Our first NY pizza in actual NYC not sure if it's actually good or I was just really hungry after our flight. I really did enjoy it a lot. Probably on the plainer/mild flavor but that's exactly y I like it. I can eat the whole slice without getting tired of chewing or the flavor. Can't wait to try more. It's first come first serve, just wait in line, order ur pizza and then pay. Place is a bit small but has plenty of seating both inside and outside. Good to grab as a quick bite in between all your shopping read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Classic White, Margherita, Spicy Sicilian Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Back again as this has become a New York staple for us. We went aggressive this time and ordered several: pepperoni: solid Hot chick: gross. Never again. Didn't like the sauce Toni Roni: excellent. Love the meat variety. Love how they have cheese, herbs, and chilli flakes to add to your pizza while eating. read more

Honestly I was really surprised by Abitino's. I don't really expect great pizza in the more touristy parts of Manhattan, especially right next to Rockefeller Plaza, but Abitino's showed up when I was hungry and just needed a quick slice on the run. Expect the place to be crowded, it is tourist central in Manhattan after all. Since most people are buying by the slice it clears out quick though so you can probably snag a spot if you're quick enough. Overall seating and look of the place isn't anything to write home about, but it gets the job done, especially for the amount of slices they're outputting every day. It's hard to be as clean as they are in that area. Pizza was great, and even though I'm biased against square pizza I have to say the Spicy Sicilian stood out as the best I had there. Especially after adding the hot honey they had next to the counter. The sausage and pepperoni was delicious. Really my only feedback was that the white pizza was severely under seasoned. They had plenty of shakers, including red pepper, parmesan, salt, pepper, and a custom blend as well, so it was an easy problem to remedy and after adding a tad of salt and some red pepper flakes it was just as delicious as the other two. Pricing was really amazing especially for the location. I have absolutely no complaints about the amount we paid, especially given what some places around the area charge. I get that there's cheaper pizza around but I don't trust those $1 slice places, I've never had good pizza at those. The guy at the counter was a hoot and super friendly even when working with tons of customers. Honestly I would recommend this place to anyone who finds themselves hungry and in the area. Are they the best pizza in NYC? Nah, but if you're going to stick to the Times Square/Theater district area they're one of the best I've had, probably one of the better that I've had in Manhattan even. So if you're willing to cross a river for some better options, this is a solid place. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - White Pizza and Spicy Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious pizza! Super fast and friendly service. Quick and efficient place, with a warm welcoming feel to it. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Decent crust but otherwise pretty bland. Definitely middle of the road. Pretty much like any of a thousand other pizza slices in the city. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pretty well baked plain slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fell in here after a play and was dying for pizza. I'm just judging on the grandma. It was delicious!! But $6 and change?? A bit high but I guess it's due to location location location! read more

Great stop for a classic New York slice. Prices were reasonable and we got through the line very quickly despite how busy it was read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid slice place just off 5th ave near St Patrick's and Rock Center . Gets really busy and crowded but they move through the line quickly . I was a Joes guy for years and still might give Joes a slight edge over this place but not by much and if you are in this part of the city it's a great alternative . Lots of variety but I always go with the basic and it's really good. read more

Ordered two sausage slices to go. Was told they wouldn't do it. What happened to self respecting ny pizza joints? This one's clearly for the tourists read more

A great slice. Slamming busy when I was there, but things moved quick and the staff were great. Good cheese and a good sauce. Nice little stop before getting back on the bus home. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Small place with cozy vibe, service was quick, pizza was some of the best I've ever had. 10/10 no notes

Service was not good at all and price for pizza not worth it! Skip this place and go to little Italy pizza on 48th .

Great selection of pizzas including the classic plane jane NYC cheese slice. You just walk in, they heat up your preferred slices, the you can sit in or outside and eat your pizza as you watch the city bustle. Crust and sauce are good. Definitely would return. read more

See all

Not only did I love this pizza but my husband and kids did too. Great assortment of pizzas to choose from. Pretty quick service so don't be intimidated by the line. Service is prompt and friendly. This is now on my regular visit list! read more

I really liked the variety here! We got slices of the veggie pizza and the meat lovers pizza. Both were very tasty! A little tight on seating but what can ya do in NYC heh. Friendly service and clean place! read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Veggie and meat lover pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I was out and about in NYC, and was craving a slice of pizza. I came across Abitino's. I got a buffalo chicken slice. The slice was not good at all. It tasted artificial, and it was barely warm. They had quite a few selections of pizza inside, but I doubt it would've made too much of a difference. They have a few tables and chairs to sit at inside, but not too much seating. The service was decent, but nothing too special. I definitely wouldn't come back. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Buffalo Chicken Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Super quick service, pick your slice and they'll warm it right up. A sizable slice of vegetable pizza was $6. Took about 3 minutes. Light crust and chewy cheese with a good amount of peppers. Good for a snack walking around town read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Vegetable pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

FABULOUS!!!!!!!!! Last night during our NY Weekend Getaway, we ran into Abitino's Pizza and we couldn't be happier!!!! We were craving a real NY Pizza experience and we were not disappointed. The place was large enough to accommodate those ordering along with some seating. The staff was great!!! The pizza was amazing; crunchy bottom and crust, cheesy, perfect sauce and super hot!!!!! Definitely recommend! read more

Pizza truly a 2.5/5. They get one star because a slice is $6.00. Unreal. This place is a tourist trap. I was in a rush, so should have know better. Go elsewhere. read more

Staying at the hotel right next to this place and in spite of the fact that there was no one there I thought I'd give it a try. New to the whole New York experience it delivered perhaps as expected. No one greeted me, and the two gentlemen behind the counter were speaking together in Spanish and ignored me. In a weird way this made me happy and I thought "welcome to New York!" Perhaps the experience might've felt even more authentic if they had yelled at me I ordered two slices back to back, one was a veggie and the other one meat. Perhaps my expectations were too high considering everything I had always heard about New York Pizza and I was really excited. In the end, the experience was just whelming... I would've actually enjoyed a beer, but also discovered that it was only soda, etc. One Thing was very clear, though, the place was extremely clean and when I came back from my second slice, the young man behind the counter was a little bit nicer. If you just want a quick pizza and want to make it convenient, this is the place read more

See all

5 Stars all they let me give Abitino, he & he's team were outstanding, even by LA standards

We had a couple slices, pepperoni and tony rony. Both were 4 star worthy. But the garlic knots were doughy and awful. The staff was friendly and everything was clean and sharp. But oh those knots. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pepperoni and tony rony with awful garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is very busy but the line moves fast! You might not be able to get a seat. All the pizzas were delicious though! I'd try this place again. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Came here at lunch time because of the reviews and left kind of shocked at how much people like it, particularly when people want to brag on New York Pizza. Since we were starving, And we were curious after the great reviews we wanted to try out a number of different slices. We got two upside down Grandma slices, a grandma pepperoni and a classic New York cheese slice. Of the three varieties, I guess the upside down grandma was the best, although I could find equal or better better pizza at 25 places in Rhode Island and pretty much any city or town here would have one. I'm not saying it's bad. I'm just saying it's super average. The upside down grandma was light and crispy which was good but didn't have much taste to it. The cheese slice had no flavors at all but the back crust was pretty good. The grandma pepperoni was spicier than it probably should have been. It tasted like there was red pepper flakes in the sauce, although there wasn't very much of that. As I said coming from Rhode Island, this is just okay. York are bragging on this place then. I'm not sure why New York has their reputation that it does. It's just kind of okay if you're hungry. There are literally five pizza places within 5 minutes of my house that I would go to before this one if it was in my neighborhood. Not bad, just mid-ish. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Upside down grandma, grandma pepperoni and a classic NY cheese slice. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Came to NYC for the day. Power shopping and wanted a quick bite and pizza fix. Found this on Yelp. Fast. Easily. Tasty. Check, check, check. A slice for about $6. Some seating. Great location. Putting it in my permanent rotation. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

very delicious!!! i especially loved the margarita pizza shoutout to our server, he was very cool and friendly read more

Pizza was cheap and pretty good. We got a slice with white sauce and then a margarita slice and both were fantastic. Bathroom was less than pleasant but overall fantastic pizza. Great stop for lunch or to grab a quick bite to energize yourself while exploring the city read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

A former colleague of mine introduced me to this place many years ago. Whenever we worked late, she would order a pie from here. Anywho, they make a pretty good slice here, I couldn't vouch for anything else because that's all I've ever had here. In addition to the great pizza, the staff is very friendly and cordial. I would definitely recommend this pizza place and it's worth the $4.50 per slice, in my opinion. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I dropped an order for 20 people on this restaurant on line at 10:40 am for lunch. They executed. 12 pizza's 15 salads etc. and they showed up at 12 noon with everything done right. That's hard to do. The pizza was very good the salads were excellent. read more

Garlic knots were burnt/overcooked; calzone was ok -could have been tastier; cheesecake was good; delivery driver didn't speak English enough to have basic conversation and didn't follow delivery instructions despite 20% tip read more

We were quite thrilled to have found a new choice for lunch around the office; especially when it's a neighborhood style pizzeria in midtown among all the high end stores. The establishment looks clean and modern. Well lit. They don't seem to have have much variety (in terms of pizza) as some other pizzerias around the city. We took a slice, a sausage roll and an order of garlic knots. My friend described the crust in his slice as "too dense". Another friend and I felt the garlic knots were unusually "moist" (if that makes any sense)... Something just seemed off with them. The sausage roll wasn't bad, but I wouldn't describe it as "great". It wasn't very busy during our visit. There were 3 workers and our order was ready within minutes. I found their prices to be very fair. read more

This pizza place seemed to pop up overnight. Like many near Rockefeller Center and 5th Ave. I've been here a few times, just to grab a quick slice. I've had the Margherita Slice and a sausage slice. It's good, and kinda just there with flavor. Nothing wrong with this place, but it will never make it to any of the lists. Save your appetite for one of the better known places to eat NY Pizza. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Clean environment. Friendly staff . Totally affordable and delicious the garlic knots and Sicilian pizza was fire read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Vegetable/ white and pepperoni we went back extra slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I guess im a regular! Haha Get the pep pizza. Its do hot inside i had to take outside read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Abitino's was right outside the door to our hotel, so it was a super convenient stop after a long day seeing sights in the city. The white pizza and "hot chick" pizzas were great. The garlic knots weren't our thing, but we also tried the stromboli which was also very good. We went back multiple times during our trip! read more

Stopped in while walking these NY streets. Pizza is 10/10. I got 2 slices 1 pepperoni and 1 pepperoni and sausage. My kid got a plain cheese and a beef Pattie. The pizza is so fresh and tasty. It's also not very heavy. And the restaurant is clean. What a bonus. Ambiance is cool. Service was great. I'll be back. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Nice pizza spot - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is a great place right off 5th Avenue. We stopped in during the St Patrick's day parade to get a slice of pizza. Quick efficient service. It was crowded but not as bad as I thought. We grabbed 2 stools and ate. Loved it! read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Pizza!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Got the spicy Sicilian slice and it had a beautiful crisp crust and soft doughy inside. The spice was great and not overwhelming, only complaint is that when they reheat the slice (it had been in the display counter) the cheese stays kind of lukewarm and stiff. The garlic knots were good just lacking a little on the butter and garlic flavor. It's a small inside and very busy, but I like it it's very classic NYC. Everyone in there was kind and service was quick. Great but probably won't return. read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Spicy Sicilian Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

$5ish/slice yum yum yummy very clean inside! Service was quick and friendly! I'd definitely go back! read more

Abitino's Pizza Rock Center - Tony Roni yum yum - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza is average. The prices are ridiculous. $4.00 for a small bottle of water. And the service sucks. Don't waste your time.