After YEARS of being a customer. Finally some thoughts. TL;DR, Not 100% Consistent, but a safe choice. Would recommend. I grew up on Two Brothers pizza. I was 9 years old when Two Brothers first came to town in 2004. I've been eating their pizza ever since. I worked at a nearby hardware store for a couple years in my late teens, ordered lunch there frequently. I still get lunch their frequently when i've got the munchies or I just want a decent sandwich. After 14 years of eating their food, I decided to get behind the keyboard to share some feedback. THE FOOD: It's pretty good. The pizza is reliable, and unique. I frequent their sandwiches. When it comes to their sandwiches, i've noticed, you're not always gonna get the same quality. It must depend on who's working or something. The fries vary on quality, and amount just about every time I order a sub combo. Sometimes, the subs are wet, to the point where I can't really eat it. This is a total bummer, because more often than not, the subs are pretty good. It's kind of a dice roll when you order anything other than pizza. THE SHOP: The staff is usually really friendly. Over the years they've learned my name and my order, a very good feeling. Feels great supporting local business, and Jimmy is a VERY friendly, and respectable guy. Gotta be honest though, I know this is Sandwich and all, but having Fox News on in the shop all the time is a huge turn off from actually eating there. In my 14 years of eating Two Brother's food, I think i've stayed and eaten once. In summary. Two Brothers is a nice pizza shop. The food is a little overpriced, but they have a great variety of items. I have great respect for the owner, Jimmy, and his staff. There's nothing mind-blowing going on here, but it's a SAFE option. read more

The salami and cheese sub was decent. I ordered tortilla chips with a side of salsa and guacamole. That was disappointing. Very obviously not home made. If you're looking for Mexican food, this is not it. read more

The service was very friendly and it was very busy there. The burritos were jam packed full of white rice, even the one that was ordered with "no rice". White rice was the main ingredient in the burritos. It was just one mouthful of plain white rice after another, surrounded by grocery store quality tortilla, with a bean here, and a tiny bit of cheese there. The chicken burrito also had ground beef in it, and the burrito that was ordered with "no salsa" and "no lettuce" had both salsa smothered all over on top, and lettuce inside. The salsa tasted like store-bought. The fish taco was ok, two giant triangles of decent deep fried fish that made it hard to close the taco and eat. Would I order it again? No. Perhaps we shouldn't have tried to get Mexican food from a pizza joint on Cape Cod. Lesson learned. read more

The people are WONDERFUL and so helpful. And the locals love them. But the food is not something I will be back for any time soon. Pre-packaged fish patty for the fish taco that had an odd flavor (and left my tummy hurting for a day or so, and I'm a nanny goat - I can eat a tin can for brunch!). We came in after dropping off our rental truck at budget. One and done. Not coming back. read more

Love this place. This is our favorite pizza restaurant! We tell everyone to go here. It is the first time I have tried the calzone. It was amazing!! Absolutely delicious. We will definitely be getting calzones again. We had a side of nachos that were delicious too. We also had dessert. The turtle cheese cake is phenomenal and the chocolate cake is the best chocolate cake I have ever had. The staff is always being friendly. read more

Simply bad food. Burrito had no flavor, mostly white rice and lettuce. Not much beef inside & pretty obviously seasoned with store bought taco mix. Served with Tostitos chips and salsa (obvious/distinct flavor). Mozzarella sticks tasted like they came from the grocery store and the chicken parm was just a Chicken tender with some pasta sauce on it read more

Great food and fantastic service. Always a good sandwich or salad. Prices are similar to other places read more

Local pizza / Mexican food shop. All the food is good and the service is friendly. Definitely one of the best steak bomb subs I've ever had! read more

Two Brothers Pizza and Mexican - Large Steak Bomb Sub - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

These guys are always pleasant and the food is delicious. We love all the menu options and visit once a week. Mozzarella sticks and taco salad is the fav of ours read more

Consistently delicious pizza and subs!!! Also they have the best grilled chicken of any takeout/delivery place around. I've been a patron for over 20 years and have never had an order messed up...I think a driver forgot the drinks once, or the crutons weren't on the side as requested, but that's pretty minor given the hundreds of times I've ordered from them. Friendly staff, user-friendly online ordering as well. Definitely my #1go-to takeout/delivery spot! read more

Best pizza in sandwich. Fast tasty pizza a must go to place to eat.... Great customer service too 10 stars from me

We don't care for 2 brothers pizza. The sauce is heavily spiced and the crust doesn't appear to be fresh made.

Usually I am not one to post bad reviews but this weekend I got a Far East bowl and this is what it looked like. I couldn't even eat it it had so much sauce it was like soup. They used Mexican chicken with an Asian sauce on it which was a bit weird. read more

Two Brothers Pizza and Mexican - Far East bowl - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Awesome pizza and service. It's delicious pizza how it should be: crispy, not floppy, and not a lot of crust along the edge. The sauce taste homemade. read more

Great Marguerita pizza made with ricotta cheese instead of mozzarella. I highly recommend it!

Dined on 8/16/19. So the menu prices have not been updated since 2016. But when they ring you up-they charge you the new prices that are sometimes $2+ more like for instance the Taco Salad that I got,should have been $9.95 charged $12.95. They simply have a sign that says prices are subject to change, Instead of printing off new menus. The poor staff gets harassed all the time about this they say. Owner should step up. First time here- won't go back because of owners lack of customer service. He has a very sweet staff and it's not fair to customers or staff. Shame on him. Don't support this business. read more

Two Brothers Pizza and Mexican - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Ordered take out for the family, staff was super friendly and the meat lovers pizza was delicious!

Owner gave me a free slice of pepperoni pizza when i didn't have cash. Jimmy is a great and amazing man!

Got delivery tonight , a pepperoni pizza, appetizer sampler, fries, steak and cheese calzone, and chicken fingers and fries for my son. The chicken fingers came with a side of honey mustard in the container but the plastic top to the sauce had melted into the sauce making it inedible. The same thing happened to the blue cheese with the appetizer sampler. Grease was leaking out of the packages. Appetizer sampler soggy , fries soggy. Steak and cheese calzone greasy, no flavor, not even baked shut. Pizza was mediocre. Most of our meal was inedible. Most concerning the melting plastic into our food. Would help to packages sauces and plastic away from fried hot food! We have gotten delivery before and it was decent, tonight very disappointing and was not cheap. read more

Love this place the service is great & everyone is friendly - my wife especially enjoys the tuna!!

I go out of my way to go here for pizza. I just tried their fire grilled thin crust pizza and it was the best pizza I've ever had.

We made contact with Jimmy the owner and he went above and beyond to make things right. I'm updating my review because our follow up meal a few days later was amazing. Thanks to Jimmy for rectifying the situation. I'd recommend this place and will definitely be back when we are in the area. read more

Food was delicious! Staff was super nice!! Bathroom was nice and clean!!!! Would definitely go back!

As good as it gets for Sandwich pizza shops! The pizza is cheesy and the crust isn't too thin. If pizza isn't your thing, they have a good selection of other options. I sometimes get the chicken Caesar salad which is good. Their Mexican options are also tasty, not authentic, but tasty. Don't go on a Friday or Saturday night because it is swarming with Sandwich high school's finest hooligans. read more

Ordered an 18" build-your-own pizza with several toppings, some veggies and grilled chicken. Each topping costs ~$2.00. Got home and realized that toppings were very sparse with lots of empty spaces. It was basically a pricey cheese pizza. Also they forgot to slice the pie before boxing it. read more

So disappointed in my dinner tonight. Fish tacos on Cape Cod were frozen squares of filet o fish slathered in some sort of crema with a bit of veggies and something that looked like guacamole but tasted like nothing. Ended up eating chips and salsa instead. Maybe I should have asked if the fish was frozen but on the Cape that never occurred to me. Cannot recommend. read more

Some caveats. This place is geared for take out business rather than eat in. You order at the counter, the food comes to the table in plastic boxes the decor is fast food. That said , we ate in. The place was almost empty on a Saturday evening in April. My partner ordered a wrap, i ordered chicken parmesian with spaghetti and a garden salad, the kids each ordered nacho supreme. The portions were large, the food mostly was made correctly. My chicken parm used real chicken, the pasta was good and cooked al dente with a flavorful sauce. The only issues: the roll on my salad was a squished rock with plastic butter pats stuffed inside, the black olives on the nachos tasted washed and tasted rancid oil. We ate half our food, the rest for later. The help was helpful and polite. Dinner for 4 including tip and soft drinks was $70. A bit on the expensive side for take-out. read more

Fantastic food, friendly staff, very professional service and great customer experience

Ordered a Gyro sandwich there for lunch today, went back to my job site 1 highway exit away from restaurant, opened my sandwich which is meat, and veggies wrapped in a pita bread, problem wasn't the food, but the packaging of it. Restaurant wrapped a hot pita bread in wax paper (or regular paper not parchment paper, so bread stuck to paper like glue! I couldn't get any of the paper off the bread so I ate what was inside, and very little of the pita bread, it should have been wrapped in just foil, not paper, there was foil....on the OUTSIDE of the paper sandwich was wrapped in. Sorry but I'll never order a Gyro there ever again... read more

My husband and I are from Philadelphia. We come to the cape regularly to visit my Dad. Every time we're here, Two Brother's Pizza is a MUST HAVE! We're pretty particular about our pizza and theirs is outstanding. Jimmy, the manager, goes out of his way to provide us with par-baked pies for our late night arrivals to the cape. Great food, great staff. And it just happens to be the best pizza ever! read more

It's hard for me ti give a 5 star rating on what little I know of their whole menu, however, what I did get was great. I ordered a Pepper and Onion pizza and toppings were fresh and tasted really good. One of my friends ordered an Calzone and he was very impressed. The Chicken Fajita that my other friend ordered was devoured quickly. Yes there is a giant TV! :-) Place was clean, bathroom was clean, came during lunch on a Sunday and orders were filled rather quickly. read more

They offer contactless pickup here probably because the business wants to deflect responsibility for spreading COVID, and you can see everything that's going inside right through the window. NO MASKS worn by kitchen staff. The others working inside and running to the cars had their pulled masks pulled down. I am not even exaggerating just warning those with health issues considering getting delivery. We could literally see them breathing on our order. Oh and the food was soggy read more

While I should be commenting on the food, what really keeps me tied to this place is the customer service. We had a group of people over from out of town. We ordered a bunch of things (pizza, sandwiches, chicken wings, etc.), everyone was starving. Once the food was delivered, we noticed it was the wrong items, but not before half the people in our house starting tearing into it. Shortly thereafter, there was a knock at the door - it was the delivery man with the correct order and a thousand apologies. The whole thing was no big deal to us, it was a rainy Friday, so I'm sure the place was slammed. But, being from NYC, I found this outstanding. We ran into another issue a few months later with the order never being put in, nevertheless, how the gentleman on the other end of the phone handled things was terrific. There are always going to be bumps in the road, but how they are handled is what should be noted. read more

I haven't tried much on the menu because I can't stop from ordering the buffalo chicken rice bowl when I'm in the area. Think of chipotle but with buffalo chicken and blue cheese. Mmm mmm always friendly staff when I come in for lunch too. read more

Two Brothers Pizza and Mexican - Buffalo chicken rice bowl - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

The service is fine and the food is decent. Depending on what you order they may have it ready in 5 minutes or half an hour. They have a really convenient online ordering system where you can schedule when you'd like to pick up your food and customize your order to the nth degree, but sadly the customization doesn't usually count for much. Well, either that or the food is simply mediocre un-customized. I usually get something like a simple sub here. Unfortunately, I've come to notice that despite my requests for things like less sauce or more provolone they don't seem to care and put on the regular amount anyway, which is a shame because they use waaay too much sauce in proportion to the other ingredients. Also the cheeses they use are never properly melted and usually still a bit cold. Aside from the food, the prices are also just decent, but you can get better if you look elsewhere. In Sandwich there's the Sandwich Pizza house for Italian and in Hyannis there's Sam Diego's for mexican. read more

I work in the area and the boys in the shop, and myself have had many lunches from here. There has never been a disappointment or problem with anything ordered here. There is truly a home made taste to the sauce, their steak tips are phenomenal, salads and subs off the charts, as well as the Mexican offerings. You will love this place as much as we do . They do a great job. read more

Once again they got my order wrong. I always get lunch for the crew this is the 3rd time the order was wrong! Thumbs down to this place. We will never come back!!! read more

Definitely not too pleased. 10 piece mozzarella sticks and a steak and cheese sub....$19?? Took it "to go"....... Mozzarella sticks were good but the steak and cheese was ordered with peppers, onions and extra cheese. Seemed the steak was burned and the cheese was minimal. If I'm paying $19+ the sub better be close to perfect! read more

Very diverse menu. Great for families with wanting multiple options. My niece really likes the chicken Alfredo. The burritos are large and flavorful. Sub sandwiches and calzones are also good. They offer Delivery in some areas. I think I would try the buffalo chicken burrito next time. read more

I like the service, the people are friendly, and overall a great atmosphere. The reason I give them 3 stars is because of the pizza. The sauce is good and a good cheese blend, BUT the cheese always tastes burnt. This is the third try, but it is apparent that this is their recipe and not one which I fond of. I won't be ordering another pizza from here. Jimmy A... thank you for the reply. I have said something before and the answer I got was about the ovens being preset. The other 2 times were over a period of a couple of months. We had been coming there since we moved to sandwich almost 2 years ago. We have gotten other items at your place that we have enjoyed so you never lost my business completely. I am familiar with the ovens you use as I worked making pizzas years ago. Since the product I was seeing on the tables looked like what I was carrying out. My deductions were that either during peak periods you turn up the ovens or that is the recipe you wish to put out. I ventured at the later, since it was the 3rd time the pizzas looked that cooked and people walk out of there with multiple pies in hand. I figured it was a personal taste on my part and my views were not necessarily that of the throngs of your regular customers. I would be happy to try your pizza again if your telling me that you don't cook your pies as long. Thanks, John read more