First time here! Was craving pizza and wings one night. Since I am fairly new to the Lutz area, I went on Yelp to find the nearest pizza place and discovered Three Brothers. After looking through the pictures I decided to get whatever they had already made to-go lol. I ended up with the garlic parmesan wings, a slice of cheese pizza and a piece of cheesecake. The pizza was delicious! It had obviously been sitting there for a while but it was still yummy. The wings had amazing flavor and the bleu cheese was very good. But let's talk about that cheesecake!!! Listen, whoever is baking the cheesecake could make me some EVERY DAY and I wouldn't complain. It's literally the best I've ever had. Now when I think about dessert after dinner I immediately think about Three Brothers cheesecake. You have to try it out! I'm so glad it's right around the corner from me now and as always, thank you Yelpers for your awesome suggestions. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Their delicious cheesecake! - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

Excellent service and great food! Pizza and salad was delicious! Atmosphere was great! Very upbeat! JRMSH

The food is always good and I recommend it. Today I placed an order for delivery with a 2L of soda. I called and asked if I could get a cup of ice with my order. They went out of their way to make sure I was satisfied and sent me a cup of ice. Great food and great service. A+++. read more

A little overpriced. But the food and service is amazing. So I am willing to pay for the food! Have never gotten a bad item here, everything is delicious and the staff is soo helpful. read more

Why 5 stars? Because this is a great option when you're looking to support local. --- --- --- I don't spend a ton of time in Odessa/Keystone, but it's a super nice area. My only regret is that we took this drive at night and weren't really able to take in a ton of what was around us. But once we arrived to the shopping center, it was quite an adorable little plaza with some character to it. Because we had our kiddo with us, we opted to sit outside where we wouldn't annoy anyone around us if he were to get loud. Despite being the only table outside, our very friendly server never forgot about us and we had prompt service all night. We ordered the loaded garlic bread and the antipasto salad to start. The loaded garlic bread totally hit the spot - the only problem was that I wish there was more of it. And the salad was possibly the most loaded salad I've ever seen in my life. It really was much more like a giant antipasta platter that happened to have some lettuce under it. The pizza was quite tasty. We opted for custom toppings: just prosciutto and fresh mozzarella. We enjoyed it but my only minor critique is that I like pizza that's either very thin or very thick. This was kind of in the middle. But even as I just ate leftovers the next day while typing this review, the pizza was still very delicious. We'll definitely head back here again to try some other items on this very lengthy menu! read more

Always great food and friendly staff! Looking forward to the next visit already. Definitely recommend! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Great atmosphere! - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

The wings have no seasoning on them at all and are fried too long, very overcooked. The garlic knots were good.

It's good pizza, is it great pizza? No. The salad is good, service was fine. Couple of good beers

I initially called the Odessa location to place an order and waited on the phone for about 3 minutes before anyone answered. When someone finally came to the phone the said pick up would be about 45 mins to an hour. I discussed with my husband to see if he wanted to dine in instead and he decided we should just pick up. At that point I didn't want to hold up the line so I hung up and placed an online order. I placed my order at 7:03. The confirmation said ready by 7:47 but I get to the restaurant at 7:52 and the order still isn't ready. I was told to wait about 5 minutes and ended up waiting another 20 minutes. I did not get my order until 8:18pm. My garlic knots were burnt and dry, no garlic sauce on them and the pizza was burnt as well with less pepperoni than expected. The only enjoyable part of my food was the wings. I was feeding my entire family of 4 from this meal and they forced themselves to eat it because we had already waited so long to eat and had no other option. I will not be visiting again or recommend this location to anyone. From the wait time to receiving my food incorrectly it did not make me or my family happy. read more

See all

Great food great service. This is the go to spot for good quality food and great customer service.

Pizza was alright, but the wing hot wings were really good and spicy. Service was awesome, atmosphere was chill. I'd go again!

Best food and pizza took my picky grandkids, and they could not stop talking about this place. The pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing the mozzarella sticks amazing the chicken wings amazing first time. We will definitely go back Mimi and Jose Pabon. read more

Amazing! First when we sat down we were greeted by a wonderful server Alex!!! This girl not only greeted us with a smile, but also told us about all the specials that they had for the night. She offered samples for any beers that we weren't sure of and made sure we were satisfied with our choices. THE FOOD !!! The calamari tasted like it just came from the sea!! Quality ingredients and delicious. The Pizza was also amazing... best pizza in tampa !!! Hands down ... New York New York Pizza has nothing on this place read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Margherita Pizza with sausage - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

See all

We had a great meal here! After reading good reviews, we ventured a little further than our typical pizza place. It was busy, but we got a table right away. They must do a huge takeout and delivery business, their kitchen was slammed. But even so, we ordered garlic knots and they came reasonably quickly and were delicious and hot! We ordered beer, they had a decent selection. They gave the kids etch a sketches to play with! So awesome! They kept busy with those and watching the TVs around. Pizza came after a short wait and it was so good! I was surprised that they have small pepperoni, you don't usually see that. It was good, but I felt like there should be more of them or more evenly distributed. But, that's fine. Our specialty pizza was awesome! Loved the crust and sauce and cheese. Super garlicky and yummy. Will definitely be back! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Etch a sketches to play with! - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

See all

Ok, my second review. My first was before the fire and closure. Upon reopening there is a different layout now. Large center squarish bar with seating all around. Most of the activity takes place here. There are some sit down tables also, but for some reason feels open and empty. The pickup counter is small and usual loaded with pizza boxes. There are several workers running back and forth to grab various to go orders. Usually, the wait is not that long as long as you ordered ahead of time, which is highly suggested given how busy they get at dinner time. The pizza is better than before. Maybe the new ovens? Maybe a new dough, but better. I tried the personal Sicilian, but it was really too thick for my liking. However, the flavors were fine. I have had their regular crust pies and will stick to them. For their main entrées, they do offer gluten-free pasta, which is a nice addition. Increasing my rating to four stars due to the improved quality and taste of their pizzas. read more

See all

Great pizza!! Thank you for opening up In Keystone. The meatball appetizer is tremendous.

Seriously the best pizza in the neighborhood. The balsamic eggplant pizza is awesome, With roasted red sweet peppers, fresh mozzarella and basil. The chicken francaise is excellent as well. Best at everything, service, food, & everyone that works there read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Eggplant balsamic pizza - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

We ate dinner there the other night, we have ordered pizza many times but this time we sat down in the restaurant. Our service was great, everything was clean and the food was surprisingly good, the baked ziti tasted much better that I would have expected from a pizza place, the wings were good and the salad was amazing (I loved pickles red onions on it!) The beer was priced well, my husband and I each had and ipa both were priced at $4.50. We had all our kids with us, it was totally kid friendly except we did not see any booster seats near the high chairs (my 3 year old wanted to switch from the high chair mid meal) it's possible they had them somewhere, I didn't ask. Over all we loved the whole experience! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Mild chicken wings - Italian Near Me - Odessa, Florida

Fabulous pizza , reminds us of NY pizza. Great service as well as quick delivery! You won't regret it!

Great place to grab a slice and a beer or glass of wine. Intimate setting, small establishment that delivers big taste. Came for dinner around 7pm on a Monday. Sat ourselves and our waitress promptly came over to take our drink order. Drinks came out right away. Since they were on a new point-of-sale system, our waitress gave us a heads up that the kitchen was a bit behind. Very courteous, as I have encountered other establishments that have not been upfront before. We ordered a large pepperoni, mushroom and black olive pizza pie with a couple of house salads. Salads came out right away and the pie was not too far behind. Our pizza was hot and fresh with a crisp crust. Even though I am biased (from New York & have had my fair share of NY style pies), this place is close if not a Very good representation of NY style pizza. Our waitress was upbeat and friendly. Even though she was slammed with tables she always found time to check in with us and was quick with bringing out refills and later the check. Great experience even though there were not so perfect circumstances (new computer system to take orders). Will be back! read more

Pizza and salads are fantastic! They have a fun dine in and u-shaped bar area with multiple TV screens on every wall streaming all sports. This place is very family friendly. They have one of the largest pie's around!... a whopping 27"!! Always fast & friendly service! Highly recommend! read more

Great to have them back operating again. Great service and tasty pizza. Good location

We enjoyed the amazing pizza and wings at three brothers. We got some great recommendations from locals whom stopped by , Shane's mom lol the garlic Parmesan wings and the ricotta gnocchi appetizer was ABSOLUTELY GREAT! read more

See all

The establishment is a fucking joke. I went it in to order food for myself and sat at the bar to wait for my food, ordered a drink while waiting and the bartender "Beibs j" thinks it's okay to disclose information about me (for money) to a total stranger about my doing that's night. I called to get the information about that bartender and he didn't want to disclose his name yet he exposed a complete stranger and the manager Sam thinks it's okay to let the bartenders do that, this establishment is a JOKE and I'm calling my lawyer. DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE UPDATE: I called shortly after giving this negative review and I notified their sorry management "Sam" that I left a bad review and would like a follow up with upper management (owner) about my experience and he stated immediately once I called that I was harassing the store (without even letting me talk) and would not even let me express my thoughts!!! this place is truly a joke And I will make sure I get my lawyer involved. read more

See all

Although I have not dined inside the restaurant, every item I have ordered tastes amazing. From the chicken fingers to the pizza to the truffle fries, everything is cooked to perfection and has a great flavor. The employees are exceptional and my food always arrives before the timeframe they provide. Highly recommend this place read more

Service and food is off the chart weather your at PalmHarbor or Odessa. and the Owners are pretty Cool also.

I was looking for good NY style pizza in the area and looked here on yelp for reviews. I decided to try Three Brothers Pizza. We were very happy. We sat in the restaurant and ordered a 16" pizza with half eggplant. There are a variety of topping available to add on. It cost $1.50 for half the pie. $3 if you want a specialty topping on the full pie. We really liked the pizza. Similar to New York pizza. Very tasty with a thin crunchy crust. The eggplant was delicious. I would definitely go there again for pizza! Yum! read more

Food is amazing but currently take out takes about 2 hours on a weekend night so plan ahead.

Really good pizza and they also have really delicious chicken parmesan for the prices they charge you really cannot beat it, the employees are also really friendly read more

Odessa location.... Great value in pies, but their buffalo tenders are the best thing on the menu. Waiting on this location to re-open after the two setbacks they had in 2019-2020..... read more

Based on recommendations from my shared community app I decided to give this place a try. The wings were fried to perfection. I thought for sure I would not find another place that makes good enough garlic Parmesan but this place is up there. The pies were really good as well. I would definitely give this place another try read more

See all

Food is fresh. Service top notch delivery service amazing great neighborhood restaurant

Have to say that while the pizza was great, the wait almost made it not worth it. Three brothers obviously needs to work some kinks out of the process. Ordered at 5:15 on Friday, was told it would be ready in an hour. Got there at 610 . Finally got my pizza at 710. If it's going to be two hours, just tell me. Don't ask me to arrive on time and stand (no seating for carry out) for an hour. Again pizza was great , but think I'll give them some time to get organized before we order from here again read more

Love this place. This place reminds me of home and it never disappoints. They do a great pie and have a lot of different options. Their dinners are great and they do a good vodka sauce. If you want to sit down and eat dinner/lunch they have a great beer and wine selection. Highly Recommend. read more

Perfect service, delicious food. Recommend this place to my friendsssssssssssssssssssdssssssssssssss

After another visit, it has been solidified as one of the best pizzas in Tampa Bay in my opinion. We ordered the huge 28 inch for four of us, and we were able to get half Portobello and half House Eggplant. It was delicious per usual, but I just prefer the large, rather than the XL because it's easier to eat ;) We also enjoyed the cannoli again. I look forward to trying some appetizers and different desserts in the future. But I sure do love our go-to pizzas and those cannoli. read more

This is my new go to place. Well, deliver from place...I've never actually been there. The pizza doesn't look very flashy, but it's fantastic. But the star of the show for me is the Penne Vodka. I order it with extra sauce, chicken, portobello and roasted red peppers, and it's literally the best pasta I've ever had. They don't cheat you by putting in a ton of pasta and skimping on the other ingredients like most other places do. And the portions are great. I get the "small" and it lasts me for two meals. I'm tempted to order the "family size" and just eat it all week long. Honorable mention: The Caprese Salad. Marinated halved cherry tomatoes, mozzarella and fresh basil with a balsamic reduction. It's amazing. This has become a weekly staple for me, and I look forward to it all week long. Give it a try! read more

Came in based on the reviews and we were not disappointed! Ordered the everything pizza and it was excellent. Props to them for using the only roni that should be on pizza, cup n char. Long gone are the days of big pepperoni, get with the times folks Cup n Char are where it's at! As I'm writing this review I'm sitting here contemplating having the pizza for breakfast. It was RHAT good (or I'm that lazy and don't want to make a bowl of cereal). Also had the mozzarella sticks, those were also very good and looked homemade. The garlic knots could have been a bit more dense and doughy, and could have had a bit more buttery garlic goodness, they were just ok. The marinara sauce was excellent. The place was jammed in a Fri at 7pm. There is a side for take out and dine in (with a bar). Seating is sufficient. Next time we are in Odessa we will be coming back! ***Edit: I ended up having pizza for breakfast read more

Excellent food and service! The garlic cheese bread is awesome! I love their pepperoni pizza. Nice selection of beer on tap. The service is top notch. We even got to try their mini cannolis on the house! read more

Family oriented joint that makes you feel welcome always. The owners are some of the most generous people that I have ever met. They support schools, hospitals, charities, you name it. Odessa community LOVES 3 Brothers Pizza! We could not imagine our community without them. I just love how it feels there - it is my favorite hangout! My family has tried pretty much everything on the entire menu. It is all super good! While Penne Portabella is my favorite entree, I am also a big fan of the Grandma's Pizza. Go try 3 Brothers Pizza today - you will not be disappointed! read more