They take reservations and as a party of 6, that's a nice start. Staff was very friendly and the…read morefood was some of the best we had in PEI.

This is an awesome stop! We had a great waitress who shared some local stories and was just…read moredelightful. The poutine was delicious and I've been craving it ever since! The ambiance can't be beat - such an incredible location! We really enjoyed our visit to Ship to Shore!

This place has absolutely ruined me. My life will never be the same. The lobster here was the…read moresweetest and most tender I've ever had. (Low key I even had lobster in Maine and Rhode Island after this and it was not as good) Service was friendly and warm. It's a no frills fish market shop and I would not have it any other way. We went fairly early in the morning and it was quiet, we had the best table by the window Lobster roll was delicious! Lobster dinner was so fun and really highlights the lobster. Shrimp cocktail 10/10. Sweet and spicy mussels were different and delicious. Oyster fresh and flavorful. I hope I get to go back in the future!

I love the interior of this Mart. Clean and well decorated with dine in options for inside and…read moreoutside. Everything was so delicious, we had to come back two days in a row. We got Lobster rolls, the lobster dinner, mussels, 6 shucked oysters from their kitchen menu and got shrimp from their counter. It was my favorite tasting lobster that was perfectly cooked. Plus they were very friendly and provided great service. Highly recommend to try!

Great service, food and ambiance! Food was fresh and delicious. The setting was perfect! Good…read moreprices.

Small place but with outside seating area right on the bay. Beautiful view. Food is excellent and…read moreprices are ok. We stayed in the area for 4 nights and went twice.

This is the best restaurant in Cavendish with a delicious variety of food, Friendly service Plus…read morewe especially enjoyed the stunningly beautiful Sunset viewed from the top Deck!

Another year, another review as is tradition at this point. We travel to PEI yearly as a family…read moreand one of our main reasons for coming to the north shore aside from the beaches of course is to come to the Lost Anchor. This year did not disappoint, we ended up going twice! We got the Lost Anchor mussels, Cajun Alfredo pasta, chicken fingers + fries and fish + chips. Mussels are always are favourite even for our toddler who stole most of them so much so she demanded to go back the following day to get some more. All the food was delicious, even the kids meal was very good. Second day we got more mussels, calimari, wings and each a dessert. Everything was really well done. We had Becca for a server both times and she did really well accommodating our toddler. We will keep our tradition going and we hope you develop the same. It is evident how much time and care goes into making this an exceptional dinning experience

The service was terrific- room was made for us even though we read they were booked the day before…read morearrived. We had a crab meat and lobster sandwich, delicious, scrumptious sweet potato fries and delicious salad with a wonderful vinaigrette dressing. Sticky date pudding and coffee rounded things off. The fried fish and chips were beautiful and three patrons having them said it tasted great. What a treat!

This is 100% one of PEI's little gems. Fantastic food (try a burger you will see) great staff and…read moreyou can't beat the location. If you are visiting PEI you wont be disappointed in making the stop. Keep it up TISP!! Cheers, Tom

The food is amazing, the staff was fantastic and the drinks were great! My favorite seafood place…read moreto eat on PEI.

Always a wonderful meal the new decor is fabulous and food and service as…read moregreat as always.

We stayed at the Stanley Bridge Resort this past weekend for my husband's best friend's wedding and…read moredecided to check out Sutherland's, since it was on-site. We didn't have time for lunch or dinner but we popped in for their breakfast on Monday morning. The first thing we noticed was that the place was pretty much empty. Now, this is probably because we're getting to the end of the season and it was a Monday, but it really didn't bother us. Our server was sweet, and actually one of the same servers that was at the wedding on the Saturday before. The breakfast menu was small but it had something for everyone. They were even able to substitute something for my non-egg-eating husband. We both got their breakfast with bacon, eggs (not for him, he got more bacon), toast and hasbrowns. It was great!! Bacon was cooked perfectly, eggs were awesome and the hashbrowns weren't deep or pan fried, they were more like a hodge podge potato - tender, skins still on, and moist - they were FANTASTIC! Overall, a great breakfast . We can't wait to check out lunch and dinner next year!

Absolutely love this place! The food is excellent and the service is great. The Seafood chowder and…read moreseafood linguine are a one-two punch that you need to try at least once!

We each had a cup of the seafood chowder. We shared 1 ounc of mussels and the grilled cheese and…read morelobster sandwich. Way too much food but it was all delicious and we don't regret having all three. The service was prompt and friendly. One of our favorite meals so far on our 3 week trip through Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and PEI.

We were on a trip to PEI, and stumbled across this place. What a great view, the location is…read morestunning. The place is clean and the staff are amazingly friendly. I had the lobster roll with chives and dill with mayo, unfortunately the lobster was not fresh. This was a little sad for me as we really are right on the water. But the fries are delicious, and so is the coleslaw.

Fantastic food! We were told by a local that this place has the best seafood on the island, so we…read morehad to try it. It definitely didn't disappoint. We enjoyed the lobster roll and fish & chips. So delicious! The beers we got were great too - a blueberry beer and the 1776 IPA. Both were delicious. Service was fine - you order at the counter and pickup at another counter - nothing fancy. They offer outdoor seating only which was wonderful as the day was gorgeous. Oh and the fries. These were amazing. And you get a ton of 'em. So good. Give this place a try - you'll want to go back.

We were told this was the best place for Lobster Rolls. They were right. Beachy order and seat…read moreyourself. Day was gorgeous. Food was amazing. Staff were so nice and on point. Amazing lunch and experience.

Great food , great service. Kyle was the best in recommending various seafoods. Both take out and…read moreeat in. $16 a lobster. Can't beat it.

We stopped in here three times on our stay on PEI to pick up food to take back to the house. The…read morestaff was very helpful in explaining the different seafood, how to cook them, and the rules around gathering our own off the beach by our rental. The cooked lobster we purchased was the best on our trip so far, and we have eaten a lot of lobster. They even got some fresh bread in that day that I purchased. The scallops were the only thing that I thought was over priced, everything else was very reasonable.