Tiff&#x27;s Love Butta

The food is always great every time I go. Service is always great as usual. The smell is just as…read moregood as the food is so don't hesitate to go in!

Lots of fish varieties to eat at Santiago. The sides aren't fresh. The guy told us the hush…read morepuppies were "this big" (size of a golf ball) but as you can see they're only size of a melon baller, but they were good! My guy can tolerate bland food but I could have enjoyed a little more flavor in the fish, but it was good nonetheless because I love fish.

Inside

See all

Menu 4/25

Broad Ripple Seafood Market

4.6(75 reviews)

6.4 mi•Broad Ripple

Veteran-owned & operated

Outdoor seating

Oyster and Shrimp Po' Boys are to die for ... Hurry the…read moreOyster Po' Boy sells out fast! Clam Chowder delights every sensation of the taste pallets!

I had such high hopes for this place a seafood market in Indianapolis? Yes please. As someone who…read moregrew up in Florida, I am always on the hunt for anything that scratches that coastal seafood itch, so I was genuinely excited to try it. We ordered the lobster hoagie and hush puppies. Both were... fine. Not bad, but nothing that wowed us or justified the anticipation. The flavors were there in a basic sense, but it all felt a little underwhelming for a spot that's billing itself as a seafood destination. What really got me was the market side of things. The seafood on display just looked sad not fresh, not vibrant, not the kind of stuff that makes you want to throw something in a bag and take it home to cook. I fully understand we're landlocked in Indiana and truly fresh seafood is a challenge, but if that's your entire concept, the product has to be able to hold its own. Left feeling more disappointed than anything. I so wanted to love this place and will be rooting for them to level up but for now, this Florida girl will keep searching.

Salmon burger

See all

Crabcakes

The Fountain Room

4.4(521 reviews)

0.6 mi•Chatham Arch

Family-owned & operated

Free WiFi

I highly recommend The Fountain Room. We recently reserved the (semi private) Pemberton Room here…read morefor the rehearsal dinner before our son's wedding. The communication throughout the process was great and it made the planning very easy from start to finish. They offered several good menu options and were also very flexible (we wanted to omit veal from a dish). The food was well prepared, and the guests commented on how good everything was, including the excellent service. The ambiance was perfect for our event and we're so happy that we chose The Fountain Room for this special occasion.

The Fountain Room was one of the highlights of my recent trip to Indianapolis. I was captivated by…read morethe stunning interior design. The combination of emerald green, gold accents, and classic black-and-white details created a sophisticated atmosphere that felt both glamorous and timeless. The food was exceptional. The Brie Brûlée was one of my favorite dishes I've ever had. The sea bass was equally impressive, cooked beautifully and packed with flavor. I also loved the thoughtful nod to the building's history. The Old Fashioned made with Coca-Cola syrup was a unique touch that paid tribute to the Bottleworks area. Between the gorgeous setting, outstanding food, and creative cocktails, The Fountain Room delivered on every level. I would highly recommend it to anyone visiting Indianapolis!

See all

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

4.4(189 reviews)

8.7 mi

As always food is great. Was craving fish n chips and it was satisfied! Takes a while because it's…read morecooked to order. It's not sitting under a heat lamp waiting to be plated. Staff is always so nice. We even got some prepared crab cakes to cook at home, can't wait to see how those are! Ooh maybe I'll make crab cakes Benedict mmmm We got there before the dinner rush so had a pick of tables which were all clean!

I havent been here for a while, since I moved out of the area, but I try to stop by when I have a…read morechance. Im addicted to their fried oysters and clam chowder! Andrew, the owner maintains a great online presence. I love that they will cook most things in their seafood case for you. They even cleaned and fried me some soft shell crab from the case once. If I had any qualms, I wish that the sides were more substantial than just a sampling. Thank you, Caplingers'!!

Our Smoked Tuna Salad is LEGENDARY!

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Charles, our Meridian manager is an OG with Caplinger's. He was 15 years old when he and Andrew 1st worked together at 56th St. Fish Market.

Charles, our Meridian manager is an OG with Caplinger's. He was 15 years old when he and Andrew 1st worked together at 56th St. Fish Market.

See all

Blackened Walleye Dinner

Slapfish

4.6(462 reviews)

0.7 mi•Mile Square

I recently tried Slap's Fish Market and sampled a little bit of everything--lobster roll, burrito,…read morecheesecake, and their lobster deviled eggs--and overall it was a really memorable experience. The service was very helpful deciding what to order. The setting was fun down town indanopolis feel. The lobster roll was definitely the standout. It was packed with fresh, flavorful lobster and had a nice balance of buttery richness without feeling too heavy. You can tell the seafood is high quality, which makes a huge difference. The lobster deviled eggs were super unique and honestly one of my favorite bites. Creamy, slightly tangy, and topped with lobster--it's not something you see everywhere, and they executed it really well. My husband tried the shrimp burrito, which was great for a seafood spot. It was hearty, well-seasoned, and filled generously. It didn't feel like an afterthought on the menu. To finish, the cheesecake was a great choice it was from the cheesecake factory is what the offered for my birthday smooth, rich, and just the right level of sweetness with a strawberry topping to end the meal without being overwhelming. Overall, Slap's Fish Market delivers on both creativity and quality. It's a great spot if you want fresh seafood with a few fun, unexpected twists. I'd definitely come back to try more of the menu.

Not gonna lie, my work group really likes coming here when we have lunch outings. My only problem?…read moreI very much dislike seafood to any capacity. Yet, I still eat here just fine. I feel like most seafood places will have vegetarian options by way of removing the fish from pasta dishes or salad, but it's also nice to know that you can get chicken as a substitute on most of these kinds of dishes, too. Granted, it's just like chicken tenders, but still good nonetheless. I really like their firecracker pasta, which is moderately spicy in my opinion. There's no particular fishy smell here, which is always a good sign that the seafood they serve here is freshly prepared. Our food always comes out quickly for lunch and we've been a group as large as 8 or 9. I do believe that ordering is mostly done online in their mass Ave location, though. I don't really seek out a place like Slapfish on my own (no offense at all, just not a seafood girlie!!), but I would assume that it's a rather popular establishment as they recently opened a fifth location in the greater Indy area. If I did like fish and such more, I'd probably be here on a more regular rotation.

Oysters and Lobster Tots

See all

Beer

Magdalena

4.6(70 reviews)

2.2 mi•Fountain Square

Situated on an unassuming block and in an unassuming building, you'd never know the amazing flavors…read moreyou'll find at Magdalena! After being recommended, we decided to visit on a Thusday evening. We were immediately greeted and seated as there were only a few other people in the restaurant. Our server, Shannon, was delightful! We decided on the crawfish Monica, the collard greens dish, and the waygu dish! I would go back just for the crawfish! Perfect amount of everything that I will dream about. I have read about different theme nights so we will definitely be back!

We dined here for a taste of Creole cuisine while staying in Indy last weekend. Upon entry the…read morebubbly hostess greeted us and sat us at our table, gave us an overview of the menu and specials, and our server shortly followed to take drink & apps orders. The restaurant has an intimate setting with beautiful soft tunes coming from the retro speakers. The staff are very friendly, drinks potent, and the food was divine! We appreciated the owner introducing himself and assuring us that they could make an order of chargrilled oysters. They were delicious!! We hope to visit again soon the next time we are in the city and catch an Uber to enjoy happy hour!

No menu Monday (the simpsons) - flaming cocktail

Whitefish dip with fried saltines and oysters

See all

Cucumber salad w. roe

Ugly Crab

4.0(151 reviews)

10.5 mi

First time here. Walked in at 425pm and I was the only person. So was a little scared. The lady…read moregreeted me with smile and welcomed me in. I sat down and she gave me a menu. Great special and offers on the menu. I went with combo #5 .5 pound crab .5 pound shrimp and 1 lobster tail. $41.99. I picked all 3 sauces spicy. The bag came and when I opened it wow it smelled great. Lobster tail was a nice size and very good. Shrimp was great the crab legs were very good. They were about size 3,5-4 on the crab scale that runs 1-5 (5 being the best size) the crabs legs had great meat in them and very big. Normally places give you a size 2-3 so this was a very nice surprise. Potato's and corn were great. Very happy with the food and value. Great deal if I lived here I would come once a week. So would I come back? Yes Yes and Yes. Come try this place.

We went there early Sunday evening around 5:45. First timers, sign hanging up says order here, we…read morefigured out what we want step up to order woman running register asked here or to go I said here she hands us two menus tell us to find booth. We sat down , she sat at a table and eats, stops to take care of pick up orders goes back to eating, servers are coming and going waiting on other diners, still nothing. We waited 15 minutes woman finishes her food stands back at the register, still nothing. We got up walked out she calls out Thank you. We both hesitated but walked away. I can't comment on the food never got to order but service I can comment on and it was horrible. We will never give it second chance. There are too many other options around. If I could give it a lower rating I would.

See all

Main menu backside.

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

4.3(944 reviews)

9.4 mi

Food is hot and fresh. I love the Caplinger's Fish…read moresandwich Special. So good!! Food is prepared after you order, so it seems slow at times, food is Perfect. This is not a fast food place. The fish is worth the wait!!!

Found myself in the area and cancelled afternoon plans just so I could eat here insteD. Yes. It's…read morejust that good! Huge fried oyster, the best fried okra and yummy catfish! They are always so nice and there's plenty of seating.

0.6 mi•Renaissance Place, Mile Square

See all

Salt on Mass

4.2(665 reviews)

This is genuinely my favorite restaurant not only in Indy but in the world. The service was…read moreimpeccable as the waitress seemed to predict everything we needed and gave us a rundown of specials. The ambiance with the music was great, and it was quiet. THE FOOD was the best part. The fettucine alfredo was cooked to perfection and the lemon slice + the sauce was an incredible combo. The Mac & Cheese was rich, and I can't wait to eat the 6 layer chocolate cake when I get home; it looks gorgeous.

We showed up with no reservation and a full house. But, the manager made sure we could get seated…read morequickly. The food was, as usual, excellent! I had the fire pasta. It had shrimp, crab and clam. It was very spicy; and, very good. My wife had the filet mignon. It was perfect. The manhattan cocktail is not on their menu; but, was perfect. It was one of the best I've had. Amaya was attentive and diligent. A wonderful server. All in all, I don't know how you could go wrong with Salt on Mass. We've been here several times and the experience has always been excellent.

Calamaria

See all

Salmon

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tiffany R.

5

3

2

2 years ago

Seafood Stuffed Salmon. Delicious!!! Indulge in the ultimate seafood experience with Seafood Stuffed Salmon, featuring a succulent salmon fillet filled with tender shrimp, delicate crab meat, and aromatic herbs, all perfectly Smothered with Tiff's Signature Love Butta read more

Tiffany R.

0

1

6

4 years ago

DELICIOUS!!! These seafood platters and that Love Butta is Soooooo Delicious!!! Salmon & Crablegs are Fire!!!!

Tiff's Love Butta - seafood - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Tiff's Love Butta also viewed

Taste This Fish

4.4

(39 reviews)

I am a whole catfish snob and this place passed my tests! Even their French fries are tasty!!!…read moreCarry out only! Staff friendly and helpful! Definitely will be back!

The whiting fish was cooked to perfection and was arguably the was best I've had in a long time…read more The sides were Fries and Cole Slaw, the perfect accompaniment to fried fish. The hush puppies were cooked well and seasoned just right. They were extremely busy tonight but made the wait worthwhile!

Juicy Seafood Indy - Castleton

3.8

(147 reviews)

I really enjoy coming to Juicy Seafood in Castleton. One of my favorite things about this place is…read morethat it's not loud, so you can actually enjoy your meal and have a conversation without shouting. The booths aren't the most comfortable, but the overall atmosphere is relaxed and pleasant. The $5 Coronas are a great deal, and my go-to order is the Juicy Special. It has a little kick to it, so if you're sensitive to spice, keep that in mind--but I think the flavor is worth it. I especially loved the lobster, sausage, black mussels, and frog legs. Everything was flavorful, and the seafood was delicious. There are some good deals on the menu if you're looking to keep the cost down. However, if you're dining with your partner and both of you order lobster or other premium seafood, plan on spending around $100 or more. For me, it's worth it for a nice seafood dinner. Don't worry if cracking the seafood seems intimidating--they provide scissors and seafood tools at the table to make it much easier. And don't forget to put on the plastic gloves and apron before you dig in, because things can definitely get messy! If you're looking for a casual spot with a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy great seafood and actually have a conversation, Juicy Seafood in Castleton is definitely worth a visit.

I visited yesterday as part of a large group (8 adults, 2 kids) for a birthday dinner. We were…read moreseated promptly and had a very sweet server. It took some time for us all to order and start getting our drinks. However, the food started coming out pretty quickly. I ordered the Plant Power with cajun seasoning at the medium spice level with a side of boiled eggs. It was so delicious! It came out piping hot and covered in seasoning. The plant power comes with a generous amount of corn, boiled potatoes, and broccoli. The boiled eggs were overcooked, though, and they were too hot to eat for awhile, though. They burned my fingers! I loved the flavor and didn't think it was spicy at all, though. I was worried that the veggie plate would be underwhelming in comparison to the seafood boils that everyone else ordered but I think I actually enjoyed it the most lol Since they knew we were celebrating my boyfriend's birthday, they gave a gift card for $15 off his next visit. They also have a neon lit birthday sign and our server lead us in singing the Birthday song -- if you don't like that kind of attention, don't tell them lol

Juicy Seafood Indy

3.6

(324 reviews)

Husband's birthday and he turned down a downtown seafood restaurant for Juicy Seafood…read more It has been sometime since we have eaten here. The last time was in Castleton. My husband thought this West side location would be nicer and less of a cheap atmosphere. We were welcomed right away and taken to a booth in the bar. It was private and the table was large. Our waitress was also the bartender. She did a great job as she kept an eye on us and also her bar responsibilities. We had the Red and Black. This entree was for two. We added 1/2lb of sausage. We had two large lobster tails. Snow crab with huge meaty legs. About 2 dozen shrimp, mussels and potatoes as well as corn on the cob. All was delicious. We were pleased with our meal and enjoyed all the juicy sauce associated with it I would give this restaurant 5 stars but the building and decoration, etc are dated and the atmosphere is that of a cheap restaurant. Will we go back? You betcha just not right away. Too much fresh seafood to eat on a regular basis

We visited on Saturday evening without a reservation. We were seated immediately. The host and our…read moreserver were both friendly and prompt. I ordered the plant power combo with the juicy special sauce, medium. It comes with 3 corn cobs, 1 lb of broccoli, and 2-3 potatoes. I also had a side of rice. The corn was sweet & juicy and the potatoes were all cooked thoroughly. The broccoli was a little overcooked, almost wilty, but still tasted okay with the seasonings. My boyfriend ordered a create your own combo with snow crab legs, lobster tail, and crawfish with the juicy special sauce - medium. He loved the flavor and everything was cooked well and he received a nice portion. Overall, we had a great time.

Hanabi

4.8

(6 reviews)

I forgot to take a photo of what it looked like before digging in but this place is AWESOME!…read more The food is well seasoned and cooked and the portion sizes are the best I've seen for asking price in the city. Can't believe this place doesn't have more reviews

Hibachi & Burritos? Hibachi & Burritos!…read moreWould never have thought about that combo but it works. The menu is simple but enough. I asked if they use fish sauce oyster sauce or shrimp paste due to Biblically clean eating and they said no. I pray that is correct. I ordered a steak hibachi lunch box for $12.95. That was a great value. I received cubes of steak cooked medium well mixed with suateed broccolli, carrots, zucchini and squash veggies, fried rice and a small chicken eggroll- thanks for the chicken! Also received soy sauce and YumYum sauce and it is Yummy. They give you a little beeper that will notify you when your order is ready. I think it only took 5 to 7 minutes. The place is pretty new, clean, had plenty of parking, nice service. So far I love this place, have to check out the Burritos next!

Salt At Geist

3.9

(127 reviews)

A girlfriend and I tried Salt at Geist for the GirlMath Master Event and had a BLAST! Such a cute…read morerestaurant spot, great choice for a date night The food was delicious and our waitress was the seriously the sweetest human. She took great care of us even with a fee hiccups (that weren't her fault). Salt had such fun instagram promos for this event which is what brought us here! My only note is that if something is being advertised there should be enough to go around. The restaurant only had what seemed to be 5 food tower stands and the event menu had the wrong dessert listed. That said, our waitress was able to get us a tower stands eventually, and the dessert misprint wasn't communicated to her until after we ordered. Again, not her fault at all - she was an absolute doll and really saved the experience and made it enjoyable! Highly recommend going and trying the lemon drop martini, sushi and kung poa shrimp!! Would go back again.

First timer at Salt and I was very impressed. The service (Sophia was great), the flavors, the care…read morein plating...it was all top notch. I started with a half wedge salad that had a perfect blue cheese dressing. The 16oz bone-in ribeye was cooked perfectly to order and well seasoned with a pat of herb butter melting on top. The parmesan risotto was perfectly cooked. There was a tiny bowl of some kind of yummy gravy-looking sauce that served as a steak sauce. I honestly have no idea what it was but it added a fusion of flavor to the already amazing steak. We also had the salmon and Brussels sprouts. The salmon was flakey and edges were crispy. Dipping it in the orange blossom honey sauce on the side added a complexity to a common dish. While the prices are on the high end, I don't mind paying well for great food and service. I can't wait to return to try some other menu items.

Kona Jacks Fish Market & Sushi Bar

3.7

(279 reviews)

Both the meal and service were outstanding! Celebrating Valentine's Day, decided to order off the…read morepreset menu. We added an order of Oysters Rockefeller which were the best I ever had. They were so huge and prepared to perfection. My filet topped with crab was great! The sides and salad were a good compliment. Upon arriving we were seated at a table, when asked to move to a booth, the hostess gladly accommodated which really made the ambience much better than sitting out in the open. Great place for fresh seafood, steaks, sushi and a host of other great options.

Service was good, (Four stars) but the food I ordered was nothing special. Gumbo and Mango Salad…read more Gumbo was over cooked (in my opinion) No shrimp, big chucks of vegetables, some whitefish, and lots of sausage. (Three stars). Mango salad was tasty but just okay (Three stars). Restaurant was busy for lunch and I enjoyed sitting outside. What I like best about Kona Jacks is the most excellent staff and dedication to customer service.

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove

3.7

(99 reviews)

My friend invited me out so she chose. Never had been so figured I should go. Very busy place and…read moreglad we got our name in before some guy took over...he was very disoriented and had no idea what was going on. Gladly when it was our turn the young lady that took my name down remembered because he was totally calling out a whole different name, could have been missed had she not been up there or if I wasn't paying attention. Got seated. Our server was very nice and helpful since it was my first time. Chloe did an excellent job by explaining how the boil works and flavoring etc. we ordered lemon drop martinis. Unfortunately they missed the mark. They definitely were not prepared properly which is fine but I guess it's my fault considering it's not known for their drinks. No hard feelings I drank mine. I ordered hush puppies to start...definitely need some more of these! Flavorful and the sauces it came with were delicious. I ended to dipping mine in my boil bag and let me just say that was AMAZING. I ordered the scallops and shrimp and added the boiled eggs for an extra charge of $2.95. Very delicious very tasty and the garlic lemon Cajun mild was a great choice. Everything was cooked exactly right and the seasoning was on point it wasn't overly salty or spicy and yet wasn't even an ounce of bland. I of course took my half home and glad she wrapped it up good so nothing leaked out. Needless to say the bag boil was very good and definitely would go back. As far as ambiance goes it was very busy and lots of people enjoying their food. Lighting was a bit soft but it wasn't bad. (Pics aren't loading, I'll add when internet isn't acting up)

Never been before. The ambience is nice, staff is friendly. All the food i got was really good…read more Despite how busy they were, we got our food pretty quick

Broad Ripple Seafood Market

4.6

(75 reviews)

Oyster and Shrimp Po' Boys are to die for ... Hurry the…read moreOyster Po' Boy sells out fast! Clam Chowder delights every sensation of the taste pallets!

I had such high hopes for this place a seafood market in Indianapolis? Yes please. As someone who…read moregrew up in Florida, I am always on the hunt for anything that scratches that coastal seafood itch, so I was genuinely excited to try it. We ordered the lobster hoagie and hush puppies. Both were... fine. Not bad, but nothing that wowed us or justified the anticipation. The flavors were there in a basic sense, but it all felt a little underwhelming for a spot that's billing itself as a seafood destination. What really got me was the market side of things. The seafood on display just looked sad not fresh, not vibrant, not the kind of stuff that makes you want to throw something in a bag and take it home to cook. I fully understand we're landlocked in Indiana and truly fresh seafood is a challenge, but if that's your entire concept, the product has to be able to hold its own. Left feeling more disappointed than anything. I so wanted to love this place and will be rooting for them to level up but for now, this Florida girl will keep searching.

Trap Got Sol & Jerk Junkies

4.0

(69 reviews)

Random Wednesday carry-out dinner. Jerk wings- smelled…read moredelicious. Amazing color. Excellent spice level (hot!) Jamaican Beef patties- yummy! Spicy. Very fine beef filling and delicious pastry. Mac n cheese- amazing! Zesty and creamy. Perfect with the green beans! Green beans- so smoky and tender. Pairs perfect with the Mac n cheese! Gumbo Greens- I was so excited, but I didn't really like it. Too much filé or herby for me. Gave it a weird taste. But it was thick with meat and rice and greens! It ain't cheap. And it's really good. We will definitely try more things!

To be honest, I had been wanting to give this place another try because the first time I visited,…read morethe main entrée -- the oxtails -- was extremely salty. I finally made it back today around 8:45 p.m. I knew the restaurant closed at 10 p.m., so I made sure not to come at the last minute. I ordered and paid for my food at 9:06 p.m. My concern is that I was told my order would be ready in about 10-30 minutes, but I did not receive my food until 10:06 p.m. I remained patient and respectful the entire time, but there was no apology for the delay. Then, after getting home, I found the food once again overly salty to the point that it was difficult to enjoy. For the price paid, I expected better quality and customer service. I truly want to support Black-owned businesses, which is why I came back and gave the restaurant another opportunity. However, consistency, professionalism, and consideration for customers should remain the standard for everyone at all times. I hope this feedback is taken constructively, because there is definitely room for improvement in both service and food preparation.

The Harbour

4.3

(54 reviews)