The service was amazing really nice people and the food was great definitely recommend stopping by.

The place was easy to find. Small and clean with wonderful service, very friendly staff... The food was fenomenal and everyone love it including my two daughters... Toys for kids and sand to play! Very family friendly and again the food was amazing. We had fish tacos, the end of the endago, catch of the day and one more that i cant remember lol . Thank you for making our islamorada experience much better :) read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Perfect place for a quick casual dinner in the Keys! I got the calamari roll with plenty of calamari. Definitely grab an Islamorada beer brewed just down the street. They have outdoor seating right on the marina and food comes out quickly read more

What The Fish Rolls - Calamari roll & Islamorada beer - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Lobster roll was great and fresh but I didn't realize it was going to cost so much or else I would have ordered something else. Love the atmosphere out on the canal. 2 cans of cokes and a lobster roll =$29 read more

Alex was such vibrant energy and they somehow managed to make their calamari salad with just calamari and arugula the most flavorful and decadent experience! read more

Amazing service and food. This place is so quaint and delicious. Alex was kind enough to explain the menu to us and answer our questions. I had the calamari roll with chips which was delicious and a good portion for the price. It was just what we needed after a long day on the water! read more

The service is warm, prompt, and helpful. The food delicious! Fresh, locally sourced fish cooked just right. Craft beer in bottles We enjoyed the outside dining area - it was quite, open, with a nice view of moored boats. We're putting What the Fish in our "have to come back next time list." read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

The rolls were the best! I will recommend to everyone I know who will ever be in the Key Largo area. What a gem of a place. Thank you for being awesome and caring about the quality of the food you serve. read more

Truly the absolute best in the Keys. They had Conch Fritters on special for the day that had a beautiful amount of chewy conch bits throughout. The Fish Tacos were SOOOO tasty. Plus, the owner is a sweetheart! Absolutely the only place I'm eating when I'm in the area. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fish Tacos and Conch Fritters. YUM! - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Ride to eat today. A typical keys hole in the wall. But the food is fantastic. Conch. Barrel fish. Lobster roll. Fried clams. Sit outside. On the water. Can't beat it. Enjoy. read more

Another great restaurant on the way to KW! In a place w/other businesses but not hard to find. Delicious food, friendly & accommodating owner, outdoor seating on a beautiful day, that's how to start a vacay!! read more

Found you guys while scrolling through Yelp, and man, am I glad we stopped in for a bite! First off the service is so friendly and the space was so clean and inviting that I knew we were about to have a great meal from this place! And that's exactly what happened. I ordered the Casa Mar Roll and my boyfriend had the crab roll. Both were equally delicious! The bread, and the ingredients used were so fresh and flavorful! I can't stop thinking about these rolls and we only ate them two hours ago. I messed up... I should have gotten one to-go to eat now while I write this. While we were chowing down on these delicious rolls on the patio we even got to see a couple of manatees! What a great place. I highly recommend if you find yourself near by that you stop in for something to eat. Thanks again What The Fish? Everything was delicious and we can't wait to come back again in the future. read more

See all

Nice guy running a solo place with outdoor seating. Good tacos. Great service. On the water

Little place, kinda hidden. food was so delicious had the crab roll. Everything fresh and cooked to order. Service, Outstanding, even called us by name as she brought out order... we ate dock facing, seeing boats and tours pass by..... read more

What The Fish Rolls - Crab roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Simple, fresh, delicious! Absolutely worth the stopping off. Perfect little place with amazing energy and tasty food. Got lobster rolls, friend calamari and French fries. Everything tasty and super fresh. Thank you guys for a great lunch break. read more

What The Fish Rolls - All that was left of the lobster roll. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Perfect little lunch spot with outdoor,covered tables that all have views of the water. We had two delicious lobster rolls at market price - $23/each. The service was perfect. Favorite place in the Keys so far. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Amazing food and right on the water! We had the fish tacos and the catch of the day and they were great. For a tiny place, they had a pretty good beer/wine selection also. Would definitely come back again! read more

What The Fish Rolls & More is by far the best restaurant we've been to during our visit to the Florida Keys. Definitely a must try for lunch! Try the Lobster Roll, you won't regret it! read more

See all

Located at key largo/tavernia area. Very small on the dock with great seating but super cute. But the food is fresh off the boat. My favorite is the testosterone booster and the lobster roll. The booster is the freshest tasting calamari and shrimp ever - it melts in your mouth. Perfectly grilled. The Lobster roll is packed and the roll itself is a delicacy. The lobster perfectly cooked and a great Mayo. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Must try!! - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Fresh & delicious seafood. Cold beer. Incredibly warm & welcoming owner. What more could you want?

Picked up a to go lobster roll and it was amazing. I called only being 2 minutes away and it was packed and ready when I walked in. The staff was super friendly and the place is super cute with shaded water views. The lobster roll was excellent and not typical. There wasn't a bunch of mayo or any mayo at all. It had this delicious green based sauce. I would eat it everyday ! read more

Yummy fish tacos. Can't miss with this laid-back waterfront gem. Olivia was so gracious. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fresh mahi tacos - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

This cute little place is awesome! It's tucked away on a side street but worth the jaunt. They were super friendly, took the time to explain the menu and the service was quick. The food was hot and fresh. We were in there during COVID and everyone had a mask and it was evident he was being careful...even offered sanitizer after using the pen. Their fresh catch is literally what the local seafood market catches. On this particular day, it was snapper. Yummy, yummy, yummy! Hubby had the crab roll and loved it too. We were driving through and they were very helpful with offering ideas for places where we could to take our food to watch the sunset. read more

What The Fish Rolls - This little guy was crawling on the dock right near the restaurant. It was fun to watch him scurry while we were waiting for our dinner. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

The lobster roll was so good! Hotdog was great for our toddler and they have a high chair which is much appreciated. The owner is so nice and friendly and explained the menu in depth prior to us ordering. We will be back! read more

Absolutely amazing! Came for lunch because of the reviews and was not disappointed. My fiance and I both had the roller lobster and we couldn't be more glad. Huge chunks of lobster, great seasoning and perfect toasted bun. Not too much bun like most places and plenty of lobster. Usually its the other way around. Not here. We also split the Calamari salad and that was amazing. The calamari was seasoned just right, it wasn't too chewy either. Probably one of the best we've had. It's a small little place, laid back atmosphere. We sat outside overlooking the canal. I can see why this was rated 5 stars. Go try it for yourself! Especially if you're local and haven't been. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Excellent food and service! The owner was a thorough gentleman. Great location for a quick bite.

Food is fabulous! Just the right size and fresh! Great and friendly service! Talked our group through the menu and made great recommendations! read more

We're so happy we stopped by for lunch. The service was wonderful and the food was as so tasty. We started off with the Ceviche Del Mar, my husband and I loved it. We then had the Roller lobster and the Castaway shrimp roll. Worth every mouthful. They welcome dogs at the place and even provided water for our thirsty puppy. Please stop by if you are going though the keys. read more

See all

Somewhat off the road, this nice spot is a must try. They have a great selection of sandwiches. Yes the lobster sandwich is good, yet don't sleep on the ceviche, it is legit. Sit outside in the back and you will love it. It's a mini escape. And yes, you should ask about the cookies. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Outside of the restaurant, you can walk through that door or go around back to order. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Service was good. Food was delicious and very quick. Loved the fish sandwich with fries. read more

It was such a nice surprise to find in our way to Isla Morada a local seafood restaurant with great seafood and excellent service. Fred was l courteous and friendly, the tacos were one of the best I've ever had and the music was just what we needed to enhance this experience. read more

See all

The owner Alex is so friendly and has amazing customer service! The food is delicious, we definitely recommend going and getting the fish tacos! They have some gluten free options as well read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fish tacos - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Fish Tacos were so dope. Probably one of the top 3 all time I've had Peel and eat shrimp were hot and fresh. Classic seasoning. No frills here. The calamari roll was good. A little dry but the spicy mayo adds flavor. Daughter loved the hot dog. It was great to sit by the dock. Good vibes all around. Space isn't that big, but not a bad thing. If you want good food. This is your place. 4.5 out of 5 read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Fresh, tasty, gracious portions. Lovely service. Small place with lots of outdoor seating. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fresh Catch - yellowtail - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

This place is good but it's not the lobster roll you think it is. It's not Florida lobsters and they add an interesting twist - not your northeaster butter and mayo combo. Honestly it's very cute just wasn't the lobster roll for us read more

See all

Stopped here on our way back to Miami from Key West. While they seemed to struggle with service (even though there were only a few people there, they had a hard time balancing orders) the food and shop were wonderful. I had a fresh fish roll, and my husband had a hot dog (not a fish lover). The Fish roll came with the local catch (maybe mahi mahi for mine), in a toasted bun with coleslaw, lettuce and a delicious sauce. It was so nice to see non-breaded fish in a bun! Don't get me wrong, I love fried fish, but this felt so fresh and you could really taste the fish. It was the star of the show. We sat outside on the deck and watched the pelicans and boats float by. read more

Lobster rolls are a MUST here. We make an effort to eat here every couple months because it's so good! read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Small place waterside. Had the fish tacos, wow! Fantastic. Wife had the peel & eat shrimp. Said they were best she's had. They were bigger than most places so she didn't get as many as other places. No side. The fish tacos came with 2 tacos and a side of nacho chips. Casual place. You order then go sit. read more

AMAZING! I got a shrimp roll and it was soooooo delicious! My family got some of the tacos with the fresh catch of the day and they said it was very good. The owner was very nice and friendly! Highly recommend! read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Super fresh! Local owners! On the water. This was just what we were looking for. Closes early on Sunday nights. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Shrimp Tacos - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all