We got our order togo because of dog reasons. Interior is super cute and the staff was overly friendly. Not in a creepy way but very nice. The food was absolutely exceptional. I don't know if the pasta was made in house but it sure seemed like it. I had the lasagna and a side of meatballs. Both were possibly the best I've ever had. The garlic bread was definitely made in house and was amazing. Highly recommend. I can't wait to return and eat in the establishment. I don't know how but I'm guessing it's even better. read more

I was craving Italian food and found this place after leaving Cedar park in the downtown Sandusky area! It's a family owned restaurant by a couple and son running the business. When you walk in the son asks where would you like to sit and he brings out the water. Then the lady who's the owner came out and was friendly and I got the lobster spaghetti and the soup on the day which is the Italian wedding both was good, delicious, and made fresh! If you want a good authentic Italian food come here that's not a chain! read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Soup of the day Italian wedding - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Food was mediocre. Service was horrible with a loud, hostile owner/chef. Ambiance is poor; in the rear of a Subway with obvious rain damaged walls. Olive garden is better. read more

The food is excellent! Best sauce anywhere. Sadly, the service is just awful. We enjoyed it last Fall, so we suggested it to our friends, and we all went on Valentine's Day. We called in and got a reservation. When the four of us got there, they were packed and had to "make" a table for us, because they simply didn't "record" our reservation. We had to wait for half an hour to get water. We begged the waitress (ONE waitress for a room full of tables, the wife) to take our order. She was run ragged, so she chose to ignore us. We would have gotten up and left, but we knew with Valentine's Day, there would be no place else with open tables. After 2 l/2 hours, we got our food. No apology, no comping of wine, etc. Worst customer service EVER. Went back this weekend on Saturday night to give it another try. Only two other tables of people there. Sat there a good ten minutes, heard the husband and wife arguing in the kitchen. She ignored us. We saw the writing on the wall. Sadly we left. Why on earth don't these people hire a second waitress? How can they not care about customer service when the food is so good? It's so sad! If you don't care about people being disappointed, at least I'd think you'd care about $70 or $80 walking out the door. read more

The owner/chef prepares delicious food consistently. Quaint restaurant with parking. I love supporting small businesses and this one hits it out of the park. Veal Parmesan large enough for yummy leftovers this trip. I will be back. read more

Another carb loading meal. Also one walking distance from bnb and the pier. I would say solid Italian restaurant. The menu straight forward all basic classic dishes. They do daily specials besides menu. I like the family run business. Husband in the back cooking and wife was running the front. We started with Bruschetta for two. I enjoyed. Nice and refreshing. The bruschetta was delicious with nice size diced tomato, fresh, and combine with perfect toasted bread. Perfect balance crispy bread and fresh cut tomatoes. I got Spaghetti in meat sauce. Fan. The sauce nothing blow u away. Great taste! Nice portion size. Hearty. The perfect carb load of pasta. Service was fabulous. She was very attentive and friendly. Both grateful stopped by said thank u for coming in. Solid food and spot I would go back if do IMOhio 70.3 again. read more

See all

We were reluctant when we arrived and saw the outside. We read the reviews and decided to give it a try. The reviews were right. We walked into a classy little Italian restaurant. I am a Bruschetta connoisseur it is how I know it's going to be a good meal. I found my favorite fresh full of Italian flavors Bruschetta. Then I had spaghetti with meat sauce and Italian dressing. Soooo good full of flavor! I do wish we were given a dinner salad just a small bowl. However I did not change my review. My daughter had Chicken Piccata it was fabulous! read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Bruschetta for two. - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

This place was the best! It's a quaint small Italian restaurant, perfect for a date night. We were actually the only customers for a while before another couple came in, and we got to talk and get to know the sweet server. (It's family run). The food was so delicious, hit the spot for my Italian craving, and the cannoli dessert was impeccable. Highly highly recommend!! read more

Most authentic Italian food you will ever eat. The veal parmesan is real veal. The service is quick, the place is very clean. I cannot say enough good things to say about this place, but my wife and I have many fond memories. No preservatives in food, the owner told me how to make my own ricotta cheese from scratch. Salad fresh and a good wine list, served with tasty bread. read more

This is an authentic family-owned Italian restaurant with excellent food served in a casual setting. Several years ago I conducted a taste test with 4 local Italian restaurants. At each restaurant, I ordered clam linguine with white sauce. Amarone was the clear winner in my experience. I don't think you will be disappointed in your experience at Amarone. read more

So after a long weekend of working many hours sometimes you just wanna go out to dinner and get what's good in every single way! This restaurant is just what I expected it to be a small diy family place that's putting out good food with great service which is something that Will make me come back here again! Of the many options I went with the most basic spaghetti with meat sauce because it's just what I wanted but let me say it was very flavorful and good all around for that spaghetti goodness you can't go wrong with! Besides the yummy spaghetti I also ordered a dinner salad with Italian dressing on it the greens were very fresh and just went very well before my spaghetti! They have a public parking lot right in front of the restaurant so that made it easy to get in and out which is always a plus! Overall this was a yummy experience and everyone in my group felt the same way it's for that reason I know that we will be back here again soon for some Italian goodness! read more

See all

I went to Sandusky area for a weekend trip and discover this Italian restaurant around the downtown area. I went on a Friday night and luckily they are not that busy. The vibe is very intimate and classy. This place will be great for a family dinner or a little date night. The Calamari Fritti just have a light seasoned breading and go well with the creamy dipping sauce. I also got the Spaghetti Monte Mare. The flavor is on the lighter side and can be brighten up with the grated parmesan cheese. I would prefer to have the creamy sauce a bit thicker. read more

See all

A cute small place in downtown Sandusky with great food. We were there on a Saturday evening and the service was a bit slow, with only one server, who really hustled! But the food made up for the wait. Chicken piccata was delicious and the side of broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots was fresh and cooked perfectly. My friend had spaghetti which he said was very tasty. The tables look rather classy with nice goblets and napkins folded in a fancy way. The lighting was too bright which detracted from the ambiance a bit. We would definitely go back. read more

The food was great. All right of us enjoyed our meals. I had the chicken parmigiana. The chicken, pasta and sauce were all delicious. The service wasn't super speedy, but we understood. It was pretty amazing that two people took care of 5 tables. The restaurant itself was quaint and classy. I highly recommend Amaron Italian Restaurant! read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Chicken Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Not authentic! Chicken Parmiggiana , lasagna, and spaghetti all tasted the same. Maybe slightly better than Chef boyardee. We also thought it may all be frozen from the Gordon Food Service store and reheated. Wedding soup was bland and more like chicken noodle soup. The soup bowl it came in wasn't even half full. See pic below. The hot soup was packaged with and on top of the Tiramisu in the same bag, making it warm and gross. read more

See all

Good home made Italian food with friendly service. Reminded us of our Italian neighbors.

Best authentic Italian food. Everything from Scratch. Chef from Rome. Best marinera sauce I have ever tasted I am really pickey since I'm half Italian. An amazing dinner experience. Grazie Mauri'io. read more

A very nice small authentic family treasure to find right downtown. Very taste flavorful dishes and served HOT!, a must. Will let them serve my family dinner monthly going forward. Waitperson was so pleasant and Nice! A relaxing and fulfilling experience. ( But I agree with a prior review, NOT acceptable IF NO respect/raised voices; did NOT hear discord with our visit. ) read more

Wow, great authentic Italian food. Ordered the beef manicotti and it was amazing. Chicken parm was also really great! Would highly recommend. This is a little gem in downtown Sandusky. read more

the food was absolutely delicious! home made from scratch and so fresh! the Ceasar salad was crispy and refreshing. the bruschetta was delicious. they made chicken francesse with lemon for my super picky son and it was so good I took all the extra sauce for my noodles. the home made gnocchi was pillowy and yummy in the marinara sauce. the husband and wife who run it are so sweet. definitely recommend especially after a day at cedar point with park food!!! read more

They act like you are an inconvenience. while I was waiting for my food I heard what I believe to be the owner tell multiple customers that they are going to wait one hour for food so they should leave. the manicotti had NO cheese in it. sauce is not good. I also listened to them argue with parents over their child not being able to have egg. this place is horrible. avoid. the man yells at the woman a lot, you can hear them from the kitchen. 0/10. I usually don't complain but I would avoid. read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

The food and service we received was absolutely unacceptable. I would avoid this place at all cost. We could hear the owner in the back talking disrespectfully to our waitress the entire time we were there. The food was an absolute disaster. How it has more than one star is baffling. read more

This place is everything you want in an old school Italian restaurant. Just like other reviewers, we loved this place. A hidden gem in Sandusky and a must visit. Being foodies from Scottsdale we have a rather high standard for dinning and this one delivered on all fronts. We started with house red bland wine, dry and perfect for great Italian food. Caprese salad and mussels as apps. Both fantastic, the mussel sauce was delicious, light full of flavor, so good I was eating it like soup. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza which was amazing. Fresh mushrooms and sauce are some of the best we've ever had. We finished with tiramisu which was delicious. My wife does not like tiramisu but ordered it and loved it. Drop by and support a great little family restaurant, you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

4 of us ate there a few nights ago. We were the only ones in the restaurant. The food was delicious if you can get past the owner yelling at his sweet wife constantly and telling his 11 year old son that he is stupid! On top of that, he starting yelling at us across the room expressing his political views after he heard his wife speaking to us. All we asked her was where she was from because she had an accent and she expressed that she missed her family back home. Even though the food was good, we won't go back! We were made to feel very uncomfortable! We couldn't wait to leave! Nobody needs his abuse, especially his wife and son!! read more

Ordered take out as we are on vacation seeing the islands. Saw the good reviews (however just now noticed they are from a year ago). Ordered spaghetti and meatballs and chicken parmigiana. The meatballs tasted like rubber and the chicken was 1000% reheated. Cold and warm spots throughout. Nothing was fresh. Even the bread I could almost guarantee was cooked hours before or easily the day before. When we went to pick up the food, no one was in the restaurant at 630pm on a Wednesday. That should've been the first sign. If you want reheated food, highly recommend. Don't expect anything fresh. read more

Chef Mic gets an A for effort, due to how often we heard the beeps in this 'supposed' authentic Italian restaurant! Not only did the microwave get used more often than not but when we heard the soup of the day was Italian Wedding soup, our ear perfekt up! We love that soup since back home, the guy that makes it is a genii is with flavor and ingredients! This soup was Horrible! No flavor and I'm pretty sure chicken doesn't belong in that soup! There was No Flavor to my Veal Parm and it had CLEARLY been reheated by Chef Mic! The owner was rude and was belligerent towards his wife, Anna. She was doing her best and we didn't have the heart to tell her that her husband is not a chef! read more

Excellent! Great service and amazing food. Had the eggplant parmigiana. Ask for the grilled calamari! Molly, WTF? read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Dinner! - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Stopped in for dinner after a long day at Cedar Point. It was amazing!!!!! I can't even begin to tell you how wonderful the food was. I had Eggplant Parmesan, it was the best I've ever had!!! Service was better than fantastic, food was authentic, and atmosphere was charming. Would absolutely recommend!! read more

Well... I have walked past this place many times. I was a fool. The food is rather authentico... The caprese salad was perfect! Wedding soup was hearty and flavorful. But the real test: Gnocchi in meat sauce... seriously excellent. Subtle flavors and excellent consistencies. The sauce was the perfect viscosity... enough stayed behind for excellent bread dipping. Hot tea was bigelow English breakfast and that held up against the robusto flavors in my meal. I am not at all grumpy about the price point. Be sure to save room for dessert! Pistachio gelato... mmmmm read more

Really enjoyed Amarone. Nice, classic Italian restaurant atmosphere. Good service. I had the linguine Pescatore. They were kind enough to cook my pasta El dente. Sauce was good. The crab legs in the pasta were especially tasty! My friend had an aglio e olio dish with chicken and sun-dried tomatoes. I tasted it and it was also excellent. He was happy with his meal. The bread was good... Soft and warm. I also had the house red which was good. Gelato and espresso were also both good! If you like good home style Italian, you'll be happy here. read more

We almost walked into the Subway next door since they have the same entrance.. and our "cheese garlic bread" looked very much like the two businesses share loaves. :P I got the Papardelle Puttanesca which was good! My boyfriend ordered something that I don't remember and also some meatballs... We thought they'd be served on top of his dish but they actually forgot it. When we reminded them we got a little bowl of 5 small meatballs on the side that were clearly microwaved. However the dinner was saved by the lovely tiramisu. Our server warned us to wait a little before driving since it was so boozy. Although the food can be a little lazy like with the Subway cheese bread and the store-bought meatballs, some of the dishes are pretty good. Worth a visit if you're craving Italian in the area that isn't pizza. read more

Everything about our dinner was dismal. We went here based on the positive yelp reviews, and we were unfortunately disappointed. To start, the bread was cold and hard. The Caprese salad tomatoes were not ripe, and no basil on the salad at all. All chicken dishes we sampled were horrible. The meat tasted like a bag of Tyson from the grocery that had been frozen and thawed repeatedly. It tasted chewy and old, like a case of salmonella impending. Spend your hard earned money elsewhere. read more

Wow! Absolutely a hidden Jewel in this town. I read Molly's review and wondered what planet she was from. Then a friend looked at her other reviews and they were at autozone and Dairy Queen. Lol. Come on Molly. Every dinner the six of us had was delicious. read more

Amaron Italian Restaurant - Yummy!!! - Italian Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

This restaurant is a gem! I checked them out during the great quarantine of 2020...blown away by the food! Tonight I tried the veal piccata...so yummy! Everyone needs to be trying this place!! read more

Small portions. Average customer service (were not busy when unordered). Average flavor

Second visit here and just as great as the first time. Very charming place. One cook, one server, they enhance the Italian experience. We had the mushroom ravioli and spaghetti alfredo (more flavor with thinner noodles). We asked about the recipes and she explained it all. I still dont think i can pull of such delicious dishes with the recipes and techniques. I even asked for a cappuccino and it was one of the best ibe ever had. Well done evening. read more

Excellent small restaurant. Staff very personable, Danielle was great. Wine, dinner and dessert options wonderful. Was very busy, but we had reservations with no issues. read more

See all

Great food, great atmosphere. Very authentic. Will definitely go back when in Sandusky.

Don't be worried that the parking lot is empty or that the restaurant is. We went here on a Tuesday night at 6:00 PM and had the entire restaurant to ourselves. But the food was still PHENOMENAL. The red sauce and lemon wine sauce are both amazing. And the prices are not high. You can tell everything is handmade and that the vegetables are fresh from a farmers market. Top restaurant in Sandusky. read more

Excellent place. Food and service A+. House made cannelloni was fantastic. Definitely stop in if your in the area.