Overall, 3.5/5, but bumping to a 4/5 since it's more of a 4 than a 3…read more
The folks behind Tail Up Goat packed up the original restaurant and turned it into Rye Bunny, a more casual "order food at the counter and seat yourself" concept. Despite the grand opening earlier this year, it already made its way onto NYT's 2026 Best Restaurants list. My friend and I arrived 15 minutes before opening this past Thursday, and we were the fifth group in line. While waiting to order, we chatted with a server who walked us through the menu and offered to grab us drinks while we waited. We passed on drinks, but other groups were more than happy to have something to sip on to pass the time.
We ordered food at the counter and were told that we wouldn't really be able to order more food (minus desserts) throughout the meal. They recommended 4-5 plates to share between the two of us. After ordering, we sat at one of many two-seat tables, and our food trickled in throughout our ~80-minute dining experience.
ANCHOVY TOASTS (2 PCS.) - 15
Each toast turned into three bite-sized pieces of a mix of savory and sweet, with the most fluffy, cloud-like milk bread. The anchovy was salty, and we were shocked at the unique combination with the sweet jam. We'd highly recommend starting with this!
TALEGGIO RAVIOLI - 28
A bit pricy for what it was, as each order only comes with six ravioli. Each ravioli contained the freshest cheese, and the creamy sauce was lightly sweet from the Asian pear and honey, with some freshness from the radicchio and thyme. I don't know how, but it truly tasted like "late summer transitioning to the beginning of fall," which was what was so impressive to me despite the price point.
SOY MARINATED AUTUMN PORK CHOP - 32
This was pretty underwhelming. The flavors were good, but nothing we haven't had before. We had a variety of pieces of pork -- some were lean and honestly bone dry, and some were 90% fat and juicy with very little meat in them. The pork rib was incredibly tough to eat. I gave up trying to shear off the meat, and my friend spent a good few minutes gnawing away. We were disappointed that it wasn't fall-off-the-bone tender.
ARCTIC CHAR A LA PANCHA - 40
This proved to be a heavier dish, and the flavors reminded me of Scandinavian creamy fish soup, but in entree form. The skin of the arctic char was a bit too dry, which made it hard to cut. But the fish was tender, going well with the bright, herb-heavy sauce mixed with scallion(?) oil and leeks that was incredibly addictive. The crispy potato was surprisingly the star, as it had the perfect texture and seasoning.
MINT CREME BRULEE - 13
Our server came by after we cleared our dinner and informally told us the two dessert options. We went with the mint creme brulee since that seemed more interesting. However, this ended up being the most disappointing part of the meal.
The torched caramel layer was incredibly burnt, and it was super thick. It was unpleasant, leaving a sticky and bitter aftertaste in our mouths. The creme brulee was way too fatty, which was sloppy and unappetizing. We thought they were going to incorporate the mint in a more innovative fashion (similar to the anchovy toast), but it was just mint-flavored. This needs work.
We felt like our meal started off at a high, but rapidly declined throughout. I'd highly recommend both anchovy toasts and taleggio ravioli, and the arctic char a la pancha was quite good too. Still, the price point is steep for a casual dining concept, and we were a bit disappointed with the pork chop and mint creme brulee.