Yotality Frozen Yogurt

Oh my goodness, Pittsford Farms Dairy lived up to the hype in every way!…read more They have a GLUTEN FREE COOKIE ICE CREAM!!! YES!!! And they have gluten free cones!!! They also have dairy free options for those who need it!!! They have pints for those who just want to dive in too I love all the local vendors they highlight in the store, and oh my goodness their chocolate milk I BO-VINE!!! So good!!! Every employee was very friendly and welcomed us to the area, and they were also so kind. I loved being able to sit outside and relax with a great cone. Tons of flavors, homemade, baked goods, incredible smiley face cookies, local vendors and food, and wonderfully delicious and reasonably priced milk and cream. No wonder it has been here for almost 100 years!!!

There's usually a long line outside to get in but it moves quickly and the ice cream is worth the…read morewait. Plenty of flavors to choose from as well as milkshakes, coffees, desserts, nuts, gifts and more. The ice cream is delicious and generously scooped. Outdoor seating is quite rustic including wood benches and a mix of wrought iron tables and chairs. Parking on site or a short walk away. The canal is nearby so it is a great location if you want to go for a stroll.

Coffee + cookies (non-dairy) & brownie razzmatazz - don't recommend the non-dairy one

Handcrafted ornaments made by a local artist

See all

White Rabbit Dessert Experience

4.0(165 reviews)

4.8 mi

Place is adorable inside! The service was wonderful and they are very quick. The desserts are…read moreridiculously delicious! Definitely a place to go again & again, so many things to try!! Just go! Well worth it!

My friends and I came here for dessert during the week. It wasn't too busy at all, and we were…read moreseated upon arrival. The menu is huge, and Im sure there is something for everyone there. I got a piece of chocolate pie with mint ice cream. It was a huge serving and very decadent. I enjoyed it nonetheless. I'm sure I'll be back!

White Rabbit Dessert Experience

Nothing Else Matters

See all

The Billionaire

Village Bakery & Cafe - Pittsford

4.0(348 reviews)

0.0 mi

Village bakery and cafe is always great! This location in Pittsford is super convenient-- right…read morenext to Main Street and across the street from the library. It's often busy during peak hours, but I've always been able to find a spot on the patio. The patio is nice, tucked in next to the building. There's often some shade from the building over the tables. Everything that I've ever gotten from VBC has been delicious. The strawberry bliss cooler is my go-to since it's similar to a Starbucks strawberry açaí refresher, but the ingredients are simpler and the caffeine comes from green tea! I love to get a strawberry bliss cooler and an egg sandwich for brunch. My favorite egg sandwich was the Lilly, but since that has been discontinued, I build a similar sandwich with BYO.

I came here for lunch and I loved this place. Lunch was so good and the service was amazing. I…read morewould definitely recommend this place and I will definitely come back. I didn't expect my sandwich to be this amazing but it was. The steak and cheese was really good, and was loaded with lots of meat. Also my drink was good and so was my pastry which was flaky and fresh. The place has an indoor and outdoor space which is quite nice.

1 or 2 indoor dining areas

Thanksgiving sandwich

See all

Simply Crepes Pittsford

3.8(480 reviews)

0.2 mi

We made reservations a couple days before considering it's about an hour and half away for us…read more Despite having reservations, we still had to wait about fifteen minutes. The place was hustling and it was very quaint and charming in the decor. My mom wanted to go here for her birthday. I ordered coffee. My sister ordered a peach yuzu mocktail with a shot of rum. My mom got the coco mango. All were delicious. My mom got the crepe madame, my sister got the banana and cream crepe and I got breakfast tacos. We split the charred ricotta toast. Everything was very good and filling. Talk about food coma. We all did note that the food was lukewarm but otherwise very tasty.

Very busy but well worth it! Definitely make a reservation! Even with the reservation, we still had…read moreto wait a little bit but it's small place. Food was very good. Crepes are light and there's so many dish options

Kitchen

The signature Burger

See all

Outside

Moonlight Creamery

4.3(150 reviews)

3.7 mi

My friends and I love Moonlight Creamery. My favorite flavor is the A Piece of Cake. It is…read moreabsolutely delicious. The workers are always friendly when I come in too. The shop itself is moderate sized with some seating inside. Its location is great to walk around with your ice cream though.

Who doesn't love homemade ice cream, on a warm night with a view? The flavors jump from breakfast,…read moreto traditional to even dinner. Blueberry Pancake? Chocolate with SPICY? Strawberry cheesecake?! Who knew?! I love coming here. The flavor combos are so fun. The staff is fun and nice. The small is enough for many with one heaping spoonful, but definitely my favorite thing I saw was a FLIGHT of ice cream. Four sample size ice cream picks of your choosing! Yes please! Not to mention they have various rice crispy treats, cookies and pie/cakes with different flavors!

Butterbeer in a waffle cone

The flavors

See all

Jembetat Cafe

2.9(10 reviews)

0.2 mi

•$$$

Excellent spot right on the canal, perfect for a nice stroll after. There's several options and I…read morelove that a small comes with two flavors. I had the triple chocolate and cookies and cream which tasted as advertised. The only downside is they don't offer samples

I've stopped at this place twice since the summer has started, and I really like it! Both times, I…read moreordered a child sized dish of lemon and mango gelato, and it's so, so good. Honestly, it's my personal favorite summer treat that I've had in Rochester so far. It's located right in the heart of the Pittsford Canal, so it's the perfect spot if you need a quick refreshment. They have a solid assortment of gelato flavors, bottled drinks, and caffeinated beverages... and they also sell "duck food" to feed the ducks on the canal for $1... which is just plain cute. I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because the ambiance is nothing to write home about. Overall, it's a super cute little spot and worth checking out if you're taking a walk on the canal.

Creme brulee gelato, Jewelry display

Treat yourself to one of 12 assorted flavors of gelato, and wander through the art gallery or watch the ducks on the canal.

See all

Dolce Cupcakery

3.6(60 reviews)

0.3 mi

My family and I stopped in for some cupcakes for a treat after lunch! The inside was super cute…read morewith a few places to sit and the people workin were all super friendly and patient as we picked out flavors. We grabbed three flavors of their cupcakes. The Mama Bear which is, Chocolate cake topped with cream cheese frosting, garnished with a raspberry. The Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss which is, Chocolate cake baked with a peanut butter cup, topped with peanut butter frosting, garnished with a peanut butter cup. And lastly, I got their flavor of the month cherry almond which I could not find the full description for. All of the cupcakes were to die for, but my favorite was hands down their cherry almond. So moist, sweet, and the frosting on top was light and perfect. We will definitely be coming back for more treats soon.

One of our best local finds. Consistently amazing and would 100% recommend to anyone looking for…read morecupcakes

See all

The Cheesecake Factory

3.2(448 reviews)

1.4 mi

It was absolutely gorgeous. Inside the restaurant looked very elegant. The service was phenomenal…read more The waitress was high energy and made sure our glasses were never empty. All of our dishes were delicious with excellent taste.

This was my very first visit to a Cheesecake Factory. I will start by saying that! And was in the…read moreevening on a Sunday. (This will be pertinent information later.) My first impression was that this place was fancy, and had really great ambience. Beautiful decorations, dim lighting, gigantic in terms of restaurant size. We were seated right away, even though it seemed to be busy still. There were only two of us, so we were seated at a small table - though we ended up asking for a booth so that we had more space. The waitress agreed to speak to a busser about this, but seemed a little disgruntled that we asked. They did move us shortly after. The booth was better for space, but it was near the kitchen, and a giant window facing the parking lot, so noise and headlights were definitely a buzzkill for the ambience. The menu was ridiculous - the biggest I think I have ever seen. There are four pages for cocktails, another four pages for appetizers, two for cheesecake. Over twenty in total. My head was already spinning. I ended up asking a lot of questions because, despite the size of the menu, the portion sizes and prices weren't always clear. (How many tacos? How many mozzarella sticks? What do you mean, the cheesecake is between $10.50 and $12.50? How do you know which is which when it's not labeled?) When I started asking questions, we were also told that they were out of things. A LONG LIST OF THINGS. The waitress stated that this was due to it being Sunday, as if that explained everything. (Told you that information would come in handy later on!) Anyway, we ended up deciding on a fried pickle appetizer, a flatbread pizza to split, and a slice of cheesecake to try. The pickles were really good, so was the spicy ranch they gave us to dip them in, and they came quickly. The pizza took.. a while. Quite a while. So long that we had started wondering if they even put the order in. It did eventually come, and it was okay. While we were waiting, our waitress had mentioned complimentary bread, but never brought it out. That didn't arrive until AFTER dessert and about three reminders. And the cheesecake itself was delicious, though the one that we ordered (Adam's) seemed like it was not enough cheesecake and entirely too much "other". I left having stories to tell, for sure. And it reminded me of what Chef Ramsay used to say about giant menus. Would I try it again? Probably. But next time, I would go at a different time, on a different day, with completely different expectations. Or maybe I would try a different location all together. For now, it warrants three stars.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Miranda W.

14 years ago

The new Pittsford location is gorgeous! Just dropping a quick note to say if you love yogurt, definitely try them out. As a loyal fan to Red mango down in NYC, this place will be my new home to hang out. Its such a relaxing vibe (even though its really cold in there! bring a sweater) and the toppings are endless. So fresh and juicy, love the fruit. Manager is a bit stiff, she needs to smile more :) But the owner is fabulous and very welcoming. I hope they open up more in Rochester. Love it! read more

Linda J.

10 years ago

Awful customer service. A guy with blond hair named john was very sassy to my family and i. He payed absolutely no attention when i asked for a sample cup because he was too busy texting on his phone. Dont come here, there are plenty more yogurt places that taste better and are cheaper. read more

Jessica S.

12 years ago

Unique flavors and lots of toppings. I'll be back!

Yotality Frozen Yogurt - desserts - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Yotality Frozen Yogurt also viewed

Lugia's Ice Cream

4.4

(213 reviews)

Best ice cream around, So many flavors to choose from. Service is fast. Plenty of outdoor seating…read moreand a text too in case it rains.

#1. Cash only. Oops didn't tell us. Said they had frozen yogurt..nope some sour disgusting lactose…read morefree sloppy glop in an inadequate cone, the kids cone dish is so flimsy it collapsed when you put a spoon in the ice cream. Hard ice cream for the kiddo was very soft. A total mess. Threw out the lactose free.. it was truly awful. The kids was a hot mess too .. that got tossed after about 4 bites . As the five year old ssud "we won't be back". Fail to see why everyone thinks this place is great

Sprinkles Ice Cream

4.4

(16 reviews)

Pro's: -Amazing prices on ice cream!…read more-Speedy service -Great ice cream cakes (u pick your cake flavors) -Open all year Con's: -Outdoor only, no eat in option

Definitely our favorite ice cream spot! Generous services and good service. Definitely recommend!read more

Scoop ‘N Twist

3.5

(18 reviews)

Just had the most amazing experience at this ice cream spot! The ice cream itself was…read moreincredible--rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. But the real stars were the warm brownies and cookies they serve alongside the price point is unbeatable. The combination was heavenly! Plus, the service was outstanding; everyone was so friendly and helpful. Highly recommend this place for a sweet treat! Hot Fudge Sundae Vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. Added crushed peanuts 9.39 Cookie tray Warm chocolate chip cookies served with your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or twist custard, topped with Nutella. Added Carmel sauce $12.81

Scoop N Twist...had high ratings on here and understand why that happened. Cute little ice cream…read moretruck in their parking lot, and an ice cream shop with ice cream, gelato, beverages, a sitting area and fun gum ball machine. The service when I entered, was nothing expected for an ice cream shop; locally owned and it showed the employees loved working there. The young lady, Grace , that took care of me, was welcoming greeted me , offered me ice cream samples and was steller in warm, customer service. The ambiance in the place was colorful, and fun. I'm glad I found this place; perfect way to celebrate my mom's memory and love for icecream. Prickly Pear, was my icecream selection kiddie size and offered a mouthful of wow flavor wise. I'll definitely stop in again when in this part of Rochester. Easy to find, located in a large plaza

Countertop Creamery

5.0

(8 reviews)

Located in the plaza across from East Avenue Wegmans , Countertop Creamery offers homemade ice…read morecream with unique flavors. Menu features core flavors and a monthly rotating menu. I ordered two scoops: strawberry patch and chocolate; a collab with local business laughing gull chocolates. Flavors were on point. I've had matcha ice cream before but none have tasted as genuine. During our visit we saw someone order the s'mores ice cream and they toasted the marshmallow to put on top in front of them! How fun! Service was quick and the owners were very nice. The location has an outdoor bench, as well as a few high top seats inside. The decor is fun and colorful inside, featuring artwork from local artists and a Polaroid wall of customers. You can also get an ice cream punch card with rewards for repeated visits. Will definitely come back to check out the rotating menu!

Small batch gourmet ice cream. A double serving will cost $8-$9 dollars but it definitely doesn't…read moredisappoint! They have very limited space inside and outside. This is more a once in awhile treat than a regular summer stop.

Sweet Bradley's Ice Cream

4.2

(9 reviews)

My only regret after visiting here, is that I didn't come sooner!…read more The place is sort of super hidden. I've driven by this place twice every day for the last year and didn't even know it was there! Pricing is excellent for the portions they provide! One small kiddie cone was enough for two people! They also feature a variety of odd/interesting flavors that I can't wait to come back and try out! Do not miss out on this very hidden gem!

Very average ice cream joint. Prices were average $13 for a family of 4 without getting anything…read morecrazy. I never realized this place was there It's the perfect location right next door from the park and elementary school where there is always soccer going on. Maybe look into some signage or something.

Dipper Dan

4.6

(37 reviews)

Had to stop on our first 90' day of the season to our favorite ice cream parlor. Service was…read moreexcellent. They have monthly sundae specials for $5. I got the Mexican sundae today with soft serve. It was delicious. My dog got a pup cup and loved every last lick! The restaurant is clean and inviting.

Very retro vibe... They do not make their own ice cream, but they do offer hard and soft Serve with…read morenice outdoor seating. Service was fast and friendly.

Frost and Foundry

4.7

(10 reviews)

Frost & Foundry is a fantastic new addition to the far end of Park Avenue, tucked just beyond the…read moremain cluster of restaurants. The shop itself is charming, and the outdoor seating is even better -- picnic tables, comfy chairs, and a glowing fire pit that makes the whole space feel cozy and inviting, especially on a summer evening. Inside, they offer some truly amazing treats. The flavors are bright, creative, and unlike anything you'll find at a typical ice cream shop. Staff were friendly on both of our visits and helped guide us through the options. We haven't yet been able to try their signature rolled ice cream -- once due to an anti‑griddle issue, and once because they were out of a specific cream needed -- but fear not, there were plenty of other excellent choices. Some in our group went with classic scoops, but we opted for the Ice Cream Nachos, which turned out to be outstanding. You choose your scoops, and they're served over delicate, crisp pizzelles and drizzled with sauces. We picked Cinnamon Roll and Banana Cream Pie scoops, both bursting with flavor and leaving us simply smiling. The finishing drizzle of pancake syrup tied everything together beautifully. Service was extremely friendly and prompt, and the outdoor seating made the experience feel relaxed and fun. This review reflects two separate visits, both of which were excellent. Frost & Foundry has quickly become our new favorite ice cream shop, and we'll definitely keep coming back -- hopefully soon enough to finally try that elusive rolled ice cream too.

What a fantastic find!…read more Cutest little corner shop in a great lil neighborhood. Sweet decor, fabulous customer service. The owner scooped up our treats himself and was so friendly and chatty. We had a big group- we have seven kids- but he was quick and efficient. The real star, though, was the ice cream. Everyone was thrilled with their choices and practically licked the dish. I had the peanut butter chip yogurt and it was divine.

Insomnia Cookies

3.1

(124 reviews)

We stopped here after lunch to grab a snack for later. While they have less crazy combinations that…read moreyou might find at other similar places, we found the offerings to tick all the right boxes. We had a slight wait on our "Brookies", though we were rewarded with melt in your mouth deliciousness right out of the oven. We also found the quality of the bake to be better than at those other similar mentioned places. The person that helped us was very friendly. We would definitely return.

Placed an order through Grubhub for pickup. Order was ready within 10 minutes. Didn't have to wait…read morewhen I went in. The box was still warm. The cookies were fine but not something I would return for. The classic with m&m's had hardly any m&m's in the cookie. The deluxe confetti cookie was a big improvement compared to the classic with m&m's. Very soft and sweet. I would say the quality overall is mediocre.

Sweet Retreat

4.7

(28 reviews)

This place is a hidden gem. It's kinda tucked away in a…read moreshopping center. We probably passed it a dozen times before trying it out. This is definitely our new ice cream/ treat destination. It's super clean, the staff were very friendly, and although it was kinda busy, it didn't take long. I got a cookie and cream shake. It came with a wide straw so nothing got stuck in the straw. My partner got Mousse Fruit Cake and Dubai Strawberry Cup. I didn't get to taste the strawberry, but the Mousse Fruit Cake she got was pretty good and not anything i really see offered around us. It's worth stopping in just for that.

Rich! So rich!…read more Really enjoyed our visit for special treats. We ordered 2 bubble waffles. We did not get a crate but I did see some I'm not sure why they're almost twice as much money but they definitely were overshadowed by the bubble waffles! We tried the Nutella and the cookie butter one and they were both fantastic but the cookie butter one was really something else! The staff suggested we try it with the vanilla ice cream and I'm very glad we listen to them! We also added strawberries to the Nutella bubble waffle and there was a pretty significant pile of strawberries on top of it! All in all a nice little spot for something different and delicious and we ended up spending $25 for the three of us If we had gone it on ice cream it probably would have been about 20 for three ice cream cones nowadays so pretty comparable!

Mr. Coolee's Ice Cream Shop

4.4

(14 reviews)