TJ&#x27;s Hero Shop

I used to live down there, when I was there on Onofrio's service was perfect. The ambience was…read moresecond to none and the food was amazing. It's a shame. I don't live there anymore. The only drawback is that they don't have a larger dining room!

Onofrios is a staple date night spot! We love the staff, and the service. The food is always top…read morenotch. My husband always gets the steak and says it's better than a lot of steak houses. The Ala Vodka sauce is one of the absolute best! Try the place for yourself!

I really enjoyed the baked clams

Flounder Marsala‼

See all

Garlic bread was good

Greek Bites

3.6(236 reviews)

2.6 mi

Cute little road side drive-up! Authentic Greek cuisine!…read moreLarge menu! Friendly atmosphere and quick service!

Stopped in and we were greeted so friendly, the lunch specials are huge (can't wait to try the…read moredinner portions). We ordered the gyro platter and it was delicious. Also ordered the chicken lemon egg drop soup, which was also incredible. They have nice outdoor seating with umbrellas so you can enjoy the food and sit outside. Will be returning again!

Outside seating

Grilled chicken platter with divine lemon potatoes perfectly cooked fresh, also comes with a good size Greek salad & pita bread.

See all

Chicken pesto panini . Husband loved it

Smack N Chick

3.8(22 reviews)

1.9 mi

The chicken was so tasty and delicious! Mild is the best one to get! Fries are delicious! I will ne…read moregoing back!

ZERO!!!. I hate that I had to add even one star to place this review!…read more My husband and I ordered for the first time this evening. I ordered a lamb gyro and he ordered a chicken sandwich, PLAIN, cutlet on a bun. No pickles, coleslaw, plain! He received a sandwich with EVERYTHING on it! My gyro was like something that I have never seen in my life! The menu says protein, COMES With SALAD and FRIES. It was a pita with lamb CUBES covered in French fries and chopped lettuce with white sauce. I have taken photos, it was disgraceful! I have no idea who would ever eat this slop! I called to speak with the owner and was told he would come to the phone and placed on hold... then disconnected. Called back and was then told that the owner wasn't there! STAY AWAY!

Where you order the food.

Smackin fries

See all

Chicken rice Fish Platter

Moriches Bay Diner

3.9(436 reviews)

2.7 mi

I love this diner! Every time I visit the staff are super friendly and accommodating. If there is a…read morewait it usually is a max of 10 minutes and is definitely worth it. The food always comes out super fast and hot. The menu is diverse and has something for everyone. The place is clean as well as the bathrooms. Overall gives diner vibes in the best way possible! Highly recommend overall!

A must go to diner! If you and your friends can't decide what to eat this is place to go because…read morethere's anything you can think of on the menu. The staff is super nice and fast. Our food came out hot and all at the same time which I know can be tough when you have a large group. Great food and great experience and will be coming back next time we're in town

See all

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

3.5(53 reviews)

2.0 mi

Food is ok. Very expensive. Staff was nice. Place is not clean…read more Also, they are MAGA. If that makes you want to go there than go there. If it makes you not want to go there than don't go there

Very clean, lots and lots of choices of sandwiches... large breakfast menu. I have a roast beef…read morepanini with melted mozzarella, onions and portobello mushrooms.... It could use a little more sauce bc it was a tiny bit dry but it was big... comes with a small salad ( macaroni/ potato) . The owner is nice!! I would definitely back and try other things .

Variety of catered food from Prisco's from the car to table. Easy!

See all

Sandwiches and salads

Anton Pizzeria

4.0(274 reviews)

3.0 mi

Amazing pizza! The vodka slice, the sausage with broccoli rabe and omg the wood fire plain is…read moreamazing! My father is old and cranky about his pizza and he's still talking about his two plain slices from here!

This is my favorite pizza spot of all time, there fire cooked personal pizzas are amazing and so…read morefresh, BUT the staff can be very rude, we came in an hour before close and got very bad customer service, again food was great but the staff were just uninviting and not friendly at all

Mini rice balls

Ravioli tartufato

See all

Tortellini Alla Volpe

Mike's Place Too

5.0(11 reviews)

1.9 mi

Best restaurant in town. Great service. Great food. Best wings best seafood. I can keep going.read more

Mike's Place Too, also somewhat known as JC's is a little oasis right as your leaving Mastic/Mastic…read morebeach depending on where your coming from. The inside is very clean although the decor feels a little dated. The staff is very friendly but the food is the star of the show. Some of the best bar burgers around! The tidbits were very good as well. If you find yourself there definitely get desert. The cookie with ice cream plate is out of this world & I'm not even a big desert guy. I highly recommend going here even if it's a little out of the way.

Sampler Platter

See all

Sand Bar

4.1(12 reviews)

1.0 mi

Kathy and I would visit Bob Condrik when he owned it. The atmosphere was like a pirates den and…read moremight get kidnapped to work on Black Beard the pirates boat. Falling off the bar stool was fun. We were drunken female sailors. Lol before DWI laws. Drinking age 18.

Friendly authentic people. I enjoyed the short time I spent in this comforting environment.read more

Inside

See all

Sand Bar interior

Freshy Fresh Bagels

2.7(58 reviews)

1.9 mi

Absolutely abysmal service, crew was in a rush to close (at 12pm, which is a rather early time for…read morea bagel shop in the middle of Long Island to close.) Misplaced my order, gave me an attitude when I asked where my sandwich was and proceeded to make the wrong order. Highly recommend avoiding this dump.

This place sucks! Lazy employees. Dirty store. Absolutely Showing signs of decline. Bare minimum…read moreeffort on everyone's part. Don't bother calling because they don't answer. This place is a bad joke run by clowns. empty showcases and shelves. Deli meat is old and slimy. Roaches prices are absolutely exorbitant!

Antibiotics!!! After two days

See all

Neighborhood Country Market

4.1(8 reviews)

1.0 mi

The food was good but messed up it once because I didn't want cheese and it had cheese on it but it…read morecomes with free orange juice overall taste wise was really good!

We used them for catering our staff breakfast and everything was fresh and delicious. Everyone…read moreloved the French toast and crispy bacon Thank you Neighborhood Country Market!

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

Fried Shrimp w/Coleslaw

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

60 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Dan J.

13 years ago

Great hero place with a wide menu of sandwich suggestions. Salads limited to potato, mac, cole slaw. Didn't love the way they assembled a hungry man - components were in different places in the sando and never really blended right. As a person who's done some competitive eating, I was intrigued at TJ's challenge - mostly because you can only do it on the first saturday of every month, which draws a bit of a crowd. The chalenge involves eating 2 feet of any hero. Not a 2 foot long normal hero - 2 feet of "party sub". It's a lot of food. $30 bucks buy-in due the day before. If you finish it all in 30 minutes - 30 minutes! - you get a $30 gift certificate and your picture framed on the wall. Note: there are no framed pictures on the wall. If it was an hour, I might stand a chance. read more

Brandon C.

114

5 years ago

I have been eating this food for years it's great it was originally a 5/5 when they first opened the as time went on they went down hill slowly and it sucks because the food is still good just not as good as it once was and mike the owner is always in there so I wish the quality was better because I ordered a Italian with the works with extra on the side and they always forget the works one the sandwiche and the side read more

Amy I G.

10 years ago

I Love Tjs , I Love Tjs , I Love Tjs hey ,hey, hey, heyyyy!!! There is no other place in this world I rather be every morning enjoying the best breakfast sandwich ever along with the AMAZING people that work there ... It's clean, in all my 12 yrs I've NEVER had 1 bad breakfast or hero NEVER for sick so that says alot that Mike is dedicated to his customers !!!! Keep up the GREAT work to the gang at Tjs!!!!! read more

Jonathan D.

10 years ago

I've been going here since I was in high school and its one of the few memories that stands the test of time every time I come back to visit. The new location is amazing and now the image fits the quality of sandwich you'll be getting. I highly recommend the Manhattan with bacon or the Philly, but you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. I've tried most of the heroes and love every single one of them. read more

Barbara F.

9 years ago

Tj Hero has the best sandwiches on the Island! The fresh ingredients, plethora of tastes that will satisfy your hunger a great deal, and much more will leave you coming back casually. In addition, the staff is very family oriented which reflects to the customer. The food is decently priced and tastes really good! Our order was prepared quickly. Staff was very friendly. read more

Beverly K.

11 years ago

If you've given this place less than 5 stars, there's something wrong with you. Any item I get is perfect...egg sandwich, philly cheesesteak, soup, I'm getting hungry just thinking about it. Best heros for miles and miles, and I can't wait for their new location to open which will provide 40 parking spots for all of us loyals as well as the newbies :) read more

Joseph M.

Elite 19

150

129

191

9 years ago

Hands down the best sandwich shop in the area! This is in my girlfriends home town and we make sure to stop here every time we visit. My favorite is the Louisiana Lightening. I also really like the Italian with "the works" and the Manhattan. You also have to try their half and half iced tea/lemonade. read more

James L.

4 years ago

If you lived in the Bay Shore area, you have heard of Leggio's. TJ's saves you the trip to Bayshore I'm in Patchogue and can make it to TJ's blindfolded. Friendly staff and the portions are usually enough for two meals. Special order, no problem. They accommodate. Wonderful Family owned business. read more

Kevin E.

7 years ago

Awesome lunch spot. The hero's are literally perfect. I've been to all of the locations and the staff are always kind and helpful. We always stop by when the whole gang meets up, been getting food here since high school and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend trying if you haven't. read more

Leo T.

4 years ago

This food is HORRENDOUS. I had a horrible experience here the staff where rude and disrespectful. I HATE this place with a pasion! I would rate it a negative rating if i could -4 stars. They tried to poison my child with alfagal i told the waiter but they still but pork on his Hero. read more

Sean K.

373

9 years ago

Best hero shop around .. this place has never let down in the 20+ years I have been coming here... homemade everything with a beautiful new building ... I have used them for catering as well and it was a party hit! Place is a definitely a must when in the area read more

Lena A.

6 years ago

Best hero's you will find locally! You really get quality ingredients at Tj's Hero Shop. I'm never disappointed with an order. They are always friendly too. I am always ordering at the Mastic Beach location. It's my favorite spot to get a quick bite to eat. read more

Claudio V.

10 years ago

No place like it the absolute best Hero place on the island hands down been coming here for years and the TJ ice tea is famous... Manhattan is my favorite plenty of roast beef never dry and and bread isn't stale... read more

Kimberly B.

5 years ago

Best of the best hero shops ever! This is the only hero shop i go to and I've been to since i was 6. Had family work there and they loved it there. Can always count on a fantastic hero from here! read more

Danielle P.

207

9 years ago

Best hero shop!! For a while i lived 3.5 hrs away & specifically came back 2x a month JUST to have a good sandwich... STELTH SAUCE IS TO DIE FOR- Put it on almost anything!!! (trust me) read more

Edward W.

8 years ago

I have been a loyal TJ's customer for ever. Tried Jersey Mikes today because I had a coupon. All I can say is TJ's wins hands down. Best hero's ever. No one can compare. read more

Dianne P.

7 years ago

Stopped in for breakfast and got a great surprise! Fresh food great service. The place is clean the people are friendly I cannot say enough. My new sandwich spot! read more

Joe D.

10 years ago

Excellent service, great people, beautiful new location and the food is amazing!!! Louisiana Lightning ALL THE WAY!!! And don't forget a pound of Mac salad!!!! read more

Smith P.

10 years ago

We love it here! Best heros anywhere! Amazing prices, food and staff! Very clean environment! We highly reccomend eating here if you haven't done so already! read more

Nicole C.

4 years ago

TJ's has some of the best hero's around! There salads are also very good! The new location has a nice little atmosphere where you can sit inside and eat! read more

TJ's Hero Shop - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

Best of Mastic Beach

Things to do in Mastic Beach

People found TJ's Hero Shop by searching for…

People who viewed TJ's Hero Shop also viewed

Hero Express

4.5

(56 reviews)

Very good food and large quantities to boot! Friendly staff. Inside is very clean, but could use…read moresome updates.

All I can say is you definitely get your money's worth here. The staff at Hero Express is friendly,…read morewelcoming, and efficient. The heroes are fresh, generously portioned, and packed with flavor--they do not disappoint. If you're looking for a satisfying sandwich and great service, this is the spot.

Sayville Sandwich

3.5

(35 reviews)

While well lit, i always come here... years and years. It's in my path... well with time true…read morecolors arise I took to long for the owner to wait for me to order Then they didn't wear Chan gloves to touch food items. The potato salad wasn't fresh felt life a few days old related to mayo Mayo asked for a scooped toasted hero sandwich with dressing on side. Not one component was correct. Really? Between no parking availability and the place being right... i won't return. His attitude towards me wasn't professional. There are several places as I threw out my lunch and went somewhere else. Where they were nice, patient and gave me a " hearty sandwich" with dressing on side and the salad was crisp and fresh. Please make sure you change your gloves and others wear them it's food! This isn't ok. I Thankfully went 1.2mi and was happy.

This place has great egg sandwiches and customer service! Definitely will be going back :)read more

Wine Country Deli

4.1

(116 reviews)

Wine Country Deli is a gem!…read more I was just visiting town for a wedding and stopped in for the Nick Rocco sandwich -- and wow, it did not disappoint! The place was busy with tons of locals coming in, which is always a great sign. The staff were super friendly, too. If I lived here, I'd definitely be a regular.

We were in town for a wedding and wanted to find a great local deli instead of another chain--and…read morewe're so glad we found Wine Country Deli. The team worked together like a well-oiled machine. Even though they were busy, everyone was friendly, efficient, and still took the time to make a genuine connection with each customer. The food absolutely lived up to the hype. We had the Italian sandwich with their mac on the side, and both were incredible. We were told, "You won't find food like this in Orlando," and they were absolutely right. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and worth every bite. We're looking forward to coming back and trying a few more things before we head home. Highly recommend!

TJ's Hero Shop

4.0

(152 reviews)

Found this amazing spot while heading to Montauk and wow... this has to be one of the best…read moresandwiches I've had! I ordered a warm turkey sandwich and I honestly couldn't believe how something so simple could be that delicious..The portions are generous, so you definitely get your money's worth. I'd easily give this place a 10/10! I also loved that they have a little grocery store inside it's a nice touch and makes it fun to browse while you wait for your food.

Got a hero. Roast pork on garlic bread with mozzarella. While very tasty I haven't ever had a…read moresandwich this skimpy. Barely any roast pork. All bread no meat

Chubs Burgers Burritos And Heroes

4.1

(171 reviews)

We get heroes from here and pig out on Fridays at work. When I say that this is the best value out…read morethere I'm serious!! You'll find yourself struggling to finish these behemoths. Everything put out of this places is firing on all cylinders. Crafted with care and passion, these foods are amazing.

Chubs just changed my standards for sandwiches, immediately. I got the American Dream and it was…read moreHUGE. Both sandwiches we got could feed two people.. However you won't want to share. Everything was super fresh and came out very fast as well. Food is flavorful, absolutely delicious. (Definitely get the onion rings) The service was amazing, guy working at the front was super helpful. All around great place and would totally recommend.

John Moore's Deli

3.4

(59 reviews)

Placed an order for the Avocado Avalanche and sadly the photo shows the avocado was partially…read moreblack. Not from sitting out to long it was just should not have been used for the sandwich. The disappointment was real.

I ordered the all-American hero. It was, quite literally, the worst quality sandwich that I have…read moreever had delivered to me. When I called, the man who picked up the phone and who had apparently prepared the sandwich told me that he was not allowed to talk to me and that I would have to speak to the manager or owner or someone next week. Stay away from them. Don't make the same mistake that I did. You will be disappointed!!! I threw the sandwich in the garbage. You should do the same with their phone number.

Naz's Halal Food - Shirley

3.5

(81 reviews)

One of the few spots open late in the area Nice and tasty…read morefood. Very nice people. The corn nuggets were delicious.

Worst halal food I've ever had. Place is dirty. Employees are rude. Had a chicken + lamb platter…read moreand it made me feel sick.

My Hero

4.0

(38 reviews)