This is a family style restaurant that is ADA accessible and has outdoor seating. There is an arcade available upstairs that includes pinball machines. They have beer on tap and the sports are always on (they're enthusiasts themselves!). The staff is always friendly and welcoming. The pizza is amazing! read more

Made reservation and they were amazing at accommodating our party. Food was great. One of the best chicken bacon ranch's I've ever had. Video games were bonus for our group. Clean and easy to access and park. read more

We visited Bainbridge for a weekend soccer tournament with a few families. This was a great spot for pizza, salads and local beers. Service was good and staff was friendly. The kids loved the video games. Perfect spot for family and larger groups. Will definitely be back. read more

Did not serve individual slices and it was before 6pm. The vegan cheese was disgusting. The pizza was burnt, I'm guessing to melt the vegan cheese. I've had them before and the pizza was great. So to pay 25$ for a medium one topping vegan cheese pizza just to throw it away was disappointing. read more

We had a large pan style pizza. The dough and crust were delicious and they were generous with the cheese! My daughter enjoyed her fettuccine Alfredo. It was broiled so it had a nice crunchy crust on the top. So good! read more

Watch out for the cameras! Food is average. Service is efficient. Better like screaming children as that is their ambiance. And YES. I'm at the Bainbridge Westside. Camera pics are REAL. I'm not mistaken as to my location. read more

Cashier insists on putting slices on top of one another inside the box when I get 2 slices to go. By the time I open the box to eat , the slices are melted together and the toppings get mashed together with the crust above. It's happened 3 times and it's during lunch. I don't want to correct the guy at his job and lunch choices on the island are limited. Kind of seems like a no f's given situation. Kind of seems like day one pizza common sense. read more

One bite everyone knows the rules: 7.1 A good balance of not too thick of crust but not too thin. Barely any flop, more on the crispy side but toppings and cheese are fresh. I'd call this a gourmet dominoes and that's a good thing. The variety of flavors will keep you wanting to try them all because they are good! Only judging pizza, not wings or other stuff. read more

Westside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all

Love West Side Pizza! Been going to West Side pizza since we moved here , 27 yrs go..I've been to other pizza place ahhhh it didn't cut it for us.. Our favorite is the Death by Pizza .. Today service was perfect, did the online order and they notified that pizza was in the over will be ready in 10mis.. got there pizza was done , it was hot just came out from the oven.. so ono! Broke da mouth! ( Hawaiian say) Mahalo! For your all your hard and fast service.. Tutulei P.s. no cinnamon stick tho.. read more

I'm a long time customer who's been coming here since I was a child, well before it was "Westside Pizza." I often bring or meet my family and friends here for food and conversation or to create new memories like during birthday parties and close gatherings. The atmosphere is inviting and you can see it on the kids faces when they're eating pizza whilst playing games at the real life arcade (that is upstairs in the dining area of the establishment). The establishment is always clean, staff always friendly and the food comes out fast. Their "Big Kahuna" and "Westside Pizza" are the families of our favorite pizzas. Westside Pizza is a staple on the island and I highly recommend stopping by here if you come to visit the area. read more

Westside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

1. First impression: Not the friendliest, but a decent spot. There was a big line and I was just someone they had to move through. "What can we get for you?" Not a smile or a "hello." Onto the next. I understand that it can be stressful when there's a rush, but come on, a little greeting is all it takes. 2. At least 35 minutes later (not exaggerating) after I went up to ask what was going on, "Sorry for the wait." One pasta with Alfredo sauce and an 8-piece no-bones chicken. The runner dropped it on the table and ran, probably to avoid any confrontation. 3. No-bones we're good, but there was such an over-abundance of pepper and cheese in the pasta, my kid couldn't eat it. 4. The bathroom was out of toilet paper. WTF 5. Final impression: Not cool. read more

We love this place for both dining in and take out/delivery. Pizza is really good, great beers on tap, kid friendly, and the staff is so so so nice. So glad to have this little gem just a few minutes from our house. Fun for kids and adults! Nice, clean, and easy parking. Make sure to bring quarters for the arcade section of the restaurant! read more

Ummm. You've got to be kidding me! Just stopped by to grab a pie for dinner and saw the menu inside. First time in a westside pizza in years. Was hopeful for a carryout special. Twenty plus dollars for their smallest pie, which is a medium. I thought, well . . . Okay. That's high for a 14" pizza with ZERO TOPPINGS. So I looked on the wall for their size chart. On their counter it shows their smallest size, a medium, at TWELVE INCHES! I saw that and started rolling. Walked right out. Pie will be ordered at dominoes for 7.99. What an embarrassment. I've had westside back in the day in Bremerton. It's nothing to rave about and definitely isn't going to get my business at THREE times the price of Dominos. Absolute JOKE! read more

Exactly what i needed. Great delivery pizza. I have not stayed to eat inside but dine in pizza is rare on the island so I will definitely be back to try read more

Didn't answer phone until the forth attempt went to voicemail with the mailbox being full. What legit company does this? Asked about our order that was 45 minutes late. Common response I have heard from them before was "there was a rush" and that's code for "someone didn't show up for their shift." Really feels like this place has management issues. read more

Convenient location next to the hotel we were staying at. Prices are on the high end. We ordered two medium pizzas (one pepperoni and one that was a make your own) and a small salad for $43. Pizza was good (nothing to knock my socks off though) and the workers were all friendly. read more

See all

Great option for quick and easy pizza in Bainbridge Island. We timed it so that we could eat during happy hour for cheaper prices and we were definitely pleased with the quality for the price. $3 small salads (more like medium sized), $4 cheese sticks, $12 large two topping pizzas..all so yummy! We fed 4 people with cheese sticks, large pizza, 3 salads, and a pitcher for less than $50 and we had plenty of leftovers! The cheesy sticks were delicious and we enjoyed our Hawaiian style pizza we ordered. Our food start coming within 5 minutes of ordering and the interior is a clean and organized dining setting. Lots of tvs everywhere to watch sports and relax. Overall good experience for pizza that isn't Domino's, papa johns, or pizza hut! Thanks, Westside! read more

Westside Pizza - Greek salad $3 during happy hour! - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

Not ground breaking, super-different, unique stuff that folks seem to be lookin for these days, but just consistently good pan pizza with good local service. read more

By the slice is an awesome way to find the pie u like! I had and enjoyed pepperoni jalapeño pizza! Fantastic service, was able to watch the game, eat and have a cold one! Ask for daily specials. To get great food and a deal, way to go Westside! read more

Minus 1 star--otherwise, I would given this review 4 stars if it weren't for the delivery boy and the safety of your guests. (Owner: On 7/20/19, late afternoon, around 1-3pm, your delivery teenager boy was a horrible driver. He almost hit our car twice. Once when we came into the parking lot and once when we were exiting your parking lot. HORRIBLE delivery boy...) Besides this experience, we enjoyed our pizza and chicken wings. The staff was friendly and pizza was good. We ordered half meat mania and half bbq chicken. read more

Pizza is OK but their COVID protocols are really bad... they do not clean in between patrons, forks are not individually wrapped and are kept on an open container so anyone who grabs one touches several others. They have a bunch of disassembled pizza boxes that are being stored on a booth open for people to sit on, those boxes will later be put together and used to serve pizzas, there was a bunch of kids playing in the arcade then seating on the booth with their backs on the pizza boxes!!! Yuck! The bathroom was a mess, did not have toilet paper, paper towels or soap. The wait was over 40 min, and they messed up my order twice! All the employees are really really young kids so... that explains a lot. Lots and lots of room for improvement here. read more

Very good pizza high recommend going back Great service fresh ingredients and good costumer service read more

Usually when we head out to Bainbridge, this is one of my families fave pizza joints to enjoy! I love their setup which is spacious, it's clean and has TVs and arcade games for my kids to play while we wait for our pizza! We always almost go here with a group of 6 or more and we have fun every time esp when it's not packed! The Pizza are a bit pricier than your average pizza joints. We loveeee pizza and the two we always order are the make your own with 2 topping large pepperoni and sausage and 2 medium chicken Alfredo! AMAAAAZIIINNNG! They pack their pizzas up with thick pieces of meat, cheese as well as any sides you'd like to add. Very flavorable and good portions! The crust is not overwhelming compared to others! Our party never complains! The only reason I would ding a star on this place is that their soda is very watered down. I almost never drink soda and when I do, it better be worth it. Lol Their pitchers are about $5 ea and I honestly would rather just bring my own soda from Safeway across the street. Who doesn't love a good cold Pepsi-mountain dew with pizza right! We've asked them about it to see if maybe the syrup is low... they'll fix it but still end up tasting the same? Thanks anyways for trying! Overall, customer service is quick! They are almost always busy so I wouldn't expect more than prepping us delicious and top quality pizzas! Besides the soda downer, my family will keep coming to the Westside Pizza when visiting Bainbridge! read more

See all

"We're supposed to have individual slices until 6 pm but tonight we didn't want to make more...". Meh.

Great pizza. Delivery gentleman was veFriendly. Hot pizza. Fresh. Very tasty. Would order from them again for sure.

Really good pizza. The "Death by Pizza" was to die for. Barbie & Ian were so nice and helpful. Would come again if I lived closer. read more

Westside Pizza - "Death by Pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

We called in our order for pick up...when we came in yjj on get our order the staff was more worried about talking about internal politics rather than greeting/handling guests. Seemed young! The pizza was yummy, the pink lemonade was out, didn't realize until we got back to the car, yuck. read more

Just had a great time here at Westside Pizza last Saturday 10.22.2022. We planned a 5 year old birthday party for pizza and video games! Kids had a blast and Tom the owner was exceptional in making sure his team took great care. Couldnt be happier. What more can i say? Duck into Westside for a slice and soda deal at lunch time. Bring the team in after a big win. This is also my go to place thats a non bar for sports...but dont tell everybody. read more

Took my family on 8/20/2022 Ordered for dine in, Soda fountain was out of 90% of the flavors, Salad was brought to the table with one fork which there was 5 of us with no plates, when we went and asked we were brought paper plates. When the pizza arrived it was just sat on the table not the pizza holder with no utensil to serve. No napkins on table had to go a retrieve ourselves. Shuffle board table looks like it has been though a war and back. Won't be dining in that establishment any time soon unless some changes are made and won't recommend to family and friends. read more

I'm from New Jersey and consider myself a pizza snob. There is nothing like simple New York/New Jersey style pizza. My brother was out visiting and we ordered a pie. On a scale of 1 to 10 he rated it a minus 3. Sorry Westside. read more

One of the best pizza spots I've ever been too. The staff was great! I love the atmosphere in this place too. Overall highly recommend!

Pretty disappointed with the pizza we just had there tonight. We're staying close by in a hotel and we were craving pizza, so figured we'd give Westside Pizza a shot. The kids working in the back was a comedy of follies, totally confused chaos!!!! And they weren't even that busy! We ordered the 'Death by pizza' and kinda chuckled at the name, big pizza kinda name, but a whimpy pizza with minimal toppings. Almost $30 after tip for a medium is an awful deal & the pizza just tasted ok. read more

See all

Noticed a flyer in our hotel room with a happy hour special and I'm all in for some cheap eats. We chose this pizzeria because of its proximity to our suite and wanted a quick bite. This restaurant has a homely atmosphere with polite customer service. Also the amount of food we purchased honestly could've fed a perfect family of four. I enjoyed the Greek Salad & Penne Creamy Pesto. My boyfriend had a Caesar Salad & Wings. I'm so glad we have so much leftovers so we'll be able to enjoy the food all over again later tomorrow Would definitely recommend and would go again. *Salads are $3 during happy hour and the portions are very generous! read more

Westside Pizza - The Caesar Salad, Greek Salad, two orders of Chicken Wings, Penne Creamy Pesto, and an order of Bread Stix. - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all

It's pretty good. The noise level from out of control kids. That's a bit much. I do really like the owners!

Ordered a pizza at 4:30 pm for delivery at 6:30. b At 7pm called and asked where they were at. "We're really busy but they should be there any minute". At 7:30 pm called and told them that they could forget it. Either they screwed up the order or their driver is out on a long break. NEVER going there again.......... vV read more

I was hoping to give WSP a 5 star but I'm not a fan of the of spongy pizza crust. I would like to say thought that beyond my personal preference of crust, everything else was really exceptional. They offer a lot of menu variety at a great price point. The facility was clean and the staff was very courteous. I'm glad I tried them out. I stopped in for the lunch special which was 2 slices and a soda for $5.50 which is a good deal. You can choose slices of choice so I went with a pepperoni and a WSP slice. The toppings were fresh and the cheese was real! My only reservations the crust itself... I know that they state that it's made fresh but I am not a fan of the generic spongy crust(like you would find at a Pizza Hut) it was too spongy for my like liking. I prefer a crust like Costco, Round Table or brick oven (thin). But if you like a spongy/buttery crust then you'll like WSP. Overall, it's a good deal with a great environment. read more

Great experience! The place was very clean and the staff was extremely helpful. We got the BBQ Chicken pizza and a Caesar salad and they were both excellent. Overall no complaints and will definitely be back again! read more

I haven't had gluten-free pizzas before, but we tried it here. It was really really awesome, couldn't even tell. It tasted like flat bread pizza. My cousin's allergic to gluten, and she's had her fair share of gluten-free pizzas, said that this place had the best! They have many different preset pizzas and you can customize/pick your own toppings, tons of variety. Great place for family to gather and eat! read more

See all

Hot and ready slices or order a whole pizza. Pretty easy and as quick as a pizza through the oven can be cooked.

Thankfully this place was across the street from the hotel we were staying at. Great location, and service was awesome. My friend and I split the large pizza with mushrooms and chicken and it was so fresh and hot. Pizza came out quick and the guys working there were so nice! Made sure we had our sauces and plates. They had a wide variety of fountain drink options, pizzas, salads, pasta and wings! Will be coming back next time I'm in town. read more

Westside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington