First time visiting and I can say that we WILL be coming back again and again! Our pizza was super cheesy and they loaded the toppings. The crust was thin but so crunch and crisp and our jalapeños were super spicy (which we loved). The owner was kind and made conversation as we waited. The ambiance was like an old game store in the best way and Napoleon Dynamite was playing on the TV's. read more

Alphonso's The Original - build BYO 14 - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

It was my first time coming here and I was in the area. On my way home from getting my food, I was within a couple miles where a tornado was about to touch down and severe thunder storms that flooded the streets. Also driving into a tornado zone that was currently active. 10/10 would do it again!! Food was amazing and worth it! read more

Added another to my bucket list! Fast food and friendly service. I ordered one lightning rod that I (shamelessly) polished off in one sitting. I was very surprised by the 5-10 minute wait! I expected it to be much longer. Here's the thing. This is not a regular restaurant mozzarella stick (clearly). It's actual quality and flavor. Real ingredients make for a really great feast. Look at that cheese pull! My only suggestion is to be cautious when entering the parking lot if you're not local to the area. It's a very sharp turn and there's not a lot of room for error. Totally worth the extra 6 hours I added to my mini road trip! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Rod Mozzarella Stick (1) - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Good stuff, not a place to write-off and/or forget about. Jump aboard for a taste and consumption treat that is neat and cannot be beat.. Yes, beat, beat, beat, beat your pizza into a digestive mood. The sausage has a tingle. The assorted addendums add delight and satisfaction. I do not want to die for alphonso's pizza but it is a close call. if I capitulate the flavor becomes nil which is a non goal. Cheesy must have come from a horny cow. Mooooo, thanks Tim and bovine.. read more

STOP WHAT YOU'RE DOING! I just had a mozzarella stick at Alphonso's and I'm convinced it was forged in the heavens by a team of Italian grandmas and culinary angels. This wasn't just a mozzarella stick--it was a mozzarella sword... no.. a lightening rod... I had to fight the urge to Excalibur that bad boy out of the marinara sauce. I'm telling you, this thing was so massive I made eye contact with it before taking the first bite. It stared into my soul and whispered, "You're not ready." Spoiler: I wasn't. Now let's talk about the customer service--are these people employees or long-lost cousins I didn't know I had? They're so nice, I half expected them to offer me the deed to their house. It's like stepping into a warm, cheesy hug. Every interaction feels like you're the guest of honor at an 80s-themed family reunion. Speaking of the 80s--OH. MY. NOSTALGIA. This place is a time-traveling slice of rad. Neon signs? Check. Retro vibes? Double check. I kept waiting for someone to hand me a Walkman and offer to trade Pokémon cards. I'm not exaggerating when I say Alphonso's is more than just a pizza joint--it's a spiritual experience. Come for the food, stay for the vibes, leave questioning every other restaurant you've ever been to. 10/10 would mozzarella-stick my life away again, or should I say lightening rod my life away? Haha... [Review 728] - 1st Review for 2025! read more

See all

so good every time. get the lighting rod mozz stick - it's a must. they also have their own cracker crust! extra sauce and ranch too. such a good pizza spot!! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

People will say to come here for the huge lightning rod stick, mozzarella stick, but the real showstopper is the pizza. We went New York style, thin, but I would say this is actually closer to a virgin type of crust. If looking for MKE-like thin crust, definitely go for the cracker thin. The pizza sauce has a little bit of sweetness and such great flavoring. Order an extra of it on the side. Be sure to be the one to go inside and check out all the nostalgic decor. read more

The smell of delicious overcomes you when you walk in! Very casual place but only does pickup or delivery. We did pick up and ordered a build your own pizza and the lightning sticks. The order was placed online and was ready about 40 minutes later. We were instantly welcomed when we walked in. I love the 80s nostalgia of the place to give you something look and talk about as you wait. Stop in- a sight and smell sure to please. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

My son really liked the cheese pizza. My order was ready for pick up when I arrived and service was friendly.

We walked in was greeted by a great staff. Walking into this place is very cool everything is from the 80s. They even have a Nintendo you can play. We got the lightning rod cheese stick and a garlic bread. Both were amazing.. the dipping sauce was amazing. I live in Chicago and would definitely drive back here just for these. Next time I need to try a pizza. read more

Alphonso's The Original - The lightning rod cheese stick was great and the dipping sauce was phenomenal. - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Very easy to order online. There is a tracker to let you know the progress of your order. Very easy and convenient. The shop smells of baking pizza.. Yum. The shop is full of nostalgia from the 70's, 80's. Lots to entertain the mind while you're wait for your pie or the Famous Mozzarella Lightning Rods. A Lightning Rod is a huge, well seasoned, breaded mozzarella log. It can feed 3-4 people as appetizer w marinara sauce. Pizza has a thin crisp crust which is my preference. I was greeted and welcomed in immediately by a friendly dude that was about to drop my lightning rod into the fryer. Everything was hot and fresh when I got home. Delicious. They have family specials also. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Rod - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

While Alphonso's is probably best known for their lightning rods they also make one AMAZING pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy with a perfect ratio of sauce to toppings. Our order was ready quickly and the staff were super friendly. The location is also super convenient with a little parking lot to stop in to quick pick up your order. 10/10 would visit again. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Sausage pizza with their delicious cracker crust in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

After seeing a TikTok months ago, I knew on a recent road trip that I had to hunt down the famous Lightening Rod!! This is a carry out or delivery joint only. There are no places to sit and there's around 4 parking spaces. I would highly suggest ordering ahead and picking it up. The decor is all 80's themed and was super fun!! There was a woman who took our order who was not overly friendly and just pointed to the paper menu. For me, this is where this place lost a star... The Lightening Rod was absolutely everything I wanted! It does have a thicker crust but you get ranch and pizza sauce to dip in! That was super tasty!! We did a pepperoni pizza with their signature crust. I liked it! It also had a nice leopard crust! The pepperoni was a bit thick for me and I didn't really like the flavor. The cheese however, made for an EPIC cheese pull!! This place is cheese crazy and I am here for it!!! This is definitely worth a stop for the Lightening Rod!!! read more

See all

I love mozzarella sticks so of course we had to stop on our way to our final destination. They are huge! The photo does not do them justice! The woman who placed my order over the phone and when we arrive was amazing! She was so sweet and accommodating! I asked for plates for our kids and she gave us pizza trays and asked if we wanted juice boxes for our littles! They go above and beyond for their customers and that's commendable! People who truly appreciate their customers. Two thumbs up all around! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Atmosphere is super cool-- 80's theme! So many things from then that I hadn't seen or thought about for years! Parking is challenging to say the least. There are 4 spots on the side of the building which are super tight... This is NOT a sit down restaurant, carry out only, but there are 80's music videos playing while you wait! They didn't call our name when our order was ready so our son in law who ordered right before us got his a good 15 minutes before my husband finally asked about ours; that sucked. Now for the food.... YUM! The mozzarella stick "appetizer" should be eaten by at least three people if you also want to have pizza! The marinara sauce was interestingly sweet. The Hami pizza was SO good. Lots of cheese and plenty of toppings. Was worth the drive from Green Bay, just next time we'll know to find a place to eat it rather than the McDonald's parking lot read more

Alphonso's The Original - Hami, 12" - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Ordered carry out-it was ready on time and front counter was super friendly! We ordered the dillorean on the scorpion crust and the Vega on cracker crust and a lightening rod. The Vega was a 10/10, the dillorean was also great but the scorpion crust wasn't what we expected--the crust was the same as the cracker crust there was just a ton of red pepper flakes on the pizza itself, so the crust itself wasn't spicy. Still tasty and spicy but not what we expected. Lightening rod is always great and they gave us plenty of pizza sauce for dipping. Great flavor overall and good service. read more

I ordered an Alzone $27.00 for a dry calzone with no flavor. Then the service they use Squareup so you can get your food delivered is a awful site to use. They end up referring the orders to Uber Eats, Doordash etc. Why not just sign up with those services instead. Anyways, the Uber driver delivered my order to the wrong house, after finding my cold food, I called Squareup for a refund. Spoke to a Liam who said he would process it. A few days later I called back and spoke to Belle who also stated it would be refunded and would send an email. Never happened. So now I have to dispute this with my bank which will take even more time. The total was $42.59. Yes, that's right a huge amount with service charges, delivery fee and tip. If I don't get my money by Monday I will be marching down to Alphonso's with a camera and demanding my money. read more

Taking on the World's Biggest Cheese Stick: My Epic Taste Test | I discovered the world's most delicious cheese stick, and you won't believe the incredible taste until you try it yourself! I tried the World's Largest #Mozzarella Sticks, made right in West Allis, Wisconsin. Alphonso's The Original in West Allis, Wisconsin. From its mouth-watering aroma to its decadent and savory taste, the #world's largest #cheese stick is a feast for the senses that is not to be missed. So if you're looking for a fun and unique way to indulge in your love of cheese, be sure to check out this culinary wonder and experience the delicious taste of the world's largest #mozzarella cheese stick. I heard these things were big, but getting my hands on one made a true believer out of me, Big doesn't Taking on the World's Biggest Cheese Stick: My Epic Taste Test | I discovered the world's most delicious cheese stick, and you won't believe the incredible taste until you try it yourself! Get ready for the ultimate taste test challenge as we take on the World's Biggest Cheese Stick! Join us as we sample this epic snack to see if it lives up to its title. Watch till the end to find out if this giant cheese stick is worth the hype. Who will come out on top in this cheesy showdown? Tune in to find out! Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more epic food challenges. Hit the notification bell so you never miss an update! Address: alphonsostheoriginal.com Alphonso's The Original 9130 W Greenfield Ave West Allis, WI 53214 414 755-0341 read more

Alphonso's The Original - I tried the World's Largest #Mozzarella Sticks, made right in West Allis, Wisconsin. Alphonso's The Original in West Allis, Wisconsin. From - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

The giant mozzarella log is what drew me in. It was fresh, that stake mozzarella stretch, and stayed hot for a bit after the drive. I ordered the 14" Shmo with added diced tomatoes on their original crust, and it smelled so good I didn't have time to take a picture before I dove in. The crunchy crust complimented the pizza marvelously, and the sausage was fresh and tasty read more

Who's making this garlic bread so perfect? I have never had garlic bread or heck bread in general so fluffy & flaky! 10/10 will be going back! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Garlic bread & Medium Family Pizza Special - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Ever since seeing it on social media, I have been wanting to try Alphonso's "Home of the World Famous" Lighting Rod Mozzarella Sticks. You're able to call ahead to order them for pick up, which I recommend because it's a small venue with a small parking lot. We had four adults sharing and they recommended we get two. I know that sounds ridiculous but they are HUGE and two was almost too much. I honestly don't know how they do it. They are handmade using Wisconsin mozzarella, and it was warm, gooey, and had beautiful cheese pulls from the first the last bite. Also, the herb seasoned breading was SOO crispy and wonderfully paired with their homemade pizza sauce for dipping. I don't understand how they're able to make these (nor do I want to ruin the magic), but I would definitely get these again! read more

The lightning rods, pizza and Calzones are all to die for! Their Marinara sauce is super tasty with it being slightly sweet. Every time I go the staff is always friendly, help and kind. I love the retro, 80's vibe inside with action figures, arcade games and stickers galore. Alphonso's is a MUST!! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Rods - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

No photos, just a quick review. Ordered delivery via third party. This review is for the pizza quality and freshness itself. We ordered two cracker crust house pies - one CSMO and the other pepperoni, pineapple, giardiniera & cream cheese. Cracker crust is really nice flaky and has good flavor, holds the toppings well. Not a bland crust by any means !! ... and if you want you can flavor your crust, they have a variety of options. Toppings are plentiful and fresh, really really nice. The toppings to crust ratio is toppings heavy. The cheese is good, the sauce is good. For me the toppings and the crust stood out the most. All around a solid choice in pizza, old school menu with an elevated twist of toppings and/or portions and next time I plan on trying that arm of a cheese log. I'm sure that's their most popular item, but I'm happy to say that Alphonsos's goes far beyond the enormous appetizer and can attest to a really fantastic menu. I'll be back and look forward to it! read more

Amazing Dillorean pizza! Best we've ever had, should've ordered two! I ordered the super special, it was good. My fiancé ordered the pickle pie, needless to say. I regret my decision. No shade on the special, but hot DAMN! That was mouth watering delicious. read more

We stopped to try the lightening rods and we were shocked at the size! The breading was pretty thick but I imagine it has to be so the cheese doesn't explode out. The taste was good and the sauce was good! Also the staff was nice, the food came out quick and it was fun to look around at all their stuff! read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightening rod - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

The crew here are amazing. I connected immediately with the Mike Tyson's punch out playing while I ordered my food. Connected with a veteran that was amazing and overall the experience is fantastic. The ambiance is immediately retro which growing up watching all of it and experiencing it with my parents and brother it couldn't be better. Fantastic crew and food is absolutely amazing. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

So good! We loved the pizza and thought the sauce had good flavor, plenty of dill and pickles to make it a true pickle pizza! The mozzarella sticks were so big that we didn't even finish one. We ordered pickup and it was hot and ready promptly. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Dillorean - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I saw a few viral TikToks about this spot and had to check it out for myself! Yes, the "Lightning Rods" (giant cheese sticks / mozzarella sticks) are really as big as they look! You can't just order one and a "half order" is 2 sticks for $14 which seems very cheap. It also comes with 2 containers of marinara sauce (each is bigger than the photo makes it look - but you can order extra sauce if you want). I had a few people point out that they thought the breading was a little thick - but I didn't really notice it. There's A LOT of cheese packed in these things. The weight... I know these are big sticks, but I really thought I got a box full of sticks. I could only finish about 3/4 of one and saved the rest for the next day. Never as good reheated as when they first come out - so go with a friend and split the order with them. When I went (10 minutes after they opened), their deep fryer was down and I ended up waiting an hour and 6 minutes for my order to be ready. If it wasn't for the wait time, I'd give Alphonso's The Original all 5 stars. It's certainly worth having the experience but the wait time makes it something that I won't be stopping by for regularly. read more

Alphonso's The Original - These Lightning Rods (mozzarella sticks) are larger than your hand! - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Mozzarella sticks the size of your arm. That's really all you need. Been meaning to go to Alphonso's for a while to get my hands on one of these! They were so good, I could eat it as a meal! The pizza was decent but this is the main event. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Rod Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I promise you the lightning rod mozzarella sticks are not just for show. They are legitimately delicious. Filled with cheese from Cedar Valley. Alphonso's somehow figured out how to create a solid breading for the stick. Pizza is also delicious. Good homemade crust and lots of topping options. Wish there was seating inside but we made it work. read more

See all

If you want a fun novelty food destination... this your place. I got the famous mozzarella sticks. First... no menu inside. Someone took their one and only paper menu. I ordered the mozzarella sticks. There's no seating inside. I asked for silverware so I can try it in the car (drive home was 2 hours). They had to search for plastic silverware. They're a carry out restaurant.. how is that not handy to have for customers. Taste..... eh. The center was not melted. That kind of ruined it to eat it immediately. Take it home, heated it up.... The breading is very thick and tastes weird. The crust should be crispy, oily and tasty. I just ate the cheese. Could have saved 4 hours of driving by heating up a block of mozzarella at home. Ate 1/4 of one, threw out the rest. Nice novelty idea... but not worth it. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Half order - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

It was ok. Pizza was average. Probably won't go back since there is other pizza places we like allot more. Mozzarella sticks were unique and good. We ordered a pepperoni and a sausage and onion pizza and they just seemed to lack any flavor. read more

Awesome place with amazing cheese sticks! Very cool nostalgic atmosphere with Mike Tyson's Punchout!

Best pizza around. the flavored crust's perfection, absolutely, and the toppings, sauce and cheese with it. People call me a pizza snob. Well this is where the standard is. read more

Great pizza. Lighting rods are insane. You'll never be able to eat a regular mozz stick again. Check out all the retro swag while waiting for your pizza. Friendly staff too. read more

We came for the lightning rods! These mozz sticks are like 2 pounds each and HUGE. It's insane! It's been like 4 days and we still have a whole stick left! The sticks were good but you can only really eat a little at a time before feeling sickly. The sauce was just ok - too sweet for my taste. We also got fries and garlic bread - both were pretty good! read more

Food was amazing, and the lightning rods were huge! Enjoyed this place and I will definitely be visiting again read more

Alphonso's The Original - Lightning Rod - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I ordered Alphonso's for a work party. They did a great job handling our large order. Everything was delicious and the party was a huge success. Everyone was asking where the pizza was from- I was a hero! I was amazed that the crust was crispy and food was hot for such a large order. The mozzarella sticks stayed hot and gooey for a long time too. Would order again. read more

Alphonso's The Original - Mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I know we are in the minority here , but let me say size is not an indicator of quality. Everyone is raving about the huge mozzarella sticks. They are enough for 5 people. So you wind up reheating it so the cheese turns to leather. So if you're a household of 2 don't bother. Now lets talk pizza. The toppings and sauce were great. The crust was WAY too hard, I love a crispy crust but this was ridiculous. I couldn't bite through the edge , the pizza cutter had a hard time getting through it.So we had to use the big chef's knife. Then there is the seasoning they sprinkle on top, sprinkle is an understatement. WAY too much... I love oregano but we had to shake it off. The seasoning should be in the sauce. I am glad to see a business do well in that little corner space but Alphonso's is not for us. read more

The LIGHTING ROD CHEESE STICKS! There is so much to say about Alphonso's that I'm not sure where to begin. We've waited so long and we're finally able too! The ambiance was retro that it was hard not to want to hang out. Service was excellent and our food was done on time. Pizza and the rods had the right amount of cheese pull! Definitely ordering again! read more

See all