Such a fun and unique dinner experience! The fish boil isn't just about the food--the explanation…read moreand the whole "show" while they're making dinner made it so entertaining. I also loved that you order ahead. We ordered the shrimp and corn, thinking that was basically what we were getting, but there was SO much more food than we expected! It also came with white potatoes, sweet potatoes, onion, mushrooms, Brussels sprouts, celery, and cornbread. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the portions were incredibly generous. We skipped the cherry pie, and the only reason I'm glad we did is because we were completely stuffed by the end of dinner! Such a great meal and a really memorable experience!

Reservations are required with a credit card, and everything has to be ordered ahead of time, so…read morethis is definitely a place you'll want to plan for. The atmosphere was very nice and had a more upscale, higher-class feel than I was expecting. We tried the baked chicken, fish boil, and BBQ ribs. The ribs were tasty and probably my favorite of the three. The fish boil came with nice chunky pieces of whitefish along with potatoes, onions, corn on the cob, sausage, celery, mushrooms, sweet potatoes, Brussels sprouts, and garlic. Personally, I wasn't a big fan of having the fish served in the broth/soup, but that's more of a personal preference than a knock on the quality of the food. The baked chicken was also prepared well. They offer the fish boil daily with seatings at 5:30 and 7:30, which makes for a unique Door County dining experience. Overall, good food, a nice atmosphere, and something different to try while visiting Door County. The ribs were definitely a standout for me. Thank You

I always try to make a stop at the Old Post Office when I'm in Dorr County! This is such a great…read morebreakfast spot and has such a great location with a view of the bay. There's plenty of outdoor seating to enjoy, but they have lovely indoor seating as well. That takes you back and makes you feel like you are in someone's quaint little home! I'm obsessed with all of the cherry and harbor themed wallpapers. The breakfast here is delicious and filling and food came pretty quickly. They have all of your standard breakfast fair and you can add some delicious Door County cherries onto pancakes or waffles. Heads up--plan to get there early or plan to wait for a little bit once you arrive.

We came for the fish boil and returned for breakfast!…read more You can't visit Door County without experiencing a unique and traditional Fish Boil! We loved hearing the history behind the fish boil and watching it come to life at the Old Post Office Restaurant! The dinner and experience was very reasonably priced at $30 per person and they offer options of fried chicken or ribs for those that don't care for fish. I'm (personally) not a big fish lover but I had to at least try it and it wasn't too bad! Dinner is also served with 3 different types of bread and a slice of delicious cherry pie! (Cherries are grown all over the peninsula). We sat outside on the front porch and watched the sun slowly set and the sky fill up with brilliant colors as we finished our dinner. I left with both my belly and heart as full as possible! We enjoyed the restaurant so much that I wanted to stop by on our way out of town, the last day, and try out their breakfast menu. I splurged and ordered the fresh cherry pancakes with a side of one egg and bacon. I planned to just eat half of my pancakes but I almost devoured them completely! My mouth is watering - several days later - as I am thinking about them and writing this review. I highly recommend the Old Post Office if you are in the area. Unfortunately you have to call the restaurant to make reservations but it's definitely worth the little bit of extra effort.

Fourth year dining here on our week's vacation and it's always been great. We do the lobster boil…read moreplus a steak entree and we've never been disappointed . Food and service have always been exceptional. Looking forward to next summer!

We loved this place so much that we came back 2 days in a row! The service was great both times,…read moreand we sat out back with such a pretty waterfront view. The oysters were incredibly fresh, but the lobster roll was definitely the highlight for me. So meaty, juicy, and delicious. The drinks were really good too. I honestly can't give this place anything less than 5 stars. Great food, great service, beautiful views, and somewhere I would absolutely come back to next time we're in the area!

We have been here many times. Good food and drinks to go…read morealong with a nice view. Recommend the Pain Killer, onion rings and the Shrimp Po'Boy.

If you're looking for a casual, no-frills place to grab a bite in Sister Bay, the Boathouse is…read moreworth considering. We stopped in without a reservation and were told it would be about a 20-minute wait. They gave us a pager so we could wander around a bit, and the wait ended up being very manageable. There's also a full bar, and you definitely get the feeling this is a neighborhood kind of place -- we noticed quite a few regulars being greeted while we were there, which is always nice to see. My husband and I both ordered the fish and chips, and they were very good. The atmosphere is definitely casual rather than fancy, so come as you are and relax. It was extremely windy the day we visited, so the large garage-style doors were closed. I imagine having those open on a beautiful Door County day would completely change the feel of the restaurant. Overall, we had a perfectly nice experience. The food was good and the restaurant had a friendly, local feel. With so many restaurants to explore in Door County, I'm not sure it would be at the top of my list for a return visit, but I'm glad we gave it a try.

Great service from the bar staff and really enjoyed our conversation with our server with the Omega…read moreSwatch Watch.

Such an adorable restaurant with friendly staff! Salmon and…read moregalette potatoes were phenomenal! Best salmon I've ever had- hands down! Steak and mashed potatoes were also delicious.

Phenomenal Location Great Bar…read moreOutside Patio to watch the bay Great food. Group enjoyed the specials and the fish and chips

Food and drinks were fantastic only rivaled by the staff and the amazing view. Waitress was great…read morefood came out quick and prepared and plated perfectly

We come here on our last night every Door County visit. I always make a reservation a week ahead of…read moretime. Our server was Kevin and he was the best great sense of humor very attentive. The food was wonderful. My husband had shrimp tempura appetizer and the small fillet. He loves getting the Door County cherry martini. He looks forward to it every time I had the Vol au vent Seafood dish it was heavenly, but rich, had to take half home. That was nice though because I got to enjoy it the next evening for dinner. My salad had the fresh made cucumber dill dressing very good no dessert for me. Grasshopper for my husband he always looks forward to that too. Cannot wait to come back. Everyone is so nice. It's a good place. Put it on your list.

Always busy, hard to get a reservation. Went on a Wednesday night at 5:30P. Huge bar area and…read morespacious dining room. Seated on time and greeted with warm bread and butter. Split a shrimp cocktail to start, shrimp were modest in size but sauce was excellent. Side salads came and were surprisingly well done. Lettuce plus mushrooms, carrots, tomatoes, cucumber and croutons. Wifey went with the Wednesday special, perch. Generous portion served with mashed potatoes and green bean medley. Very good choice. I went with the seafood pasta dish. Had a fancy name but basically shrimp (over cooked), scallops (cooked perfectly), lobster tail (medium size but very tender), artichokes, and tomatoes over linguine in a very salty sauce. Proteins were very good, sauce was far too salty and ruined the meal. Service was excellent. Recommend with caution. Everything we saw served around us looked great. Unfortunately, I chose the wrong menu item. Will return to try other entrees.

Not sure how this place has an average of 4 stars, I thought it was superb! The puff dinner rolls…read moreto start off are divine, get the goat cheese spread as an appetizer is so good. I had the Beef Burgundy (I'm Ron Burgundy?) , and it had a ton of flavor. What really impressed me though was the dessert. Get the carrot cake, one of the best I've ever had. Chocolate mousse was delicious too. The staff is super friendly and efficient and the decor is perfect for a steak and seafood restaurant. Highly recommended making the drive to sister bay in door county.

We have enjoyed many dinners at Chop over the years. Weather dependent, we try to dine outside on…read morethe upper deck with a beautiful view of Sister Bay and the sunset. Service staff is always top notch. Last year we ate a later dinner inside and the ambiance was wonderful. Old school steakhouse feel with big leather seats and candle lights. It's was great. They serve a great Kentucky Old Fashioned. Nice way to kick off a great meal. The entrees and apps are all very tasty, especially the fresh salads, soups, scallops, and crabcakes. The wine list is on the pricey side, we opted for a carafe of house Italian red blend and it paired very nicely with the filets and my wallet. Don't skip the dessert. Carrot cake and key lime pie were both amazing. Only disappointing notes this year were the mashed potatoes. They had a box mashed potatoes aftertaste, not the usual Yukon gold I remember. Not sure what was going on there but it stood out. Also, we were on the upper deck again, but it felt like there was one too many tables out there. Tough to maneuver around, needed just a bit more breathing room. Otherwise, still a wonderful meal.

Great service, cute spot, good food. Walleye was great. Interesting mix of traditional Lake food…read moreand sushi. Heard the sushi was fantastic. Seafood stuffed Chicken was ok. Decent wine list.

The food and service was great. And the dining area and bar are nice too. Fine dining at its best…read morein the this area.

I love a good New York style, wood fired pizza with a thin, crispy crust, and I think I found…read moreexactly what I was looking for here! The pizza at Pizza Bros was SO good. Simple, crispy, flavorful, and exactly how I like my pizza. I love their variety of toppings. Plus, it's inside the brewery, which makes it a perfect casual stop for pizza and a drink. Highly recommend Pizza Bros if you're looking for a really good slice of thin crust pizza!

Stopped back and dined in, having the Taco Pollo again! It came out in less than 20 minutes, was…read morehot, fresh, and tasty. TV's, games, fire pits, and indoor and outdoor seating. Counter service for food and drink.