Yotality Frozen Yogurt

Oh my goodness, Pittsford Farms Dairy lived up to the hype in every way!…read more They have a GLUTEN FREE COOKIE ICE CREAM!!! YES!!! And they have gluten free cones!!! They also have dairy free options for those who need it!!! They have pints for those who just want to dive in too I love all the local vendors they highlight in the store, and oh my goodness their chocolate milk I BO-VINE!!! So good!!! Every employee was very friendly and welcomed us to the area, and they were also so kind. I loved being able to sit outside and relax with a great cone. Tons of flavors, homemade, baked goods, incredible smiley face cookies, local vendors and food, and wonderfully delicious and reasonably priced milk and cream. No wonder it has been here for almost 100 years!!!

There's usually a long line outside to get in but it moves quickly and the ice cream is worth the…read morewait. Plenty of flavors to choose from as well as milkshakes, coffees, desserts, nuts, gifts and more. The ice cream is delicious and generously scooped. Outdoor seating is quite rustic including wood benches and a mix of wrought iron tables and chairs. Parking on site or a short walk away. The canal is nearby so it is a great location if you want to go for a stroll.

Coffee + cookies (non-dairy) & brownie razzmatazz - don't recommend the non-dairy one

Handcrafted ornaments made by a local artist

See all

Artisan Gelato & Espresso

2.7(17 reviews)

The most aggravating thing about this shop is the fact that I tried to go there three times. The…read moresign said open and the lights were on but there was no one to be found inside. Finally the fourth time around I was able to get ice cream and it tasted just like it came out of a gallon container from the supermarket. Nothing like gelato at all.

We were excited to get gelato along the canal. First red flag, no tastes. Hmmm, why? Well, we got…read moretwo cups with two flavors each. None of the flavors were very good. The coconut has almost zero coconut flavor. The chocolate was very muted. The BlackBerry had the best flavor, but even that was not strong. And the lemon was just ok. I like my lemon to make my lips pucker! Should have ridden to the Pittsford dairy, in fact, we are headed there now...

Mint and Oreo

My Tirimusu gelato (on an unkempt counter) that was more like coffee ice cream.

See all

Oreo / Chocolate Peanut Butter

Neutral Ground Coffeehouse

4.0(54 reviews)

This spot is beautiful. The outdoor seating is located right across from the canal, proper upstate…read morevibes :) I had the breakfast soup and it was delicious!! The latte I had was also strong with solid flavor. Love this little spot would def come back A++++

I came in with my family to grab something to eat for breakfast well in the Pittsford area!…read more I got a bacon egg and cheese sandwich on a bagel and a Matcha with strawberry flavoring. The inside of the place is super cute And they had so many different drink specials that all looked great. The inside was super clean and they had nice bathrooms as well. My family loved their food and I love my sandwich, but I have to say their Matcha was kind of nasty. It didn't have much flavor. It kind of just tasted like water. I would definitely come back again and skip the Matcha for some coffee, as my family seemed to love theirs.

Bathroom

Foamy cortado

See all

Jembetat Cafe

2.9(10 reviews)

•$$$

Excellent spot right on the canal, perfect for a nice stroll after. There's several options and I…read morelove that a small comes with two flavors. I had the triple chocolate and cookies and cream which tasted as advertised. The only downside is they don't offer samples

I've stopped at this place twice since the summer has started, and I really like it! Both times, I…read moreordered a child sized dish of lemon and mango gelato, and it's so, so good. Honestly, it's my personal favorite summer treat that I've had in Rochester so far. It's located right in the heart of the Pittsford Canal, so it's the perfect spot if you need a quick refreshment. They have a solid assortment of gelato flavors, bottled drinks, and caffeinated beverages... and they also sell "duck food" to feed the ducks on the canal for $1... which is just plain cute. I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because the ambiance is nothing to write home about. Overall, it's a super cute little spot and worth checking out if you're taking a walk on the canal.

Creme brulee gelato, Jewelry display

Treat yourself to one of 12 assorted flavors of gelato, and wander through the art gallery or watch the ducks on the canal.

See all

Simply Crepes Pittsford

3.8(480 reviews)

We made reservations a couple days before considering it's about an hour and half away for us…read more Despite having reservations, we still had to wait about fifteen minutes. The place was hustling and it was very quaint and charming in the decor. My mom wanted to go here for her birthday. I ordered coffee. My sister ordered a peach yuzu mocktail with a shot of rum. My mom got the coco mango. All were delicious. My mom got the crepe madame, my sister got the banana and cream crepe and I got breakfast tacos. We split the charred ricotta toast. Everything was very good and filling. Talk about food coma. We all did note that the food was lukewarm but otherwise very tasty.

Very busy but well worth it! Definitely make a reservation! Even with the reservation, we still had…read moreto wait a little bit but it's small place. Food was very good. Crepes are light and there's so many dish options

Kitchen

The signature Burger

See all

Outside

Pittsford Florist

3.8(29 reviews)

0.1 mi

Michael did an amazing job on a dish garden for a funeral. Showed him a picture and he did exactly…read morethat. Thank you Michael. Bianca and Scott Quartaro

Wonderful communication from the principal there with excellent offering and explanations on the…read morevagaries of logistics. It's very nice when the vendor wants to be sure of your preferences and clarifies this on the basis of some detailed discussion. Such customer service isn't so common these days and is quite appreciated in the times of box stores and volume to make a living, where local is both reasonable and worth the investment into the community.

Second arrangement

See all

Wegmans! $40!!

Aladdin's Natural Eatery

3.4(343 reviews)

I will start this as I always do by saying I do not give out five stars unless I am really blown…read moreaway. This is a very nice place to come and eat outside on the deck overlooking the Erie Canal. Had a great atmosphere. There was some live music playing in the common area along the canal, which I got to listen to. The view was nice. Staff was quick and friendly. The food was pretty good. I thought the hummus was very good. The falafel was just OK. But the Mediterranean salad was delicious. They're dressing was excellent. Could've used a few more olives other than that no complaints. I didn't get any of the dessert, but it looked awesome. Maybe next time. I strongly recommend coming here if your looking for some outdoor seating on a nice summer day.

Visited Aladdin's Natural Eatery in Pittsford with a group of eight. There was a bit of a wait…read morebefore we were finally seated, and unfortunately, because of the size of our group, we weren't able to sit on the patio -- which was a little disappointing. The food came in good portion sizes, but for me, it was fairly average overall. Service was also a bit fleeting, and we often had to catch a server when we could if we needed something. Overall, a decent option with generous portions, but this visit didn't quite stand out in terms of food or service. Saluti.

Restaurant

Lamb Gyro

See all

Patio along the canal

Erie Grill

3.8(164 reviews)

Erie Grill is a fantastic dining experience! From the moment I walked in, the service was warm and…read moreattentive. The staff genuinely made me feel welcome, ensuring that every need was met. As for the food, it was absolutely delicious--each dish was expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. The atmosphere was inviting, making it a perfect place for any occasion. Overall, I highly recommend Erie Grill; it's a gem where both service and cuisine shine!

Last night, we celebrated our bride to be, Jen, by dining at the Erie Grill Restaurant in…read morePittsford. We started with a glass of prosecco, a charcuterie board and salty chips, which I didn't take a photo of! There were so many items on the board, I didn't get to all of them. The chips were homemade. All of the entrees were delicious--I brought a piece of my meatloaf home because there was so much! We shared the cheesecake at the end. It was a very nice experience for all of us! The server, Sammie, was super attentive but not intrusive, and gave us time to chat between courses.

Welcome to the Erie Grill at the Del Monte Lodge

Cavatelli Pasta

See all

Order a Blackberry Fizz

Label

3.4(288 reviews)

Lovely outdoor dining space by the scenic Erie Canal. Great service & some of the best crispy…read moredelicious garlic parm chicken wings anywhere! This was my 2nd time ordering them in a little over a month & they were just as great as the first time!

Beautifully located near the canal. Walk into to a dimly lit artistically decorated restaurant. The…read morebar and additional seating is up the stairs to the left as you walk in. Greeted with genuinely happy hellos and seated quickly making sure we were happy with the table location. Quiet and comfy seating areas some booth like cushions & wooden and wicker like chairs. Our waitress was a no linger let's get the show on the road girl. I liked it. Put in the drinks, answered all questions without having to go and ask, told us the specials and had great suggestions. Quick service, drinks, and food. Now for the food. The salmon was done perfectly and she made sure to ask me exactly how I wanted it done. The salad was good, delicious Asian teriyaki dressing. The steak was virtually uneatable. Tough, and chewy. Had to discard almost all of it, discretely, since we were with another couple. Hence we never told our waitress. Great beer, cocktails & wine selection. I had the red cab Ross and it was very nice. I will try this place again. Love the location so many quaint shops are g and beautiful to walk around the canal.

Caramelized Onion Dip.

See all

Fried Green BLT Lunch with Truffle Frites Side.

White Rabbit Dessert Experience

4.0(165 reviews)

4.8 mi

Place is adorable inside! The service was wonderful and they are very quick. The desserts are…read moreridiculously delicious! Definitely a place to go again & again, so many things to try!! Just go! Well worth it!

My friends and I came here for dessert during the week. It wasn't too busy at all, and we were…read moreseated upon arrival. The menu is huge, and Im sure there is something for everyone there. I got a piece of chocolate pie with mint ice cream. It was a huge serving and very decadent. I enjoyed it nonetheless. I'm sure I'll be back!

White Rabbit Dessert Experience

Good Company Crepe

See all

"Split Company" Banana Split

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Miranda W.

14 years ago

The new Pittsford location is gorgeous! Just dropping a quick note to say if you love yogurt, definitely try them out. As a loyal fan to Red mango down in NYC, this place will be my new home to hang out. Its such a relaxing vibe (even though its really cold in there! bring a sweater) and the toppings are endless. So fresh and juicy, love the fruit. Manager is a bit stiff, she needs to smile more :) But the owner is fabulous and very welcoming. I hope they open up more in Rochester. Love it! read more

Linda J.

10 years ago

Awful customer service. A guy with blond hair named john was very sassy to my family and i. He payed absolutely no attention when i asked for a sample cup because he was too busy texting on his phone. Dont come here, there are plenty more yogurt places that taste better and are cheaper. read more

Jessica S.

12 years ago

Unique flavors and lots of toppings. I'll be back!

Yotality Frozen Yogurt - desserts - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Yotality Frozen Yogurt also viewed

Yolickity Frozen Yogurt Bar

3.6

(25 reviews)

A very solid froyo place…read more It seems to be popular to a wide range of locals, for anything from date night, to family night, to post-awards and event celebrations. This is your typical self-serve froyo place, for those of you who prefer frozen yogurt and toppings over ice cream. They also carry Perry's brand ice creams if you prefer that. The cashier was nice, although the self-serve setup lends to very little human interaction. They have ample outdoor seating out front, which is nice, although the ambience is a shopping strip parking lot so nothing too fancy. Other notable details: they do have a rewards program.

I had one of the worst experiences ever at this location. I'm still taken back by the owner's lack…read moreof customer service. Today we decided to get our favorite ice cream because we were having a tough day and thought it would be nice to treat ourselves. Usually, the strawberry sensation is paired with Tahitian vanilla. Unfortunately, I didn't notice that it had been replaced with raspberry. I realized after I had already poured it because the color looked different. I thought, "Well, it's too late now, let me try it," but unfortunately I didn't like the combination. I went to the front and spoke to the gentleman who said he was the owner. I calmly explained what happened and asked what I should do. Without hesitation, and with a very unpleasant look on his face, he replied, "What do you want me to do about it?" I again explained that I had simply overlooked the flavor change, but he rudely responded that it was "right there" and continued by saying, "We don't waste food around here." At that point, I decided to walk away and remove myself from the situation. I dumped the ice cream because I wasn't going to pay for something that was an honest mistake and that I didn't enjoy. When we finished and went to check out with a very kind young employee, the owner came out from the back, saw the ice cream I had dumped, and attempted to charge me for it. I politely replied that I would not be paying for that. His response was simply that we could leave. I have never had an issue like this at the Webster location. This owner should consider taking a class on customer service or even anger management. There were many ways this situation could have been handled calmly and respectfully, but instead it was met with unnecessary hostility. It was a very bad look for what is supposed to be a "family business."

Lugia's Ice Cream

4.4

(213 reviews)

Best ice cream around, So many flavors to choose from. Service is fast. Plenty of outdoor seating…read moreand a text too in case it rains.

On a warm summer day, Lugia's hits the spot! We ordered a "small" which was huge Pineapple soft…read moreserve with chocolate sprinkles in a waffle cone and a special black raspberry chocolate taco with peanuts and fudge! Our total was $19 and worth every penny. Quick service and the frozen treats were delicious!

Hedonist Artisan Ice Cream

4.4

(189 reviews)

Hedonist Artisan Ice Cream is right next door to their chocolate shop, and their homemade ice cream…read morehas the same high quality. My husband's salted caramel was rich and creamy. My raspberry lemon sorbet had just the right amount of sweetness. Very refreshing and a great palate cleanser after dinner. The shop is small with only one table so keep that in mind. Service is excellent.

Omg Hedonist rocks! I loved the dairy free chocolate and candy cane flavors together. The sweet…read morepotato marshmallow was so unbelievably true to those flavors that we bought a pint to take home. It went great with leftover Thanksgiving pie. The prices were reasonable and the shop was cute! Highly recommend.

Netsins Ice Cream

4.5

(71 reviews)

Wow! How did I not know this place exists? I grew up in the neighborhood 30 years ago and came…read moreback to find they have been open now 28 years! They have a huge menu, specialty Perry's flavors, soft serve homemade custard with a hundred flavors, and specials of the month. They offer shakes, sundaes, ice cream nachos, and ice cream plate. Simply delicious! We went to the side window to order and the staff was super friendly and answered all of our questions about the menu. Its location is tucked away in a quaint little neighborhood. We will be back for dure!

I love that they have so many possible soft serve flavors! They also always have a good variety of…read morehard ice cream. You order at a window and then there are some outdoor picnic tables, but I don't think there are any indoor seats.

I-Scream

4.2

(13 reviews)

They buy their frozen 5-gallon buckets from Purity in Ithaca and their soft-serve from Upstate…read moreFarms dairy cooperative. Enjoy local! The lines can be long on busy days, but it's worth the wait.

Delicious! They had decently unique flavors in addition to the typical staples. The ice cream is…read morecreamy and flavorful with a good amount of toppings mixed in. Service was friendly and patient as we parused the flavor options. You can even get more than one flavor in the small size. A++, will definitely be back.

The Creamery

5.0

(7 reviews)

We stopped here to celebrate my sons graduation. The employees are amazing and welcoming. Its a…read morelocal family run business. They had a lot of options for ice cream flavors. They had some on display and some in the back. They have so many flavors they ran out of space up front. So many options! I am someone that is indecisive so I determined I will just have to come back a bunch of times to try them all. They serve Perry's ice cream which is premium ice cream for the area. Prices are reasonable and portions are generous. They have sundaes, shakes and mix ins etc. They have inside seating and outside seating. So ice cream even when it is bad weather. This is a must try and great addition to the area. This is definitely a small local business worth checking out.

The location of the shop is conveniently located next to the bowling alley. There is a good amount…read moreof parking and a pickup window. The shop was very clean and had nice decorations. I really like how the shop offers local goods. There are many options for ice cream and you can't go wrong!

Sweet Retreat

4.7

(28 reviews)

This place is a hidden gem. It's kinda tucked away in a…read moreshopping center. We probably passed it a dozen times before trying it out. This is definitely our new ice cream/ treat destination. It's super clean, the staff were very friendly, and although it was kinda busy, it didn't take long. I got a cookie and cream shake. It came with a wide straw so nothing got stuck in the straw. My partner got Mousse Fruit Cake and Dubai Strawberry Cup. I didn't get to taste the strawberry, but the Mousse Fruit Cake she got was pretty good and not anything i really see offered around us. It's worth stopping in just for that.

Rich! So rich!…read more Really enjoyed our visit for special treats. We ordered 2 bubble waffles. We did not get a crate but I did see some I'm not sure why they're almost twice as much money but they definitely were overshadowed by the bubble waffles! We tried the Nutella and the cookie butter one and they were both fantastic but the cookie butter one was really something else! The staff suggested we try it with the vanilla ice cream and I'm very glad we listen to them! We also added strawberries to the Nutella bubble waffle and there was a pretty significant pile of strawberries on top of it! All in all a nice little spot for something different and delicious and we ended up spending $25 for the three of us If we had gone it on ice cream it probably would have been about 20 for three ice cream cones nowadays so pretty comparable!

Insomnia Cookies

3.1

(124 reviews)

We stopped here after lunch to grab a snack for later. While they have less crazy combinations that…read moreyou might find at other similar places, we found the offerings to tick all the right boxes. We had a slight wait on our "Brookies", though we were rewarded with melt in your mouth deliciousness right out of the oven. We also found the quality of the bake to be better than at those other similar mentioned places. The person that helped us was very friendly. We would definitely return.

Placed an order through Grubhub for pickup. Order was ready within 10 minutes. Didn't have to wait…read morewhen I went in. The box was still warm. The cookies were fine but not something I would return for. The classic with m&m's had hardly any m&m's in the cookie. The deluxe confetti cookie was a big improvement compared to the classic with m&m's. Very soft and sweet. I would say the quality overall is mediocre.

Chill Ice Cream Shop

4.5

(2 reviews)

The icecream was very good and they had options for people that can't have dairy or are vegan. The…read moreowners are very nice and they made conversation, serving us in good time and with great service. The shop itself was really cute and had cute decorations around the window. I think it's a great idea executed well. They also have non-dairy whipcream which I very much appriciate. Would reccomend to everyone to try.

Chill is owned by one of the instructors at Vault. Kinda of pricey for the quantity and although…read morelimited flavor options, you have something for everyone! Including protein add-on for their soft serve and vegan flavors! I tried the dark cherry and butter pecan and the chocolate soft serve, The butter pecan was so good! Give it a try!

Byrne Dairy Store

3.8

(17 reviews)