Bagels are ok. Donuts are ok. Coffee is ok. They have good hot chocolate in the winter! Service is nice.

Never did clean up. What a mess. No improvements on first review. 07/24 yea they cleaned up all the trash. Looks so much better now.

Loved this it - Best aphrodisiac in town - The staff really make me happy if you know what I mean read more

Tim Hortons - Timbits - Hot staff - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

I went to Tim Hortons ordered a decaf coffee and was told they were out of decaf and didn't know when they would get it again. When pressed the clerk said she had magically located some decaf but would not make me any. I went down the road to Dunkin donuts where they made me decaf coffee with grace. I will be meeting my friends at Dunkin from now on. The New Albany Tim Hortons is badly run and a singularly inhospitable place AVOID IT!!! read more

Always a bad experience here. The staff (tall guy) doesn't have any clue of what he supposed to do. Served uncooked food all the time.. waste of time and money.. so many competition around here and not surprised why this place is always empty read more

This is a combined location with a Wendys restaurant. My hubby and I stopped here and actually had time to go inside for lunch. Wendy's had an electrical problem and weeds not serving people so we went to Tim's. Food was excellent!! My hubby ordered the ham and cheese sandwich meal with kettle chips and an orange drink. He said that the ham and cheese was perfect. The kettle chips were actually homemade fresh. It was served warm. So yummy that I had to help him eat them. He said his orange drink was delicious too. I had the Bacon Chicken Ranch Wrap meal with a French Cruller donut and a large sweet Tea. My wrap was very delicious. Of course I helped my husband with his kettle chips so I kept my donut for my dessert. My tea was perfectly sweetened and fresh brewed. Unfortunately, the sitting area was dirty and the tables needed cleaned. We even had to wipe down our table before sitting down. Make sure to get something sweet before you leave! read more

Tim Hortons - Above menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

So RUDE. They couldn't get my card to work so the girl says "you have no money or what" and took my 2 items back and proceeded to be so rude. I came here EVERY day and now I won't be coming back. read more

Ordered oatmeal, 2 bagels, Timbits, coffee, and an iced cap. Took about 15 minutes, then I had the privilege to watch them get my "homestyle" oatmeal. They scraped it from the bottom of the pan that was probably sitting all morning then proceeded to add some completely foreign substance. I asked about it and was told it was brown sugar. It looked like rat poison to me... Why not just use real ingredients? Wake up people, we're poisoning ourselves with processed garbage food. read more

Tim Hortons - a bowl of food with a spoon in it - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

Drive through is closed almost on a weekly basis. Very slow when you have to go inside. Poorly managed.

Rude, rude, rude. I have been in practically every Tim Horton's on the east side, and this one is the very worst. The employee who "helped" me treated me like dirt. All I did was ask for a donut and he gave me a look like I'd killed his dog. He said nothing to me, until he told me the amount, then started to close the door without giving me my change. I asked for it, and again, he acted totally disgusted that he had to deal with anyone interrupting his conversation with a coworker and handed me my change without a word. Then walked away. I will never be back. I can buy better donuts at the Krogers across the street, and they don't act like jerks. read more

Stuck to dirty table. As they say, time enough to lean, time enough to clean. Counter person asked me if I wanted a plate or bag and I said plate so of course he put them in a bag. Bathrooms dirty as well. Avoid unless your shots are up to date. read more

If you go through the drive thru, this place isn't too bad. Obviously, Tim Hortons isn't meant to be a 5-star establishment and I think a few of the other reviews are a bit harsh....but everyone has different experiences. Perhaps it's because it shares space with Wendy's....I dunno. Bad mojo. I did stop at Wendy's for a bite and then mosied over to Tim Hortons to look at their donut selection. It was pretty scarce. It is what it is.....if you know of a better TH location....go there. I like to stop her to get coffee and/or a donut sometimes if I'm headed to Newark. But I will say, I've been to MUCH nicer Tim Hortons locations, bigger, more to choose from, etc. read more

As usual, the yelp rating is spot on. New to the area and this was a first visit to Tim Hortons. They were out of the advertised special; a fajita wrap, also out of kettle chips, the coffee machine was broken so no latte, cappuccino, etc. Still really wanting to try the place out, I order a soup and sandwich combo. The staff was incredibly annoyed that I asked what came with the combo. She waves her hands and told me to read the menu. I gave up told her to have a nice day, left and went to Panera. Can't comment on the actual food... read more

Really enjoy this TH especially morning shift! Staff and customer service are great. Never had any issues with food always fresh and tasty. Afternoon shift sometimes little slow but staff is nice. Like the location and It is very convenient for me to grab a coffee after dropping kid of at day care and on the way to work. This TH is much better than the one on Hamilton Rd in all aspects coffee, food, staff and speed. read more

Messed up my coffee very badly. I felt like a complete nooblet drinking this. Might as well get my dirty bean water somewhere else. read more

Tim Hortons - Yep - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

This place has been slipping down hill for years. Today was the last straw. Ordered at drive through like always to pull up and have to have my order cancelled and reordered because it was wrong and they tried giving my someone else's food. Today, my order was cancelled three times, and it still wasn't right. Never charged and two breakfast sandwiches with uncooked bacon. . The last three or four times there also, there is a girl in the background of the window (making drinks?) who always talks over the guy at the window, or me, and is very rude with her comments to the other employees. My credit card was swiped three different times for probably the worst breakfast I have ever had. My kids are adults now and we used to stop here every morning on their way to school when (Lisa) worked the window. She was friendly and efficient and I always knew I would get good service. This place isn't worth the gas I waste while sitting in line. Never again. read more

I always love coming to this Tim Horton's location. My doughnut is always fresh and my hot chocolate is actually made with milk instead of water like some other locations use. I stop by in the mornings because I'd rather pay 2 bucks for a coffee than 5 bucks. I'm looking at you, Starbucks. It's just as good. Save your money! read more

This was my first time in a Tim Hortons, and I wasn't all that impressed with the breakfast sausage sandwich I had. The women at the counter was sweet, but very unrefined. (A "what can I do you for" kind of person. The sandwich was pretty greasy. read more

Horrible. Could care less about customers. Overcharged while manager stood there. Avoid this location.

Worst Tim Horton's around! I've given it plenty of chances because it's close but they ALWAYS get something wrong and are totally inconsistent with other store. Always ask for twice as much cream and sugar or it won't taste the same as others and even then they will screw It up! read more

This is the worst Tim Horton's in the Franklin county. I've written multiple complaints to Tim Horton's HQ, but nothing changes. They're always out of everything(doughnuts, muffins, chili), service is horrible, and they always screw an order up. I sacrifice the use of a drive through to walk into Starbucks down the street. read more

If I could could give less than one star I would. On multiple occasions I have received half full drinks. Order a large coffee or latte and open the lid to find the cup half full. I can understand leaving some room for sugar and cream but half a cup? I will go out of my way to avoid this Tim Hortons. read more

I agree that this is the WORST Tim Horton's around. I love their chili and the last FOUR times I have went there I have been told that they were out! If it were just once or twice, it wouldn't be a big deal. However, four times in a row?! Bad management! read more

Waited over 15 min to order a bagel. They were clearly not staffed appropriately and offered no apology or explanation when I pulled up. So t be going there again. read more

It's a typical chain coffee shop. Sadly I wish they could say there were even average, but our hash browns were lukewarm at best, and that's below standard, even for a chain. read more

As a whole I like Tim Hortons, this location is not good though and it comes down to the poor service. Generally the wait is longer than needed and unless I'm ordering only 1 donut my order is always wrong. Simply put, fire everyone working here and start over with new staff as its just made up of disgruntled old women and kids who just don't care. read more

I probably stop by this location about 5 times or more every week. Always get the same thing no issues ever. There is a couple people that are usually there when I stop by who are always friendly. Some of them I'll name ( Ashton, Sam, Kayla) there is another girl that I can't remember her name but short blonde hair. read more

This is the worst EVER! The eggs are always burnt, the bacon is fatty and chewy and even though I order my coffee the same way every time it's always different (either too sweet or not sweet at all). The Tim bits were soggy and they are always out of something. I will NEVER eat at Tim Hortons again and I recommend that others do the same. Waste of money and time! Had to give 1 star so I could post, but they don't even deserve that read more

Horrible! Horrible! Horrible! I will NEVER return to this Tim Hortons again! When my husband and I moved to New Albany nearly 8 years ago, we got soup and sandwiches here at least 3 nights a week. As time went on, this location began to run out of everything. I would go through the drive through at 7:00 pm and be told they were out of soup and bread for sandwiches. Really?!?!?! I called the corporate office and was given the phone number of the regional manager. I spoke with her at least twice a few years ago and was promised that it would be addressed. She even asked me to ask for the shift manager's name the next time I was told they were out of something as she suspected some items were there but just not prepped to be served. I delivered her that name the next time it happened. It has never gotten better! I don't know how they stay in business. Don't even waste your time pulling into the parking lot! read more

This is the WORST Tim Horton's ever. The food was stale, and when I went back to get a replacement, the person stated "here is another stale bagel". No I am not kidding. The manager refunded my money, however had to state "can I get some customer service" to get her to respond. Do NOT go here. read more

This Tim Hortons is now under new management and deserves a second chance! All staff members were friendly, they got our order correct the first time, and they weren't out of anything. I used to drive the extra 15 min to the Sunbury Rd location, but now I'm happy to say I've got one right around the corner. read more

Listen to the reviews! This was my first time at a Tim Horton's and it was slightly disappointing. The staff almost acts as if the customer isn't there, and I only ordered one biscuit, which they got wrong. They also forgot my drink. The staff literally does not care and is just there to socialize with each other. read more

Went through drive through to get coffee. We got 2 different flavor lattes and they were the most disgusting coffees we have ever had. No flavor at all. We dumped them out and made our own coffee when we got home. Will not return - ever. read more

I have lived in New Albany all my life and it is a tradition of my family's to go to this Tim Horton's every time after our Sunday morning church services. Every time they get our order wrong. No matter how small or how rudimentary our order is they always find a way to not give me what I asked for. At this point I very well believe they're just guessing. Next, I had a very sour encounter with one of their employees. One morning me and my girlfriend decided to go here for breakfast. When I entered the establishment I saw a young boy leaning back on the counter texting. I approached the counter to make my presence known and he continued to ignore me. Finally I said, "I'd like to order." He quickly sent off his last text and slouched ready for service, I then browsed the donut case and decided on four. When I told him which donuts I wanted I accidentally listed off the wrong donut name this punk kid smirked and scoffed at me. The reason I named the wrong donut was because they had had their signs switched around. I then ordered the correct one, paid, and sat down to eat. As I was on my third to last donut I found a nice thick hair in it and politely walked up to the counter to show one of the co workers. She carelessly said, "Well what do you want me to do about it?" To which I replied, "There's a hair in my donut." Her older supervisor stepped in and I turned to show her and she quickly jumped to the response of "Well we can't give you a refund or a new donut." I then told her, "I don't want a refund," and left. An apology goes a long way. Since this experience I have boycotted the Tim Hortons in New Albany and I suggest all readers do the same. read more

Why do I have to ask for napkins 60% of the time, when I go through the drive thru.When we order bagels toasted with butter or donuts with frosting,or anything for that matter at the drive thru,of course we will need napkins.Also about 20% of the time when we are on the road we discover the order is not correct.To late to turn back.And yet when I question them to make sure The right items are in the bag,they are cocky about why I would ask.I ask because the order is often wrong.When we are lucky and receive the correct food and drink order,it is usually awesome.The last thing I want to complain about is the new contest where you roll the rim of the cup down in two places to see if you have won a prize.Out of about 50 cups no prizes yet.The last time they ran a similar contest,we would win something about every 5 cups.It is not worth the effort to roll the lip down on this very stingy contest. read more