These guys finally got it dialed in. Quite a turnaround. Always good (real) bagels here but service was hit or miss. Vince and his crew hooked me up with the best lox and bagel sandwich I've had in a long time. Highly recommend. read more

This place used to have two things going for it: great bagels and a vibrant atmosphere that made you feel like you were part of a community. Now the bagels are puffy and soft. Mine actually compressed when I bit into it and popped back up when I put it down. Fine if you like Wonder Bread. And there is no one there at lunchtime on a Friday. Atmosphere is pretty grim without happy people and walls covered with local art. We've lived here for over 20 years and have purchased many dozens of bagels here. No more. read more

The bagels are fantastic, the sandwiches are good, and overall I love this place. The only reason for 4 instead of 5 stars is that sometimes the service is not very good and sometimes they close early or run out of stuff pretty early in the day. read more

I have been to The Bagelry more times than I can count for 20 years. It's consistent, delicious, and the prices are beyond reasonable. Where else can you get a fresh, delicious meal for $2 and change (besides fast food)? There are options on the menu for just about anyone, and their Mountain Power bagel is so hearty, filling and satisfying. I also love that they offer low fat cream cheese AND low fat veggie cream cheese. read more

The Bagelry - Mountain power bagel with low fat cream cheese. Yum. - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

Was completely ignored for 15 minutes while at the counter trying to order. The employees were talking with each other about their personal life and completely ignored me! When another customer walked in they took his order immediately. I complained and was continued to be ignored. I will never go back after service like that! read more

Extremely rude employees spending more time chit chatting with each other than showing any concern for their jobs. When they're yelling back and forth with each other while "interrupting" their conversation to ask questions about your order or take your payment it is extremely awkward. Also had a barista ask me how I wanted my chai because "I don't drink any of this crap so I have to ask" and then "That looks fine" after pouring milk over the top. Even if the food was extremely excellent it'd be hard to overlook the poor customer service, but it's mediocre anyways so no reason to come back. read more

My kids were Einstein fans for years and it was difficult to convert them to fresh, authentic bagels - the kind I had in Detroit when I was visiting my grandparents. This isn't a fast food bagel place - it's a bakery. The bagels are authentic, home made and delicious. No, they aren't soft and squishy like play dough, they're real bagels made with love. This is a weekend favorite. We love the egg sandwiches and the cranberry walnut bagels. read more

Unfortunately this place has gone down hill, in a big way. The entire place is FILTHY - the kitchen is filthy and there are layers of grime and garbage strewed around on the floors everywhere. The bathroom DISGUSTINGLY FILTHY! The phone system is down, the computer system is down, many food items are out of stock or are not fresh. In the 10 years I've been going there I have never seen an owner onsite. The place is run by well-meaning hourly employees but who obviously have no vested interest . OWNER.... where are you??? read more

I just visited and saw one of the workers sneezing on the toppings bin. Never again.

Food and service is wonderful. I've had especially good service from Samantha. This is one of my favorite places to go in Evergreen and good prices for the food and I will continue going there whenever possible. read more

The Bagelry in Evergreen was a surprise stop this morning on a motorcycle pitstop on the way to Echo Lake. I knew we were gonna stop somewhere in the area and rode right past and caught it in the corner of my eye so I turned all the bikes around and we stopped to enjoy some local flavor. Flavor indeed, as the place was nice to walk into and smelled delishes! Definitely lots to choose from on the chalk board menu on the wall. I decided on the Breakfast Supreme Breakfast bagel with scallions and a cup of drip coffee. A great choice as the portion was large and well proportioned with all the layers of goodness. The drip coffee was excellent with lots of honey and cream. All other breakfast bagels were equally as good across the board. A definite stop again when I'm in the area ! read more

So I'm sitting here eating my bagel sandwich (that's the 3 stars) and as my eyes wander I realize how filthy the eating are is. A build up of food waste and grime! Meanwhile the teens behind the counter talk loudly about the loose toilet set in the bathroom. It doesn't seem to matter because the line at the counter is long for the early lunch crowd. I guess the lesson is grab and go and don't look down. read more

The Bagelry - Zoom in to see filth. - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

Found this gem while out in Evergreen. Needed a quick bite before heading back, so we stopped. Bagels were soft AF! My husband got there pizza bagel, delish, and I went with the veggie on the everything bagel. Everything was good, highly recommend! read more

A++++! I ordered bagels, cream cheese, and lox to be delivered to my friend's home for a funeral. Derek at the store was extremely helpful and friendly. Totally professional. The bagels were amazing! I highly recommend this establishment!! read more

As with everything in Evergreen the service sucks. Bagels are fine, but really.....they're bagels. As with all the restaurants up here, if any mediocrely run bagel shop came in and gave them some competition- they would go out of business read more

Being from New York - I'm very picky on what a good everything bagel is... this place is spot on. A little pricey in my opinion for an egg sandwich ($8) but at least the service was good and the bagel was even better ! read more

The Bagelry continues to be the best place in north Evergreen to meet clients (for me) or as a hub for the many great hiking or cycling loops accessed from here-- or the perfect place to get a breakfast to-go before a big day of skiing. read more

The Bagelry - It's quiet on Friday.., - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

I used to really enjoy this place for coffee and a snack. Recently the service has been terrible and I think I will find another place to go. This past visit, four young women were behind the counter and only one seemed to care at all about serving customers. I'm not sure if there's no training or if the girls are confused about the details of their job, but they seemed shocked that we expected service. There are other, better options. read more

Unfortunately we waited 1 hour for breakfast sandwiches. I have never seen so many upset people. I am trying not to let this experience ruin my day. I almost got back behind the counter and made my own read more

Definitely sad to see where this gem has gone. I grew up going to the Bagelry and even worked there for several summers when I was younger. I got a bagel yesterday morning and it wasn't toasted, the cheese wasn't melted, and my Canadian bacon was cold. In the past they used to always toast your bagel, make sure the Canadian bacon was at least heated up and when they handed it to you it was always piping hot. Also there was one option for coffee, they got rid of all the Dazbog coffee and espresso. The place just didn't feel like a comfortable place to be in anymore and half of the walls were empty. Miss the old Bagelry, really hope that it will find its way back. read more

I live in Golden but whenever I'm any where near the Bagelry I stop in and stock up. I love their breakfast sandwiches. Yum! read more

My first time here was this morning. I won't be back. The bagels were not good and they microwaved the heck out of it making it even worse. You're better off getting a Starbucks bagel if you really want one that bad...and they are cheaper. read more

I used to get bagels in South Beach and Ft Lauderdale at little Jewish delis and they were incredible. I love good, fresh bagels. Imagine my surprise when I found a wonderfuly Bagelry in Bergen Park that served up fresh bagels that could easily compete with the real deal from a Jewish deli. Very gnoshable. Their coffee is excellent, and all the girls working there are just cute as buttons, sweet and smiley and fun to talk to. read more

1 hour wait for bagels on a saturday morning... wow. I dont understand how you can take people's money and expect them to wait that long for a toasted bagel... When we ordered the building was very slow, by the time we started searching for our food there were at least 20 people crowded the counter in the same manner. Ive never seen soo many people canceling orders or demanding money back... Wild! read more

I've told myself I'll never go again but I went one more time to be reassured of that statement! Food used to be awesome but it really lacks in quality as does the customer service. I've walked out before due to the rude employees. Super disappointing and also disturbing that they microwave the eggs. For sure won't be back! read more

If you just crave plastic cheese and microwaved powder eggs, then this is the perfect place for you! If you especially enjoy waiting over 30 minutes for this interestingly crafted concoction, you'll feel right at home at The Bagelry. Save yourself the time and money, the McDonalds around the corner is equally disgusting. read more

The Bagelry had been a normal stop for me for 5 years now and i do like some of their bagels quite a bit (although Costco carries Einstein bagels now, so I go there), but i go less and less as my negative experiences tally up. Too consistently does it seem that they hire rude highschool girls, attractive ones (I'm betting the owner is a male), but usually rude. Today I went and, although the first girl wasn't overtly rude, when I told her I bought a sandwich that was supposed to come with salsa and i didn't receive it she told me that, "people don't usually want it so I don't give it out.." Yeah, but it's on the menu, I guess I should do my due diligence before I get home/work, but usually one is looking for accidentally forgotten things, not intentionally withheld items. Next time, I forgot to ask for salsa again, or look for it, and it wasn't there. When I called to ask again about it, a young man told me that I wasn't supposed to get it and should have asked. "Is it on the menu?" I asked, "uh, I guess so but that's not how we do things here, our regulars know that." He flatly put. Ok, thanks. I prefer businesses that give you what ya pay for and don't deal out snide remarks. The coffee is Daz Bog. Not my favorite, but my partner likes it so we buy it. Today at 8:30 am the coffee was burnt, smelled like a matchstick. Update: they've taken the salsa off the menu, yet have not responded to any of my emails. Bad business if you ask me read more

Since the new ownership, I haven't liked visiting The Bagelry anymore. The food has gotten sloppy and unpleasant. Employee's are rude and don't give their time to the customers like they should. The employees seem like they don't like to help customers...in fact, when I went in yesterday, the employees were all in the back for about 10 minutes and no one helped. I ended up leaving because I waited so long and I believe that was very unprofessional. Food has gotten worse, and The Bagelry is going down a downward path. Not coming back ever again, very disappointed. read more

Just went in to buy a dozen bagels and asked the young woman if she could cut the bagels for me. She rolled her eyes at me but still did it. Very unfriendly. I love their bagels but may not go back. read more

I liked to go here for breakfast sandwiches. I thought it was weird that they microwave their eggs, but they tasted okay. Then one day I had cellophane left in my undercooked eggs. That was 3 years ago and I have not been back. read more

If you like these bagels, WHAT ARE YOU THINKING? Honestly, have you ever had a proper bagel? ***(by the way, anyone know why this place has two listings on Yelp?)*** "Bagelry" bagels are the worst. They are lopsided, lumpy, randomly sized, undercooked globs of dough. I wish I had taken a picture last time I was there, it was a horror show in the glass case. The bakers obviously do not care or they would make their bagel round, approximately equal in size, and bake them a few extra minutes. They might not be as characterless as grocery store "bagels" which are not even bagels. I repeat - these are the WORST BAGELS. Am I a bagel snob? OK, I admit it. But I grew up in the Northeast, and I was a bagel dough-boy for a short stint. The dough forming machines are a bit twitchy, but if you pay attention and CARE ABOUT YOUR PRODUCT, you can adjust the machine, hand form the ones that aren't perfect, and reject the ones that can't be saved. Instead, these guys just boil whatever comes out no matter how deformed or mis-sized they are. In case you are wondering, I AM an occasional customer, as they serve Dazbog coffee which is very good. Of course, they are either out of coffee or out of cream about half of the times that I stop in. So they get 2 stars for usually having coffee, and when they do it is good. Bottom Line - SKIP THE BAGELS (I know I am yelling). read more

I come into this place every morning. My favorite thing to order is the 14er. I enjoy coming to this place because i am always greeted with a smile from the friendly people who work here. They are always super fast with getting my order done. The girl that has tattoos and piercing always makes sure to stop and tell me to have a good day. Also the tall blonde girl with blue eyes is very sweet. I would definitely recommend this place to my friends and family. read more

Just tried this place yesterday was craving a jalapeno bagel with egg, bacon, cheddar and jalapeno cream cheese. Let me start by saying that the jalapeno bagel was good what dissapointed me was the fact that all of the restaurant eggs were prescrambled in a refrigerated pan and my portion was then ladled into a plastic dish to microwave. I don't know about you but I like to know that my eggs are cracked fresh and scrambled fresh, not the case here. Who knows how long these eggs are kept that way. Microwaved eggs? Flavorless. The bacon was also microwaved. Not Good. I suppose if you're going for a bagel sandwich that doesn't require cooking anything, then you're fine. But, if you're looking for something cooked hot to order, Keep Away. read more

Usually eat here once a week, but today was pitiful service. Girl in the black t-shirt took my order, forgot my order, was busy counting her tips, when I asked for my order, she took her time, never apologized. Hopefully just an aberration, I won't give up yet in this place. read more

The bagels are awesome for sure! I don't like the microwaved eggs which by nature is just gross. Last time I was in the back sink area door was open and you could smell what seemed like a backed up drain. Super gross! If a health inspector came in with that smell coming off the sink I think it would be shut down until this was corrected. I hope it is corrected soon because I like this place! read more

This used to be a great place, I've been going since it first opened. Yesterday I had a breakfast bagle that was terrible. fake eggs microwaved, cheese that was like gum and could not get off my teeth, and a bagle that tasted stale. the entire place now smells like urine for some reason, very disgusting. It is as if someone raised a puppy there recently. I suspect they will be out of business soon. the Evergreen Bread Lounge is not far away and has amazing service, food, and even serves beer and wine. So sad to see the Bagelry go down in flames, but really it is not being managed professionally and the secret bagel recipe must have been stolen. read more

I will sooo be back! I got the cranberry walnut bagel with the Mt. Evans!! Oh man was it yummmmmmmy!!! Loved it! Perfect combo and I ordered a medium strawberry mango smoothie! It was so good it makes me wanna slap my momma! I will be back! Definitely check this place out!! read more

Bagels are the bomb and the people working are really nice. There is only one bagel place in all of Colorado where I have had a better bagel and it is nowhere near here. Oh, and Dazbog coffee? YES PLEASE. Go to order: Jalapeno Cheddar Bagel, Jalapeno cream cheese and tomato slices with a big cup of coffee. read more

Wow Sunday morn is crazy here! I didn't feel like I had enuf time to really get a feel for this place. The bagels were great! I like chewyer bagels. One bummer tho was when my sandwich was handed to me it had 1000 island dressing on it. The other sandwich foil had opened up on the drive home. Those r just being picky tho. Food was great. They use Dazbog coffee as well so if u like Dazbog this is the place for u. One tip: chk the menu online before u go. It's hard to see the menu if u r in line. They do have laminated menus on the counter so grab one. I didn't know that until I was asked for my order. read more

Better than the gas station, but I would expect more being in Evergreen and for the prices. Good coffee, but the food is heat and eat microwave with nasty processed cheese and as a few others mentioned I have had somewhat rude service here more than once. read more