Husband and I stopped in on a whim today. Got a few slices to eat in and a pizza to go. Everyone there was super friendly and it's really cute inside. I got a grandma slice and the husband got some cheese slices and a cheese pizza to take home. Everything was excellent, we will definitely stop back in when we're in the area! read more

Tommy B's Slice Shop - Grandma pie - Pizza Near Me - Craryville, New York

Pizza tastes bought frozen then thawed. Disgusting pizza and terrible food. Nobody i asked likes the food

This roadside pizza shop just opened recently along NY 23 in Craryville, just east of Taconic Hills HS. They are open 5 days a week at the time of this posting. They sell pizza slices and whole pizza pies and squares. The place is geared towards takeout with a couple tables in a cozy area in front of the counter. There is also seating outside too. I stopped in at Tommy B's recently for a quick mid-afternoon lunch. I picked out two slices of pizza including a Pepperoni Slice ($4) and a Spicy Ham & Pineapple Slice ($4.25), which were heated up in the oven and boxed to go. The pizza slices had ample toppings, red sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese on a thin very crunchy and chewy pizza crust. The Pepperoni Slice had plenty of smaller diameter pepperoni slices and the Spicy Ham & Pineapple also had thin slices of ham, sliced pineapple, fresh jalapenos, and ricotta cheese. The good sized slices were filling to eat and I would stop in again to try the other pizzas including the Vodka pizza. Just be aware the cell service here is really bad or non-existent. read more

Tommy B's Slice Shop - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Craryville, New York

First time since they reopened. The pie was ready when they promised. It was hot, delicious, and was what we'd hope it would be. Great service, cute place. We will be back! read more

Excellent pizza. Great Italian flavor. They offer a variety of toppings. Their pizza reminded me of how almost all New York City pizzas taste. read more

Really good pizza! We were off the beaten path on Thursday and starving. Loved it here. Two slices of Greek pizza and all good.

Great pizza, brings me right back to when I lived in NYC. Absolutely recommend. Great owners and they are always super friendly. Grab a slice you'll love it. read more

Do not sleep on this place! We often go out of our way to grab pies from here, even over the closer pizzerias. The roni rolls alone are worth the drive. Caesar salads, white pizzas, and the Roni Soprano are also amongst our favorites. The service is consistently warm and friendly and we can't wait to see what Tommy B's does next! read more

Growing up in Westchester, we had the best NY pizza ever. Now I can have it again here @ Tommy B's! The pizza is always on point, and the staff is so kind and friendly. read more

Best pizza around Copake/Hillsdale. NY style pizza by slice or entire pies. Only wished they offered delivery. Always stop by whenever I'm in the area. read more

Tommy B's Slice Shop is amazing! We are from New haven CT and we KNOW good pizza. We came here to get the Vodka sauce with sausage. The crust is a perfect new haven style. The vodka sauce is ON POINT! And the shredded mozzarella with the fresh mozzarella makes an already perfect pie even better. They even think about the way the basil cooks and wilts in the oven and offer it fresh on the side. Now on to the square pie which is in a class of its own. The crust is the perfect amount of crispy and soft. The cheese melted in the middle and crunchy on the sides gives the most delectable mouth feel. When, not if, when you visit make sure you get both round and square. Well worth the hour and a half drive. We will be back. read more

Tommy B's Slice Shop - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Craryville, New York

Really delicious food! Friendly staff/owners. Cute little shop- 2 tables, but mostly a pick up/take out spot. Lots of different food options, even if you have vegetarian friends! read more

Excellent pizza, many great choices! Friendly and helpful owners who really KNOW pizza. Enjoy our pizza experience discussions as much as we enjoy the final product. read more

See all

Best around, great people. We are lucky to have this quality of pizza in this area. Also, LOL at the person below who wrote a bad review without even eating the food. If I could give them a review they'd get 1 star as a human being. read more

Great pizza, almost as good as NYC. Also makes great salads. Pizza is a great comfort food and glad we have this nearby. read more

Pizza is amazing!! Definitely recommend!! Service is great and there are different styles of pies to choose from. One of my friends that was with us I'd gluten free. Said it was the best gluten free pizza she has ever had!! I wish I took pics read more

I loveeeee their pizza here. The owners are so sweet and they make my day every time I order. I also love whatever they recipe they use for their chocolate chip cookies. The toppings are always generously applied as well :) read more

Not being hyperbolic- this is by far the best pizza in the area. Cool establishment run by very friendly owners. You can tell they are passionate about their business and their product and it shows. The pizzas are delicious...made with care and attention to detail. Also - it's so neat to see a square pan pizza available here as I haven't seen that at other pizza places in the area. Great place for an above average slice or a whole pie. read more

Best pizza in craryville! The service was great! The restaurant is supper clean which means the ambiance is great! If you haven't tried it I so recommend trying it! read more

We've been excited to try this place since we heard it had opened, and we are very glad we did. The interior triggers the nostalgic feeling of neighborhood pizzerias I grew up with in Yonkers and the Bronx. The pizza itself is excellent. The ingredients seem to be high quality, the dough is delicious, and the crust is thin. We were intrigued by the vodka sauce pizza, and we were not disappointed. It is clear that they are passionate and care about delivering their best; the attention to detail to put the basil on the side so it wouldn't get soggy and wilted on the pizza was a really nice touch. We will definitely be making this a regular part of our order in mix. read more

NYC pizza maven here. The pizza is legit. Delicious crust and toppings and the salad was a home run as well. Really can't miss with any of their pies.....square or round I was thrilled with both. Enjoy. Great job Tommy B! read more

We visited once to sample the pizza, but after viewing a series of "vintage" pieces on display, we left.

I'm an Italian from NYC, I guess I am kind of a pizza snob. Pizza in. Upstate NY, yeah sure lol. OMG this place surprised me and it was a great surprise!!! I ordered a thin slice NY well done. it was delicious!!! Cooked perfectly. I thougut I was on Staten Island! Have been back a few more times and each time was just as good as the first time read more