In some respects the competition is not even close. It just goes to show, great food can be found anywhere. We almost passed on this little shop right off a very busy highway where we almost died trying to cross the road. We almost gave up again when we encountered their interminably slow line. The last straw was almost, *almost*, how long it took to get our food. But when we tasted it, all transgressions were forgiven. Very excellent and *real* Mexican food. read more

Favorite Mexican food I've come across on Long Island! I've been searching for a place that made good tortas (grilled steak sandwich with lettuce,tomato, refried beans, avocado, cheese and mayonnaise on toasted bread) for a while and found it here! Definitely will be coming back! I also got a steak quesadilla and it was great! Homemade tortillas with grilled steak, two different cheeses, lettuce and sour cream, definitely worth $7! Also, the green salsa is bomb! It goes great with everything! I highly recommend grabbing lunch here! Also, don't forget to grab a large horchata to go with your lunch! read more

See all

Finally managed to work breakfast into our schedule. Its a informal little place. Think of a food truck with A small bodega on the front. Fresh fruits, veggies & fresh breads & meats. Our food was fresh & authentic ChilaquilesMexican Breakfast were super. read more

Delicious tacos! Ordered takeout while staying in the area and it did not disappoint. Delicious tacos, rice and beans. Great authentic flavor. read more

This is the real deal. As in, get yourself here asap and order some tacos and DO NOT leave without a slice of the tres leches cake (to die for). I will say that calling ahead is the right thing to do -- because otherwise you'll wait quite awhile for your food. My friends and I ordered takeout, our first night at Hampton Bays (we were staying nearby) and of all the tacos we tried, we all agreed that the carnitas and chicken tinga were the best. I didn't love the pozole tbh, and they didn't give me the right order when I used Try Caviar (pre-order / pre paid), when we returned a second time. I'll miss having this spot around the corner. I would have gone a 3rd time today if I wasn't headed home! read more

I'm from Southern California so I believe my review here carries more weight in the Mexican food category. I normally think most of the mexican food on the east coast is average at best. It's in the middle of the Coronavirus epidemic and we were in deep deep need of some mexican food and comfort. Came here at 10pm on a Friday night and they did not disappoint. The tiny store lined wall to wall with food, produce, candy and mezcal. The staff is insanely friendly and the food did not disappoint. It will be my first place into the hamptons and my last place out (sounds so annoying but it's true). Go support this family from Oaxaca read more

See all

Great authentic Mexican food. Unlike all the places that think tacos should fried food doused in thick sauces. This is the real deal! We had Chicken tacos as well as mole enchiladas which is not often on menus. read more

Amazing, flavorful, friendly service, fast delivery. I just wish they made it into a sit down restaurant or drivethrough.

Tacos were delicious but the main highlight is definitely the homemade corn tortillas Al Pastor tacos outshined the Asada ones! Overall delicious Mexican food! read more

Taqueria Mi Pueblito - 2 Asada Tacos 1 Al Pastor - Mexican Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Chicken burrito is fresh and tasty and the spicy chicken tostada great food at an affordable price read more

Taqueria Mi Pueblito - Chicken burrito - Mexican Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Deserves 10 stars . I got the Plato poblano , everything is cooked to order and we'll worth the wait read more

Taqueria Mi Pueblito - Plato poblano. If I could give ten stars I would - Mexican Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Best, most authentic tacos in the Hamptons hands down and at an amazing price. Reminds me a lot of Los Tacos No 1 in the city. Don't want the secret to get out, but have to support their amazing food. read more

Excellent little gem out in Hampton bays. Have been here multiple times, and I never been disappointed yet. Food is always super fresh, extremely flavorful, and very reasonably priced. Unassuming storefront that also sells some basic grocery items including many Hispanic speciality products (and beers). Delivery as well as pick up ordering quick and easy online via grubhub (and others), especially for anyone who is not comfortable speaking Spanish. Even a small outdoor area where you can enjoy your food to stay in the warmer weather. High praise for this small business. read more

Excellent tacos with steak and cactus and a delicious pozole soup. I drive 30min to come here. Order via yelp and puck up. Reasonable prices. Great green hot sauce. I hope the quality will not change now that this place is getting more and more popular. read more

Taqueria Mi Pueblito - my order - Mexican Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Good lord, freaking delicious. I'm a pushover for delicious Mexican breakfast and tried this place on a lark; it was 11:00am and I'd been up for four hours without food or coffee. I looked on Yelp for breakfast burrito and this place did not show up. It could be that I am dense and missed it, doesn't matter. That's what I ordered and it was stellar. There is outside seating but you order at the counter and fetch your own food (and hopefully bus your own table). Inside feels like a bodega and has lots of real Mexican provender on sale. It had the feel inside that the owners might have had the same thing in Mexico, muy authentico. Burrito was delicious, coffee was stock deli coffee and suited me just fine - though I have a proper espresso machine and pull my own, there is a time and a place for deli coffee. Tomatillo salsa was delicious. I sat looking at my empty food container wanting to eat a second one, though past experience elsewhere has proven that an unwise move. If I lived closer this would easily be a once a week deal until I moved up a pant size. read more

I came here because a reviewer said they had a separate vegan menu. Sadly they didn't. They did have a vegetable burrito. So I gave it a try and was pleasantly surprised. Rice and beans with Pico de gallo, mushrooms, onions, peppers and guacamole. Cute convenience store deli with a kitchen in the back. Friendly and accommodating staff. My girlfriend had a steak burrito and like it. read more

I just tried this place, actually their new LIAA too in Westhampton and this place is off the charts. If you want real Mexican food look no further. I just had the best burrito in my life. Literally 100 different menu items. You cannot go wrong. read more

If in the mood for average Mexican fare this place will suffice. Nothing wrong with anything, but also nothing special. Fair food at a fair price. read more

Excellent Mexican food, regardless of what you order. I had tacos, Mexican quesadillas, and loaded nachos. All delicious. The store inside is really cool too with many Mexican delights for sale (my favorite being Sal y alimony Fritos) read more

See all

No sirve y carro. Food is pretty bad compared to others. Such as the tacos and quesadillas and the tostados. First time coming to get to and it sucks. I ordered 3 tostados and gave me two even though I paid for three. And expensive too. No bueno. read more

I'm so picky and this place is a hidden gem! I stopped because My pregnant self has been searching the island for good tostadas & let me tell you!! This place did not disappoint!! Soooo good! Highly recommend & their homemade verde sauce is fire! I'll definitely be returning !! read more

Everything here is homemade and delicious. The plates are well priced and very filling. Cute mom and pop place needs to last

The food was better before the fire. A little different after they re-opened. They still have great burritos but it's hit or miss. Always crowded! Call ahead. read more

Sirven buena comida, los tacos de quesabirria son excelentes pero un poco caro, aparte de eso, el servicio es más o menos, a veces dan buen servicio y a veces lo tratan a uno como que pidieron regalado. 6/10 read more

Zero stars for this place. The guy behind the counter is extremely rude and has no idea what customer service is. They messed up my order after I asked in English and Spanish for no onions on my kids's tacos. Instead of apologizing (minimum) he simply sent my order to the kitchen to remove my onions. I asked for my money back. Don't stop here and waste 30 minutes to get the wrong order. Spend your money elsewhere. read more

Only good authentic Mexican food in town Would definitely always be my favorite. Try their burritos, quesadillas, shrimp cocktails! read more

10/10 best burritos and tacos in Long Island and great customer service 10/10. Worth the wait

The best beef tacos I have had. Perfectly seasoned. los mejores tacos de carne que he tenido. perfectamente sazonado

Overall very good solids tacos with quick service at a good price. Wouldn't say best ever tacos in my life but very good. I liked the shells a lot read more

This place is legit. Tiny shack with seating for about 12 people, definitely a "take-out" place. My husband's exact words were, "I didn't need to order 6 street tacos." Well made and generous portions. Yummy fries. We were so hungry I forgot to take pics. read more

See all

Don't just drive by ... stop in and grab a bite. The enchiladas and chili rellenos were delicious.....the plantanes as sweet as sugar...and the tres leches topped the meal! Hard working folks. Will definitely go back! read more