We stopped in here on a whim and it was really worth it. I got the fresh cream and my husband got a blueberry crisp and a coffee flavor. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Gelato in the small cup - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

See all

Huge selection of flavors, generous with free samples, and the gelato itself is great. Plenty of seating inside, too. The line and ordering system are pretty chaotic and disorganized. It's on the pricey side, and the space felt dirty during my visit. ​Worth it for the gelato, but they need to clean up and get the crowd control under control. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Netflix and chill flavor - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Rating: 4.4 Came to stop by for gelato as this place has great reviews and we were in the area since we stopped by the LL bean flagship store. There are 2 locations, one at Brunswick and Portland. From what i've heard Brunswick is better so we decided to try this location. They don't have designated parking but street parkings are available. We parked on the street parking and walked over. It's located on nice area where its center to many restaurants and shops. Once we entered the building we looked at their menu. They have extensive flavors and also sorbet and low sugar options. They do let you try and i've tried a few. I ended up settling with hazelnut and peanut butter flavor. The gelato has nice texture and flavorful. Not overly sweet either. Service was great and the staff was very attentive. Overall it's a pretty good gelato place. I like the flavors and the texture. Service is excellent. Price is bit pricey but not too bad. Only thing is that it was not necessary special or unique. But still a solid place. Good stop for sweet desert. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Hazelnut and peanut butter - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

This gelato is to die for. Omg. I love the low lighting, chill vibe. Very clean. The workers welcomed us. They were so nice and patient while we looked. I got lavender honey and WOW. It was so delicious. I don't even know how to describe it. Unique and just overall pleasant. I'm genuinely sad I don't have time to visit again before I head home from vacation. This is a must see! They do have dairy free options as well read more

See all

A friend recommended this spot to us and I'm so glad we stopped. This gelato was fantastic and one of the best frozen treats we've had this year. My husband and I shared: - Marscapone Pistachio Caramel - Italian Banana Pudding - Cake Batter All three flavors were incredible. They have so many awesome flavors and they let you sample as many as you want. I will stop by here every time I'm nearby. If you like ice cream and gelato, it's a must. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Marscapone Pistachio Caramel, Italian Banana Pudding Cake Batter - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

After overheating at the un-air conditioned Elevenses next door, my friend and I were desperate to cool down. Gelato Fiasco to the rescue! I ordered a small of the Maine Wild Blueberry Crisp gelato. It was heavenly. Portions were generous. Service was quick - no line - and very friendly. Ambiance was comfortable (and cool!). Such a lovely experience in all. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Small Maine Wild Blueberry Crisp gelato - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Such a cool spot in a fun area of Brunswick! After getting dinner next door, we were about to head to the theater to see a show and decided to stop in here to get a pick-me-up so that we could stay awake. My favorite food in the world is hazelnut gelato (NOT nutella/chocolate hazelnut), so I was thrilled to see a hazelnut option! I ordered an affogato with hazelnut and it really hit the spot. The service was friendly and fast even though the place was super busy. I'm told this is a local chain so hope I will stumble upon it elsewhere in my Maine travels! read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Stopped in last night after a walk around town for the 2nd Friday Art Walk. The vibe is authentic Italy. Crazy busy and yet, somehow organized. One server stayed with us from the time we walked in. We tried a couple samples - the blueberry crisp and espresso chip were both delicious. They've made over 1,500 flavors! It was ultimately Dorothy's Dream that won my heart. Cookie dough gelato with miniature chocolate kisses and bright red sprinkles. Celebrating MSMT's 2025 run of "Tootsie." Oh. My. Gosh. So delicious. A small was more than enough. My only wish is that there were more outside tables/chairs. ultimately went for read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Dorothy's Delight - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

I've been many times recently, and overall it is a great experience but there are a few things to be aware of. If you go when there is heavy traffic or an event at Bowdoin, you will be in a very long and slow line. Also, during the summer especially, when they keep opening the doors to the freezers and the door to the outside during these times, the gelato gets incredibly soft and melts really quickly, so you might want to opt for a cup instead of a cone. Other than a few flavors that are way too sweet for most palates, the gelato is incredible. The prices are reasonable for the portions and how filling it is. Also, they have a cool tipping system with poker chips. Parking can be tricky if you don't know downtown Brunswick, so be patient with that. Also, they have a really cool lounge in the back with lots of card and board games if you want to hang out. It is hard for me to avoid coming here when I go to Brunswick for dinner, and if the desserts at the restaurants don't have options that sound good, you always have this spot. Finally, most of the staff are really good at what they do. They can move through a line really quickly, even if it seems chaotic. You just need to hope that the people ordering in front of you know what they want. I've seen parties of 3-4 people take over ten minutes. I recommend the god of lightning coffee gelato. read more

A stark difference from the last gelato place I went to! I absolutely loved this place--the gelato was delicious, they nicely let me sample every vegan flavor, and they were so kind. read more

See all

Fantastic flavors; the highest quality ingredients; super friendly staff. Highly recommend!

We stopped twice during our week in nearby Harpswell, Maine. Great service, amazing variety of gelatos. Entering the shop the first point listed was that they encourage customers try as many complimentary samples. Wow. Our first visit I had the Dubai Chocolate - amazing and the mascapone and caramel - very good; Donna had the Plain Olde Peanutbutter and chocolate. Second visit I had the Chocolate Noir and Scicilian Pistachcio both were great! Donna had the Plain Olde Peanutbutter again and Chocolate Mousse. She loved them. read more

See all

Best Gelato ever and so many incredible choices! I live in California and for me, Maine has the best ice cream shops but I never thought it would have the best gelato shop too! One of the servers told me they have 200 different gelato recipes that they rotate! The choices were dizzying (in a good way) and I tried so many flavors. Not only are their flavors unique but their prices are so reasonable and the place is so clean (including the bathroom). What I really loved is all the different sizes they have so if you only want a little you can get just a little and pay for that amount. In California they won't let you order the kid size and if you want a smaller size you still have to pay the amount of the bigger size. These guys really cater to making the customer happy. I sure wish they had a branch here in SoCal. read more

See all

Service here is always friendly and fast. The gelato is great with a bunch of flavors. Never have had a bad experience in years of coming here. read more

Came in for an after dinner treat on Saturday, 3/15/25 around 9pm. It was busy! However the line moved fast and the staff were amazing! So patient, offered samples of anything we wanted to try! There were fun options, unique flavors and the classics. It's so cozy and inviting inside, always feels welcoming. This is a must have every time I am in Brunswick. read more

This place is amazing! We tried several different flavors before deciding on 3. My favorite was the passion fruit... it is SO good! I also got the strawberry with balsamic and blueberry cheesecake... oh my word! My husband got the chocolate peanut butter which was excellent as well. The customer service was awesome too... super friendly employees who seemed happy to serve their customers. Wish we lived closer. read more

Always have to stop in when in the area. Since I live in Florida it's only once or twice a year. The coriander gelato is a must have! This trip I got the coriander, Maine Blueberry and the marscapone caramel pistachio. So good and the staff is the best! read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Coriander, Maine Blueberry, Marscapone caramel pistachio - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Fantastic. This place is located on Maine St. (the "Main Street" of Brunswick), has three? small tables outside to people watch while enjoying your treat. I first stopped in just to see what it was about: flavors they had, if the gelato is made locally, etc. Staff was friendly, offered as many samples as I wanted although I only took one: toasted coconut. Delish! All gelato is made in-house; they have a kitchen in the back. They feature a new flavor every Friday and this Friday's was a Sicilian pistachio. My plan was to stroll Maine St. then stop back by. When I returned, I chose a "medium" combo of the daily flavor and a refreshingly tart lemon in a waffle cone. I felt that the portions were generous and the price was fair for what I got and for the area: $8 which included a $1 tip. See pic. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Daily flavor of Sicilian pistachio, and lemon gelato - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Fantastic assortment of gelato. Well worth the drive. Very unique flavors. Don't get a large by yourself, you can't eat at all. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Large two scoop gelato - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

Visiting for the weekend and friend recommended this small shop in a cute downtown. Plenty of street parking. Very reasonably priced. Fast and efficient service. Seating outside. Just as good if not better than European gelato. The hazelnut is OUT OF THIS WORLD. Best flavor. The dark chocolate is super rich and intense. The Netflix and Chilled is a great combination of salted caramel, brownie, peanut butter cup and maybe magic. A little extra sweet but so fun and reminiscent of childhood. The waffle cone is fresh and only a small $.93 up charge. Totally worth it. No dog ice cream specific but the vanilla and cream flavors are safe per the staff. read more

See all

This place had tables full outside as I walked by so I had to stop in and check it out. I am glad I did! It has a cafe vibe inside, very dark walls but bright display cases. Tons of flavors of gelato and sorbet! Staff is happy to provide samples of flavors. I love that they use reusable spoons for their sampling spoons! Tons of indoor seating and good options outside too. The small size is quite generous so I am glad they also offer a "taste" size! read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Maine blueberry crisp gelato (small) - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

The gelato is amazing, but the service really made the experience memorable in the best way. It was my friend's birthday and we got her a little headband and pin that stated such. The gentleman behind the counter greeted us all with so much enthusiasm and friendliness and really went out of his way to make her feel so special on her birthday. He let her try whichever sample she wanted to and happily answered all of her questions. We both got the caramel cookie crunch and she also got regular caramel and they were delicious. Will come back again very soon - thank you for making her birthday amazing! read more

Was exploring downtown Brunswick on a warm-ish fall day - decided to pop in for some gelato and I'm so glad I did! I tried the blood orange flavor and it was fantastic!! Location is perfect - right in the heart of the main area downtown with all the cute shops and park area. Staff are inviting, helpful, and friendly. Vibe is cozy and chill (no pun intended lol) - lots of comfy seating and nice decor - definitely a great place to enjoy your icy treat while people watching on the main street. They have lots of great flavors - traditional and some interesting ones too - but the blood orange got my attention. I loved it! Great texture - soft with some orange bits in it. So light, refreshing, and full of orangey deliciousness!! Will happily stop in anytime I'm in the area! read more

See all

Had to try this place since I love the one in Portland so much. It's pretty much exactly the same. Interior design wise it is pretty much the same. Very whimsical. If you see this before the month of February is over I hugely recommend some of their monthly specials like the Italian Banana Pudding, Passionfruit Raspberry, or the German Chocolate Cake. The service is always friendly and helpful - you can bring kids here and trust they will love it. There is not a ton of seating but I love seeing that it is always busy even in the dead of winter - that's how you know they're doing something right. read more

Staff is always super friendly! You can never go wrong with a "treat", or more of Gelato Plenty of seating either indoors our outside. Plenty of games to play or just sit and catch up with friends. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Giving back to the community! - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

See all

The BEST Gelato on planet earth! LITERALLY CHANGE YOUR LIFE GOOD! And im not exaggerating! I (& my company) tasted divinity when we went here. The seasonal, Apple Cinnamon Dairy Free Gelato changed my life. It was all you love about apple pie with vanilla ice cream, in one spoonful, that was so creamy I had to double check... dairy free !?! WOW IT CHANGED MY LIFE! I can only pray they open one down here in NYC or Jersey! They should go nation wide! Their method and recipes are out of this world. I sampled 6 and got 3 , which they were very nice about. It felt almost encouraged. You get what you like and how you like it without it being limited like other shops. I should also note their customer service was exceptional! Warm, friendly, polite! Angelika was a treat! Someone you'd hope to meet on your travels, as we did a true asset to this business. The others we met were just as kind and helpful. Truly such a nice store! They were spacious and cozy inside with nice couches and furniture, board games, and a nice family feel. Where you can go and catch up with friends and not be rushed out! It was truly special and so happy we found it! Truly this place made my entire trip! I'm still dreaming and wondering how they made that special gelato... how it was so velvety smooth , packed with flavor... I could only describe it like when you would get good cold stone creamery, it's like that but BETTER! (Yes there's another level and they've unlocked it!) I'm telling you they can win awards and go global between their service model and product! I'm so happy my friend took me here and found them! If you're thinking of going, this is your sign! It'll be one of the best desserts of your life! You won't be disappointed! They have parking out front as well! Thanks for delicious Memory Gelato Fiasco! read more

See all

I had a cup with half passion fruit and half blueberry. Both were exceptionally flavorful. I can't say one was better than the other as they were both great! Definitely coming back here again! read more

Came here on a very hot day with young kids. The server was great and offered us several tastings. Nice play to go to get out of the heat.

Not much to say but it's all amazing and deserves all the love. The food is delicious i suggest house chocolate and raspberry truffle. The staff are very calm with me. The decor is very art deco and butiful. I do recommend. read more

I have stopped here for years for a late night coffee milkshake to keep me awake on the drive home but the last two times they were mostly milk and very thin. Hope this is just a server issue not a cost cutting new normal. read more

Loved the gelato so many flavors to choose from and amazing hot chocolate all of the workers were so nice overall would recommend if you are in the area. read more

The gelato is the best that I've had since Rome! Amazingly smooth, rich, and flavorful. Bunch of new flavors since my last visit, too! The staff were all very friendly and patient with my kids and their request for numerous samples. read more

If I could give Gelato Fiasco in Brunswick more than five stars, I would--this place is supercalifragilisticexpialidocious in every sense of the word! As someone with dietary needs, I cannot express how deeply I appreciate the thought and care that goes into every detail here. The color-coded spoons? GENIUS. Red means no dairy, black means dairy--simple, clear, and so considerate. That small detail shows just how much they truly care about their customers. And don't even get me started on the sample policy: unlimited samples and zero judgment?! That's the kind of radical kindness I live for. Want to try six flavors before you commit? Go for it. Want to mix and match in your final cup? Slay. You can have multiple flavors in one dish and no one bats an eye. It's a flavor party and everyone's invited. The atmosphere is cozy, the staff are always friendly and patient, and the gelato itself? Out of this world. Whether you're dairy-free, gluten-sensitive, or just a lover of pure deliciousness, Gelato Fiasco is the bomb place ever. If you're in Brunswick, this is not just a recommendation--it's a must. read more

Some of the best gelato I've had anywhere in the world. They're friendly and unpretentious to boot. Don't miss it. read more

I'll keep this simple: good gelato. A few facts and opinions: - they sell by volume, so if you want a medium with 6 different flavors, the scooper might be annoyed, but you could apparently do it. (Tip well if you do) - among the 3 + 2 flavors we got [blueberry (something with granola), pumpkin (not spice with chunks of graham cracker crust), banana creme brulee, salted caramel, and mango], mango was the clear winner. The more complicated the mix, the less true the flavor. - pick your favorite, but strongly suggest that you stick with the basics like fruit or chocolate. Enjoy! read more

The Gelato Fiasco - The store front - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

See all

What's there to say? Tons of flavors--something for everyone. Open late which is really great. You can sample whatever you want. A little on the pricey end but I guess that's 2023 for you. Try the Wild Maine Blueberry, any of the peanut butter flavors, the chocolate, doughing me doughing you. read more

It pains me to say that Gelato Fiasco in Brunswick, which is the flagship store has really gone down hill. There were only two people working on a hot summer day. There were a lot of customers there but the service was slow. They were not even offering samples which was always a big selling point to get their product out. They used to make a lot of different flavors and the sampling was helpful to taste before you buy. They had less than half of what they used to offer two years ago. I understand that Covid played a big role in the service industry but sometimes you need to stick with what made you a shining example pre pandemic. I did order the brownie batter and Sweet resurgam. These are my two personal favorites. The flavors were spot on, even though the gelato serving size was much less than it used to be. It is always nice to go back and they are still offering the "red spoon" club, which keeps track of your purchases and allows you to get a free gelato. Thank you for maintaining this perk! read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Sweet Resurgam and Brownie Batter small size Gelato - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine

I had to come back here on my return trip to Brunswick. They are still great and will even spilt the little "treat" sized serving. Check it out! read more

I will stamp my name to add to the 5-star rating for this place. Whole-heatedly recommend it. My main reason for the review was the service. Don't get me wrong, the gelato was plenty tasty and on-par with what I would expect from a solid gelato place, but what really made me happy what how incredibly attentive and personal the woman behind the counter was to me and my wife. I feel embarrassed that I don't recall her name, because she deserves a shoutout. As somebody who has worked in customer service for over 15 years, this girl really impressed me. She was running the place all by herself, but she had such a passion and personality that really took me by surprise. Normally when you come into a drop-in food service establishment, you expect a pretty blasé expression from the staff because hey, you're just serving gelato. But this young woman was just so excited and friendly. Not only did she make tons of recommendations for samples, but she asked engaging questions, and even went into deep detail about each gelato we were trying, giving us deeper insight into how they are made and/or sourced. It was truly delightful. And then, when she had multiple customers, she managed to help multiple people at the same time, without sacrificing the experience of anybody. She used very clear language to get permission from us before multitasking with somebody else, and it was just such an over-the-top amount of hospitality for a simple gelato joint. I know the kind of effort that takes, and I really wish I knew her name so I could give her the proper admonishment she deserves. My wife and I each got a medium scoop on waffle cones, and they were fantastic. I wish we weren't just on vacation, because we would keep coming back to sample more flavors if we lived in this area. read more

Favorite Dessert place in town. The gelatos are delicious. I stop by here every time I'm in Maine. I enjoyed the fall flavor (Apple Mascarpone Pecan) gelato. read more

The Gelato Fiasco - Apple Mascarpone Pecan (Treat size) - Desserts Near Me - Brunswick, Maine