Good pizza but the price is what makes it just ok, compared to the nearby Wild West Pizza

Great Pizza!! Hot and fresh. They had green olives for a topping choice. Love! They have a fun bar area to have a Moose Drool while you wait. We got our pizza to go. read more

This is a place that locals might go to as well as tourists. The pizza was good...not the best I have ever had but it was good. Prices are reasonable, especially for a tourist town. The inside of the place isn't anything to get excited about. There is a video game room before the dining area that has gambling machines. In the main hall are a couple of video games for kids. The tables/seats/floors are well worn, but hey, its a pizza joint. If you want a low key, inexpensive meal then this is a good place to go. read more

We ordered the make-your-own pizza withe garlic, chicken, artichoke hearts and fresh tomatoes. Yummy! The family was just enough for 4 adults and 3 small kids. Everything was great! read more

Decent pizza - abysmal waitstaff - they omitted the pepperoni and mushrooms from our pizza sending us an olive pizza. - when we asked for them to fix this - they first offered to just not charge us for those items - I said no that I would like like the pizza we ordered- they then brought us a plate of broiled pepperoni - I said no that this was just not the same and asked that they please remake our pizza. The waiter then offered in a very confusing way that they would take the incorrect pizza away and still charge us for it??? But give a small correct pizza for free. I said no and my husband approached the very reluctant manager that he had to search out - the manager agreed to give us a free pizza - the restaurant then switched servers on us without giving the poor girl a heads up about the situation- in her defense she did great / but when she came with our bill we were still charged for the first pizza - that the server had removed from the table - after another 10 min they finally came back to the table with a correct receipt. After looking at a few other reviews this seems to be a fairly common event at this otherwise decent restaurant- so just know that you are taking your chances with this one. read more

We were super hungry after a tiring day at Yellowstone and was not sure which place to pick for dinner. We turned lucky as this place was at walkable distance from our Hotel room and we just randomly picked it as it was near. The staffs were really nice and welcoming. We ordered veggie sandwiches and garlic bread. It was very tasty, hot and fresh. They do have a TV and we had a nice time watching it (Olympics 2016) while having food. read more

If we're in town again, we will definitely be back. The pizza was really good and the service was outstanding. We visited twice during our recent vacay. The only weird thing was while dining, a group of theater students came in singing and in costume. They proceeded to invite the diners to their show and passed out flyers to everyone... everyone but US, the only non-white people in the restaurant. LOL We laughed it off, but never expected this kind of behavior from a group of theatrical teenagers; clearly racism is a learned behavior. I want to make it clear that this is not the restaurant's fault, but I do want to recommend to the owners that they ban solicitors from barging in so as to not make the customers uncomfortable. read more

Great pizza! The crust was perfect, all the ingredients on the pizza (pepperoni, black olives, Canadian bacon, mushrooms, sausage) were perfectly matched. We were in pizza heaven. read more

Service here leaves a lot to be desired! We did however get a fairly decent pizza which really hit the spot after a long day in the park.

The pizza was not great - way too much dough and hardly any sauce. But everyone was really nice and the wait was short.

I have to go against the majority of reviews and go with a 4 on a 5 scale. The garlic bread was good and the service supreme. We visited for lunch and got a deluxe 12 pizza. The meat and cheese was plentiful and the crust was sweet and baked just right. I am a fan and will be back if there is time during our visit. read more

The BBQ Beef pizza was mouth-watering, and don't be afraid to make your own pizza-- it's all fantastic! Great place for groups and families, nice atmosphere. Definitely recommend if trying to get a hearty amount of good food for a decent price. Would definitely come back! read more

Very ordinary place it reminds me of my old middle school cafeteria. Utensils are served in a wax holder, food is sub par, and the ambience is very 80s. Probably won't be coming back here again. read more

Fabulous pizza. We had the Gusher, the taco and the cheese. All were wonderful. Service was fabulous. Great for our large group and very kid-friendly. Beer unique and good. Homemade thousand island dressing was great as well. read more

The best place we ate in our trip to Yellowstone! The price was good for anywhere, not just Yellowstone. The staff was AWESOME! Friendly, nice, welcoming! Totally awesome! The food was good, for anywhere, not just by comparison of the other places in the town which suck. It is one of the better pizzas I've had in a long time. read more

I was told the crust was bready. I like when the outer crust is bready, but the entire pizza was that way, and it overpowered the toppings and made the pizza bland. I'd ordered the supreme which had 8 toppings, and was expecting I would taste them a lot more. The 16" supreme was $28 and change. read more

Great pizza and GREAT local beer. The service was fast and attentive. We ordered the pepperoni pizza, a pizza with all the veggies , beer (I can't remember the name but it was local and wonderful). read more

I was there on my summer vacation. We got to the hotel rather late. It was only at 9:30 and nearly all the restaurant closed. What the heck! I just walked along the street and felt hopeless, honestly. This restaurant saved my life. Lol. But it was more than what I expected. I ordered the steak and pizza (I didn't remember the name) and they were all awesome. The steak was rather expensive, but I had salad and one side so it was good. The waiter was really handsome, cute and helpful. The place was also really beautiful. Love this place. I would like to come back if I have chance to go to Yellowstone again :D read more

Disappointing at best. The cheeseburger was inedible. Had a plastic taste and a smell to it. The patty clearly was made somewhere else, char marks on it were fake. Unfortunately the fries and the Coke were the best part of the meal. read more

We just had the morning glory vegetable pizza. It was very good. The atmosphere is exactly what you should expect in a tourist town family restaurant but the pizza was much better than most. People were friendly too. read more

Basic food, small dinning area and sometimes felt like I was walking into a locals only spot....

The food here is outstanding. Had chili, hot wings, and pizza. The food was piping Hot and delicious. Service was great as well. If your in West Yellowstone then eat here! read more

Decided to give a try despite some poor reviews. Big mistake. Pizza tasted like an over cooked DiGiornio freezer pizza - no flavor at all. It tasted even worse when we realized just how expensive it was. Onion rings were bland. Kids meals were pricey and didn't taste any better. The only happy person at the table was my four-year-old - he ordered Kraft Mac n' Cheese. The upside was the service was pleasant and fast; our waitress was nice and attentive. But overall we were disappointed with the restaurant and wouldn't visit again. read more

Solid pizza, crust more on the thicker/fluffy instead of thinner/crunchy side. Recommend getting the extra cheese. They made us a pizza just after 11pm when only the bar was open so a great option late! read more

Just barely ok. After a long day, it's something warm to eat. Service was ok, pleasant and what I'd expect but the pizza was nothing to brag about. Not a place I'd recommend nor go back to. read more

We will definitely be back! Great pizza, and great burgers! Very friendly staff. Highly recommend the Asiago and mushroom bites.

We went in on a Wednesday night got seated right away. Our waitress was great if not a little over worked, even with other servers just standing around. She did her best and was very nice and attentive. Our order came out quickly enough and looked very good. The chicken Caesar salad was good but had way too much dressing. The pepperoni pizza was also good but was more of a deep dish pizza, wish is not my favorite at all. I prefer thinner crust. I guess I would go here again because the food was good just not my personal preference. read more

Friendly waitress and fast service, but the food was horrible! Very expensive too! We came to the restaurant super hungry from a full day hiking in Yellowstone and ate about 2% of the food read more

Unfortunately, we received poor service. The server was rude, and left our food sitting out by the kitchen. My cold grilled cheese and potato soup was nothing special. Atmosphere felt too homely for West Yellowstone. read more

Not a bad place to grab a pizza. The price for a salad was a little high and would have been better if it was discounted with pizza purchase. I heard there was better pizza in town, we just did not have time to try the others. read more

This restaurant worked for our family after visiting three other restaurants with no children's menu. The food was ok and the staff were friendly. read more

It is literally Pizza Hut pizza. Not bad but certainly not worth the mark up. Service was nice albeit a tad slow. read more

Relatively quiet place to get a cheap meal in an otherwise expensive region. However, you do get what you pay for. The pizza was average with a lack of actual sauce. My main complaint is how much crust there was. It was pretty bready, but it was still better than most pizza I've had and certainly better than pizza hut. Just make sure to get water if your not into alcohol. Refills on soft drinks are NOT free, and a pitcher will cost almost $10. It will do in a pinch, but diner beware. read more

Really great food, we had 4 different types of pizza within our party of 8 people, and everyone left with smiles on their faces and very full tummies! Also had mixed veggies appetizer, which came with a side of house-made ranch that was so good, I considered eating it with a spoon. Service was great, very quick and our server was personable and extremely efficient. If/when we travel back to Yellowstone National Park, Gusher's will be a "must" on our restaurant list! read more

Ugh over priced poor food. Wrong orders. Tried it twice figuring maybe it was an anomaly. Yes people were nice but it didn't make up for it. Try 3 bears! read more

If you like frozen pizza crust, then this place is for you. It smelled freezer burnt as well. We've eaten pizza in many places over the years, and this was by far one of the worst we've ever tried. They advertised beer but then couldn't serve it because of licensing issues. Luckily it was cheap food and we didn't feel so bad throwing most of it away. read more

The food was great! Service was attentive, especially considering that we rolled in with 18 people- unannounced! Lots of choices, something for everyone. Minus one star because it was slightly pricey- $23 for a medium pizza is a little high. read more

Terrible pizza we couldn't even eat. Since we were starving we ate two slices and threw the rest out. My side salad was lettuce with 1 microscopic piece of cucumber and two microscopic pieces of celery. Plus it cost us 30$ with you can spend getting a really nice meal elsewhere. read more

Usually busy, but they're still fast in getting your party a seat. Service is polite and efficient. Pizza crust is fresh and crispy and doesn't turn soggy like most places. Got the Gusher and all ingredients were fresh and high quality. Ate here years ago with my family and made it a point to find it again. It is as good as we remember. read more

The best pizza I have had in a long time...... and the staff was very friendly and the service was fast... I was impressed and wish I could get another pizza like this in Georgia!!! read more