Favorite in KC! I've been here a couple of times and have yet to be disappointed. The server gave us their hot honey (which you should put on everything), the garlic knots were perfect consistency, entrees were delicious and the staff at the bar were so much fun. Our table was pretty small but we also didn't make a reservation. read more

See all

After seeing so many great reviews, I decided to visit the Wise Guy and it definitely lives up to the hype! The food and service were amazing. To start off then night, I ordered their Amalfi Coast cocktail. I got it because I love peach flavoring, and it did not disappoint. It was a little sour because of the limoncello, but it was definitely a refreshing cocktail to have with my dinner. For appetizer, we got the mozzarella sticks and they were just okay. The marinara sauce tasted too much like oregano for my liking. The star of the show was their Chicken Parmesan with rigatoni Alla Vodka sauce. The chicken was juicy, full of flavor and the melted cheese was the cherry on top. The sauce had a little hint of spice to it, but it brought the dish together. Overall, The Wise guy might just be my new favorite italian spot in Kansas City. I enjoyed the ambiance, food and cocktails. One tip I have is always make a reservation. There were a group of people outside letting us know the wait time was an hour. Thankfully, we had a reservation already booked and they sat us right in, but if you are debating on waiting in line for an hour, just know it is worth it! read more

The Wise Guy - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

We have been trying to get reservations to this popular spot for quite a while and they are always fully booked. We can see why! Cute location but small so not a lot of room. We all shared a few items each and highly recommend the pizzas, spaghetti and rigatoni! We had a meatball and supreme pizza and loved the thin crust. We also enjoyed the bruschetta and deviled eggs for our appetizers! Will definitely be back! read more

See all

Love this place ! Great vibe and the food is outstanding we ordered pizza , pasta, appt, drinks and dessert and everything was outstanding read more

The Wise Guy - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

So cool to be back in the former Riegler Hotel in the Crossroads and to experience its rebirth as The Wise Guy, an Italian tavern. Entering its second week, we had a great time being served by Zach Marten and Bret Springs, the creative forces behind this new restaurant. The menu features a solid selection of Italian favorites from starters, salads, pizza and pasta. Lots of delish craft cocktails to enjoy as well. We started with the Meatballs and the Baked Taleggio. As much as we loved the rich marinara sauce with the meatballs, the show stopper was the puff pastry and Calabrian Chile Fermented Honey. Wow! We followed Bret's suggestion on the pizza: the Spicy Sausage and Giardiniera. This pizza screams Chicago from the thin crust to the Italian relish. It was perfect! For pasta we got a combo of Chicken Parmesan and Rigatoni Alla Vodka. A hearty portion full of Italian yum! We made room for the classic Tiramisu and it did not disappoint. If you want to spend less money, the Happy Hour food and drink specials from 4-6pm are outstanding. read more

See all

We were in town for a quick get away and had just enough time to grab a pizza before close. the staff was kind and didn't rush us. The pizza was AWESOME and loved the atmosphere. Next time we will allow more time. read more

The Caesar salad and Shrimp scampi were both tasty, as was the slice of pizza I tried. I still miss The Reiger in this location but The Wise Guy is a place we'll definitely return to. read more

What a cool place. We went for lunch and had incredible and attentive service. We started with the mozzarella sticks which weren't nearly as good as the fig sauce they came with, that stuff is insane!! So good! The sticks were good though! I got the meatballs for my meal and they were perfect. A little kick to them but such great flavor. My wife got the chicken parm sandwich and really enjoyed it. It is HUGE so if you are wanting to share something, it's a great option. All in all, great experience and will definitely be back. read more

Great first visit here for NYE dinner. The service and ambience were outstanding. Enjoyed the mozzarella sticks for an appetizer. The fig Marsala dipping sauce was delicious. The Italian chopped salad was one of the best salads I have had. Large enough for 2-3 to share. Our entrees were the chicken parmigiana and shrimp scampi. Both were fantastic. Would like to come back soon and try the pizza. read more

See all

Had a fantastic lunch at The Wise Guy with my daughter. The tavern-style pizza was outstanding, crispy and flavorful with perfect toppings. We ordered a half Caesar salad and The Supreme pizza topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, roasted red and green peppers, and black olives. Everything was delicious. The service was excellent and the staff treated my daughter so well, which made the experience even better. The ambiance was casual, comfortable, and inviting. Highly recommend for a family-friendly meal or just amazing pizza. read more

A great chill Italian spot that just popped up in the city. It took over where manifesto used to be and they did a great job. Lots of Italian food options and I would recommend a lot of them for sure! Don't sleep on the meatballs or the parm fries! If you are looking for a gluten free option there is a great salmon that was cooked perfectly! I would totally come back to check out the pizza, because the other tables that had it looked great! read more

See all

Dont walk! Run! The garlic knot is to die for! Soft and buttery. I love the marinara sauce that came with it! Perfect blend of Italian spices and tomato. I could literally eat that all day long. The place is super chill. Perfect lighting. Moody. Jazz music in the background. They even have their own parking lot on the side of the restaurant. I highly recommend making reservations online. They got busy really fast. read more

See all

Located on Main Street in the historic Rieger building. The street presence is phenomenal and the inside looks even better. It's a total makeover in here and it is working. The vibes were just totally on point. The music was on point, it was buzzy, the bar was packed, lighting levels were coming correct via very unique lighting fixtures. But I desperately wish the bar stools had backs - especially for eating italian food. Speaking of which, ordering was a tough decision that I thought about all day long. They have lots of apps, salads, sandwiches, pizzas - which seem very popular - as well as their pasta dishes. My husband and I shared apps (Garlic Knots, Meatballs, Mozzerella Sticks) and the Italian Chopped Salad. Which was truly more than enough. The meatballs had good flavor, a little dense. The mozz sticks, also had good flavor but definitely wish we had a larger group for that dish. And the garlic knots were SO good because they were soft and fluffy - not tough at all. For drinks, husband got the Black Manhattan - delish - followed by the Hookwinked - which burned at first but mellowed out towards the middle. I started with a glass of red wine, which I really enjoyed. Then, I had to try the espresso martini which sadly - I couldn't finish. Idk if it was just the acidic nature of everything or just how full I was. I can't wait til this hot spot mellows out and we can just walk-in for happy hour at the bar or to try one of their pizzas! But for now, make a reservation if you want to check this spot out! read more

See all

I've been to The Wise Guy twice so far and both times I have been thoroughly impressed! The ambiance of the restaurant is perfect for a date night or a girl's night out. I tried the chicken parm with spicy vodka pasta and the ravioli. I loved the chicken parm, the flavors paired so well together. The ravioli was alright but definitely a solid plate. I absolutely loved the caesar salad and the meatball appetizer. Unfortunately, deviled eggs were a bit of a miss for me. I also tried a cocktail which I absolutely loved. I got the gentleman and tonic, HIGHLY recommend! Overall, this is a great Italian spot in KC and would recommend you to check this restaurant out! read more

The Wise Guy - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Went last night for first time. Ambience is great. Service fantastic or server was very helpful with suggestions. Food was very good. Pizza fantastic. Salads are huge and very good. Had two appetizers the meatballs and whipped ricotta to share and both were excellent. We will be back for sure. read more

Wish I would've gotten pictures but that just tells you how good the food was. Loved the vibe and everything about our dinner date with friends was perfect! read more

I went here twice during my trip and really enjoyed it. The service was great both nights and the food was delicious. I had the Chicken Parm the first night and a pepperoni pizza on the second. The ambiance is nice as well. read more

See all

Everything was so, so, so GOOD! The service, the atmosphere, the FOOD! The burrata in the caprese salad was to die for. The pizza was so delicious and the cannolis tasted fresh and authentic. Please do yourself a favor and bless your taste buds with The Wise Guy. read more

See all

Great atmosphere and customer service! Caesar salad was good, meatball appetizer was very good with a great sauce! Pizza was just okay. Not as good as billed on Yelp. Cocktails are good but pricey. I would come here for happy hour instead of dinner! read more

Excellent food and beer. Our waitress was excellent. Great service. Highly recommend.

I've been here before, and it's always wonderful. My boyfriend and I came for my birthday tonight and Taylor was extraordinary! She was so attentive, helpful, and I really felt like she cared about our experience! We have been wanting to come here more and she just sealed the deal. Food, service, and atmosphere = perfect night out! Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

Where do I even start... Wise Guys is by far one of the best places I've eaten at. It was a busy night when me and my fiancé went in and they got us seated fairly quickly at the bar. I got the ravioli with Alfredo sauce which I cannot stop thinking about. I dream about this ravioli. The leftovers reheated magically as well. My taste buds have never tasted something so heavenly. My fiancé got a pasta with the vodka sauce which was very good as well. Neither of us can shut up about this place. The ambiance was amazing and service was great. I wanted a sweet ice tea (which they do not have) but the server still made one for me with some sweetener and their regular tea. The food came out pretty quick and was beautifully presented. When I say me and my fiancé cannot shut up about this place I mean it we went to Chicago and tried a very fancy Italian restaurant which couldn't even compare to The Wise Guy. You'll catch me here every-time I'm in KC! read more

See all

The food is really good. Our service was ok. We came here for lunch. 2 of us had the lunch special, which is a great deal. The caprese salad was really good. Thick cut of tomato, I can't imagine how good it would be come July when tomatoes are in season. The ambiance is quite interesting. When looking for a place to eat, I noticed the pizza photos, which looked like the kind we like. Crispy crust, soke regular toppings and a little variety. When entering the charming building, we were we greeted with a dark, low kit, high end lounge interior. The music is a classic soul mix. Then there are large tvs on the walls playing sports. We really liked the vibe here. Just wished the service would have been a bit more attentive. For example, I asked for a refill and was told in a minute. They went back to the kitchen, came out, started cleaning tables, went back to the kitchen, grabbed food, delivered it and then went to get me my soda. Maybe it's just a lack of efficiency? Not sure why I had to wait for him to clear a table before I got a refill as it turns out, it was in a can. read more

I was super excited to try The Wise Guy because I love Italian, but it just did not live up to the hype for me! I went for lunch on Sunday and it was not crowded, cool ambiance and very dark. I started with the garlic knots which were a little sweet for my taste - not sure if there was too much sugar in the dough and the sauce added to the sweetness. There were also only 4 and I thought $12 was overpriced for this appetizer. I got the lunch special with 1/4 of a pizza and a half Caesar salad. The pizza is Chicago tavern thin slice style and it was just okay. The salad also did not impress me unfortunately. Service was great and the bar was cute so maybe just a spot to grab drinks! read more

See all

Pros: atmosphere, service, food choices, exposed brick, tv placement, cool bar, great seating, strong Italian/sicilian foods, cocktails, happy hour Cons: I hate small water glasses, gluten free options, the food is rich, both our dishes were a bit spicy but I'm not great with spice. Would recommend absolutely! read more

The Wise Guy - Meat pizza, chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Wise Guy was such a great experience. My wife and I went recently and we loved it. We shared a few of the apps and everything was absolutely delicious. The bruschetta was fresh and flavorful, the four cheese ravioli was rich and perfectly cooked, and the rigatoni vodka was hands down one of the best we've had -- creamy, comforting, and full of flavor. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, and the service really stood out. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made the whole night feel easy and enjoyable. Such a great spot for a date night or a night out -- we'll definitely be back soon. read more

My friends and I started a supper club where we eat our way through Kansas City dining and Wise Guy was on this list this month. We also were celebrating two birthdays. We were blown away by the food, the service (shoutout to Miss Taylor because she was phenomenal) and the celebration that the atmosphere provided. From the apps, to the drinks, and the entrees everything was 10/10. Thank you Wise for making this such a memorable experience and feeding us well. We will be back! read more

We just wandered in for lunch because we had a volleyball tournament nearby. The staff was very welcoming and attentive. It's a dark and very atmospheric space, but interesting with Sinatra, Tom Jones etc playing in the background. The Italian beef and chicken pesto sandwiches along with the house made chips were very enjoyable. Would probably be a nice place to take a date. read more

Ambiance is really nice. Kind of dark and dramatic. Food was incredible with huge portions. Very attentive waiter also. read more

See all

Food was amazing and service was great. Awesome place for a lowkey date night. Feels like a speakeasy almost. 10/10 recommend.

First time to The Wise Guy but we will definitely be back. Thought this was just a pizza place but it's more like a cool swanky bar/restaurant. It was dark & moody with cool old music playing but also lots of TVs with sports on. We had 2 types of pizza & they were both really good. They also had hot honey on the table which is always a must! read more

See all

Great experience! While the menu isn't the biggest, the quality is there. My husband and I shared a Caesar salad and the wise guy pizza. Both were phenomenal, dare I say it could've been the best Caesar salad I've had My father-in-law got the salmon entrée and asked for them to tell the chef it was the best salmon dish she had ever had. Our server was absolutely phenomenal, very attentive and helped us and celebrating a birthday. The atmosphere is absolutely perfect for what they are going for... old Italian/Frank Sinatra/mob era. Hands-down great place you should try it. read more

My wife wanted to visit The Wise Guy pretty bad so we made it a date night. We had a reservation for 5:30 pm. That reservation time allowed us to order a round of drinks during happy hour along with some food. The happy hour price for a pizza is an awesome deal. I wasn't expecting a whole pizza for $15. I got the sausage and giardiniera pizza. It had a lot more spice than I expected, but it was really good. They had a tiramisu cannoli for dessert that I liked a lot too. Additionally, we had great service all night. read more

This place was amazing. Bragged about it to all my friends. Added items to my home charcuterie business based off amazing flavors of their appetizers! Run, don't walk! read more

Great new spot downtown! We made a reservation for a Saturday night and it was packed! Service was quick and it was a cute place for a night out. I got the chicken Parmesan with rigatoni and it was delicious! Perfect amount of spice and a large enough portion for left overs. The drinks were super yummy and arrived quickly. All of the staff were attentive and quick to help. We ended the meal with two cannolis that were very fresh! read more

See all

I love what the wise guy has done with this space downtown in KC. Offering home style Italian this spot is a must go for all things home style Italian. I started with the mozzarella sticks and loved their fig Marsala sauce that paired well alongside their house made marinara sauce to dip. The chicken parm was perfectly crispy with the spaghetti al dente read more

The Wise Guy - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

We love the ambiance of this Crossroads gem. Every pizza we have tried we have loved as well as great cocktails!

Yummy food and great happy hour deals! I loved checking out this new sleek cocktail and Italian spot. I tried the espresso martini which was decent. It was a little bitter but did the trick. I also tried the Aviation. Both drinks were good but not great. I also noticed the bartender was not measuring anything. Might have been better if it was. I also tried the Wise Guy Pizza. It was so delicious. One of my favorite pizzas I have had around town. The best part was their house made hot honey sauce to dip the pizza in. The prices were great on happy hour but a bit more then my pocket would like during normal hours. The upscale vibe was lovely to enjoy during happy hour and would be great for a late night drink. read more

See all

Love the ambiance and cozy vibes here! I have been here twice already and really enjoyed the food and drinks! The service has been consistent and accommodating. The best pizza in town! Love the thin, crispy crust! So good! I can't wait to come back again. read more

See all

I ate solo at the bar while in KC for a conference. For a Saturday night I had a very short wait to be seated. The bartender was training someone, but still remained attentive, informative and friendly. His appetizer and pasta suggestions were delicious. The decor and music matched the expected vibe to a T. read more

The Wise Guy - Deviled eggs - Pizza Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all