Wanted to try a new pizza spot and Toni's just happened to catch my eye. Uber was having a buy one get one promotion, but of course at check out I didn't get a discount and had to pay for both. But I digress. The pizza arrived and when the delivery person handed me them, the boxes were so light that they felt empty. I stomped up the stairs and into my place, certain this was a waste of $35. I opened the box and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza looked amazing. The pizza has a thin crust and a fair amount of pepperoni and cheese (though one slice didn't have any cheese. Phooey!) This is perfect fold over pizza. A slice you fold in half and enjoy the pie like a sandwich. My stars! This was totes amazeballs for the tastebuds!! Totally took my back to old style NYC slices. This is not easy to find outside of NYC! It was a perfect melding of ingredients and very satisfying. I'd definitely order from Toni's again! read more

Toni's Pizza - Amazing pepperonis pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

I'm keeping this review short compared to my other reviews. I visited in July 2023 and ordered a medium size pizza to-go (takeout) with sausage, pineapple, and mushrooms. The pizza was good and the sausage was well-cooked. I would rate the pizza a 3.3/5. The crust wasn't as firm or cooked as I would have liked. I had their pizza another time when a friend ordered some for us for our church meeting last summer or Fall (2025). I believe we got pepperoni or a cheese pizza then it was fine, edible. Service was average (not too long) and efficient. The people working there are friendly and nice. **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 125/250 total reviews in 2026 - 966 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 11 June 2026 read more

See all

Excellent thin style pizza crust and very balanced sauce. Especially enjoy the sausage they use! Highly recommend if you like NYC style pizza. Take out only. Friendly employees too! read more

Open late! Might be the only place in Lakewood open past 2:30. Inviting staff and waiting space.

Very good pizza and service! Really enjoyed this homemade pizza with my kids the other day. We made Ceasar salad at home and ordered in this weekend! Will be ordering again soon! read more

The fries were frozen bag , pizza was soggy and worse than anything I have ever tasted . food was so bad the wild animals wouldn't eat it not kidding read more

Fast and convenient after a night out. Open late- really the only option open past midnight / 1 am. Have never been disappointed. Not saying it's the best but definitely no where near the bottom. Would recommend! read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

Great customer service, I had the Italian sub, really good for 12 bucks and I got fries! Not really a sit down place but there are tables. Good place to pickup from. Overall 5 stars for the food. read more

I dropped in to give this place a try because I would sometimes run orders and I've have gotten quite a bit from this place and It always smells so good when I pick up an order so I had to try it I love pizza so yeah had to it's a nice little spot in lakewood the employee that I always see amd ends up handing me my orders is pretty nice always polite the pizza was good also they are open late which is a good thing if your looking for some pizza I would recommend giving it a try if your around this area or just looking for pizza in general. read more

Toni's Pizza - Cheesy bread - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

See all

Zero filling in Calzone. Phoned owner he said not remaking Delivery guy waits on his car and must go outside to get delivery. 5. Delivery ch read more

See all

Tasty, basic, hand-tossed thin crust pizzas and wings. Open late and serves slices (earlier). Don't let the stars fool you. This is a general pizza joint and when requiring late night eats, it gets the job done. Their "jumbo" chicken wings can be construed as expensive being the way they charge them. It's by the pound and they go into detail to discuss that a pound can contain varying sizes of chicken wings. I just wished they looked jumbo. read more

Toni's Pizza - Bourbon molasses sauce. Sweet but not compelling. - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

See all

Ordered Toni's for the first time last night... best pizza we've had since moving to Parma!! And they surprised us with a free cookie pizza!! Thank you Toni's!! We'll be ordering again soon!! read more

Loved the thin pepperoni pizza great taste!! Its only pizza i tried but it was delicious. The only problem was that it arrived kinda cold and I was in a hotel with no microwave, I was 3 miles away. read more

I am from the East Coast and stumbled across this pizzeria a few weeks ago. We actually were trying to get into another pizza joint around the corner that was packed but when we walked in we found out that they did not have tables available strictly to go pizza, we drove around the corner to Toni's! no one in the pizzeria which is usually not a good sign on a Friday night but it was snowy. We were cold and hungry and thought we would try it. This pizza blew me away! The garlic cheese bread is amazing also. it is definitely very close to Real New York style Pizza. We will be back next time. We will bring a pizza back home and freeze it and reheat in our air fryer. Amazing. Super clean facility very nice staff. read more

I was sooooo looking forward ordering a pizza here. The end. Okay, kinda the end, but to help you out I'll say more. The reviews here and other places raved about this new pizza place. I've been on a search for a stand-out westside pizzeria but the search continues. This shop is 1.5 miles from my house and it was delivered, as promised, in just under an hour. I'm learning pizza places who don't do their own delivery often arrived cold or at least not hot. They have no means of insulating the box to hold the heat. Hence, tonight's veggie pizza was very meager. I ordered it as it came but it had a very vinegary flavor from the pickled peppers. The cheese either because it wasn't hot or because there was so little cheese there was none of that warm, cheesy pizza we all crave. And where was that NY style pizza sauce? The veggies were unimpressive, too. The crust had no real flavor, no crispy texture, and overall the pizza was soggy-ish. I thought this was going to be a pizza I'd rave about as the best ever. Instead, it was a "meh"' experience. I'll move on. I don't expect to order here again. A waste of money and unlikely this place be around for long. So sad because I wanted it to be amazing! So far, it's Dewey's for the win. And Angelo's if you want a deep dish. read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

See all

The food here is pretty darned good and the prices are fair. However, they, as apparently food places all around, have hooked up with Uber et al to deliver their food. Is there a strong union that is driving out free deliveries? One ends up paying close to double on deliveries that were previously done by the restaurant's own people. is it going to be requisite for all? Even Marco's Pizza no longer has its own delivery people. So, my review for my last hold out is based on their agreement with Uber and the like. Sad. Has priced me out. read more

Toni's Pizza is the best NY style pizza I've found in Ohio yet! Only here for less than 6 months I'm so glad I found this hidden gem. It's owned and operated by Toni himself and you can taste the difference in the pizza made here. After searching for and finding the place I'd order pizza from, I placed a call and put my order in. It was easy and quick and pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I chose to pick up so I could see the location and learn more about this new pizza spot. They also offer delivery, and they are open till 4 am!!! They even have more than just pizza! Burgers and wings are on the menu also, as well as subs. For desert lovers, the cheesecake is out of this world! We ordered the cheesy bread and an 18" pepperoni pizza. Prices here are great and the quality is above and beyond. First the cheesy bread was sooo tasty and their marinara paired with it just had my taste buds singing. The pepperoni pizza had me feeling like I was back in NY enjoying a slice. So happy I stumbled across this and took a chance. Top of my list for future pizza nights! read more

See all

Far to often you hear monikers like New York style pizza and Chicago style pizza. This establishment deserves the headline NEW YORK style pizza in cleveland that is right don't "forget bout it!" "It's mor den aight" ;). The pizza is truly a thin foldable slice with the perfect amount of cheese, pepperoni and grease. Cut into huge slices. Enjoy the pizza from New York with out the smell and crowds of the city. read more

Toni's Pizza - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

Pepperoni pizza is awesome, and everyone there is so incredibly nice and helpful! It's a pleasure going there, truly.

Delicious New York style thin crust with the best cheese and pepperoni. Picked up very late (about midnite) after a Cleveland Guardians ballgame. We devoured almost all of it, saved some for breakfast (cold) and it was still great. By far, the best pizza we've had in years!!! Thank you Tony's read more

Always a go to when I get the munchies late at night and want a reliable pizza place that delivers until 12am. They have a very underrated Philly cheesesteak. My usual order for 2 is the Philly add extra mushrooms (comes with a large portion of seasoned fries), and a small cheese pizza. -- It's a great deal and more than enough food for a hungry couple with limited late night food options. Pizza: 6.5/10 Philly Cheesesteak : 8/10 ***They are technically open until 2 am every night for carryout, and delivery times vary. read more

I ordered two 14 inch pizzas. One pepperoni & the other only cheese and they were delicious. I forgot to take pictures beforehand but still feel the need to add pictures. Very neat and delicious food. Came hot and fresh . I couldn't be more happier. read more

Toni's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza ( ate portion of it was delicious) - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

See all

Wow!!! We arrived late to our hotel for our flight crew overnight. Nothing opened in the area. I called to see if they delivered to our area. They didn't but recommended a delivery service. I delivered each pizza to my crew. We all started texting how good it was. Definitely giving Toni's a . Can't wait for another CLE overnight read more

-Toni is doing things right. Phenomenal thin slice in Lakewood. When you walk in, the place smells like an actual pizzeria. -Step two, you pick up your order and he's keeping the box warm on the top of the oven. -Wife got the veggie pizza and the smell of the seared peppers is unmistakable. No shortcuts. -This guy is working really hard and if he continues to keep the quality this high; he'll be really successful in Lakewood, OH. -Prices were extremely reasonable too. I'll be back for sure. Check it out. read more

Toni's Pizza - 18" Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

Excellent pizza!!!! The sauce was very flavorful without being sweet. The crust is thin style but tastes awesome. This maybe my new favorite pizza place!!! read more

3 AM , should be the only words and that alone is golden lol , but needless to say I need to give y'all the deets sooooo *flashback to Toni* . The place is small halal type spot but makes up with the huge flavors in the food they serve ! My party ordered ...get this ....BEEF PEPPERONI PIZZA ‍‍‍ and buffalo wings (Fried hard because we like our chicken not to resurrect lol) when places offer halal options you've won me over already so that was a huge big plus for my party and I . The staff was major nice and greeted us and soon as we walked thru the door with fast service , got our orders and had us in our seats ready for the show ! Now as I mentioned earlier the spot is small but they do have some chairs and tables so if you want to eat there you kinda can. It seems to be a great staple in the city of Lakewood for both police and citizens of the night visit there to feed they bellies as we did lol , definitely a place you have to see for yourself and when you get there just bask in the greatness that lil place has ! read more

Toni's Pizza - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

just like, what the heck man. who eats and or wants that much arugula on a pizza. Its like they just dumped a whole full tray on there. Tbh its kinda funny but ruined the pizza experience. i guess dont order the toni special lmao read more

Toni's Pizza - the oldest most choice cuts of celery ripe for the picking - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

See all

Just average, run of the mill, pizza. The pictures look good but didn't seem to match what I got so maybe it's better other days.

I just ordered from Uber Eats and my pizza got here cold, it was flimsy and not enjoyable at all. My chicken wings were cold as well and to be honest for me to have a 14 inch pizza and six wings for $40 is absurd. I don't know who keeps giving this place. Great reviews, but you definitely don't know anything about food. I was recommended by a friend and honestly it is super overrated. There are many better pizza spots in Cleveland than this. After today's experience, I'd rather go to Georgio's. read more

Pizza is cheap and good. However, I ordered "2 lbs" of wings and paid $18. They only gave me 11 wings total. $18 for less than a dozen wings is INSANE Riverwood Cafe right down the street does 25 wings for around $13 regular menu price. Save yourself the disappointment and go there for wings instead. As for Toni's, I might come back for the pizza if I need something quick but I will never order wings there ever again. read more

Toni's Pizza - $18 for 11 wings - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

Great food and quick delivery! We were visiting from out of town and wanted to try the most local spot! I would 10/10 recommend!

Recently moved to Lakewood in May and have been on the hunt for the best pizza place.. Well I've definitely found it! You can absolutely taste the difference in Toni's Pizza, it is authentic and made with real care. Seriously you've gotta order a Toni's pizza; you won't regret it. Owner is genuine and very kind. Can't wait to go back read more

Toni's Pizza - Supreme pizza with banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

In Lakewood we have no shortage of pizza places from supper cheap to fairly high end. Out favorit is Toni's. We like a full bodied sauce combined with an appropriate amount of tasty toppings on a thin crust. Toni's hit a homerun!. We only had a meat pizza and a cheese pizza. We will order agwon! read more

I only stopped here once after work late after 11, and they are standup people. Timed my pizza to be hot as I arrived. Theres nothing open this late and the pizza was great. read more

Wow was this pizza delicious! They really nail the thin crust/ New York Style Pizza experience. I really like that they keep the menu simple and focus on the quality of the core offering . Their pepperoni pizza is one of the best i've had in Cleveland read more

I'm new to Lakewood and decided to give this place a try is my first pizza place in Lakewood. I'm glad I did. The reviews say New York style thin crust are accurate. It's so good!!!The cheesy bread as well. Don't forget the giant chocolate chip cookie! I will definitely be visiting this place over and over again read more

YUM! I am more than happy that I decided to branch out and try a new pizza place in Lakewood. Toni's Pizza was absolutely delicious and is just what I look for in a slice of pizza. It has a thinner crust, plenty of cheese, and the toppings were great too. I went for the supreme and it did not disappoint. The cheese sticks were also delicious, so gooey and garlicky. Toni's will more than likely be my new go-to for pizza night! read more

Love that this place is so close to home. Will be coming back often! Good prices for their size and quality of the pizza.

Having been to numerous pizza places to NY in the last year, I can safely say this is some of the most authentic New York style pizza I have had in Ohio! The sauce was incredibly flavorful and tasted homemade, and there was just the right amount, and there was a perfect amount of cheese/pepperoni, and a solid crust to round out an excellent foldable NY slice. It is a little greasy but I'm all for it, just make sure you have extra napkins! Pricewise, it is very cheap compared to other far inferior pizzas out there. Highly recommend! read more

Toni's Pizza - Simple pepperoni and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Lakewood, Ohio

This is my "go to" pizza place, and with good reason! They're open late, the pizza is always hot and delicious, and they're really nice people. Thanks Toni's! read more