Stefano's is clearly a local favorite, given you often see their boxes at school events, camp lunches, and neighborhood gatherings all the time. So I wanted to like it more than I actually do. Here's my main issue: the sauce situation. There's barely any on the pizza by default, and if you want what I'd consider a normal amount of sauce, they charge extra for it. That feels a bit like charging extra for a burger to actually have seasoning. The cheese is fine, the crust is fine, the toppings are fine. Everything is solidly in "okay" territory. Nothing offensive, but nothing that makes me think "I need to order from here" either. Skip the wings. They taste like they've been reheated from frozen, often arrive soggy, and have this thick breading that slides right off. Worse, they're frequently overcooked to the point where the bones actually splinter inside the meat, which is both unappetizing and kind of concerning. Just not worth ordering. The staff is genuinely friendly, which counts for something. There's a private parking lot, so no circling the block looking for a spot. And the coupons they mail out regularly do bring the price down to a reasonable level compared to other chain pizza places in the area. I wouldn't go out of my way to order from Stefano's, but I seem to be in the minority here. Plenty of people clearly love it. There's a reason it's become the default pizza for so many local schools and camps. Kids especially seem to be fans, and if you're feeding a crowd on a budget with their coupons, it gets the job done. It's a perfectly serviceable neighborhood pizza place that works well for many people, just not my first choice. If you're curious, maybe start with just a pizza (extra sauce, trust me) and form your own opinion. read more

Disappointing Experience at Terra Linda Branch I ordered a Hawaiian pizza with the XL $30 off promotion, but it turned out to be an absolute disappointment. There were barely any toppings or meat on it at all. If you're going to discount your food but slash the quality this drastically, you should just warn customers beforehand that the promotion only gets them crust and 20% of the actual toppings. I thought the discount was a genuine deal, but it was just a terrible experience. Very disappointing read more

Ordered a combo pizza, felt like the ingredients were a bit light, not teriffic Chicken tenders were lightly breaded, real tenders, not sure if they're made in house but I hope so! An order of tenders also comes with a couple dipping sauces you can choose from bbq/ranch/bleu cheese read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - Chicken tenders - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

See all

Called in an order for delivery. It seemed the guy who answered was friendly. I ordered an XL Mill Valley pizza and requested mushrooms only on half and a Caesar salad. Because I was staying in a hotel, I requested plates, napkins, pepper flakes, parm cheese. I also requested ranch dressing. The guy said no problem and my order comes with 3 ranch cups. Hmmm... Deliver arrived on time as stated 30min. He did not bring any of the requested items, not even utensils for the salad. Delivery guy stated it was not on the receipt. ‍ I called the store and spoke the guy who took my order. He said he would let the delivery guy know and redeliver the items. He called back and said the delivery guy would return in 20-25 min due to delivering other orders. That was ridiculous and horrible service. There was nothing done to resolve the situation. The pizza ended up being cold while waiting to see if I would get my items. It was good tasting but looked mediocre is presentation. The salad was not worth the price at all. This was a Very disappointing experience!!! read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

See all

We keep giving Stefano's a chance and we are continually disappointed. We placed an online order for four pizzas on Christmas Eve for a gathering at our home. A delivery time for was committed to and payment plus tip was collected from our credit card. The pizzas never came and nobody answered our several phone calls. It looks like we will be spending our holiday break trying to collect a refund from Stefanos. Our guests are eating frozen food. This is one of many headaches we have had with Stefanos including pizzas dropped on our porch with no knock and unfriendly phone interactions. This place is so close to our house and we really want it to work. We will be picking up at Lo CoCos moving forward. read more

Ordered 3 xl pizzas regular crust. Got thin crust instead so I called to let them know I got the wrong order. The guy's explanation was that they use the same amount of dough for all their crusts even though I paid extra for an XL REGULAR CRUST pizza. Go figure. Then he has the audacity to say they offer thick crust too...for what reason lol. Why would I want a thin crust or thick crust when I ordered the regular crust. What a joke. Not ordering from this place again! read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - My regular crust pizza that was NOT - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

I want to give a shoutout to Tellio. He took a large pizza order for my son's bday party at Launchpad and he made sure everything was correct and delivered on-time. He was super friendly and professional. This man deserves a raise! Thanks again Tellio! read more

I ordered 5 XL pizzas for delivery last weekend for a group of 20 people who were all in town for a memorial so we were at a hotel. The pizzas arrived quicker than the expected time. They were hot and the looked just like the photos. The ingredients seemed to be fresh and of high quality. The only thing was that I had asked for 20 plates and I think we got around 7. They were gobbled up quick so I was unable to get any photos of them. Overall we were highly impressed at the speed and taste of all the different pizzas we got. Thanks for a tasty meal. read more

I thought I was ordering an XL pizza online to use the current emailed coupon. Entered the code at checkout, only to be told on arrival I didn't qualify due to ordering a large. Turns out the default is large, which it defaulted to. Instead of remedying this by paying the difference and honoring the coupon, the store handed me a refund. No pizza. No working it out together. No options other than a paper receipt. Myself and my business have been customers for years. No thanks. Poor customer service. read more

it was very easy to order online. They offer takeout or delivery. We did a pick up and had a great pizza. What I like best about their pizza was the crust and the quality of the meat and cheese. We were visiting and did not know all the different places to go so we ordered Stefanos. When I talked to our family & friends who have been living in the area for 20 years, they call Stefanos for their go to pizza delivery. read more

Had to grab a pizza for home dinner, and this was the place! Got a large, half with artichokes, black olives and garlic and half with pepperoni and sausage. The order was called in and ready in 20 minutes. Quick, easy, delicious! What more can I say?! read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - Large -1/2 artichoke, black olive and garlic, 1/2 pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

I was visiting a friend and decided to order pizza and chose Stephano's the pizza was good. Sauce had the perfect amount of garlic the chicken on the pizza was really good over a really good pizza. The only complaint that I have is the crust could have been crunchier! But I warmed it up the leftovers in a pan the next day and it was great got the crunch I wish it would have had day 1. But I would still order from them again because the crust still had a good taste and the over all pizza was delicious! I definitely recommend them because it all tasted very fresh homemade crust and sauce and fresh ingredients! read more

We love this local pizzeria. It's a bit pricey compared to your popular chains but the ingredients are really good quality and delicious over all. A great treat once in a while. read more

Stefano's is the best pizza place in Terra Linda. Pizza is always great and staff is super friendly.

Negative 1. The pizza was left outside the front door...cold! The crust was thick crust...we ordered regular. I spoke with the manager Carlos...He was obnoxious. Worst Pizza on the planet. Carlos kept me on the phone for 1/2 hr then hung up on me! BAD read more

They have great deals and constantly send texts for coupons/deals that we love to use. Pizza is a bit on the salty side, but it's still great. read more

Stefanos Pizza is the best pizza ever in Terra Linda!!!! come stop by and grab the sausage or the pepperoni pizza, it is to DIE for. I can eat 100 slices and not be tired of it. read more

This Stefano's location must be the worst one. Prior to the pandemic the place was decent but since I've noticed the toppings are scarce. I ordered extra pepperoni once knowing that a regular order had very little. picked up the pizza and I swear there was no additional pepperoni! I live in Terra Linda and work in Mill Valley. If you choose to order Stefano's in the future, I'd advise you to order at the Mill Valley location. Much better, you'd think it was a different business, which I guess it ultimately is. Will never go back to the TL location again. read more

I ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza (prepaid online) for some workers at my home because another pizza place suddenly cancelled my order. I should have ordered from Stefano's in the first place. My order was super fast and delicious. On top of that, when I arrived, I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and forgot to pay for it. When I called to give them my cc#, I was told "no, I know you'll be back." Now THAT's how you get customers to come back! Thanks, Stefano's (Terra Linda). read more

I've been meaning to do this for a while now. I like to nominate the Stefan's Northgate, To be faire I seldom go to the others. Yes like to nominate them as the most inconsistent pizza, and the most impolite employees, they all look like they hate bing there, never say hello, or thank you, don't bother, giving them instructions, not only they won't follow, they make a mistKe too, and act like it is no big deal, so what you can't get it the way you want, get the hell out of our store, I made a promise that I will not support a horrible business no more, so with this review I am closing this chapter will never go back. read more

local favorite for 30 years. Love the crust and sauce. Support local small business - Anytime you want it better or different just ask and you may be pleasantly surprised. read more

This particular location was recently the "martian" pizza place, so I thought I'd check out the new configuration. So, I love lots of things about Stefanos - the whole Solar thing, the fresh ingredients, the dough itself. Not too much cheese (a pet peeve when it's too drippy) so a good ratio of ingredients. For me though, the ovens they use just don't cut it. The finished product seems to need to go thorugh a second time to get the kind of browned, crunchy crust you get say at Amici's or W Brooklyn if you ask for it. The suzy homemaker oven ... meh. Still, I think it's an improvement, hope that they can figure a way to get to the crispy zone instead of the soggy zone. read more

i always get stefNos when i stay here. i look forward to it. ordered 2 this stay. decided to give them a second chance since the first one was bad and we have always loved their food. pizza doesn't go uneaten in my house. these did. never going back. it used to be so good. read more

Pizza never came. They told me it would take 2 extra hours from the delivery time. Total failure. I wouldn't recommend ordering from here under any circumstances. read more

Short form: don't do it. If you do, don't order online. If you do order online, bring proof of a completed order with you -- for your own sake. (I mean, it's pretty much academic if your order isn't ready). To be clear: I didn't leave a one star review because they lost my order. Mistakes happen. Or because I lost my place in line when I had to run back to get my phone (and 2 year old) out of the car, to prove that I'd placed an order in the first place. No need to make others wait too. Not Stefano's responsibility that I had a hungry 2 year old and guests arriving shortly*. If it had just been how baffled they seemed by their own ordering system, or that they never really owned the problem ("You must have placed the order at the wrong store"), or didn't appear to actually be listening to any details, or even that the manager became ruder the more exasperated (but still polite) I became... aggravating, but still not one star-worthy. No, this one star review is because -- after all of the above -- no, I could not receive the courtesy of a text message when my order was finally ready. Instead, I could jostle my toddler outside the door, listen to the staff mock other customers who'd had problems ordering, and wait for my order to be unceremoniously dumped on the table when it was finally ready. This wasn't just a bad night. This is how they treat customers on a regular basis (e.g., see, also, Lauren F's review). No idea how the other locations are... but I highly recommend avoiding this one. * ETA: As one of my guests observed, "They deliver, right? The smart thing to do would have been to send you home to meet us and deliver the pizzas when ready." Yes, that would have totally solved the problem! TBF, it did not occur to me, either... but, again, it's not what earned them a one star review. read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - Simply Untrue - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

We have been enjoying Stefano's pizza in Corte Madera since 2005. And in Novato on occasion as well. Always delicious, our go-to choice for pizza. But EVERY time over the years that we have gotten a pizza from the Las Gallinas location (for convenience) it is CONSISTENTLY terrible. We tried again yesterday and we couldn't eat it. We threw it away. The dough was half raw. The half and half toppings were tossed on all over place and these was 3 times more cheese than even we cheese lovers could enjoy. Stefano's management might consider looking into improvements to the quality of this location. We won't attempt to try it again. We'll stick with Corte Madera and Novato which are delicious. read more

Not really sure what they use in their pizzas, however our family shared one today and felt like we were going to fall asleep, felt low/depressed and had heavy gross stomachs afterwards. It reminded us of the effects of fast food in the documentary Super Size me. Tasted good in the moment, and within a half hour of eating the pizza ruined our happy day vibe and killed our energy for the rest of the day. Ugh. What's in the ingredients?!? read more

Very upsetting experience. Husband (who has been at a wildfire for 2 weeks and was trying to be nice) ordered a pizza for our family at 4pm for a 5:15 delivery. It's currently 6:15, and they "can't locate the pizza" and the pizza man "can't remember where he put it." Which is obviously not at my house... she then said she needed my card info again and she could make another pizza for a "discounted price" don't order from here. It won't arrive. read more

I learned that a new Stefano's location had opened up in Terra Linda after reading a recommendation on nextdoor.com. The nextdoor discussion quickly diverged into a debate on pineapple pizza that people took way too seriously because internets, but I was intrigued by the comments from a few New Yorkers that Stefano's is the real deal. Since I moved to California, I've been on a search for the holy grail of real New York style pizza. Now that Napoli Pizza and Pasta is gone, there are no real contenders. Stefano's comes pretty darn close. Their pizza margherita has a nice chewy crust, although it does not have the exact same texture as authentic New York pizza, according to my New York born mom. The sauce is fresh tasting and not overly sweet. This will probably be our new go-to pizza spot. Also, pineapple on pizza is a travesty. read more

This used to be our go to place for pizza. Recently the pizza is dry, little sauce and meager toppings. Seems like these guys are too busy to care. Pizza should have ample sauce and toppings. Stefano's Corte Madera much better. Maybe they are giving less to make up for their 25% coupons. Cashier can use some manners too. read more

Love it! My kids love it.. there's no pizza like Stefano's.. and we always get coupons to use

Incredible service on Mother's Day what a treat for Marin!!! #MommaMia highly recommended for great service and wonderful ingredients!!!

Probably the worst pizza I ever had. The price is good for two slices and a drink but. The pizza was way over cooked. Sauce dried up and about 6 pieces of Sausage on each piece. I give it 2 stars. 1 because it was shaped like a pizza slice and 2 because it had a hint of meat on it. This was in San Rafael . A monkey on a chain could make better pizza read more

I use to order from the Novato store all the time. This time i ordered delivery from the Terra Linda location. I am not sure what happened if it was a delivery issue or a location issue. I got extra cheese and it was basically regular cheese, it was not a piping hot pizza. It was luke warm but didnt take an excessive amount of time to deliver(sub 40). Maybe they dont use the warm insulating things other places do? Also a delivery charge? I expect this from dominoes but from local establishments that charge much more than chain pizza stores is kind of crazy. Might or might not give one more try. read more

Yes, a Stefano's has finally opened a location in northern Marin - across the street from the Terra Linda Northgate Mall. Oh the joy... when I found this little gem on my way into Michaels... a NY sized slice was in order and what's there not to like about this small pizza spot ? Well, I might just be a little bias since it's been the pizza I grew up on... and the pizza I would go to after long days of smoking recreational medicinal mmmm grass lol. The gourmet Pizza, chicken garlic pizza and Portuguese special all have a very special place in my heart + tummy + thighs lol read more

Stefano's Solar Pizza - Come sit down and have a NY sized slice on a sunny day in MARIN - Pizza Near Me - San Rafael, California

See all

This is my ultra-convenient go-to for a kids' birthday party or a babysitter (I've gotta feed the babysitter!). They have good wholesome ingredients to choose from (I like to build my own veggie pizzas!) a nice crust and a mild sauce kids love, and unlike most pizzerias will actually deliver to my home address! read more

might be the best pizza, Marin county. and for these sensitive ones, they sell a non-gluten pizza.

Super friendly crew at Stefano's. Ordered my pizza online through the website. They gave me an estimate of the time and picked it up at the store exactly as they had described. It was hot, delicious and a regular staple in this house. read more

What's it so dry lol where's the sauce?? It's the best part I've been eating at Stefano's for 15 years I've never complained I just order extra sauce, but I'll never understand this. It should just come with actual sauce on it is pizza. It feels like dry bread with a paintbrush of red sauce that you can barely see, and then cheese. read more

Stefano's on Las Gallinas steps into the familiar space once held by Three Martian's Pizza. The day I stopped in, the cashier greeted me with a smile and was friendly with the customers as they came through. As this was my first slice from any Stefano's pizza, I was glad to learn two things: 1. A "slice" means two pieces of pizza 2. It was REALLY good Given the seating options, I see this location as more of a "takeout" place. That said, if you're just there for a slice, the colorful outdoor cafe tables and handful of barstools along the window will do just fine for up to a few people. Given my appreciation for the previous pizza place, I was delighted to find this worthy successor. We'll definitely keep this Stefano's location on our go-to list. read more

See all