Thee Ice Cream Parlor

4.0 (74 reviews)

InexpensiveIce Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Custom Cakes, Waffles

Closed • 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Updated 3 weeks ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Thee Ice Cream Parlor Photos

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - salty caramel - small in sugar cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - pumpkin - small in gluten-free sugar cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

+49

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Vanilla Peanut Butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Thee Ice Cream Parlor Popular Dishes

1 Photo4 Reviews

about 2 months ago

I was so happy to see one of my hard to find favorites of Black raspberry chocolate chunk!! Convenient from either side of highway due to a traffic light right there. Also, Overflow parking in the back.

12 months ago

My husband had black raspberry with chocolate chunks. Lots of specialty sundaes too

4 Photos2 Reviews

about 1 year ago

I got the chocolate hazelnut that tasted like chocolate with chocolate syrop and brandy in it rather than any hazelnuts - nobody liked that flavor. The pricing was fair and staff very nice.

almost 8 years ago

Chocolate hazelnut and tiramisu are amazing. They have every ice cream topping you could want.

2 Photos2 Reviews

over 5 years ago

They have lots of ice cream options to choose from, and we went with vanilla soft serve, dipped in cherry magic shell, on sugar cones. Really nice quality. Delicious. Everyone enjoyed it. Nearly $15 for 3 cones seemed to be a bit...

almost 11 years ago

I went here on a Saturday night around 5:30 PM and it was pretty crowded which is always a good sign. I ordered frozen yogurt with red velvet flavoring topped with rainbow sprinkles and my boyfriend ordered two scoops of hard ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Our total was $10.65 which is was a little pricey in my opinion for the size. The hard ice cream was decent - coconut almond swirl and peanut butter.

My red velvet didn't taste like anything red velvet but it tasted like a good vanilla soft serve. Overall- expensive but good ice cream. Not a place to frequent but for a special treat I'd go back.

Thee Ice Cream Parlor menu photos

Menu photo 1 Thee Ice Cream Parlor Flemington, NJ

Menu photo 2 Thee Ice Cream Parlor Flemington, NJ

See all

THEE ICE CREAM PARLOR ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

6 Photos

Outside

8 Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Thee Ice Cream Parlor

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos - Thee Ice Cream Parlor

This Vanilla Soft Serve jawn with Rainbow Sprinkles

Chastity R.

$5 for a pretty large small cone with sprinkles. Not bad at all. The sprinkles were fresh... very crunchy and not waxy tasting at all. The vanilla was just that. Very vanilla &, for lack of a better word, boring. It wasn't watery nor was it creamy. It wasn't gross either. It was just there. They have lots of other options if soft serve isn't your thing. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was a nice day out so I sat on one of their many benches instead of my car. They even have picnic tables in case you need to put a banana split down.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The lady who served me was nice and appreciated that tiny tip I left. And trust me, it was tiny. Sorry. It's all I had. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Overall, a chill place to treat yourself.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]

Katarina L.

Gotta love a walk up window ice cream spot. They are fairly new to Flemington (like a few years old) but I love seeing the crowd on hot summer nights. Their ice cream is pretty wonderful and I am still searching for a flavor I don't love. The last trip included a scoop of tiramisu in a sugar cone and oh man, just so good. Loved that you could actually taste all of the tiramisu goodness mixed with creamy ice cream. It was a hot day and I could not have been happier. Can't wait for another trip and another flavor!

Emily M.

My mom and I decided to stop by Thee Ice Cream Parlor to try some homemade ice cream on our way back from shopping. We both got small sugar cones! I got the Vanilla Peanut butter which was good but nothing crazy. Then my mom got the Cappuccino Blast which was definitely more unique and very delicious. Every time I pass it there is always a line! So be prepared to wait in line, we waited almost 10 minutes. My only suggestion is to bring your own extra spoon because there is a 10 cent charge for an extra one... lol Would I go back again? Yes! Would I go out of my way to pick it up? No, but if im driving by I definitely would stop!

Elizabeth G.

Really really great ice cream, good vibes and atmosphere and loved the outdoor seating. Just a couple things they can work on: 1) could definitely use more flavor options. The ones they have are really good but there should be more of a variety. 2) a small pet peeve, but ice cream parlors shouldn't just put a scoop on top of a cone, they should fill the actual cone a bit as well. In general, I will absolutely come back. The sundae wall was great and the ice cream tasted fantastic.

Karolina M.

Always busy and its obvious why! Delicious icecream for a reasonable price. They offer so many flavors and toppings galore! My parents are fussy icecream eaters but they loved it! 100% a go to spot!

See all

Review Insights

Michael E.

8 years ago

I thoroughly enjoyed Thee Ice Cream Parlor! Great flavors, good prices and most importantly, very friendly employees! The decor takes you back to early style Ice Cream stores! Love it! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sara S.

8 years ago

Great local ice cream shop! The interior has a 50s diner feel. The outside seating is great to hang out with active children. It's conveniently located on 202. I believe they relocated to this new space about a year ago. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian H.

8 years ago

Excellent ice cream choices. Chocolate hazelnut and tiramisu are amazing. They have every ice cream topping you could want. read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John D.

9 years ago

There really isn't anything special about it, it's basically store bought ice cream and compared to it's counter part the polar cub way pricer for what it is, I got a brownie Sunday and it was literally like 1 by 2 inch's long and was almost comical considering the prices they charge. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa D.

8 years ago

Stopped in only after hitting "The fudge Shoppe" best chocolate ever! Order two double scoop cones,plain & simply. The girl was pretty rude & impatient. Didn't even know there was an ice cream menu flavor sign hanging on the wall, asked & she made us look on the case. Small portions~ high price, plus she over charged us. Charged for 3 cones! Extra 2.99! Girl was rude and dumb! Really ten bucks for two tiny cones~ Total rip off.. First & last time there. Won't go back, ice cream wasn't even good.. Grochowitz in Glen Gardner is the best "real homemade" ice cream in Hunterdon county.. No doubt! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C R.

7 years ago

Wonderful shop! At a short notice the owner made the most beautiful frozen yogurt cake to celebrate a special Birthday! Great service and the cake was so delicious. This is truly a gem here in Flemington read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George B.

7 years ago

I just had a 3 scoop dish and thought it was delicious. This was my first visit and the salty caramel flavor was quite good. Then I added moose tracks and black raspberry chunk. No disappointment here. I will be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael T.

13 years ago

Place is old fasioned and awesome! So many different things to choose from and everything is good! My daughter goes there on Friday nights in the summer and watches movies outside on the lawn. The staff are nice and friendly! Will be back for sure! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Fran C.

105

10 years ago

Very cute setting, love the 1950s theme decor. Ice cream is good, not great. But I did enjoy it.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kate L.

Elite 23

142

335

526

11 years ago

Nice, old fashioned ice cream parlor with stools and booths and everything. You can get a good malted shake here and they have a private room in the back for parties. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Elizabeth N.

11 years ago

We loved this place! Brought my four kids here after a fun trip to Northlandz nearby...this is an adorable ice cream parlor, very clean, amazing variety, and yummy ice cream. Great all-around. Also had a nice talk with the owner...she's wonderful! Highly recommend!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mark N.

8 years ago

Families beware. Went to Thee Ice Cream Parlor with my 2 daughters (6 and 3)on a Tuesday night. Only other customer was an older gentleman. My kids were just being kids, nothing out of the normal for kids of that age (and I'm a teacher). Older woman (maybe owner or manager) treated us rudely, and referenced my kids as elephants. We paid and left. No business should treat the customer in that fashion....just give us our order and let us be on our way. It's like you never had families as customers. Would love to support local non-chain businesses...but this one no more. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ed P.

10 years ago

Classic looks, and the ice cream doesn't let you down. Good selection of favors, toppings, overall choices. Great staff, clean and organized store with friendly knowledgable staff. Can't wait to go back! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bella L.

9 years ago

Chick behind the counter totally over charged me and my boyfriend! I've never paid $10 a piece for a stinking ice cream cone, even on a special cone! The ice cream wasn't worth the money at all, didn't taste all that great, and I left completely disappointed. Plus, the parking lot was very small and over packed; people kept driving up through the wrong entrance. That was my first and last time coming here. I will at least say one nice thing about the place though, love the design layout. It's a shame the place left a bad taste in my mouth because they have what looks like an amazing list of sundaes... read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elaine H.

8 years ago

My husband and I went there about a half hour after it opened and requested our usual sugar free/fat free chocolate/vanilla swirl medium cup. We were told that the machine was being cleaned and wasn't available. My husband is diabetic and that's the only ice cream he can eat. I thought it was unprofessional to be open for business, but not have the soft serve machine operational. Shouldn't they be cleaning the machines prior to opening for the day? Also, it took 5 minutes for someone to come out front and wait on us. This is not a professionally run business. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher G.

12 years ago

I would definitely visit this place again...stopped by tonight after work. The servers were very nice and helpful....I had the salted caramel ice cream with chopped pretzels in a milkshake and it was awesome! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Linda N.

8 years ago

So disappointed with this place. Intended to invoke a 1950's ice cream parlor feel, the decor instead reminded me more of a Walmart clearance aisle. Except for a framed Elvis album cover, there was nothing original to the 50's. It is a very cheesy attempt at vintage, indeed. I waited on line and when my turn came to be waited on three times I was asked what I wanted and three times as I was about to open my mouth the order taker turned and spoke to someone else. Finally on the four attempt I was able to answer only to find that they were out of the flavor I had come for, vanilla peanut butter. I made a second choice, butter pecan, paid my $5 and left in my car. The ice cream itself was a major disappointment. Not only were there just a few tidbits of pecans, the ice cream melted at an extremely fast rate and had to be eaten quicker than I would have wanted. The temperature was in the mid 60's with about 70% humidity. I fully realize that the fillers that are used in commercial ice creams that keep ice cream from melting are not present in hand made ice creams. But perhaps thee ice cream parlor should read the following article from an award winning ice cream maker on how to keep ice cream from melting. http://icecreamscience.com/ice-cream-melt/ In the end I wish I had saved my $5 for a Starbucks, instead. Better places to go for hand made ice cream: Summer Ville Handmade Ice Cream Somerville, NJ Gabriel's Fountain Martinsville, NJ read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stephen F.

12 years ago

We had two cakes from here last night. They were delicious. Rachel was easy to work with and the cakes were beautiful. She really did a great job. Thanks!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pete R.

7 years ago

Just had an awesome birthday cake from TICP...everyone raved about it...beautifully decorated...it is the best ice cream place around...great soft serve, and a huge selection of hard ice cream flavors...something for everyones take.....they have gluten free cones and all....also a great frozen yogert....friendly and attentive staff... read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michele H.

12 years ago

OMG! So many flavors to choose from! Cute place with friendly staff! Oh and the ice cream is good too... If you like soft serve they have like a gazillion flavors. We will be going back to try some more! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cynthia C.

10 years ago

The ice cream here is wonderful. Yogurt is delicious. Actually made me a milkshake with water and yogurt and it was absolutely the best milkshake I could ever have with so little calories. A little overpriced but the server was extremely nice. I would definitely frequent this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peter D.

8 years ago

Have been here twice. While slightly expensive, the ice cream is worth the price as it's homemade and their servings are not skimpy. Milk Shakes were very good too. Custom ice cream cakes also seem worthy of a try. The place was clean and the service adequate. In my opinion this place is way better than Polar Cub which I always thought quite average. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Fart M.

8 years ago

The first time I went to the ice cream parlor only ice cream frozen yogurt every thought that I would ever have until I die or they close. The ice cream parlor is a very family and community based company. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Victoria S.

11 years ago

Nice old school ice cream parlor. Will never purchase a Carvel cake again!! Even have movie nights for entertainment.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria S.

8 years ago

The ice-cream here is so good! Even better than Polar Cub! So good! It's slightly expensive but well worth it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Holly R.

9 years ago

Ice cream was great! As a person who has tried plenty of ice cream places in random places while traveling, this place was great! Love the feel & the options and the woman that helped us was very pleasant. Would highly recommend! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shootem C.

9 years ago

This place is still Gross! Gross gross even though they moved to a new location. Don't waste your calories on junk. Go To oh wow cow for true homemade organic ice cream. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mark R.

283

12 years ago

They have the best ice cream around and the cakes are awesome as well. For price: standpoint, they are much more reasonable than 16 handles.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt C.

12 years ago

We have been to Thee Ice Cream Parlor on a number of occasions. The staff is always as friendly as can be. The ice cream is delicious. The decor is fun. We decided order an ice cream cake for our son's 3rd birthday. The cake was adorable and absolutely delicious! Everybody at our son's birthday gathering was blown away by the cake. I highly recommend this ice cream parlor. You will NOT be disappointed. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Renay S.

108

9 years ago

The best ice cream in town!! Wonderful staff & very helpful. Unique flavors that you will not find anywhere else! Worth the trip every time!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pink S.

9 years ago

Pretty new establishment, very friendly staff and owner, accomodating to show ingredients since have many food sensitivities. The ice cream itself, eh. It melted funny, and stuck together weirdly. Odd consistency. Didn't seem very rich. Decor is nice and old fashioned looking. I tried 3 flavors and had to settle since none tasted as creamy as I've had elsewhere. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John M.

10 years ago

Terrible customer service. Overly tanned woman with short Kate Gosselin hair charged me extra money for using a debit card before I could get my cash out and said "Too late, already ran it." The ice cream is average and you can find a worthy substitute anywhere. I would recommend going to Rita's. They treat you a lot more nicely and it's cheaper. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Debbie H.

10 years ago

They have a nice selection of ice cream and a ton of different sundaes. I've been here a couple times and the ice cream is good and they give you a decent amount of ice cream and toppings for the sundaes. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shawn T.

12 years ago

My wife and I love this place! The servers were super nice and they have great soft serve flavors. I had pistachio and next time I go back I'll get pumpkin...it is the fall. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 2

More info about Thee Ice Cream Parlor

463 US Hwy 202
Flemington, NJ 08822
Directions
(908) 284-1233
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.theeicecreamparlor.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Thee Ice Cream Parlor open?

Thee Ice Cream Parlor opens at 12:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Thee Ice Cream Parlor close?

Thee Ice Cream Parlor closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor take credit cards?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor have catering options?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor does have catering options.

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor have a drive thru?

No, Thee Ice Cream Parlor does not have a drive thru.

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor serve alcohol?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor serves alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor allow dogs?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor have bike parking?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor has bike parking.

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor have parking?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Thee Ice Cream Parlor wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Thee Ice Cream Parlor is wheelchair accessible.

Does Thee Ice Cream Parlor have free WiFi?

No, Thee Ice Cream Parlor does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Step back in time to the 50's! It not just our great ice cream it's the whole experience!! We have thee best Home-made Ice Cream along with the world's healthiest frozen yogurt; "ONLY 8" calories per ounce!! and it comes in over 100 flavors! Absolutely delicious!! Come in and check it out! Ice Cream Cakes...custom made to however you want! Please call us or stop in for more information.

History

Established in 2004.

Started in 2004; stayed 6 years in another location before the move to a larger facility; 299 South Main Street, Flemington where we have two large party rooms.

Meet the Business Owner: Rachel C.

Born and raised in Flemington.

Ask the Community - Thee Ice Cream Parlor

Do they have any vegan options?

No answers yet. Be the first to answer.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

La Bella Cakery

Loved the cake they made for us. Just the right amount of everything. Ordering was easy and got…read moredelivered on time. Quality of ingredients were on point and the cake looked so pretty

I ordered a cake for my sister's baby shower and La Bella was able to deliver it to the restaurant…read morewhich was a huge plus because I live out of state and would have been unable to pick it up. I sent a picture of what I wanted to have done and the colors of the cake. The cake was made absolutely beautifully and very delicious! I ordered vanilla raspberry and the raspberries were extremely fresh. I would 100% recommend La Bella to anyone especially if you are looking for a custom cake.

Photos

See all

Fondant cake : top - chocolate / raspberries ; bottom - vanilla / fresh cream and pineapple

Sweet As Sugar Desserts

5.0

(2 reviews)

55.4 mi

We recently celebrated a friend's birthday in Tobyhanna, and I needed a nearby bakery since we…read morewould be driving in from Brooklyn. I was considering ordering a cake from ShopRite until I came across Sweet as Sugar Desserts. I'm so happy I found them because I prefer supporting local businesses, especially when they are POC and women owned. Right off the bat, the customer service was amazing. No more than 2 hours after I submitted the order form online, was I contacted by the proprietor Christiane. After a short email exchange, we spoke on the phone to communicate order specifics and to ensure she understood my "vision." And boy, did she come through! I already had a good sense of her decorating skills, but since there were no other reviews, I really did not know what to expect in terms of flavor. I ordered a tres leche cake with dulce de leche filling, and it frikken delicious!! The cake was perfectly moist, and the flavor of the filling was well balanced with the cake - which with this flavor combo can be overly sweet. But she really killed it and everyone loved it, the birthday girl especially. I couldn't recommend Sweet as Sugar Desserts enough!

Really good service. I ordered a cake from NY for my husband's bday with her in Poconos because we…read morewere celebrating in Poconos. She made the cake exactly as requested with all the details I requested. And the cake was delicious!!!

Photos

See all

Buttercream Dreams

5.0

(7 reviews)

27.3 mi

Highly recommend this artistic cake maker! I shared a few inspo pictures and was so happy with what…read moreKathy created. The cake was also very delicious and a huge hit at the party.

Buttercream Dreams has done it again! So many beautiful cakes added to our memories! Every cake has…read morebeen delicious, fresh and absolutely beautiful! The service is impeccable, Kathy always goes above and beyond to make sure my imagination is brought into reality!

See all

Creative Cakes by Sweta

5.0

(1 review)

12.1 mi

Sweta is the only person I go to now because I don't believe there is another baker more talented…read morethan her. It's hard to make sth look pretty and taste good, and Sweta somehow has achieved the impossible each time. She's great with communication, reliable, and she knows what you are looking for with only a few messages. She exceeds my expectations each time, and my birthday cake pops by Sweta have been the highlight in my friend group year after year.

From the owner: Call or text (724) 726-1792 Custom Cakes, Cupcakes,…read moreCakepops and more

Photos

See all

Where the wild things are

Debbie’s Creative Cakes

5.0

(5 reviews)

42.8 mi

Debbie just provided gluten free cupcakes for my daughter's baby shower at the Molly Pitcher Inn…read more The rave reviews were wonderful to hear. The cupcakes were beautifully decorated and beautifully presented. The chocolate cake was rich and moist. The flower designs on top were gorgeous. The frosting was delicious and creamy. Debbie worked with me on every detail. She was a true professional and a delight throughout the process. She's honest and she truly cared about our special occasion. I will absolutely call her for my next party. Thanks so much, Debbie!

Debbie did an amazing job for my husband's 40th cake! I sent her some photos for inspiration and…read moreshe did a fantastic job. Most importantly, it tasted AMAZING! Multiple people texted me the next day comment again on how great the cake was. Highly recommend her cookies and cream flavors!

Photos

Sculpted cat on a pumpkin cake

Modern navy and gold cake

See all

Chocolate tiered with handmade sugar flowers

Storybook Cakes

5.0

(1 review)

7.5 mi

Storybook Cakes designed a gorgeous custom cake for our wedding day this past weekend. It was…read moreabsolutely beautiful! She also baked chocolate chip cookies and cupcakes for our day - everyone commented on how delicious the desserts were!!! We are so thankful we found Trista and would HIGHLY recommend her!!!

From the owner: *Gluten free & Paelo specialties available*read more

Sweet New Creations

Highly recommend Sweet New Creations! Daisy, the owner, responded quickly after I reached out to…read moreher for a cake for my daughter's third birthday. I was so happy to see that she offered a variety of flavors for cakes especially Ube macapuno. We ordered a 8x5 round Ube macapuno cake with Ube buttercream filing and macapuno strings. When placing the order it was very smooth without any complaints or confusion. The cake was absolutely divine! It was moist and flavorful, not too sweet, it was perfect. My family demolished the cake! She will be our go to for family events.

Attended a baby shower on Sunday, we had a few friends who were in charge of pulling this off for a…read morefriend. My gf was in charge of getting the cake which she ordered from Sweet New Creations. The Mommy To Be is a huge Harry Potter fan & I honestly wasn't sure how we would incorporate this theme into a baby shower but we did and boy oh boy was the cake out of this world! The details were amazing! The little baby cake topper was so cute, and they gave instructions on how to keep her (to dry her out) which the mom will do. The cake not only looked amazing it tasted delicious also. Often so many of the ascetically nice looking cakes don't taste so good. In this case it was a win win all around. I usually just have a bite of cake to taste it as I am not a dessert eater but I ate the entire piece. Definitely will go there for cakes in the future!

Photos

See all

BAM Desserts

4.6

(109 reviews)

16.9 mi

I see why this business has so many great reviews! I came on Yelp to search for a place that…read moreoffered vegan cake, cupcakes & cookies. Boy was I in for a literal treat!! This small space is packed with a whole lot of goodies. I was fortunate enough to purchase 4 deliciously moist vegan cupcakes. Unfortunately I had to share two of the four, thankfully though I was able to have a small sampling & the richness & perfect amount of sweetness was superb. I can't wait to travel back & try some new holiday flavors! Also, customer service is as sweet as the pie's they serve. I love that they offer/sell a boxed sampling of a couple flavored cakes, plus icing for when you want to order a custom cake or cupcakes. Even the website is great! My only con, I wish they had pictures showing/sharing the difference between a 3 tiered cake & a 3 layered cake. Plus detailed names/titles of cake decoration options would be great. I was a complete virgin to ordering a custom cake & I honestly felt like a lost kid.

The personalized cookies were fabulous. I had three different photos on three dozen cookies…read more The Bam cookies are consistently delicious and beautiful

Photos

Gender reveal cake

Cupcakes!

See all

Knead More Sweets

5.0

(3 reviews)

15.4 mi

I'm not a big sweet person but these cookies were amazing! It wasn't overly sweet and melted in my…read moremouth perfectly. The cookie had a thickness to it which made it so sturdy, and the royal icing designs were done so neatly. This bakery was at an event I was recently at and Carley was super nice. Offered as many samples as I pleased. Along with the cookies, she was also selling some cookie cakes. I bought a cookie for a friend for Valentine's Day but it was so good I ended up eating it. Oops. When I unwrapped the cookie, I was surprised that it was sealed even under the tied top. Very small detail to notice but it shows that they care about the freshness of the cookies and take the time to make sure the customer gets the best product possible! (Side note: I love the design of the logo! The letters flow so seamlessly together - the K and M look like an apple with the stem and leaf still attached. )

Incredible sweets! This bakery is woman-owned and the service is fantastic! She is quick to respond…read moreto requests and can do pick up or drop offs for orders. I've also ordered custom cookies from her-- she does such an amazing job turning my vision into reality!

See all

The Cake Addict

5.0

(2 reviews)

25.6 mi

Once again,Sabrina, you outdid did yourself! The cake was as amazing amazing to Sage and everyone…read moreas well as absolutely delicious! Thank you Flavor: Chocolate Filling: Black Forest Frosting: Vanilla Buttercream Sabrina, The Cake Addict, is the best!!

Our guests raved about how gorgeous the cake looked. Also got feedback that the cake tasted good…read more We asked for this to be made with only 1 week notice - very grateful for being so accommodating and responsive.

Photos

See all

City Bagel Cafe

Best everything bagels in Flemington!!! The kindest people at the counter! I'll be back forever!read more

My first review was 2 years ago and there have been no changes. The owners (Edward and Stella and…read morePak) are as genuine as you can get. They love their customers and greet everyone like family. The bagels are the best around, no doubt

Photos

Sitting Area

Sliced Lox on everything bagel (Vegetable Cream cheese/Tomato/Caper)

See all

Outside

Dutch Country Farmers Market

This is an amazing Amish market. It is 5 minutes from my sister's house. As soon as you walk in you…read moreare greeted with the pleasant smell of fresh pretzels and freshly baked doughnuts! All the food and products are from the Amish people. Everyone is so friendly and the service is fast and efficient. My mom ordered a strawberry milkshake. She said it was one of the best milkshakes she ever had. They put a bunch of fresh strawberries inside and she said it wasn't too sweet but just perfect. My husband ordered a cookies and cream milkshake. He also said it was made really well and was not too sweet. Just a clean creamy cookie flavor. Of course we had to try the doughnuts. I ordered an apple and a chocolate with sprinkles. The apple was really good! It was freshly baked, and the filling was delicious and had a nice cinnamon flavor. The chocolate was also very good! They are big donuts too! 2 for $5. Now to the delicious soft pretzels! They are freshly baked, soft, buttery, and delicious!!! You can also get them in garlic, cinnamon, and sour cream and onion. They have pretzel dogs too. Fresh fudge anyone? They have a large variety of fudge treats. They have fresh meats, jewelry, furniture, and other items for sale as well. I wished we had more time to explore and try more things. They are only open on Thursdays and Saturdays until 3:00 PM.

Prices are a bit high (like everywhere else on the planet right now too), and not entirely sure…read morewhat percent is really affiliated with Dutch Farmers (Amish). I did have some very tasty donuts (10000 times better and more "real" than Dunkin and less expensive than some bougie places that charge $5 per donut). I have had the filled pretzels - my spouse liked those, me not so much though (I felt like they were too moist/undercooked for my personal liking). I don't have complaints, I just can't buy what I can't afford and guess I will refrain from the pretzel things while my husband enjoys his.

Photos

Inside by the bakery and deli

See all

Bistro 55

This place is excellent! The food was delicious (we had several salads, both chicken and lamb…read moresouvlaki which came with rice, salad abd french fries, hummus, baba ganoush, spicy feta with pita bread ...) The coffee was so strong and nice, and came in the cutest cups and saucers that looked like purses. And there are cake parfaits (photo below) in a variety of flavors. I had pistachio and chocolate, my sister had the strawberry shortcake - everything was fresh and flavorful. They can accomodate larger groups but it is best to call ahead as it is a popular place. The staff was also very nice!

I had chicken that was so dry I actually choked on it. My husband( Charles, I'm Brenda ) had…read moreoctopus, calamari and shrimp. You know that was expensive! It was so overcooked he said it was like chewing on rubber bands. It never broke down. He basically had to swallow it. Worse experience ever!!!

Photos

Entrance

See all

Store front

Main Street Bagel

I return to Main Street Bagel after trying a few others. They all have their interesting twists but…read moreI continue to return to Main Street bagel in Flemington, NJ because the taste of the on prem baked bagels, coupled with great fresh toppings, and care for consistent quality and rich flavors keep me coming back again and again. My go to is a Toasted Onion bagel with Bacon(crispy) eggs, cheese, katchup, pepper, a dash of salt. Heaven in Hunterdon County. Coffee is always fresh and rich. Service is amazing as only a small American diner can deliver. I love coming to Flemington's Main Street and enjoying the old school shop to bring the experience home. It's got plenty of clean seating, in warmer months sitting on their front porch is a must. I'll always search for a nice bagel but I'll always return to the great American Bagel restaurant for the best quality & flavors anywhere.

I love their bagel sandwiches here! They use really great ingredients and they're always amazing…read moreand flavorful. The bagels are the classic, slightly dense, NYC bagels - the everything bagel is also amazing. The staff is also really great and friendly - though they're sometimes rushed with orders on the weekends. Additionally there's a nice seating area to sit and eat in Main St.

Photos

Delicious coffee

Tasty coffee and absolutely required with any bagel choice.

See all

Menu (interior)

D’Serve

4.9

(15 reviews)

1.6 mi

I had a great experience at this restaurant and can't wait to go back. The donut was incredibly…read moretasty - fresh, soft, and just the right amount of sweetness. I also ordered the Puerto Rican Plate, and it did not disappoint. Everything was flavorful, well-seasoned, and cooked to perfection. One thing I really appreciated was that they offer vegan options, which I'm excited to try on my next visit. It's always a plus when a place has something for everyone. The real standout, though, was the coconut tres leches - it completely stole the show. Rich, moist, and packed with coconut flavor. Overall, the experience was fantastic, and I'll definitely be coming back

The Chef , Andrew met us outside while we were walking around before our reservation. We were early…read moreand he ushered us right in. The service was warm and helpful. The food was amazing. The vegan Shakshuka was so flavorful and the Puerto Rican Breakfast was perfect. We will definitely be back for dinner and brunch again! Thank you for the great meal and experience!!

Photos

Diners

Bathroom

See all

Cool light fixture leading into kitchen

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Maria E.

6 years ago

the ice cream is delicious, I love the service and has different flavors. In addition to having hot dogs we can go with family and friends on hot days!!! read more

Luciana Rabelo D.