For a few years I have given Hideaway Pizza in Stillwater another try , time after time but it continues to fail in leaving up to the orginal owners 20yrs ago and is not even in the same league as the Hideawy in Norman or Tulsa which are 10x better. The ingredients are not as fresh as others, cheese is worse, toppings not as tasty, crust tastes totally different. IDK how a franchise can taste so much different than other great tasting ones, but the Stillwater location is the worse. The fried mushrooms is the only reason it gets 2stars as the pizza is 1star at this location (5star at others) read more

My pizza delivery was right on time and my pizza was hot & DELICIOUS. The delivery man was VERY NICE...LOVE HIDEAWAY PIZZA

Great pizza. Food came out fast despite how busy they were. Close to campus and convenient location.

I give only three stars because the pizza was quite undercooked. Perhaps some people prefer this kind of pizza? Mushrooms were basically raw on top of the pizza. And especially the crust was underdone, chewy on the inside. And the pizza was room temperature, barely heated. The fried mushrooms were delicious. read more

The ORIGINAL lives up to the legend. My absolute go-to. Fun college atmosphere, pizza is out of this world, appetizers are fabulous, sandwiches & salads round out the menu for options that will not disappoint. Lunch menu is the best value in Stillwater & easy to fit into a busy schedule with the attentive service. read more

This place is a local icon and has the best pizzas and great appetizers. Great service.

There is no comparison to the original Hideaway in Stillwater. Love the pizza, the side salad is a generous size, and the mushrooms and cheese sticks are the best at this location! read more

While this place is known for its delicious , I would like to bring to your notice the showstopper of this place - The famous fried mushrooms. If there is anybody who is not a big fan of mushrooms, try this and I guarantee you would change your opinion towards it !!!! read more

The Original Hideaway - Famous fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Pizza was great! Service was also very good. Ambiance could have been better. There were school-aged children working on their homework at the table. Just not what I expected. read more

I have ordered both delivery and pick up. Always ready or arrives earlier than expected. Professional friendly service every time. read more

First time visiting Stillwater and I had to find the best pizza in town. This is hands down THE BEST pizza that I've ever tasted. When ever I'm here this is a must stop. Don't second guess go NOW! read more

See all

Food is pretty standard nothing too crazy and the pizza is not my style but all of my friends liked it. If yo don't get pizza the menu prices are really cheap and Their salads are cheap and very good. read more

We came here late Saturday night. It was after 10 when we arrived with a group of 8. I felt bad since they closed at 11. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. We ordered a couple of pizzas and a pitcher of beer. The beer was ice cold. The supreme pizza had the right amount of cheese with lots of fresh topping. The crust was good. The cheese pizza looked really good. I didn't try a slice but everyone else in our party raved about it. We stayed past 11 pm but the staff never rushed us. Right up to the point that we left the staff remained courteous and professional. I would come back again, but next time a little earlier. read more

We visited some dear friends in Stillwater Thursday (8/22). They ordered pizza for lunch and it was delivered. They payed, tipped and opened the boxes. It sadden us to discover that the crust on two of three pizzas was burned black. It embarrassed our friends to serve us these pizzas but I made excuses for y'all. Why would you deliver these burned black pizzas to a customer's home that you couldn't sell in the restaurant? Review, question and contact information was entered on Hideaway's website last week but I don't see. Not requesting refund/other, just a response to the question. Thank you. read more

Great food! The fried mushrooms are a must. Our service was a little slow. Loved the atmosphere.

Menu looks great and offers variety including several yummy salads! Veg options which is appreciated and service was quick and friendly. However, for a college town with hospitals near capacity and ICU's primarily full of unvaccinated covid patients, I was shocked to see only one staff person with a mask on! Sadly, this wasn't who waited in us. read more

Great pizza , great service . The spaghetti is pretty awesome. One of my favorite restaurants in Stillwater

This pizza place has great food and friendly service. I like to go at lunchtime for the salad and personal pizza special.

Stopped by for lunch with my son who toured OSU. We're from Northern Virginia. Pizza was great, the service was AWESOME. Everyone was friendly and attentive. Great place. read more

If you are looking for a slightly different taste, then the commercial guys pizza, then give them a try. I think they're better. The fried mushrooms are good if you eat them fresh and hot. read more

I absolutely love the Original Hideaway Pizza! I always feel like I've had a treat when I eat here or get it delivered! Love to bring out of state friends here‼ read more

We decided to have a family Christmas gathering at Hideaway in Stillwater. We made reservations for the back room and to have the specialty buffet for 41 family members. There was a little communication error on how many people would be there and the manager did a great job in accommodating us. The pizza, mushrooms, cheese sticks were all delicious. The cooks and wait staff did an excellent job also. The family had an excellent gathering. Nothing is better than the original Hideaway. read more

Great pizza. Good service. Always loved set up and dim lights. Parking is hard but usually cuz it's busy.

After being told the Hideaway here is *the* original and different than the ones in the Oklahoma City metro, I was eager to see what the fuss was about. Husband and I came on a busy day but didn't have to wait for a table. We were seated and greeted fairly quickly and ordered a large Pizza Supreme. One of the things we like here better than the other locations is the dough--it's softer and even a little crispier. The toppings were just average. I like sausage on pizza but definitely like it in larger pieces than the crumbles that were on the pizza we ordered. It was kind of a struggle to get our server to check up on us as there were a few things we wanted, like ranch for dipping, refills, and a to-go box to put our leftovers in. This Hideaway is simply a Stillwater staple but I think I may prefer the others. I know it's hard to judge an entire place based on one order and one pizza. But the large is very generous and good easily feed 4 people. read more

Went In Friday night for date night with my darling and friends. Pleasantly surprised, nice little place to grab a beer and pizza or sandwich. Pretty good appetizer's as well, had the mozzarella sticks, friendly wait staff. Will return again . read more

This isn't just another pizza place, it's an institution. Tons of seating for large groups and the friendliest service in town. There are so many specialties and topping options, we sometimes order individual or small pizzas to customize. read more

Food was very greasy and i took forever to get our food. They ren out of a lot of drinks quickly and they did not have any ice. When we got the food it was warm which was good. read more

We were gifted with a $20 off coupon and ordered a medium Five Cheese pizza (which was about $20, yikes!) We we're expecting top quality, elevated taste to match the cost of the pizza... and it was mediocre. Dominos pizza tastes better to us. From the cheese, the dough, and even the sauce. Maybe we just order the wrong thing to try out the place... but it didn't leave us wanting to go back to try anything else. The cost of the food doesn't help us want to go back either. If the taste matched the cost, it would be worth it. Like I said, maybe we just ordered the wrong thing... if you've never had this place, give it a go and let us know! 3 stars because the food was edible and okay. But just okay, nothing spectacular. read more

It was a super busy Valentine's Friday night, but The Hideaway was still great! The fried mushrooms were absolutely wonderful. We skipped the pizza this time because they were offering mushroom Brie soup. DEVINE! The hubs had the Dagwood, which is always a favorite. read more

The best pizza in town! Also the only pizza in town lol. Good variety of topping choices and almost always within the 30 min pick up window.

The pizza is great but try the ice, it's amazing!! So soft and cold. I also like the mushroom caps. With ranch, not blue cheese. read more

The Original Hideaway - Pizza Near Me - Stillwater, Oklahoma

Yummy - we had a couple bottles of wine and they were great!! Appetizers...OMG THE GOUDA MAC AND CHEESE BITES WERE AWESOME!! Get them for sure!! We also had the cheese bread - it was also a huge hit!! Love love love!! The cheese sticks were good as well, kids loved them! Finally we had some spinach dip - very good as well. Then we ordered pizza - BBQ Chicken pizza was very good - a lot of chicken!! The pepperoni pizza was also very good - those who ate it loved it! Last pizza was a Margherita pizza - so good, fresh, crispy crust!! Great place - if you want some great pizza and great service stop by here!! read more

We drove to Stillwater from OKC to go to the Original Hideaway. My husband swears the pizza is lots better than at the other Hideaways. It was mom's weekend for OSU so I was afraid we wouldn't get in. It was really busy but they were able to find us a free table fairly quickly. They were prepared for the crowd and had lots of workers there. Our waiter was great. He got our drinks immediately and then took our order. Hideaway is never really fast so I was happy when we got our pizzas in a decent amount of time. I ordered a Canadian Bacon/hamburger small pizza. It was lots more than I needed but leftover Hideaway is always good. The pizza was awesome. Just the right amount of toppings. Tons of cheese which I like. My husband ordered a double pepperoni. There was tons of pepperoni on it. I have never seen that much pepperoni on a pizza. He loved it. I should have taken a picture. You couldn't even see the cheese there was so much pepperoni. We both graduated from OSU so this is a nostalgic place for us to go to. It was a little loud but it was cram packed full. It is almost always busy. Very popular place to go because the pizza is so good. If you are ever in Stillwater, you should try it. read more

Great pizza their specialties are really solid. The plain Jane pepperoni is by far my favorite! Excellent service, super friendly folks. Highly recommend read more

We had to visit the "original" Hideaway while visiting OSU. It was Orientation for the incoming Freshman class. Thankfully it wasn't too hard to get seated for lunch. Service was a bit spotty which is not what we are used to from Hideaway where we come from. We didn't have a lot of time before we had to return to our meetings. We normally get the Paradise Pie and it never disappoints. Interesting; and it worked out, but not the service and quality we have come to expect from this franchise. read more

Good pizza but it's overrated and expensive. There's always a long wait though. It's not student budget friendly whatsoever. It can be a fun place to go on game day if you don't mind waiting. Getting it to go is the best option. Parking is a headache. Decent pizza. Definitely Americanized though! read more

Best pizza in the state, the fried mushrooms are to die for never let a chance to go the Hideaway

If you are visiting Stillwater, you can't miss the original Hideaway. Order a delicious pizza, and while you wait for it, enjoy a salad. The bowls are small... too small... but they pile on the salad fixings... You may need to ask for extra dressing. Play a game of Pente and check out the cool murals and the kite collection adorning the walls. Great music adds to the fun atmosphere of this place, and the staff will make sure you are taken care of. There may be other Hideaway's around the state, but there's nothing quite like the original Hideaway Pizza. Enjoy! read more

It's ok. Crust tastes premade. A little like deep dish. I had the kahuna. Chicken n sun dried tomatoes. Meh...

The pizza is really subpar. It's bland and salty. Maybe the cheese could be improved? It tastes like they don't spend money on ingredients.