This was our first time here and The Sizzle BBQ did not disappoint! We had empanadas- Reuben, spicy chorizo, and cheesesteak flavored, Argentinian sausage sandwich, and the half order of pork ribs. Everything was amazing! The empanadas were full of flavor, some of the best we have ever had! The ribs were tender and didn't need any sauce. Our server was very nice and personable. I loved the inside it was homey and inviting. There is seating outside as well as inside. We were able to sit inside as they have large door sized windows that open all the way which was great for today's humid weather. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

First trip here beyond exceeded expectations. First off, decor inside is beautiful and they really did transform the place. Our server, Dan was excellent! Super informative in telling us about the flavors and making reccomendations. We got a chicken Caesar salad which was perfect, French fries were just like McDonald's fries and i mean that in a really good way. SPICY PORK EMPANADA is everything. Wanted to go back today for second day in a row for some more. The toast they bring out before the food is yummmmmy with chimmichurri sauce. All of the sauces were my favorite part of everything. 10/10 will definitely become a regular here read more

The Sizzle BBQ - Cute presentation of the empanadas - Barbeque Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

This is the third time we have eaten at The Sizzle BBQ. Every time we have eaten here we have gotten a consistently good meal. I ordered the pork ribs and my fiancé ordered the steak sandwich and a ham and cheese empanada. The empanada was fried to perfection and the dough was extremely tasty. My ribs were perfect and delicious. They don't put bbq sauce on and it does not need it with how tender and juicy they are. The food came out quick and the service was excellent. Definitely would give this place a try if you are in the area! read more

We had our first take out from this place today. Place looks lovely and the ladies working there greeted us nicely and with a smile. We ordered chicken and pork ribs combo with a side of rice and fries and an order of steamed vegetables. I asked for sauce to go and they gave me an assortment of sauces which was really nice. Pork ribs, chicken and fries were very good, however, rice was overly salty, we could not even eat it. I hope it was a one time mistake, maybe they salted it twice but honestly it was inedible Ended up throwing it out. We are however planing to give this place a try again in the future since the rest of the food was delicious! read more

Very good empanadas! We will be ordering takeout in the future but beware of dining in. A 10% gratuity was included in our bill (just 2 of us) without disclosure that I could see. Then there was a tip suggestion on the original receipt to be kept by the restaurant. Review your receipt! We had to request a copy. The waiter told us the undisclosed tip has been a topic of conversation for a long time and nothing would be done about it. The food was adequate. We couldn't determine if the $38 pitcher of passion fruit punch had any alcohol in it. The effort of our server was very good considering what seems to be a lack of training. Unsealed, unsanitary pallet wood used as decor. read more

The food is good, the green sauce is great the owners are super friendly and very accommodating. I have been going to sizzle since it opened and it does not disappoint. read more

A very pleasant atmosphere with an interesting but limited menu. Sometimes that's better. Friendly service. Pork ribs are recommended. ( beef ribs not. Very tough) Salads huge and with additions it best deal in Hackettstown. Recommended. read more

Great Argentinian grill. Try the chicken and pork ribs. Many other menu items to choose from. Food is always fresh and well prepared. Large side orders accompanied meats. read more

Absolutely wonderful. Wait staff attentive friendly helpful. Our server Sophia was went above and beyond. Attentive but not overbearing. And then the food. Sooo good. Pork ribs tender juicy delicious. Definitely will return to check out rest of menu read more

My friend and I stopped in for lunch the other day and were delighted to have done so! She had chicken quesadillas and i had meatless empanadas . Corn, Caprese, and Bean . The meal came with a little bucket of toast with three spreads to munch on while we waited. Each of us also had the Spinach, apple, ginger juice. Everything was very fresh and delicious! The restaurant is very charming in its decor, family friendly with a couple games for little kids. The food is presented in an appealing way as well.Very attentive service. Easy to social distance inside the restaurant and we took take out menus as we left! We told our kids and friends to go there and plan to support this business! read more

Great food and reasonable priced. We have eaten here many times and loved everything we've ever ordered.

Wonderful BBQ place. A lot of options in the menu. The ribs and meat are to die for. Nice staff. Great vintage decoration.

We always have a great meal here. The servers are young and a lot of fun and a very very sweet personality always. I love their plantains. The pork ribs are also delicious and very tasty of course. For $12 they give you 4 large ribs and a side of rice or fries. I also love their empanadas although for three dollars they're a bit small. Hackettstown is becoming the Mecca of restaurants these days and believe it or not on a Friday night this is the only place we can get into hackettstown is becoming the Mecca of restaurants these days and believe it or not on a Friday night this is the only place we can get into. I've been here about 5 times and it's always good read more

Ribs and empanadas are really good! It's a BYO and the service is very good. Great atmosphere too.

My husband and I ate here last night. We tried the beef and cheese steak empanadas as an appetizer; they were delicious. As our meals, we ordered the chicken and ribs. The ribs were a good size and very good. Chicken was moist. You got to pick your sauces and how much you wished to add to your food, as the sauce came on the side. The server was attentive and polite. I would return and recommend the restaurant to a friend. read more

This place messed up our order 3 times and the food was extremely dry.The service was also awful and didn't try to help the situation.

Excellent in every way. Loved it! Food delicious. Very clean. Friendly service. There are several great restaurants in this town! This is one of them. I definitely recommend it. read more

A friend and I went for lunch. What an adorable, relaxing atmosphere! Staff is friendly, welcoming and knowledgeable. I ordered the barbecue chicken and rice half order and my friend had the spicy chicken panini. We were both beyond impressed with both serving sizes and taste. Everything was clearly made with fresh ingredients, and made with pride. Looking forward to returning and trying more menu items. What a gem! read more

Best clean, drinks that are prepared with fresh, raw ingredients right in front of you...no skimping (overloaded ice) or sugary syrups here. Pure antioxidant magic! Jerk/Cajun Chicken Salad is robust, hearty and filling. Portions are just perfect, where you can also enjoy later at home. Empanadas are good, love the sauces, as well. Servers are great and the owner really strives for quality, happy customers and a wonderful experience. Certain items can be overpriced, but the atmosphere and ambience - whether inside with the homestyle decor or outside during warmer months with their covered picnic tables and festive Argentinian style decor..is just wonderful. Would be remiss not to mention that the beautiful, invitingly powerful smell of their gorgeously grilled anything, is an absolute delight and is as mouthwatering, as the food is delicious. As a NYC OG, when I drive past Sizzle or dine - it brings me back to authentic NYC street grilling and hearty portions that are so hard to beat anywhere else. Well Done, Hackettstown Sizzle! read more

We had my husband's 50th birthday in the party room and everything was fantastic. All the food was excellent and the the service was outstanding. Maria, the owner, was so accommodating and made sure everything was just perfect. I highly recommend the cozy atmosphere at Sizzle if your having a small gathering (35 people max). You definitely will not be disappointed!! read more

This cozy Argentine cafe/restaurant has become our go-to place for fabulous grilled steak with chimichurri sauce, wholesome/savory salads and amazing "Maduros", empanadas and "tostones". It's a BYOB establishment that welcomes large or small groups. They do a great take-out business. Staff is friendly and the husband/wife owners are always around to welcome customers Now that autumn has arrived, Maria is making five different kinds of homemade SOUPS! She and staff actually pick pumpkins and prepare an amazing pumpkin soup from scratch. There is also black bean soup, lentil soup and traditional chicken noodle or chicken and rice soup. read more

Holy AMAZING! These are hands down the best empanadas EVER! If you have not been here yet, you absolutely MUST go. Bring your appetite because you are going to want to try them all. The shell is super yummy and flakey and the fillings are even better. My personal favorite so far is the steak but like I said, in still working my way through all of the choices. Our server was super sweet and friendly. Definitely ask for Cameron! read more

We visited The Sizzle for the first time tonight based on some reviews I read and it was delicious!! Adorable atmosphere and our waiter Justin was great. I had the Gardener juice and 2 of the best empanadas I've ever had - and belive me, I've had plenty! My husband really enjoyed the ribs and the portion was extremely generous. The dipping sauces were an added bonus. We'll definitely be back. read more

See all

I can only speak for the empanadas here because that's what we got on our first visit and it's all we have gotten since- because they are that good. Every one we have tried has been delicious but the cheesesteak definitely stands out the most. The service is always so nice and the food is always out promptly. The decor is cute and the restaurant has an overall cozy feel. If you're on the fence about giving this place a try I highly recommend- you will not be disappointed! read more

The decor didn't make sense to me for a BBQ place. It's was cute. I totally didn't understand.. Do you seat yourself upon entry or wait to be seated... Or go to the counter to be seated? Then upon seeing the menu, I really wanted a traditional BBQ chicken dish. Something like chicken, corn on the cob, and shoestring fries. The only thing I could find was a 1/2 chicken. It was dry and messy. They should hand out those handiwipes for your fingers when you order BBQ. Would have liked more extensive appetizer menu. Like corn fritter, or wings. Again, trying to keep within BBQ theme. I expected pulled pork, BBQ ribs, chicken breasts and legs.. I also saw the take out menu prices were lower than the dine in menu. Complete turn off. So would they rather you not eat in? Wait staff was friendly. read more

Steak sandwich was inedible. Ribs were fatty. Not coming back here. So disappointed. Lousy service too.

Been wanting to try here for a while and finally stopped in for takeout yesterday. I got the skirt steak and my girlfriend got the lady in red salad. The steak was perfect, nice char yet also tender in the middle, perfectly cooked! The chimichurri sauce was also perfect. My girlfriend loved her salad especially the dressing which she kept raving about....we will be back very soon and often. read more

Eaten here twice already and absolutely love it! All of the empanadas are amazing and the banana/nutella empanada is insane. Pork ribs dinner with rice and beans is my favorite. Will definitely keep going back. read more

This is a new restaurant here in diverse Hackettstown. It's a great addition to all the other ethnic restaurants we have here. It's where the old Leo's Lunch used to be. Parking on the street. Very nice inside, nicely decorated. Small about 10 tables along with bar seating. To start out, they give you bread & butter & a small ramekin of potato salad. Its BYOB. Service was great! We started with a variety of empanadas waiters choice, they were all delicious, along with 3 sauces. We ordered a house salad which was enormous and fresh. For the entrees we had the skirt steak, & the beef & pork rib combo. Both entrees excellent, cooked & seasoned perfectly. We had rice &beans, which were good but I would try something else next time. The owners son Wakeen (sorry if its spelled wrong) came to the table, introduced himself and told us a bit about the business, welcomed us and invited any comments or suggestions we had. We didnt have dessert as they were quite typical desserts, nothing that really stood out. All in all it was excellent, and we will definitely come back! Only gave a four star because its new, I will up it to five if it continues to be as good as it was tonight! read more

See all

I was looking fwd to enjoying a quiet peaceful meal with my husband after a busy work day. well that was NOT the case! it seems like the owners daughter (toddler) was at work with them for the evening. she was running around the place, i mean running non stop, without shoes, screaming, laughing, touching all the decor, going up to all the tables and touching peoples food, etc. the owners were in the back and it did not even phase them that she was out of control. our waitress seemed very frazzled and annoyed but could not complain bc it was the owners daughter. we had the most stressful experience! i kept politely asking her to not touch our food, purse, and coat but she did not listen nor care. its obvious that the owners just let their children run arnd wild during business hours. if you are looking for a quiet and peaceful meal then this is NOT the place for you! read more

We ate here last Saturday night, and really enjoyed it! The décor was stylish and welcoming. Our waitress was friendly and well versed in the menu. She recommended the mixed grill and one more main course for our family of four. It looked like too much food when it arrived, but we ate it all (teenage boy!). The mixed grill included beef and pork ribs, two kinds of sausage, skirt steak, and roast chicken. All were delicious, and I would go for the mixed grill again for two or three people. All in all, a welcome addition to the Hackettstown restaurant scene. read more

Delicious! Went today to try the empanadas and was not disappointed. I have family from Nashville visiting next month and have this place as a go-to for their visit. read more

After reading a review from a previous writer about how outstanding the ribs were, I was excited; so I take-out ordered the half rack of pork, half rack of beef ribs. Pork ribs were very tasty, but nowhere near close to melt-in-your-mouth. Beef ribs were just tough and chewy. Empanadas were really good.. very small, but good. We had spinach and cheesesteak and enjoyed them with a variety of sauces. I noticed they had a Rueben empanada.. unfortunately they ran out by the time I got there. Be sure to check your take-out order.. kitchen communication appears lacking as they neglected to give me rice and beans as ordered; just gave me rice. In summary, the only reason I'd go back would be the empanadas, but then again Hackettstown has a dozen shops that can provide that. read more

My family and I have been regular customers of the sizzle since they first opened. We have recommended them to countless people and have used for multiple catering events and frequent large orders. Unfortunately, after our last several experiences here we will not be returning. There have been multiple instances at this point where orders that were placed, both over the phone and online, were not fulfilled. Mistakes happen, but each time this occurred at time of pick up we were made to feel as though this was our fault and no solution was provided. Over the years we've come to expect that if you're told a certain time for pickup, wait at least an extra 20-30 mins or you'll be sitting waiting for your food. We were totally fine with this since we felt the food was worth it. But being treated as though you're in the wrong when an order you placed was never put through is just unacceptable. It's really a shame because we do enjoy the food, but I'd rather spend my money at a restaurant that actually values their customers. read more

The wife & I were out on the bike for the first time this season so we came to Hackettstown to try this place. We were not disappointed! The place has a great vibe, the waitress was super friendly and the food was hot & fresh. My wife had a huge spring salad with chicken. The chicken was cooked well and had nice flavor. The salad had fresh greens, avocado, and mango which made a nice combination. I had the beef & pork ribs combo. Big portions, lots of rice & fries as well. Portuguese bbq is different then American style bbq. I typically don't like sauce on my ribs. I like to taste the smoke & seasonings. With this, there was no heavy smoke or seasoning but the home made sauces really complemented the meat! We will be back again! read more

The Sizzle BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

New Argentinian Barbecue restaurant in Hackettstown. Have had a variety of fare over a couple of visits now, and everything is fantastic. Empanadas are flavorful and perfectly cooked, grilled meats are all wonderful, and the sausage sandwich is a winner. Top it all off with service that is friendly and attentive. Will frequent this one often. read more

Stopped here for dinner while our kids had a sleepover. My husband ordered the Rib platter (with fries and rice) and I ordered the chicken with rice and beans. Both were very good and fresh. The sauces that come with the meal are absolutely fantastic (parsley garlic may be my favorite)!! Try the sauces in your rice or on the chicken. You'll be back for more! Oh, and the service is outstanding! Everyone from the young owners to the other staff are friendly, helpful and make you feel warm and welcome! Go try it!! read more

I was there with my friends yesterday night. We were only three. I was not impress with food or services. I ordered steak medium rare with rice to go and they gave well done ( Almost burn) with french fries. My friends and I were mandated to pay tips that was include in the bill. Each person pay almost 12 $ for tip because we asked separated bills. Total of my bills was 75$ which I dont To mind to pay if the food is delicious. The waitress every time we asked for something she roll her eyes like she was annoyed to bring sauce for the table. read more

Absolutely love this place! we order every week at least once! The vegan empanadas are delicious and the rice and beans are fantastic.....and I can't leave out the dessert choices, I've had them all! The owner and employees are always cheerful.....it's a gem to have in town! read more

I would like to post this review as a WARNING. This place should be shut down for STEALING. anyone who has ever gone here before and enjoy it, the atmosphere has changed DRAMATICALLY. I went here a year ago and had a lovely experience. Went back a few weeks ago with some friends and had the worst experience of my life. A couple of my friends are 21 and they ordered a pitcher of sangria. The restaurant did not id any of us and handed all of us (including the underage ones) glasses to drink the sangria. We ordered cups of water for the table, as when you are drinking it is very important you stay hydrated. They brought us bottles of Poland spring. We questioned the waitress if we would be charged for the water and she said yes $2 a bottle. I said, we didn't want bottles, we want glasses of water for the table, like any normal restaurant. This woman was EXTREMELY rude right off the bat. She said they didn't have a filter for their water so they would not give us cups. (What kind of business serving food doesn't have a water filter?!?!?! That's disgusting!) The waitress then demanded that if we'd opened the bottles of water we MUST pay for them. I spoke to the manager after and she was just as rude if not more. I reminded her that it is a FEDERAL LAW, especially if you SERVE ALCOHOL, that every food serving establishment MUST PROVIDE A WATER SOURCE FREE OF CHARGE. Both the manager and the waitress teamed up on me, arguing and yelling at me that we all would have to pay for the water. I refused, sticking to my guns. The fact that they will serve alcohol to underage kids and DENY them water is a hazard of epic proportions. It is a ticking time bomb for the wrong 20 year old to come in, drink too much in the middle of the summer with no water , and pass out of dehydration. After I told her I would absolutely not pay for it, she called someone, who I'm assuming is the real owner, Maria, who has not been there much lately, and had a conversation with her. Following the conversation she said she would take the water off my bill, so it was pretty clear that whoever that woman is who is taking Maria's place right now is trying to turn the restaurant into a money trap. I said ok and went back to the table. Then when I received the bill I noticed they made an edit at the bottom for an addition (clearly typed in) of "1gratuity" for OVER TWENTY PERCENT OF THE BILL! I was infuriated. Instead of starting another war, my friends and I all left the exact amount in cash, excluding the gratuity. However, after reading recent reviews I've seen SEVERAL people say the same exact thing has happened to them. EXCEPT they paid with card and the restaurant CHARGED THEIR CARD AN EXTRA TWENTY PERCENT AFTER THE BILL WAS CLOSED. THEY ARE STEALING FROM THEIR CUSTOMERS!!! This is credit card fraud, it is JAIL TIME. They are very lucky that I didn't pay with card because if that had happened to me I would have gotten a lawyer. This business should be shut down and that is that. Unsafe, toxic environment, with a staff of thieves. read more