We stopped off here before headed to The Civic Theatre for a quick bite and Brooklyn Pizzeria did not disappoint. $5/slice or combos for about $11-12 and our food was ready in a matter of minutes. It was pre cooked and warmed up in a brick oven. We got the Supremo and the Margarita pizza with a couple of garlic knots. Now our breath will be extra amazing as we enjoy our show! We may have found our new go-to! read more

Three strikes. Done. Ordered triple pepperoni and pineapple online. It showed up late, with less pepperoni than a regular order, barely any pineapple, and no ranch. When we called, they told us they couldn't read the printout. So my wife had to get back in the car and drive down there to pick up what we already paid for -- no apology, just an excuse about font size. This is the third order in a row they've gotten wrong. Not close to right. Wrong. The pizza is good when they actually make what you order, but we're done finding that out the hard way. Brew Co next door has our business from here on out. read more

No grills little pizza joint that's perfect to grab a quick bite before shows at the Civic Theatre. We were on a tight time schedule between work and a show at the Civic theatre that evening so we ran in here to grab some food. First time there and we decided to each get a slice of pizza and drink. The spicy pepperoni pizza was delicious and huge too. Great value for the food plus convenience! The guy behind the counter was also very nice as well. read more

See all

Okay so this is the smelliest pizzeria I've ever been to. And THIS is HAPPENING during San Diego Comic Con! Like, okay. I walk in there to maybe get a pizza. And let me tell you, it stank up in there. People in there were like, "Dang, what are we doing in here. It smells bad." read more

This is a little hole in the wall pizza joint that we checked out because we needed a quick bite to eat and that was very close to the Civic Center Theater. The guy working there was friendly and our slices of pizzas come out quickly. They offer many pizza chooses but I wanted the freshest pizza which was the jalapeno pepperoni. It had a thin crispy crust with the right amount of cheese , pepperoni and jalapeños. I had to remove some of the jalapeños because it was spicy! I had to ask for a cup to dispense water from the soda dispenser. This was spicy but delicious and hit the spot. I would definitely return for a slice of pizza if I have to watch a show. read more

See all

Ordered the Brookly Bridge Pie for my coworkers and I. Slices were pretty big and enough to feed a staff of 7. Pizza was tasty and my coworkers enjoyed it. Ordered take out and it didn't take long. Always looking forward to come back. Plenty of seating inside and it can get cold since it's in the shade and the doors are open. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Brooklyn Bridge Pie - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Pizza slices were warmed and toasty. Got a pepperoni slice, veggie slice, and bread rolls! Price was very decent for what I got. Service was good and fast. My pizza slices were put in the over to re-heat and came out hot and toasty! Place looked like they were getting ready to close since they have a stack of chairs in one area. Nonetheless, I ate inside and left. P.S. I did see some area that needed cleaning. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

The only good thing in San Diego. And I fucking hate San Diego. Beautiful pizza, Thanks.

I'm a frequent traveler and I luv to find the best pizza spots in walking distance from my hotel whenever possible( Marriott on 8th n B). This is the best pizza I've had in Downtown SD. Flavorful crust, quality cheese n meats( the meatball slice was hittin). It's probably my favorite buffalo chicken pizza anywhere. Right balance of sauces, cheese and skinless chicken pieces prepared in house. The quality of the brick oven really comes through in every bite. read more

See all

The dough here hits that perfect balance - crisp crust with a chewy interior, topped with zesty sauce and luscious mozzarella. Highlights: *Flavorful and crisp pepperoni *Fluffy garlic knots *Reliably good cheese pulls Good to know: -Friendly counter service -Metered street parking available -Less crowded before 6pm to avoid dinner rush A dependable spot for satisfying, no-frills pizza done right. Exactly what you want in a casual neighborhood slice joint. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Perfect little spot if you need a quick, cheap, and most importantly delicious bite before seeing a show at the San Diego Civic Theater. 20 minutes before show time, I popped in and grabbed a $5 meat lovers slice...Having spent some time in New York City, I delightfully surprised that these NY slices had the little crunch in the crust while still being bendy...lovely. Generous on the toppings too! The sauce was sweet and good, but didn't have any "Wow" factor. Friendly folks working here, ambience is simple, casual and clean. Wish I tried another slice! read more

See all

This place is our go to when we want to grab a slice of pizza and beer. They have combos you can get that make it even cheaper and the slices taste better than some over priced places in the area. Everyone is always friendly. We have never had to wait much to both order our slices and get them. They have limited seating, this is not a place you hang out for hours. The pizza selection is pretty big, they have something for everyone. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Pretty decent slices. Got here towards the end of closing and there was only one other person in front of me. The owner I believe was working and he was super chill. I took home 3 slices. One cheese. One pepperoni. One that had sausage. All of them were pretty good. Wasn't blown away. But happy I came. Tons of seating. Good enough for maybe 30ish people. Pretty standard setup. Parking is atrocious since it's downtown but it's on a corner and right in front of a trolly stop so that's clutch. There is a tv on as well read more

See all

The best pizza in all of San Diego! This restaurant boosted my impression of food in this city! Along with affordable, delicious pizza; this spot has amazing customer service and a warm,casual ambiance and is in an incredibly convenient spot in the city! read more

This is the best pizza I've ever tried and I've tried many pizza places from all over. This is a must try! Don't forget to also try the homemade cannolis they were amazing! :) read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - pepperoni slices & white spinach slices - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Great pizza and perfect ingredient ratios. Garlic knots are amazing too. Crust is really good read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

The pizza here never seems to disappoint . It's always on point and the ambiance let me tell you A1 . The guy who takes my order every time knows how to make his customers feel welcome. Good customer service read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Chicken Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

This place has a decent selection of pizza, but if it is your first time there you will need to ask which pizza is which as there is no indication of which is what. We order the pizza slice combos and they are decently priced and not bad for the flavor. The service is pretty quick as long as the people in front of you know what they want and pay. I would come back if I was in the area. read more

The pizza was pretty good. It was better than I was expecting. Parking was difficult to find.

This place never disappoints! It's my favorite pizza place in San Diego! I love the sizes of the pizza and it's affordable. Give it a try I like the supreme slice of pizza with all the vegetables and everything on it so delicious! Warm and toasty I'm going to have to stop by again soon read more

Pizza was amazing! Slices were big and yummy. The employees were great and super friendly, they for sure make you feel welcome. Clean place, only down side it's that is located in a "dangerous" area of downtown. But overall great place! read more

This is not New York Pizza the staff isn't considerate of your time so get ready to wait a long time, the pizza slice was over burnt and over priced. being from New York myself I can tell you folks label everything New York and its supposed to sell. It gets better when the owner I assumed emerges from the back he starts talking this language I have never heard. I asked him if the sauce was Italian home made : he tells me he ain't Italian and he was rude to me as well. When I tried to tell him they have flies on the inside of pizza display I got ignored so unless you want overcooked burnt pizza with flies stay far away from this joint it's not New York Pizza. The environment was loud TV and New York memorabilia everywhere hung but it's not New York Pizzeria they need to change their business name don't be fooled!!! Read reviews other places downtown that sell pizza more reasonable. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Fake Brooklyn Pizzeria Joint - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Good, big pizza slices. I got veggie pizza, which was good, I would get again. There was a small piece of pepperoni on the pizza, not a problem for me but could be for someone else. You can get two slices or a slice with salad and a small fountain drink for 12 dollars. A slice alone would be 4-6 dollars depending on type. You can get six garlic knots for six dollars, seems like a good price to me but I didn't try them. Service is fast but nothing special. Drink cups are plastic, which I just hate. They also have can soda. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria is located on the corner of 4th and C Street in downtown San Diego. They have a good selection of pizza by the slice at lunchtime and a cool brick oven to cook their pies in. Service was friendly and they seem to do a good bit of business at this location. They have a few tables inside for dining as well as some window bar type seating by each window. The pizza as definitely solid and had a good flavor. The only thing I didn't like so much was all the homeless people hanging around. It definitely takes away from the vibe of a good meal. All in all, thumbs up for food and service and thumbs down for atmosphere. Probably a better place to get take out from. read more

See all

So, I got the two slice combo for $12. The pizza had good flavor. It was a bit thin but passable. But I wouldn't say the two slices and a drink is worth the $12. read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Two Slices of Pizza and Soda for $12 - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

I went here on a rainy day, The cheese calzone was amazing, The guy was really kind as well, Though this spot seem to not be as popular, But Its very good, The vibe was really Relaxing and The food was delicious, Great place if you want to dine in by yourself, Its very quiet, and the service was great, would 100% come here again read more

TooGoodToGo had a solid deal. For 6 bucks I got 2 slices and a garlic knot. The pizza had low flop and the the toppings were delicious.

Came to pick up a surprise bag order for the first time and chose a Brooklyn Pizzeria. I got two slices of pizza and a chicken roll. The pizza slices come thing but large in size and when I got the order, everything was so warm! I am pretty impressed by their pizza and that chicken roll was super cheesy. The pizza I had came with jalapenos, pineapple, and pepperoni. I thoroughly enjoyed everything and the freshness of the food when I picked it up to go! read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

This business is in a tough area for parking. And that's my only complaint this pizza is top 10 in San Diego and it's not 10. I'm not a plain pie guy but I would get the plain pie all day from here, the buffalo chicken pizza not the greatest but you can't be good at everything the slices are crispy sauced well and cheese is on point. I want to try that garlic shrimp pizza when is that on the menu so I can pull up and purchase I'll be back for damn sure. read more

See all

Wanted a place to quickly eat before a play at the Civic Theater and this worked out perfectly. Was able to order a bunch of slices (there were several to choose from) and a drink and food came out quick, hot and delicious. Not a lot of inside seating but we found counter seats with no issues, ate our pizzas, and were on our way. Would eat there again. Windows need to be cleaned, they're a bit dirty and not much of a view (closed-down buildings), but it gave us something to talk about and didn't distract from the pizza. read more

Kahina blessed me with a delicious piece of pizza when I was in need.i am hypoglycemia and when I go for too long of a time not eating any food I jsve been know to faint. Karina was my guardian angel tonight read more

I used the Too Good To Go app to get pizza. It was supposed to be $18 worth of pizza. I only got two pieces of pizza. That's not $18. So this was very disappointing and really not what I expected and wanted. I would just like in the future for the restaurant to take the app seriously and give the correct amount of food that people have paid for. All that being said, the pizza was good and I did like that they took the time to warm it up for me. read more

This place is great. I love the standard peperoni slice with an order of garlic knots, or one of their subs. I don't really have a lot to say other than I don't mind going to the office knowing I get to eat here for lunch. It makes the commute worth it. I bought pizza for the office and one of my colleagues is from New York... She was a bit skeptical when I brought the box into the office... She took one bite, sat down, closed her eyes and said, "Thank God." (I wish this were an exaggeration...). read more

Summary: the food was good, 2 of 3 staff members were great. The third guy tried ripping us off. The experience: The Cashier charged me an extra $12 from the actually price on the menu. He put in on their computer. "Custom item, Custom item." I trusted the guy and paid $50+ a tip. Then I looked at the menu again. I asked him to run down the items again with the prices on the board. His number came to $50 when we ran it again it came to $38. I asked for my $50 receipt and the dude pulled out a 5 from the register and gave that to me instead. read more

Authentic when it comes to the pizza authentic when it comes to the character. The owners have the family businesses feel to them and the pizza was delicious. As a NY native I'll be back 100% read more

A Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Diego, California

Could not have been happier with this delightful place. It is a family business and the family are so kind and caring -- they went above and beyond to accommodate a vegan by making me a special salad & then they baked me some delicious vegan bread! We were going to the theatre so we picked it up after the show, along with my daughter's leftovers. Simply wonderful. Thank you!!! read more

I don't know why the rating isn't a 4 for this pizza. It is the best slice of pizza around. Giving a true NY experience. Fantastic!

Ate there on a whim, pizza was great and everyone was super friendly. Had a good variety of slices available.

Super cool environment we will come back for sure food was good and the staff kept everything together

Very delicious pizza and close to my condo. Friendly service and abundant condiments to enhance the flavor. Plenty of seating and tables although I'm not thrilled about this stretch of C St. My only complaint is that they have to tighten up on their hours of operation. I reward myself with a couple of slices of pizzas on Saturdays and enjoy an early lunch. The hours on YELP say they open at 10;00AM and I realize it's not always reliable. A couple of times though I've arrived after 11:00AM and last Saturday I came at 11;30 and there was a chair blocking the entrance...I had to go to that NY place on Market. Other than that, I see a fifth star in the near future. read more