Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Hayloft

    4.6 (43 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Order The Hayloft Takeout or Delivery

    The Hayloft Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like The Hayloft

    Recommended Reviews - The Hayloft

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    I love the changing cookie flavors. The banana is one of my favs!
    Hannah F.

    Anytime that I'm in Brownsburg on a Saturday I like to stop in at The Hayloft to get some cookies. I love browsing the shop and looking at the local meat, jams, cupcakes, mixes, and Indiana wines. It's such a wonderful little store. The cookies are similar size to Crumbl and come in a cute little box too. I can't resist!

    Cutest local shop with allllll the goodies

    Such an adorable local shop! Can get anything from fresh meat to fresh flowers! The cupcakes and cookies were super yummy. Definitely check it out!

    FromTop Left Red velvet and Carrot Cake From bottom left Cookies and Cream and the Hayloft
    Jessica M.

    My family and I are always looking for sweet treats. The Hayloft is perfect and close to home. The bakery has awesome treats for everyone in my family. We have cookie lovers, cupcake fiends, and cake pop fanatics. There's literally something for everyone. Priced right for what's offered. There's also a small market that has meats, cheeses, and other odds and ends from local farms and vendors. Haven't tried any of that but looking forward to on another visit.

    exterior
    Ken N.

    I enjoy shopping local, especially when the independent shop carries mostly local artisan products. Such is the case with the Hayloft, tucked away in a corner of the Main Street Shoppes on US 136/Main St east of Hornaday Road. The shop doesn't have a lot bright colors to draw your attention so I drove around a bit just to find it. I also thought the store front a little dark (my wife thought the place was closed), but once inside, the two room shop was much brighter and appealing. The main room you enter has the order counter in the rear with coolers filled with meats, eggs, and other food items on the right. There were also lots of mixes, snacks, and other items. The room to the left carries coffees, sweatshirts, gift bags (?), and more canned goods. I ended up having a bag of coffee beans ground for me and picked up a mix for baked mushrooms. The woman behind the counter was friendly and answered my questions while she ground the coffee (no extra fee.) While we chatted, I noticed the order counter had lots of baked cookies and a display of cupcakes, but since I was going for ice cream after my visit, I passed on the treats. A nice shop for finding quality items while supporting local (90% of the items in store are locally/Hoosier made). Review #3737

    Wanda M.

    I was warmly greeted as I entered this cute little shop. The shop carries dairy, meats, fruits, herbs, flowers, fresh veggies, bottled sauces, mustard, preserves, pastas plus more. The Apple Chicken Patties, Sirloins and Jalapeno Cheddar Brats were tempting but I'll wait until we're grilling out. The Hayloft also bakes their own Cookies, Lemon Bars, Flourless Chocolate Cake and several different flavors of cupcakes. The Flourless Chocolate Cake is rich, gooey, creamy and sinfully good. The Snickerdoole Cookies were soft, flavorful and perfect. The Lemon Bars are the perfect size with a paper-thin crust, not overly sweet lemon filling topped off with a thin topping of powdered sugar. I'm glad to see a fresh, farm market in the little town of Brownsburg. I'm curious to try out more products and see what new products arrive seasonally.

    Liberation Roasting coffee
    April K.

    What a great little store and a nice addition to Brownsburg. I found lots of great local products like Fisher Farms, Cornerstone bakery, and Liberation Roasting. It's also next to a Wyliepalooza Ice cream emporium so tons of gumminess in this little corner. I think with a place like this, Brownsburg can really get on the map as a place on the far West side to represent all that Indy has to offer. I'm not too close to here but it was worth the drive to check it out and support local businesses. There is a great section for fresh herbs and also frozen meat. There are also freshly in house made cupcakes. I'm definitely impressed with what the Hayloft has to offer.

    Wedding cake cupcake

    See all

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Heidi E.
    46
    30
    17

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Sarah A.

    Sarah A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - The Hayloft

    Does the Hayloft deliver Keto bakery items within Brownsburg IN?

    We do deliver within 10 miles and a $50 minimum order. Delivery is $5!

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    Review Highlights - The Hayloft

    This little farm-to-table store offers LOCAL Indiana meats, cheeses, sauces, jams, preserves, chips, milk...

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Grocery 1,895 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Walmart Supercenter

    Walmart Supercenter

    2.2
    (26 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$

    It's that time of the year and this Walmart partners with The Salvation Army to offer Angel Trees…read moreinside the store for underprivileged children.....and YES for seniors too, known as Silver Angel Trees. Yay!! The Salvation Army suggests you spend between 25-125 dollars per Angel. If going inside Walmart is not possible for you, no worries you can still give by visiting "The Salvation Army's Walmart Angel Tree" page and enter your zip code to find a registry near you. From there you can shop for the items online and have them delivered by Walmart Spark Good Registry to a local Salvation Army. Keep in mind not all Walmarts have actual Angel Trees inside. To locate a Walmart with an actual Angel Tree, visit the Salvation Army website. Remember the Angel Tree program does have a deadline and it varies by location. See ya there!!

    Typical big store, predictable hit and miss staff, inventory, and general disarray of trying to…read morefind items slightly swapped around from other locations I am used to. Payless and Fresh Thyme are the much better options not only for easy shopping but supporting local growers who provide much better quality produce. Walmart continues to hold back decent pay to its staff, add to the insane food waste generated by ignoring proper expiring food discounts and discolored fruits and veg, until that changes I got to tell everyone avoid and shop anywhere else where there's some access like at Kroger to help reduce waste and make good use of good farmer products.

    Photos
    Walmart Supercenter
    Walmart Supercenter
    Walmart Supercenter

    See all

    Trader Joe's

    Trader Joe's

    4.6
    (167 reviews)
    10.3 mi
    $$

    This was our first visit to Trader Joe's in a few years, and honestly, I have no idea why we…read morestopped going. We filled a heaping cart with groceries and spent just a little over $100--something that seems nearly impossible at most grocery stores today. The quality, selection, and prices were outstanding. What really made the experience memorable was Neal at checkout. Neal was friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely took the time to talk with us about Trader Joe's products and commitment to quality ingredients. In a world where customer service often feels rushed, Neal made us feel welcome and appreciated as customers. The store was clean, well-stocked, and full of healthy, affordable options. Between the value, quality, and exceptional customer service, we've officially rediscovered Trader Joe's. A big thank you to Neal for making our visit such a positive experience. We'll definitely be back--and this time, we won't wait a few years!

    I absolutely love Trader Joe's, and while I usually shop at the E. 82nd St. location I occasionally…read morestop by this location when I am on the west side of town. I'm very happy that Indianapolis has TWO Trader Joe's locations while many cities have none at all. Employees are always incredibly friendly and helpful. And it is never difficult to find someone to assist. I always check out the plants first, as I often find something I need to add to my collection. Some of my TJ favorites: Cheese of all varieties but especially Unexpected Cheddar, Cottage cheese, yogurt, peanut butter, squiggly knife cut noodles, Danish Kringle in all varieties, peanut butter cups, frozen mashed potatoes, frozen hash browns, and too many other things to list. There is always something new and different to try at Trader Joe's, and I often stop in just to see what is new. It is always a fun experience and great place to shop.

    Photos
    Trader Joe's
    Trader Joe's
    Groceries

    See all

    Groceries

    The Hayloft - grocery - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...