Erin Loved Loved * 2026-08-07 (Website Order/San Rafael) AMICI'S Never disappoints!! I have to say, TODAYS order (7/7/26) was the ABSOLUTE BEST Ever!! They gratuitously honored every single one of my "special requests," (what can I say, I live in Marin!! Doesn't everyone from Marin have special request?? ha!ha!) At least I had no dietary restrictions (I'm a former Marin server, so "I know & can RELATE!) . Thank you Amicis for hooking a girl up!! Dinner is, and continues to be WONDERFUL!! Tonight's order will easily last 3-4 nights!! I highly recommend Amicis to EVERYONE! Much Love & Appreciation to the Exec Chef, ALL the cooks, Mngmt, and the owners! xx, Erin Mc read more

We have liked Amici's in San Rafael for years. Recently, however, there has been a real problem getting what we ordered deliver ed and in a condition one would want to eat. We have three incidents in a row where the order was delivered other than what we ordered or arrived lukewarm or cold. To try and get the order delivered correct, tried Slice, which is marks the prices up and also imposes a delivery charge. Call Amici's direct. Amici's and Slice appear to have an arrangement where Slice drivers pick up the order from a designated spot in the kitchen after Amici's notifies them of the order. We received delivery estimates from Slice, but in one and one half hours had not received the order. I called and was told it had sat on the counter and Amici's somehow did not call Slice so the order sat and became cold. When we complained, Amici's sent it over by simply reheating the ordered food, and both pizzas we ordered we burnt and nearly tasteless. The order was not the Margherita pizza ordered, but instead was a cheese. The chicken wings were dry and tasteless (if properly cooked they can be very good) Two days ago, we ordered by phone. The Margherita pizza was a cheese pizza without any tomato sauce; the Hawaiian had almost no discernible pineapple or ham. Both pizzas arrived barely lukewarm. (We live no more than 15 minutes from Amici's (generally about 7 inutes) The chicken wings arrived overcooked and bland. Confirm your order very careffully! read more

Great pizza! Nice service! Really authentic. Delicious. Love the New York decor. Wish they had one in Santa Rosa/Sonoma or Napa county. Miss the ones in sf. read more

I am back in San Rafael visiting the fam. Of course that included our tradition of ordering a pizza (or two or three) from Amici's. They offer Detroit thick crust and New York thin crust pizza with a gluten free option if the thin crust. The NY crust is my fave... thin, chewy crisp crust. Mmm. This time, we dined at the restaurant. It is in the heart of downtown San Rafael on 4th Street . The shop front is not very large. We got there early and they were able to accommodate the eight of us. The fam ordered garden salads and three pizzas with one being gluten free with vegan cheese (Daiya brand). The gluten free fam bammers liked the crust. It looked just like the non gluten crust and had the same beautiful flame fired blistered crust. Mmm it was delicious as well. Our food was served quickly after ordering. Besides pizza, the menu includes appetizers, salads ( in various sizes), sandwiches, pastas, desserts, kid menu, and alcohol (wines, beers, and hard seltzers). Heads up on the parking situation. There is metered street parking ($1.50 per hour and free on Sundays & after 6pm) and is mostly parallel. If parallel parking is not your jam, the downtown city lot is around the corner on C Street ($1 per hour and free on the weekends). FYI - they accept: cash payments with bills no larger than a $20, credit cards, Apple Pay, and Goggle Pay. read more

See all

Love these guys. Pizza is always solid. We had their pepperoni the other day, yummy

WAY overpriced for the output. $80 for two cold pepperoni pizzas that were truly nothing special. The pizza wasn't even cut all the way through so when you took a piece the cold cheese ripped off the slice. There are plenty of great other options. read more

I couldn't pass up the opportunity to try this pizza spot for the first time on Pi Day! Grateful I follow them on IG and saw they were doing a special for the holiday between 2:00pm and 3:14pm and I was able to snag 2 small cheese pizzas for $3.14 each. The service was absolutely great! Everyone was so friendly and they even offered to ring the deal in 5 min early so I could run a grab a coffee next door. Within 15 minutes, both pizzas were ready! The pizza oven added to the ambiance of the restaurant and really felt like a "family" staff environment. Pizza was great!! I love trying pizza spots with a plain cheese and I will say, I was impressed. Not only was it light, perfect crust, but also tasted great! We cannot wait to return and try some of their speciality pizzas! Thanks for celebrating Pi Day and offering a great deal! read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

Gluten free pizza is tough to pull off. Oftentimes gluten free pizza crust tastes slimy. That makes me sad. Great pizza, to me, tastes undetectably gluten free. It should taste "regular" This is that. Everyone knows what to expect from Amici's: a thin crispy crust with a tender middle and a modest smattering of high quality ingredients. If you've visited Italy this feels familiar. Tasting this pizza, you know it's different from every other pizza in your neighborhood. That's a good thing. Grab some gluten free beer to go with your gluten free pizza from Amici's and turn the game on. It's what we did while enjoying these delicious pizzas. read more

See all

Best pizza in the bay. I used to come to their Embarcadero location with my family. Had a snafu with uber eats, and they took care of it right away. The people are friendly and wonderful. Their San Rafael location is clean and beautiful. Yay! read more

Kind of hit or miss. The pizza can be quite good here if it's not burnt. We often order a regular cheese pizza but its clear the consistency Isnt quite there. About 50% of the time is burnt at the bottom. And i dont mean nicely cooked, i mean literally burnt. read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

Oh my goodness way too high priced. $100 for 2 pizzas. I ordered for my crew. They said they where ok

Forgot 3 out of 5 items in a delivery order, despite them being charged and on receipt. Careless going on over there. Pizza was good. Don't bother trying to order anything else. read more

DO NOT GO HERE You can get a better pizza for 1/3 of the price from dominos. I paid $40 for a large cheese pizza that was extremely greasy, and not even cut properly. Spend you're money on a better pizza place in San Rafael like Oliver's if you want expensive pizza read more

I'm a pizza snob and I know this place has no hipster vibe. But Amici's is a really good pizzeria. The crust is always crisp, thin and cooked just shy of burnt, which is how I like it. The Caesar salad rocks, the cold broccoli is really good and the meatballs too. Plus there are daily specials (like half price salads). Service is great and the atmosphere is fine. So if you're near an Amici's try them out. read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

This place is so unreliable. They mess up the order over 50% of the time and worse, they never make it right with even a simple apology. It's infuriating. Extremely poorly run business and horrible service. The quality of the pizza has also gone downhill. I don't know if there is new ownership but it should be avoided. read more

Take out but make you ask for it not to be overdone. Sadly the same day 2nd order was burnt on one side of the pie read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Order a large pizza today using the code tax day to get $10.40 off your pizza! Rodrigo will make your day - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

The Detroit style pizza is marvelous. Someone brought some to a party a few weeks ago and I had to come in for dinner tonight. I couldn't stop thinking about this crispy cheesy crust. Yum. Had the house salad too and the blue cheese dressing is great! A wonderful meal. read more

We ordered two Caesars with Chicken. It was not chicken but maybe a processed chicken from god knows what parts of the chicken. Even my husband who can eat anything refused to eat it. Was like rubber and every piece looked exactly the same as if it was cut off a flattened roll of processed parts. Unbelievably bad. It hasn't always been like this. Maybe the pizzas are ok but do not order the chicken Ceasar. read more

Amici's is a Bayer brand of pizzas actually really good pricey but really good. I have a gluten analogies so that even their gluten-free pizza it's really good I usually get it with their pesto sauce, red sauce and pepperoni and roasted garlic. If you like garlic, cut the roasted garlic and also don't miss theirCaesar, salad dressing to die for read more

I got the Detroit style pizza. Deep dish pizza with cheese crisp crust. Best pizza ever!

Excellent pizza, excellent service. If you enjoy true NY pizza this place is the spot. Their pepperoni pie is the most authentic NY style pizza I've had outside of NYC. Heshmi was an excellent server. His attention to detail was second to none. Highly recommend this place if you want truly good authentic pizza. read more

The pizza was pretty average, nothing memorable, especially for the price. With these prices, I expected much better quality.

We ordered a large clam pizza with thin crust slightly underdone through Door Dash. So, I have no idea what service or ambiance is like if you eat in. If I could give 3.5 stars I would. I am an east coast girl and finding a true thin crust pizza is so challenging out here. It was delivered quickly and the pizza was good though the clams, while clearly fresh, were not cleaned super well so we had little crunchy moments lol - the crust was decent enough (sorry! I am SUPER picky!) that we will try again though probably not the clams. ****Update - Based on Amici's excellent customer service I can honestly now give them a solid 4 stars. They reached out to me immediately and offered me a gift card for the cost of our clam pizza. We will definitely be trying them again - and as they suggested, we might even dine in so we can get the full benefit of the pizza right out of the oven. I will update again once we have a chance to try them again. ***** read more

Definitely a smaller location but in a very nice area. We happened to be in the area and decided to have dinner here. It was quite busy on a Friday night but we were able to get a table right away. Servers were very nice and food was great. We ordered the breadsticks, a margherita pizza to share and each got a pesto pasta with chicken. Everything was cooked well and tasted great. Honestly had no complaints at all. Would definitely come back to this location. read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Penne Pesto pasta with chicken breast - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

See all

Nice spot for a New York style pizza I got 3 slices in b4 I started this review Cute place , courteous staff, nice atmosphere read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - AMICI'S COMBO - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

I get it, people have had issues. But every time, especially tonight, I've had a great experience. Giovanna, my server was super sweet. My kale and sausage pizza was delivered fresh and hot within 10 minutes. Nicely done thin crust, delicious with the roasted garlic and hot sausage, (which wasn't spicy hot). A bit pricey but at least I got a 20% discount because it's Happy Hour All Day Monday! I went up a size to a small so I would have leftovers. Including an inexpensive glass of wine and tip, it's close to $40. Overall, a great experience though still a splurge for a small meal. 4 stars because of atmosphere and cost. 5 stars for service and food. Wish we could do half stars! read more

RIP OFF! Ordered two medium pizzas to the tiune of almost $80 including tip. Pizza took 1 1/2 to arrive was told 60 minutes and was cold. Didn't even bring the Parmesan and Chili Flakes I asked for. Called after waiting and hour and fifteen and was put on hold for 15 minutes. Such a bummer. Lesson learned. read more

The pizza is not very good, it's over priced and the place smells strange. Plenty of better pizza to be had at other restaurants in the area. Service was good either way but I would not make a habit out of this spot. read more

This place is my kinda pizza spot. A bit pricey but the food is good. They have good customer service. The servers were very kind. read more

Amici's East Coast Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

See all

My wife and I used to eat at Amici's all the time when our daughters were young. With time, we ate there less frequently. We decided we wanted a thin crust pizza with clams and bacon bits. We ordered the antipasto salad to start and enjoyed their white clam and bacon pizza. It was so delicious. The restaurant was very busy and our server was so apologetic for the slow service that he gave us a discount. We didn't really need the discount any it was a very nice gesture. The meal brought back very fond memories and we will definitely go back more often. read more

This is the best pizza around. The pasta is good too especially the lasagna it's hot and cheesey. The service is good and the place is small but cozy. read more

Delicious pizza! The Manhattan Red Clams was so goooood!!! My girls loved the New York Style crust. I personally loved my Philly! First time I tried it in New York style crust. Staff was attentive and friendly. Glad We found this pizza place near our hotel! read more

See all

First off, the service was good. I called in my order ahead of time and their marketing worked because I've signed up for the Thanx app, so I ended up taking the suggestion of trying their Flame Roasted Chicken Wings, although those wouldn't have been something I would have instinctively tried. I think they were actually our favorite menu item in our order! I wasn't quite sure what to expect, but the meat was tender and the lemon leant a zesty, sharp taste to the nicely roasted wings. The other menu items fell a little short for me. Nothing was terrible, mind you and I got a deal, so my intention isn't to be ungrateful either. Altogether, with the promotion, we got a great deal on a decent meal. The trick is, it's so tempting to want better than decent, right? While the citrus flavor for the wings added to their tastiness, the lemon in the broccoli primarily drowned out the vegetables and, for some of you, perhaps that's a win. Biting into greens and getting a mouthful of spicy zestiness might be ideal if you fear vegetables, but for those of us who look forward to at least some of the delicate sweetness of broccoli, it was lost. To their credit, nothing was overcooked, quite a feat when it comes to take-out, but not quite enough to salvage the dish for me. The Mac N Cheese checked the basics without offering the comfort of true comfort food. The cream sauce was heavy and the cheese didn't have the depth of flavor I hoped for. Again - adequate and not bad, but not quite good either. For the New York Pizza, I liked that it was thin crust. The tomato sauce tasted a lot more like Campbell's Tomato Soup than a fresh marinara. It had a mellow almost sweet flavor that threw me off a bit. Usually, the brilliance of your basic cheese pizza is in the balance between the salty, rich cheese and the tangy red sauce, contrasted with the crisp crust, but everything fell in the mid-range here. I enjoyed the Milano Pizza. The flavors seemed well balanced and it worked well as a thin crust option. Thanks to the staff. The manager especially did a great job of greeting us, making sure our order was complete and delivered in a timely fashion. Overall, my issue is probably with a lack of inspiration when it comes to the recipes, but they own a string of restaurants and I'm a Yelp reviewer, so the owners probably know better than I do! read more

See all

Pretty decent New York style pizza. They also offer a Detroit crust which is very nice.

I had a decent pep pizza from hear months ago but tonight I got a pep pizza that was so trash I ate a slice and threw the rest out. Really disappointing it honestly didn't even taste like pizza it was like hot buttery white bread with flavorless cheese and a very lacking sauce proportion. Very disappointing. read more

we have been eating at amicis for many years, and we are always pleased. it's as close to NY pizza as you will get here. but my favorite is the eggplant parmesan sandwich (we called hero). it's the only place you can get it, and the bread is like a pizza bread and delicious. read more

One of the best pepperoni pizzas in Marin. I recently tried the meat sauce pasta too and it was delish. Always fast pick up and friendly workers. We have never had a problem with our order, always done take out. Last time they delivered our pizza to the bar in San Rafael lol! Not cheap at all, a little over priced but hey it's Marin - they have to pay rent too what do you expect. Maybe loyalty cards or coupons occasionally would be nice but we will keep ordering either way read more

We ordered the four cheese lasagna and the Caesar salad with anchovies and the bread. The food was delicious. I will definitely come back. We got a pizza, but we would've liked it. better, had we not added the chicken, but it was good as well. read more

Long time customer. I think their pizza is best in Marin. Normally, they deliver what they quote and if they don't, the manager makes up for it with a future discount. Not anymore. Was quoted a 45 minute-1 hour wait for delivery. My pizza took over 1.5 hours, came cold, and the manager did nothing about it. It's way too expensive for this level of service. read more

Everything here was great. The service was excellent. Loved the pizza and antipasto salad were delicious. Good time all around!