This place is great. Went on a Sunday morning. I didn't have a wait, the server was friendly, and the food came out fast and hot. Had the mushroom Swiss omelette with hash browns. I love that they have the scattered hash browns and not the patties. The costs was affordable and I took home leftovers. Will be back! read more

Very rude waitress Kim Ruined our meal and upset us She was too busy eating herself to want to stop and wait on a table Food was t good enough to put up with that fat hose bag read more

Great service with amazing breakfast. Best chocolate chip pancakes around with big portions.

Great food. Good atmosphere. Friendly customer service. Next time I'm in town I'll be heading to Sam's.

Great food close to home, service makes you feel like you've been on of the regulars for years. The type of ambiance you not only tell your friends & family about. But want to bring them to! read more

Best diner ever! service was great! The servers were friendly food was to die for !! Yess coming back again

Sam's Diner great food and customer service 5-stars. Will be returning next time I'm in town.

It was a seat yourself diner, with no signs. The server came over quickly and greeted us. Breakfast stops at 11:30, didn't see that anywhere until we got there. Cute old diner with lots of regulars. Food was mediocre at best. Got a side salad and the lettuce was wilted/brown. Food had barely any seasoning and chicken was dry. I'd suggest a sandwich and nothing more. They forgot our additions. read more

not cheap. Every price went up but KIDS MEALS went up 40%!!!! please reconsider. Fast food might be next choice. No french bread anymore for pasta read more

Waitresses are always cheerful, great interaction and very alert when you walk in and greet you and ask you if you would like something to drink and allow you to take your time to decide look at the menu and come back and ask you if your ready to order or if you need a little more time never had a bad meal there weather it be breakfast, lunch, or dinner it's worth the drive we're ever you live highly recommended read more

This is a gem in Holley which is a 5 min drive from Brockport. The menu is huge! My husband's fried chicken was great & the coleslaw was the best either of us had ever had! I'd love to get the recipe! I had a stuffed ground beef burger which was nothing special. I should have tried something else! The chili was good & the crisp bread they served with it was great. It would have been good instead of the sub roll I had. Our waitress was so nice, informative, & not a hoverer!! read more

See all

We had a terrific breakfast at Sam's and the coffee just kept coming. The everything omlete was huge. I could only eat half if it. My husband had two eggs, pancakes, and bacon. This classic small town square diner was perfect. We also took a walk to the nearby falls located down a path behind the diner near the historical society. read more

See all

Very nice diner. We were in Brockport looking for somewhere to eat and this was only about 5 minutes away. They had a large selection and the diner was clean and neat. The dinners were tasty and if I'm looking for a diner I would definitely go here ahead. Bonus, Holly falls is about 2 minutes down the road and gorgeous! read more

See all

My wife and I went here for dinner last Friday and really enjoyed it! They have a wide variety on the menu and the food was delicious! Our waitress was very friendly too! read more

Sam's Diner - Diners Near Me - Holley, New York

Wow! We need more of these type of diners in Buffalo.... fair prices, excellent food, huge menu, and, of course, nostalgia! I worked up an appetite hiking around Holley falls, so we were definitely in the mood to eat once we got seated, I ordered a chicken deluxe sandwich (with ham and swiss) and opted for macaroni salad as a side ..... my father got a cheeseburger club (a new twist on a club that needs to be added to every menu) with chips . The bill with 2 beverages only ended up being a little over $20 ! Service was friendly and quick, just what you would hope for! And the food hit the spot! Thank you Sam for providing such an awesome dining experience! read more

See all

Friday fish fry hot spot. Cute hometown diner with fresh homemade food and friendly service. Portion sides are big so be prepared for a "doggie" bag. Little disappointed in the rice as a side. It came out and was cold so I sent it back as the server put in microwave. Tasted like it was old and the waitress was happy to replace it with a side of homemade Mac and cheese which was creamy and delicious. read more

Sam's Diner - Side salad - Diners Near Me - Holley, New York

See all

They have the best fish fry around ! Wow 85 characters-I'll try . The fish fry is haddock NOT cod and it is wonderful .

Great food and fast polite service! Highly recommend especially in a small little town! Thank you!

The breakfast is the best around! Most of the waitresses have worked there for years, so it's always a friendly face.

I used to be a regular here for years. It hurts to write this, but the quality and service have seriously tanked lately. My wife and I went there for breakfast a couple times. We waited a half hour for what was essentially eggs, potatoes, and toast. Meanwhile, 2 other tables who were seated after us were served before us. The hash browns were clearly frost bitten, and tasted like nothing. The eggs were overcooked. It looks like Sam's has become a glorified cafeteria, where they just heat up canned or frozen stuff, with nothing that's truly their own. Do they no longer care? After all these years, I am very disappointed. read more

It occurred to me that I have eaten more than several lunches and at least one breakfast at Sam's, yet have never reviewed it. So, here goes. It's a diner, that's not a bad word, it's a type of restaurant. If you want something fancy, Holley Falls Bar and Grill is a few hundred feet away. It's fancy. It's also expensive, but the food is not diner food. Back to Sam's. It's a diner and a really good one. Huge menu so you are sure to find something to eat. The burgers and fries are really good. For breakfast, I had an omelet that was huge and delicious. Home fries are good as well. Service is always good, with friendly faces and real personalities. It's seat yourself and they'll find you, and they always do. My buddy and I like to go to the less public room that is up two steps and usually not crowded. The only thing I can think of that could be improved is their coffee, but that's true for almost any restaurant. Fresh ground would improve the flavor if they could find the time. Getting rid of the Bunn coffee burners and buying some real coffee machines would cost some money initially, but it might give them a little more to brag about once the staff was trained in making good coffee. Can you tell I like coffee? Their mediocre coffee isn't bad enough to keep me away from the rest of what they have to offer, so they likely won't be improving it anytime soon. You should eat here. I do, and enjoy it. You could always order tea or a milkshake if you don't want to risk the coffee. read more

Absolutely delicious!!! First time dining here and I was NOT disappointed every thing was made to perfection 10/10 recommend!! Such a wide variety on the menu read more

Great food, service and prices. You won't be disappointed. I get a Sam's country omlett every Saturday morning, fantastic! Make sure to tip your servers well. read more

Service was great the waitress was very knowledgeable and helpful. The food was average at best and the pre food dinner rolls that were served to us all had MOLD on them. Won't be in a hurry to come back here anytime soon read more

Sam's Diner - Dinner roll with MOLD - Diners Near Me - Holley, New York

The food at this place is amazing. Chicken Deluxe Sandwich is one thing they have there. But my favorite is the Mac and cheese

My daughter treated my sister and myself. The food was great and the atmosphere was comfortable. We enjoyed ourselves.

The food is diverse and very good. The service is AMAZING. Kim is awesome and very personable. The ambiance is great and helps welcome all those that enter. read more

Best fish fry around. Great food and service. Friendly staff. Highly recommend Sam's Diner.

The best in town and around! GREAT diner food, great prices, quick service, sweet and attentive staff, clean, small town, family friendly. Has been here forever and is family owned by an amazingly hospitable family- make sure to say hi to George! This place is worth traveling for! Well known for its fish fries and the breakfast is amazing. Large portions so make sure to save room for a milkshake or piece of pie! read more

See all

Great place for coffee & a burger. Food is tasty, service good, and the prices are very reasonable. read more

Sam's Diner - As good as it looks! - Diners Near Me - Holley, New York

First time visitor and we were not disappointed. We stopped in for breakfast before golfing. Our waitress was very friendly and the food was excellent, absolutely no complaints. (Recommend Sams omelette) We are only up here one weekend a year and this will definitely a breakfast spot for us. read more

This is the best diner on the globe. The best fries you will ever consume. Their menu is always so diverse and is so cheap. I went to this place growing up and still make sure I make a trip here when I'm back home. Go here, go here now. read more

Really good food at a reasonable price. If you go away hungry from this restaurant it is your own fault, because they give a generous portion. read more

Great diner! We go here almost every week for breakfast. Very large portions of food for cheap. Lately I have been getting the Everything omelette with home fries and Italian toast. The omelette is huge and ver delicious. For lunch they have a huge menu. I have had the super club with fresh cut fries. You won't leave hungry and your wallet won't be empty. read more

sam's is a small town diner and it's about what you expect. everything is solid and the waitstaff is nice. i had two sandwiches, the reuben and the patty melt. both were good and good enough. the fried zucchini however were disappointing because they were overfried. i went on a friday night for a fish fry dinner and it was gigantic and tasty, but the fish was slightly overcooked. I also prefer a lower fish-to-batter ratio (for more fried skin), and the included Kraft tartar was just bad. i didn't expect much from the tartar, but i didn't expect it to be so bad either. the included fries were cooked crisp and perfect though, and the coleslaw was coleslaw yummy. overall, pretty good. read more

Sam's Diner - Fish Fry dinner - Diners Near Me - Holley, New York

Food is okay, pretty much just classic diner stuff. Good fish frys and the sams club is one of my favorites. I hate their mashed potatoes though they tast like boxed mashed potatoes. read more

Awesome breakfast, lunch and dinner at a price you can't beat. I've been coming here for years. They are a true asset to Holley!

Hmm I guess you can say its the best in town when it appears to be the only full on restaurant in town. It was food, I ate it, the wait staff were lovely. It's a diner, set your expectations accordingly. Perhaps breakfast is better. Did love the meat gravy. read more

This Diner is the real deal in town! Fresh breaded zucchini. Serving up burgers with A-1 steak sauce (did they read my mind?) Their desserts are not to be missed!! If your too full ask them to bag it to-go! read more

See all

DONT ORDER FISH FRY! We went here about 7 years ago and the fish fry was pretty good. I went back recently and was disappointed to see prepackaged kraft tartar sauce. They have switched to frozen fish which lacked flavor and was mushy where the meat and breading meet. I'm sure it is a financial decision but should not be sold as a western NY fish fry. My mom ordered it broiled and thought it was good. Everyone who ordered other food was happy. read more