One 5 Star deserves another! Great menu, great service and great burger. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating. The listing of beer on draft is listed on a chalkboard. I debated between the 5 star burger and the gateway. They also offer veggie burger and bison burger on the menu. Gateway burger $12.95 - Smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, onion rings and house made BBQ sauce. Great tasting burger and lovely BBQ sauce on the side. The bacon pieces were a bit on the crunchy side. Sweet potato fries $3 - Crispy and delicious. .|\---/| | @_@ | ..\_^_/..2026 read more

See all

After raining earlier in day, Lynne and I were able to find a patio table on a Saturday night. We love eating al fresco, so bonus on getting a table and being to watch the fancy cars driving by! However, we soon discovered the restaurant was short staffed and servers were in the deep weeds. It took a very long time to order water and drinks and an equally long time to receive them. In fact, we were very close to leaving, which is saying a lot since I've worked in restaurants for years. But this is not a negative review. As those who know, know....5 Star's kitchen crew saved the day by jumping right on our food order and getting us served quickly. Lynne enjoyed the always delicious Blue Ribbon burger...think gorganzola, bacon and port braised onions (aaahhh, sorry, I may have drooled a bit there). I tried the Burger-Of-The-Month, which was not actually a burger, but a sandwich And not just any sandwich, a classic Rueben. I love a good Rueben and this 5-Star version did not disappoint....loads of moist corned beef (yes, I said moist), sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing on marbled Rye! We also split the wonderful 5-Star Salad and a basket of Mixed Fries (combo of seasoned fries and sweet potato fries). This would have been a 3-Star review based on service but the food and drink saved the night! read more

See all

I've seen this pop up across Yelp a few times and decided to give it a try since we were near the area. We came on Saturday and going street parking close to the resturant. No parking on Saturday is a plus. No wait to sit inside and out wasn't crowded but steady. They also have outside seating for nice days. We were greeted immediately upon sitting and our server was spot on. 2 of us ordered the 5 Star burger, 1 a grilled chicken sandwich and 1 bison burger. The sandwiches were good and the fries too. However my hubby did not like his bison burger which was a surprise because he usually enjoys bison burgers. He says it just didn't taste as good. Also the "large" fries were not enough to feed 4 of us and went pretty quick. If in the area, I would likely visit again to try other food options. read more

See all

I have a friend named Bob from Cincinatti. When he comes into town we go to a place to get him a burger. This means I should have a few burger reviews. We arrived a little later in the day which meant we got good parking - Clayton is always "iffy". We also had fun service. There were a couple guys there cleaning and singing. We loved that. They engaged us - seriously, a lot of fun. Bob loved his burger. I ate my mushroom burger so fast it was really good. One of my other friends got hot wings. She said they were really good. I'm a wuss with heat or I would have tried them. I'll definitely be back. read more

5 star burgers, 5 star restaurant! We were looking for a casual burger spot, but also wanted to watch the World Cup game. We picked 5 star and sat out on the patio. The family all got different burgers, and all were in fact 5 stars! We also got the fried pickles (awesome!) and the mixed fry basket. The pickles came with a tzatziki sauce, and it was really good together! The fries also came with a maple cream sauce that was so good! To top it off (and a main reason I picked the spot) we all got their $1 ice cream shooters! For $1, to get a scoop in a cone is unheard of today. Highly recommend the ice cream shooter! In addition to good food, best value dessert in STL, and good atmosphere, the servers were all super friendly and great! read more

See all

This restaurant was busy, but we were sat right away! Had the sweetest server and ordered the burger of the month. The burger was sweet and spicy, mmmm absolutely worth every calorie! We shared a basket of sweet potato and regular fries and cheese curds-all so tasty! What I love is the $1 ice cream cone, it's the perfect size and treat on hot summer days! The ambiance was what you'd expect from a burger joint, busy, loud, and chaotic! Would definitely go back 10/10!!! read more

5 Star Burgers - Burger of the month - July - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

Service was very good! I was visiting on a work trip but the waiter helped me get around! It was pretty busy on a workday lunch. I liked my burger of the month but it wasn't my favorite burger of all time. My milkshake was fantastic and they even gave me pretty much another full glass of "extra". That's how you do it right! I was hoping to convince my coworkers to eat dinner here but unfortunately they chose somewhere else. I would recommend and hope to be back one day! read more

5 Star Burgers - Burger of the month - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

My family and I had lunch at 5 Star and enjoyed it. We were seated very quickly and the service was good. We also enjoyed the music played throughout the restaurant. My daughter ordered The Breakfast of Champions, a side of onion rings, and a vanilla milkshake. She really liked her burger (especially the egg on top) and rings. She said she would like her shake a little sweeter but enjoyed the consistency and appreciated that it wasn't hard to drink. She loved how crispy the onion rings were and that they onion itself wasn't slimy. My husband ordered the Patty melt, coleslaw, and cheese curds. He said it was cooked to perfection, juicy, had a great sauce, and the bread was toasted just right. He liked the cheese curds but would have liked it more if they had marinara sauce as an option. He did not like the coleslaw and thought it was bland. He appreciated that they had his favorite beer on tap, the Civil Life Brown Ale. I ordered the Blackened Barramundi with a side of fries. It was good but I would have preferred more seasoning. It lacked salt but the sauce helped. The fries were ok. I loved that although they are a burger place, there were many options for people who don't eat beef. We happened to go right a happy hour unknowingly and they have daily (even weekends). They have a great happy hour menu. Looking forward to trying new things in the future. read more

See all

5 star burgers has some of the best burgers in St. Louis hands down! I had (and always get) the Bison burger and fries! It was cooked perfectly! I also decided to grab an off menu drink from the bar, a whiskey sour, and I was extremely impressed. Both the waitress and the bartender were so gracious and complementary of how drinks are made, and the skill behind who was making the drinks. It was evident when I took my first sip, lol! 5 star burgers is in Clayton on Maryland along the strip and it seems like a small restaurant from the outside, but when you walk in is actually a lot bigger than it looks like. The bar area is really small so if you go for happy hour I will suggest going right at the beginning if you want to get a decent seat. this is one of my favorite places and I will make sure to come back again. read more

5 Star Burgers - Bison Burger and fries - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

We really enjoyed this place. Stopped in for dinner one evening, and it was definitely a lively atmosphere. We were seated immediately. Service as friendly and efficient. Prices were also quite fair. The food was very good.. We had the patty melt and the Gorgonzola bacon burger. Both were tasty, as were the fries and coleslaw. Absolutely no complaints on food. The meat was even cooked to temp, which doesn't always happen, and served very promptly. We'd definitely return. read more

See all

We just moved back to the area and were craving a non-fast-food burger, and 5 Star Burgers popped up as highly recommended. I placed a to-go order online and drove over to pick it up. This is a really cute restaurant, located in a charming area. Parking is limited, had to parallel park. Staff was very friendly and had my order hot and ready. Everything we ordered was very good and had a hefty portion size as well. The cheeseburgers were pretty big and had fresh toppings, and the fries are cut in house. Although it might not have been the BEST meal of my life, I'd gladly order from here again over a run of the mill chain. I would say it was worth my money. read more

See all

Grabbed lunch at 5 Star Burgers in Clayton and walked out wondering why I haven't been coming here for years. The bacon cheeseburger is built for people who actually want to taste beef. The half-pound patty came out medium-rare with real char marks and seasoning that went all the way through -- not just a salt crust on the outside that fools you on the first bite. The toasted bun held everything together start to finish, which sounds like a low bar until you've had a $20 burger collapse into your lap. The bacon had a genuine snap to it, the cheese melted into every layer, and the produce was clearly cut that morning. You can tell the difference. The fries are a full portion and they stay crispy long enough to actually eat them. Service moved fast for a kitchen cooking everything to order. The room has that no-nonsense burger joint feel -- you're there for the food, and the bar-and-grill setup makes it easy to linger if you want to. Clayton location is convenient, parking is straightforward, and the price-to-portion ratio is better than most places charging the same or more for half the effort. If you're in the St. Louis area and want a burger that doesn't cut corners, this is the one. I'm heading back next week specifically for the mushroom Swiss. read more

My wife and I joined a couple for New Year's Day. This location was one of few that were open. The service was excellent. The food was exactly what we ordered and fresh. My cheese curds were unbelievable. I also love their chicken sandwiches as they give you two patties essentially. This location is well kept up and had vibes from the host to the waitress. read more

First time for a meal to this location. I was excited to come based on reviews. In a nutshell, it was just ok. Food average, portions? Small, and service was less than stellar. The prices are high, and you are metered out ketchup and mustard? I don't like that at all. read more

The name is not a lie - the burgers are really five star. I ordered the five star burger and the patty was flavored SO well. Just the perfect amount of salt and pepper to bring out the flavor of the beef without being overpowering. The pickle chips were deliciousssss and the perfect thickness for a burger. The burger prices listed are just for the burger, fries are extra and worth it. When I first saw the fries I thought they would be generic fries, but they are so perfectly crispy and salted. I got a speakeasy to drink and a mint chocolate chip ice cream shooter to finish, and both were delicious. I love that they sell the $1 ice cream shooters, which are just a small scoop of ice cream in a small cone. It was the perfect lil nightcap (nonalcoholic) to end the evening. I was full so I wouldn't have wanted a full dessert, but the ice cream shooter hit the spot. The service was great. I sat outside and was checked on several times by my waitress to ensure that I had everything I needed. The food came out quick. There is plenty of seating. There's paid parking right in front of the restaurant, and free parking in the neighborhood around the corner if you're willing to walk a very short walk. I love that this is a chill restaurant with great food. It's not super fancy, it's relatively cheap, and it serves up great eats. read more

5 Star Burgers - Mint chocolate chip ice cream shooter. - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

We recently got takeout from this restaurant. I was really disappointed with my burger. It was supposed to come with onion rings and bbq sauce on it. Well, they forgot the bbq sauce, and for the onion ring they chose the smallest slice that was hardly larger than a quarter. It was so funny (and disappointing) seeing this giant burger with one tiny little onion ring on top. I wonder what the person who put the sandwich together was thinking! Or more likely, they weren't thinking at all. Wondering if they didn't care because it was a takeout order and so there was nothing I could do about it. read more

First time trying this place as it is conveniently located close to my job. Decent size place that offers indoor and outdoor seating which is always a plus in my book! Upon arrival I wasn't greeted, stood there for quite a bit actually. The person in front of me got seated and they never came back to seat me. Luckily there were spots at the bar so I took that instead. The lady bartender was extremely nice and provided excellent customer service! I opted for the Gateway Burger medium-well that was cooked to perfection. The temperature was right on. The burger lacked seasoning just a little bit the toppings were fresh and the bun was perfect. The fries were nice and crisp! Though they were packed, the food came out really fast! read more

5 Star Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

Great spot for a casual lunch or dinner. It took us a second to find a spot to park on the street. We were seated pretty quickly. They have indoor and outdoor seating along with a bar. We got the 5 star burger, patty melts my heart and some fries to share. Both of the burgers were cooked perfectly and were delicious. The chopped chillies added the perfect amount of spice to the patty melt. The restaurant is family friendly and had a kids menu. The service was a bit slow but they were busy. read more

See all

Friendly and prompt service. The chocolate milkshake with the toasted marshmallow was my high light. You can always win me over with a toasted marshmallow! Bison burger - maybe should've gotten it cooked medium instead of medium well but it was dry and not very flavorful. Good size though. Pay attention to the toppings! It doesn't come with cheese, which was a sad realization for me after I got back with my takeout order. Sweet potato fries with the dipping sauce - also was a miss overall for me. read more

Love this place! The burgers and chicken options are still fabulous. We also enjoyed the beers on tap options. The veggie burgers and the salad left a lot to be desired. The veggie was soggy and the salad with tired lettuce and hardly any nuts or dressing was ridiculous. Sad your standards have slipped. read more

A burger joint that the target audience is higher middle class people. So a "gourmet"burger that don't come with fries are included in the experience. read more

5 Star Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Fun place with kids and bag for the buck. Parking in the back with side door entrance,

Amazing fried chicken sandwich. Huge portion and great service. I'll be back. And the new seasonal cocktails look wonderful and creative.

Food is always delicious, and well priced! The five star burger is worthy of its name. The sweet potato fries with the aioli are INCREDIBLE! Service can be a bit slow at times (it seems to be mostly younger servers), but it's worth the wait. read more

5 Star Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

I had never been to Five Star Burgers before last week. I was prepared, for some reason, to be underwhelmed. My son had given me a mediocre report. (Clearly he has defective taste buds from his mother's side of the family.) But I was nearby and thought I would stop in with my wife and give it a try. I had the patty melt and it was excellent. And then I had a wild idea and ordered a bowl of chili. I mean, what the heck. It's spring! Let's celebrate ! And it wasn't even cold outside! This was so terribly beyond my comfort zone. But how very glad I am that I did! This is some really good chili. I dipped the patty melted in and suddenly I had a Chili melt! I drug my fries through and I had chili cheese fries! And then I just used an old fashioned spoon and I realized that this is some of the best chili I've had in a very long time. I'm hoping they serve it all summer and not just during the winter months. So if you haven't been to five star burgers, I suggest you dash in. And no matter what you order be daring and have the chili! read more

5 Star Burgers - Patty melt, and a bowl of chili - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

5 Star Burgers will hit the spot for your burger craving. The concept doesn't reinvent the wheel, but is satisfying nonetheless. I ordered the The Gateway Burger with a side of fries and I thought it was delicious. If I'm being real, I think the burgers (and not including any side!) were pricey, but I will say the ambiance of sitting outside on their lit patio, looking out at Clayton, helped me stomach the bill. read more

5 Star Burgers - The Gateway Burger - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Love the place. Excellent service and the burgers are solid. Was able to watch football by the bar area.

The bartender, Allen, I think. He was awesome. We were laughing our whole meal. The food was amazing. Blue ribbon burger and the homemade pickles were . Only recommendation would be more space at the bar because Allen was great and the lines for the bar seats make total sense. Don't sleep on the cheese curds. read more

Nice family place in Clayton. Stopped by for dinner and tried a couple of different things. The sandwiches are the stars of the show, and all 3 that we tried were good. The spicy chicken sandwich is covered in sauce and has a great kick! Grilled cheese has nice Smokey bacon, and the green chili burger was tasty. The sides were a bit odd, as they all came out at room temp, except the fried pickles that were hot. That made the onion rings soggy feeling and without a dipping sauce (why?) disappointing. My daughter asked the server for help on picking a milkshake and she suggested trying the half chocolate and half salted caramel. It was very good, rich and filling. Would definitely come back, but would just get sandwiches and split a normal fry. read more

See all

Happy hour was fun! The food is good and the happy hour drinks were strong. Sat outside and it was a lovely day.

It's been almost ten years since my last review, so it is time for an update. Damn, these burgers are the boom. I absolutely love them. My hairstylist now works a few doors down, from 5 Star Burgers and that may be my demise of my diet. How am I going to resist stopping in for a quick lunch each time I get my hair-cut? We'll just have to wait and see. Perhaps, I can just eat my way through the menu. This day I enjoyed a, Green Chile Cheeseburger. I could not resist the crispy and chopped hatch chilies with my favorite cheese, Pepper Jack. It also had a smear of, green chile mayo. I had mine prepared medium and they nailed it. My burger was thick, juicy and the perfect treat before seeing my stylist. I was dining alone, so I had a hard time choosing my side. Normally, when I am with a friend, one of us gets fries and the other picks onion rings. That way, we both get to experience both. Today, I picked a small basket of fries. They were super crisp and I like the little cup of ketchup instead of a bottle. Today, I enjoyed a craft beer with my burger. I liked their variety of selection and was pleased that they offered, Logboat Brewing from Columbia, MO. However, next time I am going to break down and enjoy one of the hand scooped milk shakes. I sat at the bar and the bartender was friendly and attentive. When my food was ready, one of the kitchen workers walked it out to me. That was good team work, as the bartender was out working one of the hightop tables. I am so glad my stylist changed salons, for the simple reason that I get to have lunch here. I'll try to keep you updated as I eat my way through the menu. read more

See all

Went here with my wife and Grandchildren. My wife and I both ordered the burger special of the month which was a half pound hamburger with seasoned green beans and Bulgogi sauce and two egg rolls. It was absolutely delicious. Grandkids enjoyed their hot dogs and chicken fingers. I tried them both and the hot dogs were first rate and the fried chicken (dipped in bulgogi sauce) was to die for! We ordered 5 of the $1 ice cream cones and they were much larger than expected and wonderful. Service was excellent. If you haven't tried 5 Star Burger go now! read more

5 Star Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

This is the absolute best place to go for 3-5 pm happy hour in the St. Louis area! It is so affordable and kiddo friendly- the sliders are such a good deal and absolutely delicious. Our service was a little slow but it was also busy and I believe we had someone new serving us. We got street parking because we got there early enough- but should be easy enough to find. This price cannot be beat half price beers and discounted cocktails and wine! read more

See all

Hot, fresh, juicy burgers!! Great experience overall. Patty melt had a green chili mayo that added a little heat and extra flavor. Went perfect with the grilled sourdough and melted cheese. The 5 star burger was massive! Hand formed patty that had a nice griddled crust that kept the meat extra juicy. Fries and onions rings were crispy and made to order. read more

5 Star Burgers - Patty melt (front) Star burger with cheddar (right) Hand Natural - Cut Idaho Russet Fries Battered Onion Rings - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

I've been to 5 Star Burgers many times, and they always deliver an exceptional burger - I prefer a thick, juicy patty over the smash burger style and know I can get a medium rare perfect burger at 5 Star. This trip, we tried a strawberry milkshake, tomato soup, regular and sweet potato fries and the special burger (slinger smash burger). Stopping by for the first time in about a year, I was happy to see everything was still stellar! read more

See all

I was on a business trip & sat at the bar. Good service, great burger & nice beer selection. I enjoyed this place and will return when i return to Clayton. read more

Tried for the first time, met promptly and choose to sit outside. Our server, Sam, was quick and attentive. I had the Korean hot fried chicken sandwich. Perfect level of heat, enough to taste and feel,but not sinus cleaning. My wife had the veggie burger. Texture was perfect and the taste amazing. My son had the Patty Melt and said the caramelized onion gave the perfect amount of sweet. My daughter in law had the five star burger and it was dome quite well. We had pickle chips and onion rings and the best part was the batter STAYED ON. Nice atmosphere, friendly service, good prices 10 out of 10 would recommend. read more

The food was amazing!! My daughter had the 5 Star w Pepper Jack and I did the Green chili burger. And both of us ate the entire plate. Which for her is huge. She got a side of cheese curds and we shared the mix bag of fries. Again both were a hit and have full side of fries to take home. Parking is paid meter for $3, for 2 hours. Surrounded by some cute little old downtown looking restaurant and shops. read more

5 Star Burgers - Mixed fries and Crispy Cheese Curds - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

All the food is great, the drinks are great, the happy hour is 100! On a spring day, hit the patio for happy hour, and walk out spending no more than $20 and being full! read more

Low key place to have very decent burgers and some beer. We got the hatch green chili cheeseburger with fried hatch green chilies- 10/10 . Burger was cooked medium, very juicy , seasoned well Also got the Korean hot chicken sandwich - 7/10. I can see what they were going for, was fried and glazed well and good slaw, just felt it was missing something. Will definitely visit again and try other options, eg patty melt read more

5 Star Burgers - Green chili cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all