I've had cheesesteaks all over New Jersey and Philadelphia, and yes, I'm fully aware that statement is going to upset some people, but Yellow Submarine still takes the top spot. It's hands down the best cheesesteak I've ever had. The steaks, predominantly Chicken Cheesesteaks, are always flavorful, the bread is just right, and every bite reminds me why I keep coming back. There are plenty of places that claim to have the best cheesesteak, but this is the one that has earned my loyalty. Yellow Submarine has my business for as long as they're around, and as long as I am. If you're looking for a cheesesteak that lives up to the hype, this is the place. Sorry to everyone who swears by another spot, but this one wins for me every single time. read more

Food is a 4/5. Friendly and fast service. Prices are average. Clean small dining area but most patrons grab and go. I tried a 17" cheese steak hoagie and a 17" buffalo chicken sub with cheese. Both were decent. Just average fare. read more

Yellow Submarine - Cheese Steak Hoagie Large (17") - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Phenomenal steak and people working the counter. Shared a 10 inch steak with my daughter and it was quick and delicious. Well seasoned, perfect amount of cheese, and chopped to perfection. It is also probably one of the most reasonably priced steak around. My only complaint is that the roll was cut too deep and the sandwich was a bit difficult to handle. This place is worth the trip. read more

Old school drive in with cheesesteaks and ice cream. Honestly, I was not expecting much from the place . It's a little rough around the edges . The Cheesesteak was a great surprise . Very old school. Great roll, simple, clean ingredients. Properly seasoned and well balanced . This is not a jaw opener like Lillos or Mamas meatballs. But it is a very nice steak. Fries were good and plentiful. We went for the ice cream but were more impressed with the grille . read more

Yellow Submarine - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Need to give a huge Shoutout to Yellow Submarine. Their food is excellent! Great prices. The employees are always nice. Cheesesteaks are the best in the area!! read more

The bread was fantastic .That's really what kind of sets the bar! Definitely will be back! read more

Yellow Submarine - 7" Philly American cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Can't believe all these years I didn't know about this place. Cheesesteaks are really great! Definitely tops in the area.

I've been looking for a place with great cheesesteaks since our local spot changed owners and the quality went downhill. I came across all the great reviews for Yellow Submarine so I figured it was worth a try. My husband and I are currently eating our cheesesteak and chicken cheesesteak and both are delicious! Meat is cooked perfectly, great flavor and fresh. Curly fries are good too. Will definitely order from here again. read more

I had a plain pizza pie. It was above average. I'm raised in Pennsauken all my life and never thought to give them a try.

Found this place by accident. It is a very casual dining facility. The "works" steak sandwich was healthy portion! The flavor was really exceptional. The ONLY down side was the horrible soggy roll. Had they used a decent roll the experience would qualify as a 5 star. read more

So I hate leaving a negative review . But, I eat there for lunch sometimes twice a week . I call ahead of time in hopes that my sandwich will be ready when I arrive so I can pay for it and leave . I only get 45 minutes . This is the fifth time in a couple of months . That I called ahead of time and they didn't start my sandwich until I got there . I asked the fellow at counter what's the sense of calling in . He kind of smart and said well we weren't busy so it will only take a few minutes . That's a few less minutes I have to eat .​ I've never experienced this anywhere else except Yellow Submarine . I love their food . The people that work there are very friendly . But damn it when I call to order a sandwich start it then . Not when I arrive . Yes they weren't busy . But I'm very busy . I would appreciate my meal being ready when I get there . It would be a different story if they were crowded. But I usually get there around 3:00 in the afternoon when they're dead . Waiting because you're busy is one thing . Waiting because they didn't feel like starting it until you get there is wrong . read more

This is the only place in NJ I'll order a cheese steak- without worrying it won't hit like Philly- always consistent- best for last 15 plus years since moving from Philly to NJ can't go wrong cheese steak extra American fried onions ketchup mayo read more

Yellow Submarine - Small cheese steak extra American fried onions ketchup mayo - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

I have been ordering from Yellow Submarine for YEARS. This was the worst experience I have had. I ordered a Mini Cheese Steak and Fries. Door Dash delivered the Order but when I opened the Paper it was a Chicken Cheese Steak I Spoke to BLAKE at Yellow Submarine and the cook said he Remembered making a Cheese Steak. I told Blake I know the Difference between a Cheese Steak and a Chicken cheese Steak. I do NOT Eat Chicken Cheese Steaks. He said I had to Call Door Dash if He could Not get Me a Refund. WHY!! I ordered from Yellow Submarine and I am Paying You for the Meal Not Door Dash. I asked for the Owner and was told He would Not be available for some Time. Blake then told me he Corrected the Problem so why am I so Upset. How dare You speak to a Customer that way. I own a Business and If Blake worked for me, he would have been Fired. He suggested reorder again. No Thank You. It is now 8:00 PM I lost My Appetite. I know alot of Neighbors who order from Yellow Submarine. I hope they never have this Problem and if they do, Do not speak to Blake. Maybe he should Deliver Pizza's instead of working for a well known Cheese Steak place in Maple Shade. read more

Since the last reviews in 2017 no change but if you're wanting to get a bite and don't value food this place is like McDonald's. But higher in price. read more

OMG, I've not eaten here since 1987, that's not a typo, and had a Cheese Steak Hoagie with Mayo and fried mushrooms. Still, 36 yrs later this place rocks the cheese steak and very filling on a modern day fair price. read more

Yellow Submarine - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Cheesesteak and pizza shop. I can only comment on their cheesesteaks which are consistently excellent, large and overfilled and delicious They has a few inside and outside tables if you are sticking around, otherwise most people just grab and go. Service is perfunctory, strictly business, don' t expect a lot of banter. Our favorite shop for years since I found it about 15 years ago. read more

If you're looking for a good sub, they have it the cheesesteak are fantastic The service is good too read more

Has always been a go to for classic submarine sandwiches! many years in the business and still top notch. call ahead and take it home- the chicken cheesesteak hoagie is great. read more

We all live in the Yellow Submarine... the Yellow Submarine... the Yellow Submarine Ok now that the song is out of my system haha Craving cheesesteaks and wanted something close to Cherry Hill due to pure laziness haha and saw great reviews for this place! Order was placed online... easy prays, no hassles. Arrived at the location and order was ready! Literally was there less than a few minutes! Cheesesteaks had great flavor! The only thing I wished for was the bread was a little more toasted! They give you 3 different sizes in cheesesteaks: mini, small and large. I actually ordered a small and was only able to finish the mini, but I happily ate it afterwards after reheating in the oven! Of course got fries with it and wish they were more crispy. Overall.... great spot to get cheesesteaks! They've got other items I'd like to try eventually. Super fast service and super easy to place your order online! Parking is limited if it gets crowded but there's street parking in the neighborhood as it's located right in a residential area! Will definitely be a regular customer since I live in the area :-) read more

See all

The food was great!!!! I had their ice cream and she made it in the span of 5-10 minutes (she made three ice creams) Amazing service!!! The seating at the back of the ice cream place was very cute!!! I definitely recommend the ice cream and I can't wait to try their cheesesteaks read more

Yellow Submarine - The front of the restaurant/ ice cream parlor - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

This is not what we meant by we wanted it in a cone. They said the gummy worms wouldn't fit but they clearly can. We had to make it ourselves! See the gummy worms do fit!!! read more

Yellow Submarine - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

Grew up in town enjoying their great cheesesteaks. Full of meat and here it is over 30 years later and consistency of quality still going strong! They also have some tasty pizza too! Staff is also consistently polite and professional. Very reasonable prices in today's ridiculous inflated era. Worth the trip!! Cheers and thanks Yellow Sub!!! read more

I LOVE this place. I order from here almost every Friday and the food is always very good. That's what I love about it .. always consistent. The delivery driver is super nice and we always get the food really fast. I recommend the Italian hoagie, cheesesteaks and wings. I wish the rolls were a little more tough I think they tend to get soggy if they sit in the foil with the hot cheesesteak in it but aside from that I will continue to order from and recommend this place to everyone. You will also not regret ordering their house made mozzarella sticks. read more

Yellow Submarine - Mozzarella Sticks - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

First time coming here and the staff was super nice. They have seating outside and making more around back. Their mozzarella sticks were huge and they tasted great! I enjoyed my hoagie it was really tasty as well as the cheese fries. I am definitely coming back to try more of their menu. read more

See all

Stopped by Yellow Sub for an Italian Hoagie after a few brews over at Jay's on 73. I was the only customer there, as it was around 830PM. Seemed there were a few mobile or phone orders still coming in, but I received my sandwich promptly. I ordered the Italian with extra meat, oil/vinegar on the side since it was going for a short ride home. For the price point (~8 for a "small" which was around 11") this was pretty solid value. The provolone was cut thick (wish it was actually a bit thinner) but was flavorful and paired well with the salami, which stood out to me more than the capicola or Genoa salami. The amount of lettuce, tomato and onion was on point and the slight touch of oregano added perfect amount of seasoning without being too cloying. My only reason for not rating this higher is the bread. While the bread wasn't bad or stale, it was definitely the softer bread you see a lot in SoJo/Philly that's used for cheesesteaks-I'm accustomed to the chewier, crustier bread from Italian bakeries such as Italian People's in Trenton. Overall, a solid sandwich for the price point. I can tell this is not "their thing", as the main focus are their cheesesteaks. I'll have to revisit them for a proper steak! read more

South Jersey fame for good reason... Worth the drive across the river from Philly. Their interpretation of the region's famous steak sandwich is delicious. So is the grinder. read more

I ordered a sausage, peppers, and onions hot sandwich with mozzarella cheese added. The sandwich was very good! Bread was toasted and was perfect for this sandwich. The sausages were delicious and the onions and peppers were cooked just right. It was served up with a little tomato sauce mixed in which added to the great flavor. Note:. The sausages were of the "hot" Italian variety. Not sure if it is regularly made that way. I did say "hot" when I ordered. Either way I like both and this sandwich was a home run!!! DEFINITELY will have this again and will try other items on the menu here. I would've taken a picture of it but I ate it so fast that I forgot to do so! read more

I am so disappointed!!! I literally just paid $20, including tip, for the worst white pizza I've ever had. My normal pizza place is on vacation so I thought I'd give Yellow Sub a shot & I am so so disappointed. This pizza had zero taste. It literally tasted like nothing, like white pizza normally has oil and garlic on the pie under the cheese & it gives it flavor. Nothing. The spinach was clearly the frozen kind that they must have thrown on there frozen & it thawed while cooking & it made the whole pie including the tomatoes watery. I never leave reviews, but I was so looking forward to a white pizza and this was a huge disappointment. read more

I think the yellow submarine had the screen doors in because we sank. I heard great things about this place and was really hoping for a great cheesesteak. As soon as I picked it up the back of the roll blew out and it was down hill (ocean) from there. The one thing about this cheesesteak was it had an amazing taste. It needs more and better of everything else but it did have an amazing taste. read more

See all

One of the best Italian sandwiches I've ever had in my life!! The meat to bread ratio was perfect and all the fixings were on point. Also got a cheesesteak which was very good but the Italian Hoagie blew it away! read more

Yellow Submarine - The Italian Hoagie! - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Cheesesteaks are the best in the area including Philly. The cheese is melted into the meat and the bread isn't thick. This place has been highlighted on food network and is a local staple. Curly fries are pretty good too. read more

Decent place to get a cheesesteak for a decent price. Reason I would not recommend this establishment is because of the service. Typically there's a female at the register and this particular female was rude af! I ordered a cheesesteak over the phone and specifically asked if the lettuce could be at the bottom of the sub (like I always order from here) with the meat on top. From the time I walked in the female rolled her eyes and took a deep sigh; not at me but assuming who she was taking the order from over the phone. I pulled my card out to pay for my order but before I did she says "I don't think they put the lettuce on the bottom". I asked why not? She says "idk I put it on the receipt he said he couldn't do it ". So I proceed to check my order and the lettuce was on top of the sub. I simply said "whenever I order from here I always ask for my lettuce at the bottom and it's never been a problem". She cut me off and said "well I didn't make it". She could have simply apologized and asked me if I wanted to speak to a manager but instead it seemed as if I was annoying her. With that said I told her I didn't want the order at all and because of this, I'm sure I'll never order from this place again. read more

Best cheesesteak in the area. Hidden gem Much better than the big names in Philly Rolls are excellent read more

Overpriced, underwhelming cheesesteak. I hate to rip on a small business, but this place is filthy. Even though I frequently drive by this place, now I know. I won't be stopping again. read more

Yellow Submarine is real food: it brings Wawa to shame. I've heard raving reviews about Yellow Submarine's cheese steaks: I agree. As a loyal customer I've noticed they are very consistent, receiving what I've been expecting. Thank you for your great service Yellow Submarine read more

See all

this was the worst cheesesteak I and my wife ever had. it was bland, boring and a waste of money. the girl serving the food, a little brunette should not be there. She was not helpful and not an asset to the store. How the TV show gave this a great rating is beyond me. the food they made for that Tv show had to be different then what they serve to customers. Do not waste your money read more

Great Sandwiches and never disappointed!! Our go to sandwich shop in Maple Shade... Lunch Sandwich Specials are amazing

Dear Yellow Submarine, My kids had your pizza at Skyzone in Maple Shade New Jersey. We've been on a pizza tour for three months plus, and this is stop number 20. I have to say at this point I'm not sure that I really like pizza. I have been opting out for salads. However, your pizza was actually very, very good. My daughter gave me a bite of her pizza. When the kids disappeared to go jump around on the trampolines, I went back and ordered myself a slice. I have to say that I enjoyed it. I have NOT enjoyed pizza very much since stop number 15. So, congratulations for putting my faith back in pizza. read more

What you want....simple delicious giant cheesesteak. Friendly at the counter ... no frills inside .... good value. Sub was gone before I could get the photo sorry read more

Yellow Submarine - Sandwiches Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Got a cheesesteak with fried onions. Roll was the right one for a cheesesteak. Meat was cooked perfectly. Def best in maple shade.