Was renting a temporary apartment in the area and come across The Comfort Diner. Mostly the reviews were good, but some people whined about their food lacking flavor. I ordered a rare burger with cheddar, lettuce and tomato for $14.00, it came with fries. First of all, their fries are fantastic. They came piping hot and stayed hot. The 1/2 pound burger was grilled between rare and medium-rare. It was perfect and flavorful. Even better was the staff, from the owner to the servers. I love a good diner. My favorite diner dish is a Hot Open Turkey Sandwich. Unfortunately The Comfort Diner doesn't have that on the menu. The best in the city is the Waverly Diner in the West Village and the Orion Diner on 23rd & Second. read more

Came here for a late breakfast. Very cool ambiance, throw back in time. Sat in a booth and just scanned the walls at the vintage items.. Great menu reasonably priced. Chose the red white and blue waffles! Food came quick and was very tasty! Service was great and attentive. Will be back! read more

The Comfort Diner - Red white and blue waffle! - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

This diner was across from our hotel, so we decided to give it a try. It was nice and quiet, which was a great change of pace from the hustle and bustle of this city. I got a Reuben and my mom got mini burgers. Pros: the sweet potato fries were delicious, my mom loved her mini burgers and LOVED the mashed potatos. Less than pro: the meat on the Rueben was so thick it made it tough to eat the sandwich. It was good, but really messy. It was also not the cleanest. Overall we would definitely come back! read more

The Comfort Diner - Sliders - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Comfort is definitely served here! Started with mozzarella wedges (to die for) you can tell they're fresh! Ordered them cause of their description on the menu and couldn't have done better. I got the pot pie after speaking to the gentleman asking what to get and he said people come 7 days a week and get it everyday and I CAN TELL WHY! Such a flaky crust, absolutely delicious I live in Boston but can't wait to go back. My boyfriend got the breakfast burrito and said it was amazing. DOES NOT DISAPPOINT has the classic diner vibes I was looking for, man I wish it was closer read more

The Comfort Diner - Comforting Chicken Pot Pie - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Oh man, it was a bummer to leave NYC on such a down note, but that's what we get for placing convenience over quality for our breakfast destination. Jamie W and I wanted to stick close to our hotel because the sidewalks were iced over with snow drifts embedded against buildings. We just wanted to find a family run greasy spoon where we could get our calorific guilty pleasures. Now how could we go wrong with a place called The Comfort Diner? Well, things started on a sour note when we were seated next to a mother and daughter who were having a loud and long exchange. The daughter tried to shush her, but mom was enraged about who knows what back in Queens. Welcome to New York City! Jamie was hoping to offset the squabble with the $16 Country Breakfast, which consisted of two scrambled eggs, two buttermilk biscuits, and a heaping side of white sausage gravy and grits (Photo 6). The eggs and gravy were OK, but the biscuits were stale tasting. I had the $16 Western Omelet which should've been a slam dunk with ham, peppers, and onions, but it was barely edible, so I subsisted on the decent home fries and sourdough toast (Photo 7). I don't know if the results were due to a faulty grill or a new cook or maybe we expected more. Judging from the extreme opinions about this place on Yelp, I'll go with my gut and find an alternative next time. FOOD - 2 stars...unfortunately mediocre AMBIANCE - 1.5 stars...we needed a Cone of Silence SERVICE - 2 stars...they came and went TOTAL - 2 stars...no comfort here read more

See all

Just grabbed breakfast here. Wonderful, fast service and the food was great! This was my second time eating here, and I will be back.

The Comfort Diner - Yelp Review (5 stars) Just had the most heartwarming, delicious breakfast with my family at this hidden NYC gem and I'm still smiling! Location & Vibe: 5/5 Tucked right across from Grand Central, this classic 1950s-style diner feels like stepping into a time machine--in the best way. Retro chrome stools, checkered floors, autumn scarecrows on the counter, and that unmistakable "old New York" energy. Even on a chaotic travel day, it felt like a warm hug. Food: 5/5 Everything was perfect: * Caesar salad on a sunny yellow plate that somehow made it taste even fresher * Gooey tuna melt with extra cheese dripping over the edges (yes please) * Veggie omelette loaded with spinach, mushrooms, and feta * Kid-approved grilled cheese + fries and a vanilla milkshake that disappeared in 30 seconds flatPortions are huge, prices are honest, and every bite tasted like someone's mom was back there cooking with love. Service: 5/5 The staff treated my kids like their own grandbabies. Refills appeared before we asked, high-fives for the little ones, and they even packed extra fries "for the train ride." That kind of genuine kindness you rarely find anymore. Bonus points: * Spotless retro bathrooms * Super family-friendly (booster seats, kids menu, zero side-eye when the 6-year-old did her dramatic "I'm full... JK one more fry" routine) * Perfect pit-stop before catching Amtrak--literally rolled out happy and full straight to our gate. If you want real diner food made with real care, in a place that still feels like 1955 but with 2025 cleanliness, RUN here. We're already planning our next NYC trip around another breakfast at Comfort Diner. P.S. That orange juice in the photo? Fresh-squeezed. Fight me. TL;DR: Best diner experience we've had in years. 10/10 coming back every single trip. PSA:: Wyndham Guest gets 10% read more

See all

Not my favorite diner in the city. Definitely very old school feel, but it's dirty and service is pretty bad. Food was surprisingly decent (great pancakes) read more

The Comfort Diner - Home fries, pancakes, coffee - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

I can't imagine running a small diner in the middle of Manhattan. I've been here a couple of times now and the food is delicious and the meat in the omelette I got is always fresh and tasty. Coffee is good and the service is quick. Not the cleanest place, but I actually like the grittiness. read more

The Comfort Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered the breakfast set for approximately $18. For the amount of food I got, this felt a little overpriced. The pancakes were good, but nothing special. The sausage was a little too greasy for me, but the eggs were done well. read more

The Comfort Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

The Comfort Diner was truly comfortable! My siblings and I stumbled upon this gem after finishing a transaction nearby. Before heading back to Grand Central, we decided we were in the mood for brunch. As we looked up, The Comfort Diner was practically glistening and beckoning us inside! We walked into a surprisingly packed diner that gave off the best '90s nostalgic vibe. Right away, we were offered two seating options and chose a cozy spot further back in the restaurant. Our server was friendly, attentive, and incredibly helpful throughout our visit. My sister and I shared The Comfort Breakfast, which came with eggs, grits, biscuits, and sausage gravy. It was AMAZING. I'm usually not a fan of gravy on my food, but this platter was hearty, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Special shoutout to the sweet, fresh biscuits -- chef's kiss! My brother ordered the lemon ricotta pancakes and The LEO -- a large platter loaded with lox, eggs, onions, home fries, and toast. Our server gave us a heads-up that the pancakes have a different consistency than traditional pancakes, and wow... they were some of the tastiest pancakes I've ever had. Sooo delicious! My other brother had the steak and eggs -- a hearty plate with zero complaints. He said it was genuinely delicious. Solomon, who we believe is the owner, even came over to greet us. Such a sweet man. I truly pray his business continues to thrive for many years to come! All in all, please try The Comfort Diner -- you won't be disappointed! read more

On a recent visit to NYC my wife and I were looking for a place to grab a quick bite before a meeting. One of the things we miss about NY/NJ is the diners, so given this opportunity, we stopped at The Comfort Diner as it was right around the corner from where our meeting was to take place. It's an old school diner for sure and was exactly what we wanted. You feel like you are stepping back in time about 50 years. Subway tiles on the wall, old art adorns the walls and lighting sconces. Just a quirky fun little spot in Manhattan. We both grabbed soup and a sandwich. The split pea soup was good and both sandwiches were delicious. I had a grilled cheese and it was perfect. Sometimes simple done well is exactly what's called for. Perfect goldeen brown crust with a gooey American cheese inside. It hit the spot. service was great. They took care of everything we asked. We will definitely stop in again. read more

Friendly. Hot coffee. Typical diner. Few short steps across from Club Wyndham 45 Hotel. Old decor. Served its purpose for a quick, convenient & hot meal. read more

Grubby diner, floor and walls are gross. needs a total overhaul and a real chef. Waffles all mushy, and zero presentation as everything piled on the plate. Basically avoid read more

Food was fresh and very tasty. Server was helpful and cheerful. Building is old of course but the inside does need some upkeep (blue painters tape still on walls and hanging off). read more

Came here for a quick breakfast and everything was delicious! We mainly just got your typical breakfast of eggs, potatoes, bacon! The people working were also very polite and it was perfect for what we needed. read more

The Comfort Diner - Hot chocolate - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

3 Stars for the food and 4 for ambience and excellent service Visited yesterday for a brunch date. The employees really made it a delightful visit. Food and coffee were typical diner fare. The interior has that nostalgic feeling. read more

This is where you wanna go for melt in your mouth lemon ricotta blueberry pancakes. Oh my gosh! They were so so good. Worth every penny. We also ordered the American breakfast which consisted two eggs, toast (we got sourdough!), and home fries for $12. We walked in at around 8am which was a good time to be there, but 20 minutes later it began to fill up and the one waitress on duty was snowed...so not the best experience service wise--the order came to us wrong; we asked for a warm cup of water and was given a cold bottle of water---but y'know, understanding the present situation helped keep everything positive for us. I'm hesitant to eat here again because, overall, things just felt so rushed and the prices are kinda high for your average diner. I came here specifically for these pancakes and they DID NOT DISAPPOINT. read more

See all

Have come here for years. Remember the owner Ira very well. We lived in the neighborhood. Awesome on all levels. Grits are in duh house. Delicious. The very cool furnishings and tile floor, bar stools, clocks, etc . Great service. Worth catching for sure. read more

Had to ask for everything, no tap water, food was bad. If you're looking for a diner in midtown east, look elsewhere

Terrible service. Over charged. My food wasn't cooked the pancakes were raw mix still. The reply by staff was that's the way they come. My daughter fell over in the toilet because of slippery floor, hurting her knee. read more

The food was really good and everyone was very nice, I love this place. I would definitely go back for those delicious fries.

Food 5 Service. 5 Ambiance. 5 Everything was awesome. I had the breakfast burrito and my wife had a Greek omelet. Fast and large portions and a fair price for manhattan. The service is over the top good. Had Christmas music on in a cozy old school diner. Highly recommended read more

The Comfort Diner - Old style diner in heart of manhattan - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Attentive service and a superb breakfast! The heartiest, most inventive and colorful corned beef hash anywhere. It had large chunks of corned beef, sweet and white potato, and beets, crowned with two poached eggs. A MUST for the corned beef fans everywhere! read more

Wonderful little place. Great big breakfast. Wonderful coffee! Love their cups. Bought one. Greeting and service were excellent. read more

The Comfort Diner - Exterior shot - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I ordered the fried chicken and waffle, the waffle part was delicious and probably one of the best I've ever had. It was soft and fluffy and didn't get soggy even though it sat in syrup. The chicken on the other hand was mediocre. Fried well with good spices on the crust, but the meat was too thin and didn't have the spice flavors. The meat was a little dry and I had to dip it in ketchup or syrup. Overall meal was pretty good. The service is good and the restaurant has the vibes of old time diners read more

The Comfort Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Just what you would expect from a long standing NY Diner - good service, large portions and great food. Visited twice during our stay - consistent quality and service. read more

It's an old timey New York diner. So few exist anymore these days. Not much in terms of street appeal. Came here for brunch on Easter Sunday and was seated right away. What more can one ask for? I had the eggs Benedict... instead of Canadian bacon, it was made of bacon bacon! Maybe not as healthy (if eggs Benedict can ever be thought of as healthy), but it was very tasty, especially with a perfectly poached egg and sauce. Coffee was just okay. "A glass of milk" meant whole milk. Service was quick and friendly, the server called us "honey" and "my love" throughout. There was even an old man (the owner?) greeting customers. My 15 year old was confused about what was happening. Just goes to show things are different now. The decor is definitely dated and could be original. No frills. I'm not mad at it. It's a bit cramped. But it adds to the charm in my view. read more

I feel bad about giving a bad review but I was there for over 30 minutes and my order never came. I informed 3 different staff about my order and nothing was done. One of the staff even tried to take the utensils out of my table to give another costumer. bad experience. My recommendation would be to go during low times and have lots of time (and not be hungry) when they are busy read more

I love me some good diner breakfast food! We decided to try this place out after the concierge at our hotel raved about the place, and we ended up enjoying it so much we ate there twice on our trip! This diner is locally owned and has been in business for over 80 years, so you know they're doing something right! When we walked in we had gotten there before it got busy, and were seated right away. After looking at the menu we decided to order the Pancakes, New Yorker, The Lox, Eggs, and Onions (second trip), and The All American (second trip). I am ABSOLUTELY a smoked salmon for breakfast now...especially after having the New Yorker. The combo of smoked salmon and capers was everything! My husband really enjoyed the pancakes as they weren't too thick, and loved the all American breakfast! I think our only complaint was the wait to get our orders taken, but the restaurant did get pretty hectic with how popular it is. The food more than made up for it. While we were waiting we were able to take in some of the interesting decor including the inappropriate children's book titles lol. Whenever we come back to this area, we will be sure to visit again! read more

See all

I was treated to lunch here. This place has such an old diner vibe. It was overflowing with nostalgia with its booth seats and menu choices like double-decker chicken club sandwiches and sweet potatoes fries. The service was friendly, and my food arrived pretty quickly. The food was simple and decent. The booth seats were very comfortable, it was relatively quiet so it was a very good place to sit and chat over your meal especially in this busy bustling area in mid-town Manhattan. read more

1st ones here this morning. Potatoes taste like they are yesterday's leftovers. Eggwhite "mexican" omelet was just ok...no salsa here...none!! At least they had tortillas, but waitress had to ask if she could get those for me! It's a Mexican Omelet! read more

All the staff was very nice but that's all I can say. I'd rather not mention anything else.

Amazing, retro diner, throwback, decor, eccentric wall, decorations, delicious food, awesome, comfort, food, five stars read more

The Comfort Diner - Comfort Dinner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Where do I start? Their prices don't overreach and meals are freshly made. The restaurant surpasses what praise can express. We received consistently good attention. This place warrants your immediate visit. read more

Nestled in the storefronts near Grand Central - this was our second breakfast choice of the trip. The front of the building looks like the steel diners, and inside there is small tile flooring and a bar you can sit at. Parts of the interior are somewhat run down, from defunct signage, to the front counter where they used to check people out. There's not wrong with that the places that are more concerned with the food rather than the decor are some of my favorites. We were sat in a booth quickly and ordered the standard water and coffee. I opted for the cheese omelet adding bacon - it came with home fries. What I like about places like this is the homefries aren't the orange cubes that everyone uses - these are cut potatoes which are seasoned and cooked with peppers and onions. The omelet was standard - nothing above or below par. Good start to the day - and recommended if in the neighborhood early. read more

See all

My experience here was excellent, with the beautiful venue a bonus. Their dishes preserve genuine flavors. The host welcomed us with a smile. People make this place successful. The team here is remarkably efficient. read more

The quick service BLT was a delightful reminder of simplicity, while the grilled cheese overflowed with warmth and comfort. The fries complemented the meal perfectly, showcasing how quick, easy, and good food can elevate our spirits. read more

A great place for breakfast or brunch. The menu is simple but service is fast and courteous. Prices are competitive. I recommend The Comfort Diner! read more

The Comfort Diner - a group of people sitting at a table - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I absolutely love The food at The Comfort Diner. You get prompt attention and pleasing tastes. The staff was notably outstanding. Their dishes show cooking skill and good flavor. This place delivers uncommonly well. read more