We came here to celebrate our friend's birthday and was pleased with the visit. Our last time here was filled with a few underwhelming dishes. Service was good as always and we had a long, leisurely dinner for six. Appetizers Poached Pear salad Octopus & shrimp special Garlic shrimp Jersey corn bisque Entrees Duck breast w foie gras Halibut Lobster in a basket NY strip Dessert Rice pudding Gelato Chocolate cake Left with full stomachs and fully satisfied. read more

The Poached Pear - Poached pear salad - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

As a first time visitor to the area and restaurant I was not aware of the BYOB optionality. This should really be front and central when booking a reservation. Something as simple as including it in the confirmation text would be a game changer for an experience. Nonetheless the food and service were nothing great. Strongly recommend getting the poached pear salad, great portion as well (we split it between 3 guests) the calamari was very fresh and light (I know even for a fried item you could taste the lightness) For our meals we ordered the scallops, the lobster special and a chicken pasta (modification) the seafood quality is absolutely palpable and the accompaniments are very well thought out. The food lacked salt but that's an easy fix. Will definitely be back (with a bottle of wine!) read more

See all

Back again, to one of our favorite restaurants to celebrate two birthdays! We came on a Saturday and reservations are strongly recommended. We started our meals with Asparagus Fries (I really liked them) and Cajun Calamari. Both were excellent. Entrees consisted of Corvina, Halibut, Pork Chop and a Frenched Chicken Breast. As usual, all entrees were delivered in a tmely fashion and piping hot. Dessert (of course, we needed dessert) consisted of Peach cobbler and Bread Pudding. BYOB! read more

ok, I'm lowering my rating to four stars. I went for my birthday dinner tonight and unfortunately the scallops were overcooked. they were VERY stringy. I'm not a big scallop eater, so I mentioned it to my friend and also googled stringy scallops, friend and Google both confirmed this means they're overcooked. my friend also reminded me the scallops were not good the last time we went either (she's the scallop connoisseur). the bathrooms were also in the same state they were since my last review. the good things about this evening's visit were the corn bisque and the creme brulee. I may stick to soups/dessert if I come back. The price isn't worth gambling on the entree personally. it's still a good spot and I may be back, it's just not a five star spot to me. read more

See all

I have been to this restaurant several times and have never been disappointed. Everything on the menu is delicious. The service is skilled, friendly and professional. It's BYOB which makes it a good value as well. read more

Delicious food and great service! I've gone here twice with friends and it was a pleasant experience. The food was scrumptious and service was excellent. We never felt we were waiting around for our server. Our water glasses were filled promptly when nearing empty. The seafood here is fresh and tasty. I'm not a big fan of the fish special they normally offer that comes with jumbo shrimp and I believe corvina fish. It lacked something for me and the sauce seemed too much. I recommend another seafood option instead. The temperature felt nice in here and not too chilly. It is a great date spot or a night out with friends or family. There is a small parking lot in the back, but enough that there's usually some spot open if you go around 5:30pm or so. It is located a straight shot down the street from the point pleasant boardwalk. My friends and I went here for dinner then enjoyed the rest of the evening playing boardwalk games and walking around. I highly recommend! read more

The Poached Pear - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

See all

Been here a few times, maybe 4-5. Food is pretty good. Biggest "con" is that the menu never changes. Specials are normally pretty good, so I'd grab one of them if it speaks to you, because the other thing you're thinking about getting will probably still be there next time! read more

The Poached Pear - Corn soup - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Food, service, parking all excellent. Had steak - absolutely delicious. Crème bulle wonderful too

The food is always great with the most knowledgeable accommodating staff. The decor is upscale with paintings that will grab your eye. Color scheme is serene with shades of cream and tan, very calming and comfortable. Make that reservation, you will not regret your choice. read more

Beautiful inside on a cold and windy night. Our server was very good and knowledgeable on everything the kitchen had to offer. I opted for the Halibut, but I'm looking forward to returning to try the duck entree. read more

The Poached Pear - Halibut - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

The Poached Pear has a modern look inside but with a quaint feel. My waitress was friendly, knowledgeable about the menu, and very thorough when explaining the specials. There were multiple servers making sure the water was always full. The food was delicious from appetizers to the main course, and there was a plenty to take home. The fish I ordered was phenomenal, and was sitting on a copious amount of creamy risotto. My wife ordered perfectly seared scallops, so we both ate from each other's plates. The Poached Pear is a great experience from beginning to end, and you will leave full and satisfied. read more

Beautiful dinning room, amazing food and great service. I have been here five times since I opened my beach house. very hard to get a reservation in season. I love there Octopus appetizer or cream of mushroom soup. I rotate entrees the lamb chops, braised lamb shanks, pork chop, salmon and Corvino fish. read more

Went for our celebration of our engagement today & it was really nice! The service was perfection & i was happy with the quality of the food! I would definitely go back if I had the chance. The menu is very unique and stands out in comparison to many other places. read more

Loved coming here. Nice ambience. The crab cake was amazing. Have to go back for another sometime soon. read more

The Poached Pear - Jumbo Lump Crab Cake - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

See all

The food here is amazing! Lots of options and good sized portions. I enjoyed the dick breast, which was cooked perfectly while my parents loved their entrees-- the halibut and the lamb shank special. read more

Highly recommended by friends and it was a truly outstanding meal at this BYOB restaurant. Outstanding service. The wedge salad and the octopus appetizers were delicious and shareable. The main course steaks and fish dishes were also outstanding. Added bonus is that the restaurant has sound panels throughout making very easy to carry on a conversation there. I was able to pull right into a street parking spot a couple of doors away from the entrance. read more

See all

This is a high end place with simply spectacular food and service. While a byob they take amply opportunity to fill your glass and ensure a delightful experience. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. It's simple. Want a great meal... go to the Poached Pear. read more

Food was excellent.service is very attentive throughout the meal. Ambiance is soft and pleasant. Overall this restaurant is gem and deserves all 5 stars read more

One of my favorite places for a nice, upscale, intimate dinner. The restaurant is beautifully decorated. The staff are polite and professional. The menu is absolutely delicious. From appetizers to dessert, there is something for everyone. I have been to this establishment at least a half a dozen times and I've never been disappointed. The pear pizzetta and beef carpaccio is our favor appetizers. For the main course, I have indulged their ancho-coffee rubbed New York strip, parmesan, and almond crusted halibut, and the diver scallops. All were amazing. Their gelato and sorbet is all made in house and melts in your mouth. For a little more indulgence try the lemon Napoleon. All in all this place is amazing. It's BYOB so I'm willing to pay more since I can bring my own bottle. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

the food and service is always very good. one of the best restaurants in the area mmmmmm

My friend and I have been going to The Poached Pear for a few years now, and each time we order something different. Each time the waitress is excellent and the food outstanding. We have found this restaurant to be consistently five stars, which is rare. The prices are all what you would pay for fine dining. The atmosphere is also nice, with warm lighting and tables spaced nicely apart so you're not listening in on the diners next to you. read more

Very good food and service but grossly overrated. Honestly, I'd rather have a casual fresh seafood meal overlooking the water in any one of the great spots nearby for the price. I do not see the appeal. But the food is very good and so is the service. Place is tiny. It did nothing for me except drain my wallet. Not memorable at all as far as my meal. read more

Decent and creative but wayyyyyy overpriced. Food is good to very good for the most part. Service is alright. Ambiance, I suppose nothing stuck out. I'll try again someday. I prefer a Bass' bistro up the road, but everyone likes different things and I'll for sure give this place another shot. read more

Second time in a few weeks. Service was exceptional as well as food. The fish special was excellent. The lobster special was good but maybe a little disappointing in portion size. Deserts were on point and delicious! Will definitely be back read more

See all

Once again an incredible dining experience, Nick and team were beyond attentive. Our table of four each had the evening specials, two enjoyed the lobster/crab cakes, angel hair with shrimp and corvina, shrimp over risotto were all devoured. Not much room for dessert but who could resist the peach cobbler or crème brûlée. See you soon. read more

The short rib carpaccio and scallops were perfect. Great service and it was byob. Risotto with scallops was great and they have vegetarian risotto options. read more

Had out of town visitors today with two children 9 and 7. Went to the Poached Pear as they have a children's menu but also an upscale adult menu that would appeal to my NY foodies. They were impressed as the food was excellent. The staff was quite solicitous and and accommodating; especially when it came to the children and their meals. The dinner couldn't have worked out better. read more

Hi everyone Susan Anne Franchesky here! My family and I had dinner here tonight and it was exceptional. The food and service are ALWAYS consistent. I have never had a bad meal. Small menu but every plate is a star. Highly recommend I ordered the Grilled Filet Mignon (for the millionth time) and requested it cooked medium rare and when I tell you it was perfect, It was PERFECT . Texture is juicy and tasty yet not super filling. It's a top choice grade A piece of meat. FYI Mark is so accommodating and never misses a beat. Can't wait to come back for the 86th time! Time for happy hour!! - your favorite foodie yelper read more

Love this place. Food is better everytime. Service is fantastic and seems to be the same staff year after year.

Not as good as in the past. Rushed, we said to pace the meal but as soon ans appetizers done our entree wa delivered. Good service overall. I would definitely give them anopther try. read more

We recently enjoyed a lovely meal in this pleasantly quiet and ambiance approved bistro. Our server, Sandy was quite helpful and knowledgeable about the menu to navigate a wonderful experience. The ancho-coffee rubbed NY strip steak was cooked to a perfect medium rare perched on top of asparagus fries and mushroom risotto. The beet salad was delicious too. We recommend Poached Pear as high quality BYOB eatery. Fine for date night too. read more

The best of point Pleasant. Amazing food and incredibly friendly service. Love this place.

Excellent food, service, & ambiance! Highly recommend this wonderful local restaurant. read more

See all

I had an amazing experience at The Poached Pear last night and would give them 10 stars if I could! Wow, I was blown away by the food, service and ambiance. The restaurant has been highly recommended to me so I decided to check it out with a colleague for a celebratory dinner. The restaurant is very nicely decorated and could be a great option for an intimate dinner. We were promptly greeted upon arrival and seated. Please note that they are BYO so don't forget to bring you favorite wine pairing for dinner. Our server, Margie, was phenomenal. She was attentive and knew all of the specials like the back of her hand. I was also really impressed with the variety and quality of the specials. The more information she shared the more difficult it became to decide what to order! We started with the garlic shrimp, calamari, and burrata. The garlic shrimp were divine! The calamari and burrata were also very good but you can't skip the shrimp. As our entrees I had the crab cake and my colleague had the lobster/crab/shrimp special. I don't know what they put in their food but with every bite we commented how delicious everything was! To wrap up we tried the bread pudding dessert. If you haven't tried The Poached Pear you have to book a reservation ASAP! I'm already planning my next reservation! read more

See all

Went here on a friends recommendation and I could not have been happier with the meal. We started with the duck ravioli and gnocchi. The duck was amazing. For entrees my girlfriend and I split the porkchop and the halibut and both were A+ Dessert was the flourless chocolate cake and ended the meal on a high note. Will be back for sure. read more

The Poached Pear - Porkchop - Desserts Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

The food was excellent as was the service! I can't wait to return. It was our first time ever but it won't be our last

Went in for an early Saturday family dinner - first time here - we had a great time and food/service was very good. service was diligent, even multiple servers bringing plates so everyone served at the same time. We will be back. read more

We tried this place Friday evening, everything was perfect. The service was impeccable and the food great. We were surprised at how many app/entree selections they had we wanted to try. The soup of the day was very nice, Caesar salad and crab cake were quite good and our entrees, the Lobster Special and fish were delicious. I had the bananas foster for dessert, we will absolutely be back, a must try in my book. read more

The food here is fantastic! Probably the best restaurant in the whole area. Have tried there lamb shank, scallops, octopus all excellent! Very flavorful with great sauces and perfectly cooked every time! The veal and their lobster crab cake was good as well, but the lamb shank is consistently our favorite! read more

Dinner was amazing! We had the Pizzata Pear, the burrata, and Poached Pear salad. Absolutely delicious. My husband had the NY Strip with shrimp special. I had the Corvina with shrimp special. It was perfection. For dessert we shared the Key Lime pie dessert. Our waitress Sandy was wonderful, too. Highly recommend this place. Can't wait to come back. read more

See all