We love The Slice and could probably be considered "regulars" here! My husband and son love the pizza... well cooked and a great crust and toppings! I love the garlic Parmesan wings - extra crispy (well done). And you won't have to worry about vampires after eating lol! My husband also loves the Mango Habanero wings... a good amount of kick to them but very flavorful! Great experience all around! read more

Really good food, fair prices, nicely decorated and good atmosphere. Our server was friendly and accommodating, the food came out in a reasonable time and we really enjoyed our time at the restaurant. We will definitely be back and highly recommend this business. read more

First time guest. Got a large extra cheese and pepperoni pizza. It was perfect. Looking forward to going again. Service was also spot on. Star came and checked on us multiple times. It's a fun place in downtown Simpsonville. read more

It was a pleasant experience. A quick tip they don't serve extra slices on the weekends, only what's available on the glass counter. We ordered our 14" Cheese Pie with extra cheese. Make sure you order it Well Done so you don't get any flop. The Crust was tasty with a crunch. No extra grease which was a good sign. The sauce was good it just needed a pinch of garlic to amplify the sauce. The cheese was spot on with flavor. I would recommend this location especially from a New Yorker read more

The Slice - 14" Cheese Pie With Extra Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

A bunch of friends had the best time here Thursday night. We absolutely love The Slice! You can't go wrong ordering their pizza, but our fave is the pepperoni. The cheese and the pepperonis are full of flavor. The service was amazing, too. Thank you, Emma, for your excellent service! Michael, the manager, was good to us, too, and he made sure we were happy and had plenty. We sat inside (too hot and rainy for rooftop), but we were very happy with the seating and ambiance. Amazing night and fantastic food read more

Went to this place for the first time a few months back and I would go once a week if I could! My mother and I went for dinner and we both got a pasta dish and the noodles are so fresh and cooked absolutely perfect and the sauces are amazing. The garlic knots appetizer are not at all what you'd expect, they are massive rolls coated in fresh garlic and seasonings with Parmesan sprinkles in a bowl of olive oil. They are the DEFINITION of heaven in a bite of bread. Another dish I highly recommend would be the buffalo chicken pizza, it is amazing! Only downside I had during one visit were the chairs being very uncomfortable but I was also 8 months pregnant at the time! The staff are all friendly and attentive, I'm excited to visit again once they are done renovating and building the upstairs area!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza is Ok Folks. Pizza and Service meets the other local Pizza Places. The Vibe is not as good as across the Street. If all You want is to Grab a Slice of Good Pizza and Drink You have your place. read more

The Slice - Good Pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We finally got a chance to go back and dine in since they've reopened. The aesthetic is awesome and comfortable. Staff super friendly. The garlic knots to die for and pizza just the same. Great flavor and crips. Our northern family we took with us gave them their stamp of approval as well. Overall excellent. One thing we hope to see again from the old menu is the calzones. Regardless though, we will be back! read more

The Slice - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

One of the best pizzas I have tasted in a very long time. My husband and I ordered the meatball ricotta pizza but added buffalo mozzarella and basil. It was delicious beyond words. We loved the thinly sliced meatballs and the basil added an extra kick. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy. You know what was even better? Having it again the next morning for breakfast. Love the place. Very clean. Great music playing and you can also watch one of the many TVs. Our waitress was perfect. She didn't smother us and she didn't abandon us. Also kudos to the bartender for a very tasty and perfectly spicy Bloody Mary. This is it! Our new pizza spot! read more

So they changed ownership again and I gave it a try. Way better than before. I really like the pizza. Reminded me of true New York style pizza. The sauce was so good. I'll definable going back. read more

Love their Grandma Pizza. The Garlic Knots are The Best I've had bar none! We ordered the Grandma the other night and it was as good as the first one we had. Have had it several times on Friday nights when it's slammed and hasn't been as good . But with that being said The Slice is still one of the Best pizza places in the Upstate! Their Gnocchi is really good as well. read more

Upon our first visit we ordered a pizza pie (I forget the actual menu name) and it was delicious. You couldn't eat more than one slice! On our second visit we had a traditional pizza and I much preferred the pie variety we had the first time. It seemed to have a lot more flavor. I have also had the gnocchi which was wonderful (but very rich). It would be nice if the pasta came with bread. We have had different wait staff on our visits but none seemed overly friendly and were rather brusque. I will return because the food is good, just could use some friendlier wait staff. read more

Awesome crust and sauce. Super nice folks. We will be back after the renovations! Well worth a trip out to downtown Simpsonville read more

The Slice - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Highly recommend. Rooftop is great! Live music. Lots of waitstaff all of which are highly attentive. Several managers checked in on us (bigger party) and were kind and genuinely interested in our experience. Amazing in every way! read more

Found this place while looking for a central meeting for a business lunch. I was born in Brooklyn so this was a pleasure for me. The accents of the owners and the aura produced are definitely NY. The owner was such a nice lady and the prices were not outrageous especially for lunch. I had a chicken philly (not on the menu) and minus the missing mustard (my preference) it was good! I'm not a fan of pizza, I have to be in the mood for it so I can't review the pizza but what I could review was great. Hidden gem! Try it out! read more

The Slice - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

One of the best pizza places out there !! By far the best in the upper state !!! Garlic knots are amazing

Absolutely love this restaurant! We have eaten at pizza places across the US and this is by far one of our favorites. Everything is excellent, but I highly recommend the Italian salad and Alfredo spaghetti with spinach....superb! Service is fast and staff are always friendly. read more

I was in the mood for some New York style pizza being from Philadelphia. I don't didn't know any places in South Carolina that's that sold it. This place was The Slice was great and just what I wanted. I did take out so I didn't sit there. I want to go back and try their steak sandwich. read more

The Slice is our favorite in the Greenville area. It's the closest we've found to true NY style.

I recently had the opportunity to dine at The Slice, a pizza and pasta restaurant on Main Street in Simpsonville, South Carolina. It was reminiscent of a New York City pizza and pasta shop. Mike, the owner, was very friendly and shared his New York background. The Slice is a local and independently owned restaurant. They had a number of pizza pies, the classics, as well as white pies, and the Sicilian semi-thick crust type pizzas. If pasta is your thing, they had a focused selection plus all of the pasta is house-made. You have the choice of outside or indoor dining. They also have the traditional walk up window if you want to purchase just "a slice" on the go. The Slice is family friendly (kids menu) plus they have gluten free crust if needed. The Slice is another "gem" in downtown Simpsonville and worth the drive for a great slice of pizza. read more

We love this place but the prices have definitely gone up just like every place else but 9 bucks for a high noon. That's crazy.

Went in to try pizza. Got one slice of each.. Regular and Sicilian. Crust on regular slice was burnt on bottom and edges. Sicilian slice had cheese on top and some had wrapped around and covered bottom at front 1/3 of slice. Needless to say Sicilian was soggy and uncooked. It was easentially unedable. My wife on the other hand liked the regular slice. No complaint from her there. Posted review on other forum and owner tried to tell me I was getting his place confused with another pizza joint. As an owner you need to own your product. You may have had only one complaint on the pie that day however you had complaint. Trying to tell me I was mistaken and didn't eat at your place whe. I have photos of the product. SIR I do know where I eat and will not be back. Not that you seem to care. read more

See all

Love this place. Family from out of town loves it too! I will admit there isn't really a place to stand while waiting when it's packed. But, nevertheless, it's worth waiting for! Awesome garlic rolls, I could go here just for them. Great tenders and fries for the little kids who don't eat pizza. They love them too! Always clean. And pizza always yummy! read more

It was our first visit to Slice of Brooklyn since the ownership changed. The food, service, and atmosphere felt just like being back in Jersey/ New York. Good people great food. Pizza was spot on! Antipasto salad was beautiful and delicious. The fam and I dug into the sausage pie and fried mushroom appetizers before I got a picture. read more

The Slice - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Wings and pizza were fantastic. Crust was perfect and the meat lovers had tons of ingredients.

Call me loyal. Hands down the best pizza in the Greenville area, Consistently great. There is just something about it that makes it exceptional. The wings are also to die for. Enough said...just go eat at The Slice. read more

Closest thing I've had to NY pizza since moving here. Order was accurate and ready when I picked it up. Service was friendly. Most of all the food was delicious! read more

Don't go here by yourself.. There were three tables open on a Tuesday, and no they were not big tables. I guess they were planning for a rush of two or more. Decent pizza but I'll never be back. read more

Great pizza, and homemade pasta! We were visiting the Greenville area, and went here on a Saturday night. The place was busy, but the owners were all working the front, the bar, and the kitchen. We had pizza, and one of our group got the "Tiny's Trippin" with rigatoni instead of gnocchi. That sauce was amazing! (Wild mushrooms, parmesan,, and sherry truffle cream sauce). You have to try this!!! read more

First time at this place, but I will be back. So much more on the menu I want to try. Pizza and service were great. Love the full bar too!

Ok here we go. I need to stick with pizza and salad when I go there. The food here is good and they get crazy busy. A few weeks ago, I called in a to go order and it was done completely wrong. I ordered the gnocchi with vodka sauce and chicken parmigiana with marinara sauce. When I opened my package the chicken had been thrown on top of the gnocchi and vodka sauce was poured over the chicken, no marinara sauce! This is not what I ordered and when the restaurant sent me a text requesting a review, I was able to tell them of my disappointment with my order not being processed correctly. They were very responsive and issued me a gift card. So last night my wife and I do the 45 minute wait in the bar area with our two adult children. We got our high top table upstairs and our server was extremely busy. When we placed our orders, I explained to the server about my previous experience and she made it a point to show me how she understood my order and how she had it written down. About 20 minutes later which was fine our food was delivered. Mine was wrong again. The vodka sauce was on my chicken and the marinara sauce was on my gnocchi. My server was apologetic and confused. She stated that the person must not have read the order correctly and she took my plate and sought a manager to help her. My family enjoyed the food they ordered, I weighted for my dinner. When my family was finished eating my reworked order made it to the table and at this point the food was underwhelming and I was feeling like I needed to leave without fuss and never order anything other then a salad or a pizza if I ever go back. read more

Meh. The pizza was good....but I've had better in the area. The wings...we ordered mango habanero and got buffalo. Not to mention the price....for an 18" pizza, small order of wings and 2 beers it was $60!!!!!! . read more

Pizza was your average greasy slice of pizza. Nothing bad but wasn't overwhelmingly great. It didn't stand out to me as something going out of my way to get. Portions were great though! We also got the garlic rolls which came in 2 inches of butter in the bottom of the bowl. 15 year old me would've love it. They were good but definitely could've done without the massive pool of butter under them. read more

The meatball pie is absolutely amazing. This is New York Pizza !! So happy that this spot is here , I'll be ordering today as well being as it's football day. Cheers all. Simpsonville is so lucky to have a great pizza spot like this. Best in the upstate for sure. read more

It looks small inside. You can come in a buy a slice or buy a whole pie. My husband and I got Pepperoni Pizza, it was so good. We also got Garlic Rolls, they were big as your fist so delicious. My son ate kid's spaghetti, he really enjoyed it, being only 10 months old. We tasted it and we thought it had great flavor. read more

Seeing the mixed reviews we were hesitant. We were tied of the some old thing, as I think we all are right now, We had our sons get it for us. I am happy with every part if the order. I get Sausage, Beef, mushrooms, and olives. Great crust. Great sauce. Yes it was a 1 off but will try it again. read more

Was the pizza better than say... Little Caesar's? Yes, barely though. Another chain pizza joint (first Albanian pizza I've ever tried). Then the dining room is a loud bar with loud tipsy patrons and sports on big screens. Why always sports on big screens? Never music vids, movies, cartoons...always sports. read more

Best pizza I have had in South Carolina! I hear the May be opening another location in Fountain Inn?! Hope so.....

Excellent meal. The salad was fresh with a variety of vegetables. The pepperoni pizza had a crispy and flavorful crust - outstanding. The pasta Bolognese is clearly fresh pasta. Service was quick, friendly and efficient. read more

Mediocre pizza sauce and the chewiest pizza crust ive ever had. My jaw hurt after my first slice. Absolutely disgusting wings. Hour and a half wait to order. I would have been 20x's better off going to Pizza Hut. read more