Place looks great, but they need to work on their ordering system. I was totally disappointed when I opened up my sandwich at my destination, and instead of the cheesesteak I ordered , I received someone's chicken cutlet sub with bacon, pickles, tomatoes and lettuce with Russian dressing - What a combination! ;( read more

TJ's is one of those iconic spots that I recommend to EVERYONE who is new or visiting the area! Best hero shop in the land! Try the Louisiana Lightning and their ice tea! read more

Love this place always welcoming and the Philly cheesesteaks are omg highly recommend it

I always get the Tuna melt on toasted garlic bread with mozzarella cheese!!! Delicious! read more

Good sandwiches and salads. Very fresh and not skimpy on the ingredients. The hero bread is very good. The cole slaw and potato salad taste homemade. The breakfast sandwiches are very good too. Prices are normal for Long Island but their full size heroes are a challenge for me to eat in one sitting so they're a pretty good value. Good iced tea too! read more

They make the best hero's. They fill up the sandwich, you get your money's worth. Also try Rhein soups. My favorite is chicken pot pie. Plus the workers there are great! read more

Louisiana lightning is amazing!! The stealth sauce is top notch. Add cheese, you won't regret it

Absolutely fantastic hero shop and local business. First rate. The fresh bread and recipes make this an obvious choice over and type of Subway or Arby's any day. Always pleasant to find a local sandwich shop of this quality read more

TJ's Hero Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Mastic Beach, New York

See all

Food is good people are nice. Just high priced. The other issue is they close so early. I get home at 630 a 700 pm and they clos so it is what it is. That my only problem read more

Sandwiches are out of this world and good is phenomal my ONLY GRIPE ia the nasty employees I have encountered there . Food -5 Service- 3 (at most) read more

Excellent food. I do however wish they delivered as I am a business owner. Sometimes we are unable to leave the office to pick up food. Delivering to local businesses would bring in more revenue for TJ and we would so love the service sure many other businesses owners would agree too! read more

Get heroes fresh bread great service friendly employees but the prices r jacked up and crazy

Awesome catered 6ft chicken cutlet Parmesan hero. It was so delicious and plentiful!!

The best hero's around hands down, but everyone already knows this, wings are great there as well. Mike is another great owner

This place has the best sandwiches you can ever ask for my favorite is the Philly cheese steak or the Italian sandwich

First off, the place is nice and clean with ample parking. The staff is friendly and quick, we got our heroes fast and they were very good. We also had the bisque and that was also very tasty although not as chunky as I'd prefer. My only complaints are that we weren't asked what size sandwiches we wanted and ended up with 2 huge heroes (good thing we like leftovers ). The other thing is that the menu board is all the way in the back and hard to read. Definitely coming back again and again though. read more

I mean what's there not to love, they have a large menu of specialty heroes. You are going to want to go there yourself and pick a few out because there's a reason why they're here after all these years. A1. read more

I love this place. Is it the cheapest? No. But is it the best sandwhich you will have in the tri hamlet area? You bet! Not only are the sandwiches, ice tea, and cookies they have near the register the vest, but the service is always on point. Everyone I have encountered working there in the past 10 years has been friendly and professional. Love tjs! read more

I want to give this place a better rating but the prices are very high but oh my god food is amazing and the customer service is great always very courteous and they value their customers. read more

I've been going here since I was in high school and even though I've moved away I'll still make a trip for a hero from TJs any time I can. These are the best hero's ever, and I use them to cater every get together I have. Highly recommend. read more

The sandwiches are Soo Good! Lots of choices. Fast and accurate ordering. Friendly and personable. Clean and organized. Love TJs Fresh and tasty always read more

Amazing. There is something about that bread... mmmm mmmm mmmmmm. Best cold cuts, evenly sliced and fresh. Breakfast sandwiches are great too, though I haven't had one in years :) I'm confident the quality remains. read more

Great food!! They must make a ton of money when they are open because the hours of operation certainly do not indicate the desire to do anything but basic business. The food is excellent! Order anything off their menu and you'll leave happy. read more

[Edit] Seems like I caught them at a bad time. Every other time they came here they have food ready in a reasonable time. I will update the review to 5 Starts. . . I have I hate to bash on a local business l, but the reason for my rating is that they take forever to for-fill Door dash orders, they usually take 10-15 minutes long. The building is nice and the food is good, but they need to pick up on orders. read more

Ordered a Hero. It was good. Not super familiar with Heros, so I can't comment on how it stacks up. Clean and seemingly well-kept establishment. Generally efficient service. Not overly kind, but not rude. Plenty of parking outside. Moderate amount of seating inside. It looks like they have a very nice patio seating area in the warmer months. Affordable based on the amount of food you get. read more

Amazing food, amazing owner and staff no place I would go in town for another hero. Clean, all the staff wearing masks. Following Covid guidelines. Overall, I would recommend this place over and over!! read more

I like the Louisiana lightning a lot and the Big Steer is really good too. I wouldn't get breakfast from here though. Also they preslice all the cold cuts way ahead of time so meats like the roast beef get all weird and def doesn't taste fresh by the time it makes it to your sandwich. Slice yo shit fresh dawg. Lobster bisque is good. read more

TJ's Hero Shop - Louisiana lightning - Sandwiches Near Me - Mastic Beach, New York

The best heroes in town . Stop in for lunch,you will not be disappointed. Forget subway this is the place

The best heroes on the island. Can't go wrong with TJs, the quality is great, the service is great. Wouldn't go anywhere else for a sandwich

Best hero's and wraps ever! Highly recommend for those craving a good Sandwich! They also have very tasty homemade sauces with spice -ask for the stealth sauce! Recommend! read more

Very good sandwiches but a bit pricey! Always fresh and the iced tea & lemonade mix is perfect!

I was told by a friend who grew up in the area that TJs made top notch sandwiches and it did not disappoint! I had a half of a Manhattan sandwich with onions added. It's delicious roast beef cheese and brown gravy on a sesame bun done up with garlic butter. Amazing lunch at insanely fair prices. read more

This is the only place I go to for my sandwiches, always fresh and tasty. I'm surrounded by many delis so that says a lot.

There Heroes are out of this world for the price. I have tried a few heroes from there and they where great taste and filling coming from a man with a few extra pounds around the waste. All the heroes I had where hot heroes like Philly Steak with the works on it Hot Pastrami Hero extra all great Heroes. read more

Very good hero shopfresh ingredients always..bread is always crisp n fresh..as well as produce! Prices are ok..but there are not many other Goid places to Get real heros around so..pay or not..or make yer own is good too..if ya caN.. read more

The best of the best..... no one can complain except for the lines out the door, even with that the food is worth the wait. I recommend the Louisiana lightning or the big steer. #LI'sBest read more

The freshest best hero's in the area! Staff is very friendly and if your there often they will know your name. Soups are fantastic

Been going here since I was in middle school, hands down best sandwich shop on the island. No matter where you're at, it's worth the drive.

Great food decent people . Crazy hectic in there but for the most part things move pretty fast

Best heroes around. Could eat them everyday. Great service and great prices. Love the Manhattan