Tony&#x27;s Coneys

On the way home from a recent trip to the Cincinnati area, we stopped at Handel's for a sweet…read moretreat. We used to have a location closer to us in Pittsburgh, and we very much miss it, so we make sure to stop anytime we are on a trip and come near one! This specific Handel's Ice Cream location is on Feder Road, just down from the Feder and Hilliard Rome intersection. It is close to the business district on Hilliard Rome, but just far enough off that it is not too loud or busy. The building sits by itself, and can be accessed via Hartford Village Boulevard, or an unnamed road to the right of the store. There is a large sign that sits near Feder Road, so you will know exactly where to go. Since the building sits by itself, there is dedicated parking on both the right side and in the rear. I can see potentially at peak times this being full, but there are other parking lots adjacent to Handel's that potentially could be utilized. Some Handel's locations have an inside, but like most in Ohio, this location is completely outdoors. So, to place your order you simply walk up to the windows, and can then enjoy their bench seating or take your items to-go. When you approach the windows, you will see all of the signage, menu items, and flavors. The overall ambiance here is nice. There is a lot of bench seating and grass area to socialize and enjoy your ice cream at. There is also a fence at the front of the property to prevent anyone getting too close to Feder Road. The building itself is a classic, older Handel's design, that is very recognizable if you are familiar with the brand. They have a very nice, bright mural painted on the right side of the building that brings a lot to the space. Our visit was on a Sunday evening in September, around 6:30 PM. It was not too busy, as it was lightly raining when we stopped. We briefly waited for the few groups ahead of us to order, but then got waited on less than 5 minutes after arriving (including the time we took to look at the menu). The menu had a lot of different flavors to choose from. There were some fall options being that is was mid-to-late September, including Pumpkin flavors! Like all locations, they had cones, cups, milkshakes, sundaes, novelty items, cakes, pies, and much more. My typical order at Handel's is a 4 Scoop Sampler. This is a takeout-like container with four singular scoops of up to four different flavors. It is a great way to try several different kinds of ice cream, or simply when you cannot decide what you want to have. It is a good size if you are wanting a large sweet treat, or to split with someone else. You are able to get anything that is scooped in the 4 Scoop, which includes the sherbets, ices, and other non-traditional flavors. We were not super hungry when we stopped, so my mom, sister, and I shared the 4 Scoop Sampler. For the flavors, we chose Confetti Brownie Batter, Frosted Animal Cookie, Knot Your Average Dough, and Blueberry Cobbler. I had never tried the Knot Your Average Dough before, so I was excited to taste it. The Confetti Brownie Batter and Frosted Animal Cookie were new to my mom and sister, and then the Blueberry Cobbler is a personal favorite for my sister. I really enjoyed Knot Your Average Dough! It is a Cookie Dough-flavored ice cream with a Salted Pretzel Ripple and Cookie Dough Pieces. The ripple was my favorite part, and I would definitely order it again. I am not a huge fan personally of Confetti Brownie Batter (nothing wrong with this one, I just believe there are much better flavors Handel's makes) and Frosted Animal Cookie (in my opinion, does not taste like Frosted Animal Cookies except for the actual cookie inclusions), but both were made well. Blueberry Cobbler had a ton of Blueberry Ripple, and was great. No complaints about the quality or taste of the ice creams! We all enjoyed getting to try some new-to-us flavors. Since it was raining, and were were trying to get back to Pittsburgh, we took our ice cream to-go. Though, I would love to come back and enjoy the outdoor area on another visit. Pricing here was fair. A small scoop will run about $5 after tax. Our 4 Scoop Sampler was around $7 after tax. Most single-serve items are less than $10, so very normal as far as ice cream is concerned. Considering they make all of the ice creams in-house and with high-quality ingredients, I definitely believe the value is there. All of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful. As stated, our service was very prompt and quick. I have no complaints about anything relating to the staff or the overall customer service here. Had a great visit to this Handel's location! Service was excellent, the ice cream was all very well-made, the location is clean, and the overall atmosphere is great. Glad that I got to have some delicious ice cream, and check out a different Handel's location. I highly recommend stopping at Handel's if you have never been, or are simply in the mood for some incredible ice cream!

Personally I think the best ice cream place around! Great service with a friendly staff.read more

Handles off Feder rd

Graham central station

See all

Order window

Dulce Vida Ice Cream Factory

4.0(65 reviews)

1.5 mi•Hilltop

An ice cream place that you can't get a sample is a turnoff. Won't go back. Any high quality…read moreplace with good service allows a sample!! Take graders for example!!!!!

I've been wanting to stop by here for so long, and finally made it a point to do so. Disappointed…read moreit didn't work out better. The inside is very colorful and fun. There are TONS of ice cream flavors to pick from. I tried the strawberry and mint and both were good but I was feeling a milkshake instead so went with that. They used the chocolate ice cream in the display case to make it. It somehow came out very freezer burned and awful tasting, I hadn't sampled the chocolate beforehand. Bummed the milkshake was $8 and probably the worst I ever had. Further, the scanner at the register was confusing and the lady showed me how to operate it and she clicked yes for me to add a tip without me selecting it to do so, which I thought was pretty presumptuous and rude considering this isn't sit down service. If I went back again I would probably still do the ice cream but stay away from literally anything else they have to make by hand.

Strawberry Cheesecake Shake

See all

Milkshake

Weldon's Ice Cream Factory

4.3(52 reviews)

32.7 mi

Pros: The were open on a chilly Easter Sunday…read moreTastes using regular spoon instead of plastic - the Earth thanks you! Super creamy ice creams with lots of flavor options Friendly service Cons: 6 dollars a scoop The caramel flavor didn't taste anything like caramel. If I closed my eyes I would have guessed it was vanilla. I'll try another flavor the next time. Pro tip: If you are visiting Buckeye Lake, it's worth a visit for the novelty.

I love the atmosphere with the decorative front porch and old school seating inside. So many…read morechoices for ice cream, sundaes, and shakes. I went with a simple butter brickle ice cream scoop. It was delicious especially on a hot summer day. The servers were quick and efficient. We will be back!

Almost forgot to get a photo before it was all gone. Don't sleep on the sweet corn flavor!

See all

Warm sundaes

Toft's Grand Scoop

4.5(22 reviews)

5.9 mi

I had never heard of Toft's until this past spring, when my son's baseball team informed us about…read moreToft's running a promo for little leaguers. Apparently they're a popular ice cream place up near Sandusky, and this location in Grandview is their first shop in Central Ohio! So the biggest impression I've gotten from this location is that they have the nicest people working here. They're always really cheerful, helpful, and patient. My kids sometimes take forever to decide what ice cream flavor they want... Their prices seem kind of high at first glance, but it's actually reasonable considering their standard order is a large scoop each of 2 different flavors. They have a large assortment of classic and specialty flavors. I haven't tried it yet, but their made to order ice cream cookie sandwiches sounds amazing too-- we are definitely getting that on our next visit. Writing this review has gotten me craving Toft's actually... I may have to go again this weekend!

I really liked my ice cream flavor which was coffee with some chocolate like pieces. It was…read moredelicious. Service was quick except the cash register broke down and there was a line of people who were waiting to pay. There is some outside seating but it is rather limited inside. There were some funky flavors. Very ice cream parlor like atmosphere.

Chocolate dipped waffles cones make everything even better!

Sweet Black Cherry ice cream

See all

Mona's Eats N Treats

4.6(69 reviews)

5.7 mi

Nice people, decent food, delicious ice cream, as of 2025 open year round! I enjoyed my grill…read morecheese and ham on a ciabatta roll. Everything was fresh and they wrapped the giant sandwich in two halves. Nice touch.

Nice treat today in this hot Ohio heat. Grand daughter had Rainbow Sherbert with a chocolate…read moresprinkle cone. The cone looked yummy, the ice cream was a very hefty scoop. She loved it. We also took a cute pic outside.

7.6 mi•Italian Village, Short North

King Elvis ice cream cone

See all

CRMD

4.2(228 reviews)

Hands down the best ice cream in Columbus. The out of the box flavors are out of this world and…read morestaff is so friendly! The piffle is an absolute must especially if it is your first time. Honestly the ice cream is so fantastic that the toppings aren't even needed (but why not go crazy right!!!) Love it so much we always have to take a couple pints to go when we make a trip. Highly recommend the coffee flavor, biscoff cookie (try it mixed with coffee!) or if your really up for having your taste buds go wild go for the fruity pebbles flavor (thank me later!).

Honestly was kind of throne off with how empty this location was, no tables or chairs but a lot of…read moreopen space. I got the matcha ice cream in a waffle cone and it was a really subtle matcha taste, but perfectly balanced. I'd definitely try more flavors!

Viet coffee in a puffle cone

See all

Graeter's Ice Cream

Quick service. Love the Elena's Blueberry Pie Ice Cream. So…read moreflavorful! Respect the Cure and donations for charity. Busy place! People inside and outside enjoying their ice cream. Yum!

While visiting Columbus, OH, I asked a few locals for their favorite ice cream spots, and they all…read morepointed me to Graeter's Ice Cream. I am so glad they did. It was so good that I found myself thinking about it all week. The shop has a charming old school vibe that makes the whole experience feel nostalgic and special. The customer service was fantastic and the staff happily let us sample different flavors before we made our final choice, which made it even more fun. Every flavor we tried was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. You can really taste the quality. I will definitely be going back again and again. Highly recommend if you are in the Columbus area and craving amazing ice cream.

See all

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

4.3(10 reviews)

5.5 mi

Casual dining

Locally owned & operated

Really cool area to chill down and relax. Service was excellent, and food was good. Definitely a…read morego to when it gets hot

There is so many flavors of Italian ice and the ice cream. The workers are very nice and happy to…read moreserve you. It also a good place to go and get a treat and go.

See all

Hilltop Dairy Twist

3.8(23 reviews)

3.5 mi•Hilltop

The new owners really did their thing. The server was super nice, I got my order quick, and they…read moretake card now. I've been back multiple times and plan to keep it that way.

Hilltop Dairy Twist is a good ice cream place in a ghetto area. It's not too bad of a neighborhood…read moreto be honest. Pretty much the basic kind of ice cream stuff. For sure it has a great big menu. There's a selection of cold or hot treats like cones, burgers, and other things. I had a blue raspberry slushie because it may be one of the healthiest items on the menu. It's about $2 for the medium, which is a pretty good size. The slushie was ice cold without being too frozen and it hit the spot. Its menu features an extensive amount of ice cream, shakes, and hot food. The Z Swirl is a Blizzard knockoff. It's okay to call this that because it looks like it. They even say so on the menu. Among the other items offered on the menu is something called a walking taco, which is something like taco meat in a Dorito's bag. Of course this place isn't what you call high class, but it seems good enough for the locals. It also provides some entertainment. The oddest thing is next to its parking lot is a Confederate cemetery, which is pretty cool looking. If you like neighborhood ice cream shops come here. It's better than corporate ice cream shops. This is usually only open in summer or when there's warm weather.

See all

Pine Coast

4.6(43 reviews)

4.6 mi

This past week, I had the absolute best Smash burger of my life at Pine Coast Hilliard! I ordered…read morethe Kimchi Burger and it was cooked to perfection. The flavor of the kimchi could not have been better. Also the fries were so so crispy as well. Lastly, I could tell the employees truly cooked with love and their kindness was unmatched. I really can't say enough positive things, please check this place out for phenomenal and affordable food!

So, the owner is a wonderful cook and great person to chat with. The burgers were delicious. Had…read morethe Kimchi burger and its sweet Kimchi and it was delicious. Everything comes a la carte, and a hamburger that is of normal size at 15.00 is a little costly with no fries or salad, or something. Everything made to order. They need some iced tea, freshly brewed or something healthy to drink in their drink cooler. It was all sodas and Gatorade or water. Even coffee or cold coffee would have been nice. Plenty of seating, when you go in, make sure the AC is working if its a hot day. Bc the kitchen hogs the whole place to just heat up the restaurant. I will be back, supporting locals. The food was excellent.

Order counter

Classic Burger with fries

See all

Inside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lisa W.

8 years ago

Luv the food for years my moms last resteraunt before she died it took 2 years to build up her strength rolled her wheel chair onto cota to take her their she wanted to have her strawberry ice cream. She used to eat their every week Was no ((((WHEELCHAiR RAMP)))no access into resteraunt luckly 2 nice strangers help lift her up stairs then once on porch it's another foot up to get in door I know place use to be house but they do sell ramp wedges read more

Joshua M.

9 years ago

Food was fresh. Came out quickly. Taste was good. Just could be better. The all beef dog at Dirty Franks really makes a difference. Good but not Dirty Good. The slaw was slightly off. Needed more sugar. Mustard a little to much and the hot dog was not all beef. Was a good stop for a quick hot dog. Cheap as well. ! 4.00. Was full. read more

Stan The M.

2 years ago

Just asked the kid with a bandana on do you have combos w a shake and hot dog. No..... really !? Dumba%#! It's on the counter. These liberals are unreal. read more

Tori S.

7 years ago

This place can get busy from but they always help you as quick as they can. Always a friendly staff and everything I've had taste great!

Jason B.

4 years ago

I don't have any complaints or suggestions just wanted to be nice and leave a good review for a good place!

Brady B.

4 years ago

Although it took a little while The service and the food is always amazing. I highly recommend

Michele B.

13 years ago

This place is heaven seriously if you havent tried them go now!

Sue L.

7 years ago

Delicious coneys! I love the slaw, too.

Joe S.

14 years ago

Best Ice Cream in Town

Robert H.

12 years ago

Fun Food

Tony's Coneys - icecream - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Tony's Coneys also viewed

Tonys Coneys

(48 reviews)

If you're looking for a great hometown spot that serves up classic American favorites with a smile,…read morethis is it! It's the kind of family-friendly place that reminds you what supporting local businesses is all about. Whether you're grabbing lunch with coworkers, stopping in during your shift as a first responder, or treating the family after a trip to Bambi's Fresh Market, this place always hits the spot. The menu has something for everyone--from juicy hamburgers and classic coneys to loaded nachos, crispy fries, tasty subs, creamy shakes, ice cream, and even banana splits. The customer service is outstanding, and you can tell they genuinely appreciate every customer who walks through the door. There are plenty of seating options both inside and outside, plus a convenient drive-thru when you're on the go. It's a true American hometown gem that's perfect for a work lunch, a family meal, or simply satisfying a craving for comfort food. Proud to support a local business like this--highly recommend!

Today, as we made our way home from our adventures, we decided to stop at one of our favorite local…read moreconey spots, Tony's Coneys. If you know me, you know I love hot dogs! And when you add coney sauce and cheese? Forget about it! That's my kind of meal right there. For lunch, I ordered two of their classic coneys. Each one came loaded with savory coney sauce, mustard, diced onions, and shredded cheese. The best part? They're only $3 each! You can't beat that with a stick these days. My wife went with a slaw dog and a bag of chips, and our entire bill came to just $9.00. That's what I call a "fargain bargain!" Finding good food at prices like that is becoming harder and harder these days. Tony's offers a surprisingly extensive comfort food menu, so even if hot dogs aren't your thing, you'll find plenty of other options. And if you're in the mood for something sweet, they've got ice cream and shakes ready to satisfy your sweet tooth. Every time we visit, the place seems busy, and it's easy to see why. The combination of good food, friendly service, and wallet-friendly prices keeps customers coming back. In a world where fast-food meals can easily cost twice as much, Tony's Coneys feels like a hidden gem. So do yourself--and your wallet--a favor. Grab the family, head over to Tony's Coneys, order a couple of coneys, and finish it off with an ice cream cone. You'll leave full, happy, and with a few extra dollars still in your pocket. We'll definitely be back!

Hilltop Dairy Twist

3.8

(23 reviews)

The new owners really did their thing. The server was super nice, I got my order quick, and they…read moretake card now. I've been back multiple times and plan to keep it that way.

The Creme Corner

4.7

(9 reviews)

Creme Corner is an absolute staple for everyone within the Sunbury community. The service is…read moreimpeccable every time and the desserts, of course, are delectable and nostalgic. It's always full of people, even for being a small location, which makes it feel so at-home.

First timer today. My wife and I got hamburgers and fries. Food was hot and good. This is a walk…read moreup place, old ice cream style place. Servers were friendly. They even walked by the table and checked on us. All outside seating unless they closed the garage doors. You need to give it a try.

Dulce Vida

(21 reviews)

Don't come for the food. We decided to eat first so got the Cubana, hamburger and nachos. They told…read moreus the fries would come with ketchup, mayo, & mustard on them but they were drowned in them. Which was the theme for the rest of the food. The Cubana had so much mustard and mayo my wife had to take the meats from one half and add it to the other to deal with it. My daughters nachos were buried under way too much sour cream. Also had no flavor at all. Finally, my burger was the oddest I've ever had. Again dripping with mayo and mustard. The patty was super thin but not a smash burger. Just like a meat drink coaster. Again. No flavor other than the jalapeños. The ice creamed saved the visit. Just don't order any food.

Came here for my daughters bday because she specifically requested gelato, which in their location…read moreon google maps specifically says they have. There is NO gelato but the ice cream was good quality. A lot of interesting options I didn't get to try (elote and queso ice cream) Maria was amazing and let us sample whatever we wanted and had patience with us. She made sure we got lids extra spoons and napkins! Super colorful and bright inside.

Bite Me

4.8

(9 reviews)

I wish I could give this business 10/10. The food is amazing. Makes me only want to go here for…read morebreakfast. I got the sausage egg and cheese on Texas toast! Which was fantastic. I also got the tator tots on the side and a Jarritos Pineapple soda, did I mention everything was amazing! The service and food was all done with a smile, the truck is clean and nice. All is well. Look no further support small and local food trucks! For life!!

The Bite Me breakfast food truck is not to be confused with Bite Me by Annie bakeshop, both of…read morewhich can be found in Clintonville. Same name, different vibe. The Bite Me food truck specializes in breakfast foods and coffee drinks. The menu is short but appealing. They also offer rotating weekend specials (menu on Instagram). This weekend, one of the specialty coffees is a Honey Bear latte. It was really nice - not overly sweet, little bit of spice from cinnamon, and graham cracker dust to finish it off. If you ever liked golden grahams cereal, this is your drink. Service was fast and friendly. Their monthly schedule of locations is posted to their Instagram account.

Bowzers

(39 reviews)

Omw to lowes and noticed they were finally open! Stopped by on my way home, owner said they had…read morebeen closed for a few months and now they are back. Owner was super friendly and talkative, this is probably the only reason for the 3 stars. Ordered two coneys w/ light onion. The sauce tased like it was from a can and the sauce wasn't warm, awful! one of the coney's buns was completely soggy, didnt even finish it. I wanted to love these coney's cause the reviews have been good, but it was just mid!

I do not what to think. Years ago, I loved this place. But this year I have tried many times to buy…read morefood and there was no sign of anyone working.

Nana & Pap's Pizzeria & Ice Cream

3.8

(13 reviews)

I went to Nana and Pap's pizzeria for pizza last night. The second I walked in it was a great…read moreambience. The service was really fast. The pizza was blazing hot straight out of the oven. But when I walked up to the counter and no one was there. It was the best pizza I've ever had. Other than that, this is my favorite pizza restaurant.

Service was terrible. Had to wait an additional 25 mins for another pizza. They burnt the first one…read moreand was never offered to be compensated for my time waiting. Won't be back.

Tres Potrillos Galloway

3.3

(116 reviews)

The chips and salsa were really good! I came with a group of 5 and we were seated and served very…read morequickly. I got the quesabirria tacos and they were tasty. I wish the consume was a little thicker as it was a bit more like clear soup more than a consume broth. Other than that I enjoyed the portion size as well as the onions, lime, and cilantro on the side. I would definitely come back to try other menu items

This time we ate inside. Pleasant service. Very authentic decor. Had to have the Birria tacos…read moreagain. The beef both is amazing. Spices to perfection.

Catering By Scott

4.9

(749 reviews)

Scotty's Cafe came recommended by my wife's OSU colleague Isaac and it did not disappoint on two…read morefamily visits. First time my wife and daughter stopped before our daughter headed overseas for two years in the Peace Corps. Scotty''s is super close and convenient to the airport. Scotty learned of the imminent departure and came with cookies and treats for the long flight! And now this morning it was another airport drop off. It was my turn, dining alone but nothing about a table for one at Scotty's is lonely. The staff are immediately welcoming and every customer is every employee's charge. Four different people helped me or just checked in. The Gina breakfast combos have lots to offer for breakfast. But I was thrilled this 9:30 am to be assured the whole menu was available. I was looking for something less common and was excited to see potato latkes with sour cream and apple sauce as an option. That would have been great but then the waitress (Salome maybe) said, "Do you like corned beef?" The Schmoozer is 3 enormous latkes with thinly shaved and lightly grilled corn beef on top with an over easy egg atop that. Seriously, I can declare victory for finding something I'd never had before. Never would have found it without the nudge. Had to cut myself off with all the coffee offers. Just a great vibe. You rarely see a 4.9 rating and even more rarely that high based on so many reviews. But I understand why - like in so many things in life, it is about the people. And the joy they bring to every conversation. And I will just add, in this age when some would divide us, this dining room is filled with all manner of folks, reveling together over food in fellowship.

As someone who considers herself a pancake connoisseur, theirs were genuinely the best ones I've…read moreever had. They have such a wonderful vanilla flavor, I could eat them plain. Their baked goods are also a must-get, especially the lemon cookies and oatmeal raisin cookies! The workers were so kind and attentive and made our first experience there absolutely amazing.

Chocolate Café

(316 reviews)