Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    All Star Bagels - New Prospect

    3.5 (18 reviews)

    Order All Star Bagels - New Prospect Takeout or Delivery

    All Star Bagels - New Prospect Photos

    ALL STAR BAGELS - NEW PROSPECT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like All Star Bagels - New Prospect

    Recommended Reviews - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Typical bagel shop
    Nicholas G.

    This place has been here as longer as I can remember. It is a small little bagel shop with a hometown vibe to it. They have the usual suspects here in terms of bagels and breakfast items. I went with the sesame bagel with cream cheese and a plain with egg and tomato. The bagels were pretty good. It was soft but had a little crunch to it with the crust. They also had a clean bathroom in the back if you are dining in. I would come back here for a breakfast sandwich. The prices were extremely reasonable and it is always nice to support a local business.

    a bacon and egg sandwich

    Sandwiches were a joke. Barely any cream cheese and the bacon, egg and cheese was pretty much bare. Save your money and go somewhere else.

    Dozen Bagels

    See all

    7 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Nancy S.
    3
    230
    475

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 11
    Thanks 0
    Love this 14
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Delicious chewy bagels and quick service. Lox was fresh and pork roll sandwich was delicious. Also love their pumpkin bagels!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Phil G.
    71
    79
    7

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Anne C.
    40
    32
    13

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Good food and nice staff. Never going to Rosko's again because they're rude and over priced, keeping my business here

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Freshest in town! Friendly owners and new management. Baked daily and lost of options.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

    You might also consider

    Harvest

    Harvest

    4.5
    (326 reviews)
    6.5 mi
    $$

    I can't believe I waited so long to come back to Harvest. What was I thinking ?…read more We went out for lunch to celebrate my friend's birthday and Harvest turned out to be a great choice! The location is a little further than we would normally travel, but it was worth it. I loved all the farm to table foods they have. They even nicely promote all the partners they use right on the wall of the restaurant, so you know where all your food comes from. Everyone loved their meals! I had the Thai chicken sandwich and it was so flavorful and delicious. It came with a side and I picked baked sweet potato wedges that were really good and so memorable that a week later I am still thinking about them. Other dishes ordered were the chicken salad and strawberry salad which my friends both enjoyed. Our server was very good and didn't rush us as we were just chatting up a storm. The restaurant suggests reservations which are a good idea, especially for dinner. I will definitely be back and can't wait to put Harvest on my restaurant rotation. Sorry no photos this time... the food was just so good and we were hungry!

    This is not a food review. The dishes looked excellent. Management would not honor a older gift…read morecertificate from prior owner. It was for $50. Based on the menu prices, I would have likely had to add another $50 for a 2 person meal. Bad business decision. Not a nice way to treat a senior veteran who moved from the area and wanted to enjoy a meal there. So, for $50, you get a 1 star review and I'll never consider coming back. Guess you don't care.

    Photos
    Trilogy cake Just ok
    Trilogy cake Just ok
    Cherry bread pudding very good!
    Cherry bread pudding very good!
    TOP DISH Cioppino OUTSTANDING!

    See all

    TOP DISH Cioppino OUTSTANDING!
    Tenth And Willow

    Tenth And Willow

    4.5
    (31 reviews)
    7.9 mi

    Along this highway in Farmingdale, you will find an Italian deli that serves quality ingredients. I…read moreonly went there to support local businesses, and I will say that I do not regret it. Brand: 5/5 Tenth and Willow is an Italian-themed deli located in Colts Neck Plaza in Farmingdale. The logo has the Italian flag emblazoned in the background. The solid aesthetics on the website of the sparkles and shining rays perfectly represent the brand. When it comes to the interior, I will say that they deliver on all they promise, for you will find many Italian food and ingredients throughout the establishment. Website: 5/5 It brings you immediately to an image of a sandwich, which makes a good first impression on anyone coming to the site. Scrolling down, you encounter the backstory and the menu with many selections from beverages to wraps to heroes. You will find at the bottom a regularly updated blog section filled with fun facts of Tenth and Willow. Wait Time: 5/5 I experienced no delay or disruptions during the time I waited for my order. Ambiance: 4/5 The establishment housed plenty of Manhattan Specials of varying flavors throughout the aisles. You will also find plenty of cookies and treats upon racks, including meats and cheese hidden behind large glass counters. The aisles and the space between them and the deli did feel cramped with no tables or seats available. Food: 5/5 I ordered the Maple Ham Hero, which considers maple ham, fontana cheese, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic glaze. The maple ham had a sweet taste, as expected, which complements well with the sharp fontana cheese and the lettuce. The balsamic glaze had its own strong taste. The bread held well and had a decent amount of crunch, without becoming stale. Everything in the hero stayed in place while it also had a rich, thick taste. Service: 5/5 The staff managed to get my order without any issues. Worth The Money?: 4/5 The selection of meals, such as heroes, definitely reflect the brand of Tenth and Willow as an Italian market-and-deli. While I did not have a problem waiting, it did feel cumbersome in a cramped area for my order. Nevertheless, the ambiance of exploring around the establishment did not have an issue with me, especially as I got to see the delicacies from the cookies to the marzipan. As for the Maple Ham Hero, the appropriate wait time matched the quality of the food. The organization of the food shows that the staff care about their ingredients. They make it clear on their website that most of their partners provided locally sourced ingredients. If that is true, then this establishment deserves more attention, and I can see how Italian restaurants would rely on this deli for their ingredients. While the website does not scroll down with silky speed, it does provide a sense of welcoming ambiance with its deep, green color. I will say ultimately that the price of the Maple Ham Hero and the experience going to Tenth and Willow was worth it. Rating: 5/5 Stars I have hope that Tenth and Willow will continue to have relevance in Farmingdale, and among those who prioritize Italian cuisine and ingredients. Recommend To... Anyone just starting an Italian restaurant and is looking for key ingredients, since you would be supporting local producers while propping up your local business, thus creating a network of local businesses that help the community through the local multiplier effect. I also recommend to anyone looking to add more to their Italian-inspired cuisine and need suggestions about which meats, cheese, or spices to use. If you like Manhattan Special, then I would also recommend this establishment to you.

    There used to be a barbecue place in this little plaza that is no longer there, so I stopped in…read moreTenth and Willow for a sandwich. I never tried this place before. I had a tuna wrap (spinach wrap). The tuna was flavorful. My only issue was the spinach wrap. It took a little effort to bite through so I don't know if that means it wasn't as fresh. They had some other things I would like to try and will. As for the wrap, I would just call it a one off.

    Photos
    Homemade corned beef
    Homemade corned beef
    Tenth And Willow
    Tenth and Willow sign

    See all

    Tenth and Willow sign
    618

    618

    4.6
    (970 reviews)
    8.4 mi
    $$$

    I've recently been mesmerized by sister property Mezcal, and haven't been back to 618 in some time…read more Last night we were in the area and decided to swing by for a cocktail and appetizers. Very cool that Venue 618 was the only NJ restaurant to make the recent Yelp Top 100 restaurants in the US. Sitting at the bar, we were served by Zoey, Steve, and Mike. They've re-done their cocktail menu to include beautiful color illustrations. I enjoyed "One in a Melon," a well-balanced whiskey cocktail with Frank August small batch bourbon, melon, poblano pepper, Aperol, and lime. This was followed by a tasty whiskey sour. My wife ordered a Lemon Drop martini, followed by a decadent chocolate-pistachio dessert martini. All of the cocktails were well-balanced and delicious. On the food side, I munched on a baked macaroni & cheese with chorizo. It was perfect! The Death of Hospitality brand thrives on personalization and unexpected surprises. Mixologist Steve, realizing that I'm a whiskey afficionado, surprised me with a small pour of Rock Hill Farms Single Barrel bourbon. This is a difficult bottle to find in New Jersey. Rock Hill Farms was incredible, with a super long finish. Thanks for the memories 618!

    After dining many times at 618, I hosted my wife's retirement dinner there last night. We had the…read moreprivate oak room with our own bartender to make sure there was no wait for drinks. The food was amazing. The filet mignon, halibut, and chicken Milanese all drew rave reviews from my guests. What made the night even more enjoyable was the outstanding service by June, Ro and Beverly. I got more compliments on the service than on the food. These ladies never stopped moving and made each guest feel like they were the only ones in the room at times. From the first minute guests entered until they were thanked by the ladies on their way out the door, these three ladies showed why they are an asset to your restaurant. If every party at 618 goes like this one, I will be hosting more celebrations there. Everything was 5 stars!

    Photos
    Inside festive!
    Inside festive!
    Artichokes
    Artichokes
    Drink

    See all

    Drink
    The Committed Pig

    The Committed Pig

    4.1
    (601 reviews)
    10.8 mi
    $$

    Great spot for refuel after a lifeguard comp in Sea Girt. They had a great cold brew which I…read moreneeded! No pictured were the wings and fried pickle chips the boys had for apps. My husband and I split the PigMac and the Double fried chicken sandwiches. The sweet potato waffle fries were a nice touch. Service was great (thanks for the recommendations) and the decor was cute with the mid matched chairs.

    We stopped by for lunch and sat upstairs on the rooftop deck, which is first come, first served…read more The restaurant is beautiful with plenty of seating and a great atmosphere. Although it wasn't very busy, service upstairs was fairly slow, and several nearby tables also seemed to be waiting a while for food or checks. For drinks, we ordered the Boardwalk Lemonade, which was sweet and refreshing, and their version of an Aperol Spritz, which had a beautiful presentation. My dad's Baked Brie Burger was delicious--the fig jam paired perfectly with it, and the waffle fries were fried to perfection. I ordered the Mr. Beautiful Burger, which tasted great at first. Unfortunately, I felt VERY sick almost immediately after eating. I can't say for certain what caused it, but since my dad didn't try my burger and felt fine after his meal, I suspect mine may not have been cooked properly. Despite that, I enjoyed the atmosphere, drinks, and overall experience. I'd definitely give this place another chance, though I'll skip the Mr. Beautiful Burger next time.

    Photos
    First Floor bar
    First Floor bar
    The Committed Pig
    Rooftop bar

    See all

    Rooftop bar

    All Star Bagels - New Prospect - bagels - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...