Here's a polished version of your review: We didn't dine inside, but placed a large carryout order for our family. The staff was incredibly friendly. Everything was fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious! We ordered the lemon-pepper shrimp, Rockefeller oysters, crab legs, hamburgers, and the BBQ platter, and every single person in our group was happy with their meal. Not one complaint from anyone. Great food, great service, and a wonderful experience overall. We will definitely be back! read more

Ribs were too tough to eat! Pulled pork was very fatty . Would recommend another bbq. Servers were good but had too many tables to handle read more

We ordered takeout BBQ for 6 people. It was quite good and also good value. Four of us returned the next morning for breakfast. Service was friendly and quick. Again, this restaurant provided good food at a reasonable price. The ambiance is about what one would expect for a BBQ restaurant. It's a good choice for those who prefer to stay on the island. read more

Short staffed, the waitresses were also making bar drinks. We waited 15 min for a server to greet us. The fried seafood is the best part of this place. HUGE yummy shrimp and the grouper was good. Everyone loved the baked potato. Despite its name... we would not get the BBQ. It was very dry and unflavorful. Got sat very quickly though. read more

The Beach Pit - Brisket sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

See all

The ribs were sawdust. The restaurant smelled and was dirty! The best part was our waitress and the stray cat.

We had an enjoyable dinner at The Beach Pit a couple of weeks ago. Great, friendly, casual environment. We were able to bring our well-behaved dogs in, which was nice. We chose burgers for our meal, with fries and fried okra as sides. I loved the fried okra! And the burger was tasty as well. I noticed a very nice, well-stocked bar that would be a great hangout spot. Service was good, and I'd highly recommend The Beach Pit! read more

The Beach Pit - Super cool bar area - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

See all

Always a delicious breakfast! Nice and friendly staff. The hash browns are the best. Never had the BBQ, but pancakes, bacon, hash browns and eggs were great!! read more

The food was very good, portions are large and prices are reasonable. But the best for us was the way they treated our dog! .... On our way into the restaurant, in the parking lot, a feral cat was lurking, snuck up on our dog, and scratched her face! This drew lots of blood and we panicked.... But the restaurant staff came to her rescue with water, lots of napkins, and helped with stopping the bleeding. Then, they allowed our pooch into the restaurant where she shared some pork. In the end, we had a good experience and doggy was fine. read more

We have had breakfast there several times this week. The biscuits and gravy will make you want to slap your Momma. The staff is friendly and will gladly accept substitutions. Only negative is that the hash browns were undercooked. read more

Let me start off by saying that our server Beebe was amazing. She was attentive and sweet and accommodating. We each ordered different items. Some were ok, some were not. The bagel sandwich was not toasted and, therefore, had a gummy texture that was not appealing. It tasted like a cheap bagel you would buy in the middle of the grocery store. I asked Beebe what she would recommend and she said the loaded potato. It could have used more condiments (sour cream, green onions, etc), but overall it was the best thing we ordered. The strawberry waffles were ok. A little gummy versus crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, like I like them. My mom's boyfriend got the oyster omelet and I about puked when I tried that. The Bloody Mary was good, but on the menu it said it was $8 and when our bill came they had charged us $9. I know $2 extra isn't the end of the world, but it's the principle. You should charge what is listed on your menu. When I brought up the discrepancy, another woman came out and told me the price IS $9, but they haven't gotten the updated menus yet. To me this isn't a good excuse. All it takes is a sharpie and a few minutes to update the price until the new menus arrive. They didn't want to make it right and because of that and the subpar food, I would not go back. I probably wouldn't be writing this review had it not been for the unwillingness to honor their menu pricing, but I do feel like it should be noted because I have my doubts as to whether or not they are truly waiting for updated menus. Check your itemized receipts. 05/23/2026 read more

This bbq is awful. Service is good. But the food is terrible. Beans were ok, but I think they were those canned Bush beans. Save your money. This was disappointing. read more

The Beach Pit - Maybe the driest brisket I've ever been served. The pit master should be ashamed. - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

Our group of 6 came in for a late lunch on a Friday afternoon. The staff were friendly and welcoming. We brought our fish we had caught and they were willing to bread and fry them for us - delicious! We ordered a bunch of sides and drinks to go with it. Highly recommend checking this place out while visiting SGI. read more

The Beach Pit - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

See all

We did a to-go order! It was ready quickly! I ordered blackened shrimp and okra and it was delicious! My dad and son got cheeseburgers and they were devoured! My mom got fried shrimp and a baked potato. She said they were delicious! My youngest son got kids chicken strips and he said they had the best chicken! We did not get any bbq but the burgers and shrimp were great! read more

We always eat at the Beach Pit on our first night in SGI. We are never disappointed! The food is great and the prices aren't huge! Kid friendly food items and a huge selection for all kinds of eaters. Wait staff is super friendly and we've never had to wait for a table, they have tons of available seating options. We've eaten dinner there and their breakfast as well which is one of the best breakfasts I've ever had! read more

The Beach Pit - Huge prosecco glasses!! Absolutely love the Beach Pit every time we come to SGI - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

Good staff!!! Cute little outside seating area (loved the porch cat, Midnight) Steak was a little over seasoned, baked potato was really good. The southwest rolls were amazing! And teriyaki wings were good! Baby back ribs were pretty dry but the baked bean sides were delicious! Overall for a quick bite not bad, a bit on the expensive side for the quality. read more

If you want last weeks BBQ then this is your place. Very dry. Their fryer works though. The fried food was fine. read more

The Beach Pit - Brisket - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

Delicious bbq!!! had to go twice before our vacay was over!!!! The fried okra, chicken tenders and southern potato salad were amazing!!!! read more

The Beach Pit - Pork Sandwich with baked beans - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

See all

We've been here before and it's always good, from the menu to having them cook your catch. But I think this was the best ever. The service is excellent. Over two visits we had lemon pepper shrimp, seafood platter, fried shrimp and barbecue sampler plus the islander oysters. Everything was exceptional. Green beans, fried okra, baked beans and Brunswick stew are all wonderful sides. I think they have the best fried shrimp I've had in a long time. read more

Great food and service but they do charge a to go fee at $6.25 and don't tell the customers about it.

We went on a Monday night and it was pretty busy. They seemed like they may have been short on waitresses. I ordered the smoked turkey breast, fries and coleslaw. Needless to say I was very disappointed. The turkey was so dried out and overcooked. It looked dry and was like jerky. The smoke flavor was almost like a liquid smoke flavor. The two sauces they offered weren't very good either. One sweet and one spicy. I asked about white bbq sauce and they had no idea what that was. Fries were over cooked as well. Coleslaw was ok. My husband had a pulled pork sandwich and he said it was ok but he haha had better. For being the only BBQ place on the island they could really pack it in if they just maybe cut the menu down and focus on doing the basics really well. Our waitress was great but she was running the whole time. read more

Let's start with the positives the hostess was very polite and our server was polite and attentive. When it comes to their food it was not great. We had the oyster Rockefeller, side salad and brisket sandwich. The oysters were ok, brisket was fatty and the side salad was a joke. read more

Went for breakfast 2 times and it was great both times. Also went for dinner one night and was surprised they had a lot more options than just bbq read more

We ate here twice the week we were on the island. They have a great selection on the menu and it's always crowded.

Sad that the only positive for lunch was the side salad. As a local I have steered clear of this place because of my experience at their other business across the street, with poor food, but decided to give it a shot. Ordered ribs and stew and the baby back ribs were chewy, dry and no flavor (seasoning). Brunswick stew was way too sweet. Should be a sign disclaimer that says..."not southern BBQ". Fat daddy's will continue to be the BBQ go to for me in Franklin county. read more

Food is good for this location, quiet nice view, service is good, nice seafood, convenience location

The worst BBQ we have ever eaten. Do not waste your money on this place for BBQ it was dry and tasted like it was cooked last week.

My family and I got the burger, bbq sandwich, and the whole chicken. My sister ran into something hard in her burger and she said it was not very good. The bbq sandwich was just mostly fat. The whole chicken was very good though and it was cooked thoroughly. The service was nice and the employees were very sweet. There was a wild black cat on top of the tables so if you do not enjoy that do not go. read more

The Beach Pit - bbq sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

We stopped in this place during a storm looking for a new breakfast spot to check out. We got right in thankfully. The food was ok, wasn't bad but wasn't anything to rave about. We tried the meat lovers omelet which was decent but they only give one piece of bread with it. I ordered the French toast because it said cream filling so I thought it would be inside. Well, it's literally two pieces of bread with a line of whipped cream separating them that cost $8.50! No homefries or anything else comes with any meal. They also add a surcharge if you use a card. For high prices with mediocre food, we won't be skipping back to this place any time soon! read more

My partner and I went into this morning, they were very busy mind you. We were sat immediately and multiple tables were sat after us. No one came over to help us despite the whole service team walking by us at least once. People sat after us were helped before us. I overheard the host tell a server someone needs to help us and she said "that's not my section". We sat there for 15 minutes and eventually we walked out. If this place cannot accommodate all those people walking in they need to stop seating people. I was very frustrated seeing everyone who came in after us get help before us. I understand being a busy server (as I am in the service industry back home) but no one even touched our table to tell us they would be by soon. read more

We visited for breakfast. Food was fine, service was good, the owner, however... not good. he yelled at his employees on the floor in front of customer numerous times. The employees looked humiliated and it left our table feeling uncomfortable. I would not give him my business again. read more

This spot was my happy place at St. George - the crab legs were fantastic. Friendly atmosphere & our server was a darling - I wish I could remember her name. Will definitely be back! read more

The Beach Pit - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

Casual ambiance, seared tuna, grilled shrimp and brisket were the highlights. The sides of fries, onion rings, side salads were average. Fried okra, and southern potato salad were better. Loved the hot and sweet BBQ sauce, were excellent! Service is exceptional! read more

We had breakfast here. It was really good. The waffles and pancakes aren't 5 star, but they are good enough. The star was the breakfast steak. Man that was good. Son says it was the best meal he had on the island. Ham was great and eggs were good too. Service was good and the prices are good also. Certainly would come back. Especially since it's about the only sit down breakfast option. read more

The breakfast was very impressive. I wondered why they didn't ask me what kind of toast I wanted, because they don't give you toast with your breakfast. The plate looked so plain and the food tasted the same way. read more

Best seafood around. Service is great, food is even better. Breakfast is tops also. We tried others around the area and this one restaurant was always the same, never a bad experience. read more

The interior feels like a BBQ joint because that's what it is. But with the natural surroundings I wanted a bigger brighter atmosphere and less dark wood and tin corrugated. Got the ribs to go and the brisket. Ribs first - they didn't remove the back membrane. But the ribs were good, firm not fall off the bone mush which I really appreciate. Good flavor of smoke but needed a little salt. Overall though I really liked the ribs. Brisket - under seasoned. Good smoke nice melt and firmness and I appreciate that they gave me both lean and fatty cuts. Baked beans were okay, not great not bad just not special. There's brisket or pulled pork or both mixed in so they've got that going for them. Like the spicy bbq sauce. The regular sauce tasted like Sweet Baby Ray's. Maybe it is. Key lime pie was interesting, its a circle like tart of key lime pie. But it was good, not the best but solid. Pecan bourbon pie was to die for, got in a bit of a fight over who was going to finish and I lost it was that good. read more

The Beach Pit - Paddy's Key Lime pie on the left (typical wedge), Beach Pit BBQ key lime pie on the right (tart shaped) - Barbeque Near Me - St. George Island, Florida

The Beach Pit turned out to be a great choice for lunch. My husband had a grouper sandwich and I a burger. Both were quite good! Our server was very sweet and made sure we had everything we needed. The restaurant is kind of the typical rustic and worn styles that you would find in a fishing village. Price was middle of the road for a beach town. Sorry I didn't get any pics. We were starving and were too busy eating to snap a shot. Perhaps next time! read more

I don't understand how this good restaurant and the one across the street (Mango Mikes) could be owned by the same people. We ordered to go, got the beef plates with several sides. The beef was absolutely amazing! Tender, tender and tender! Bbq sauce was nice and thick with a bright full flavor. The baked beans and onion rings, I could eat every single meal. We had breakfast there also, pancake was slightly burned, but buried in the bottom of the stack. The bacon was cooked perfectly! Plus, they offer a man sized mimosa. The breakfast for 2 cost $10 more than lunch for 3, but both were very good. Such a Shame they can't get it together for Mango Mikes. read more

Four adults went for dinner, sat outside. The food was 4 star, but the slow slow slow service was 2 star, so ending with 3 stars. They did not have tap beer, something wrong with the keg switch. The server didn't know what they had not on tap. read more

See all

Food is good if you can get in. For a restaurant on a vacation rental island, the hostesses reaction to our party being a family of 12 is completely unacceptable. Quoted us an hour and a half when there were multiple empty tables and staff standing around in the bar area. We were relegated to getting takeout instead because their wait staff couldn't be bothered. Pretty shit tbh. read more