pasta was over cooked. service slow sauce tastes like something out of a jar. toddler was given basket of gel pens which were all out of ink and a few broken crayons. order was wrong zero attention to detail. read more

Amazing dinner start to finish Great service and a nice clean dining area. The portions were generous but not overwhelming. We had the Lobster ravioli, chicken parmigiana and homemade lasagna YUM We will be back again to try more off the menu read more

See all

Went here before getting on the Chautauqua belle. Fantastic ! Best antipasto ever (and we are tough about such things.) When you tell them you have to make a boat in less than an hour, they deliver fantastic food on time. read more

Pizzas are decent but a little pricey. Not a whole lot of options in the area though so worth checking out. Would order again.

We took my daughter and her friends to dinner here in July because we were looking for a menu that would have some flavorful good options for variety of dietary restrictions (vegan, and a vegetarian, and some other food sensitivities). The dishes were each prepared well. Salads were well portioned. Pasta dishes were Al dente with balanced sauce. Service was great. Frustrating that they didn't take reservations for a party of 6 so even going early at about 530/6pm we had to wait just over 30 minutes. Still I'd say a good place to go if you're in the area. read more

Great food and great people. Always a great place to get something tasty. Stop by and check it out or order take out

Best pizza in the Chautauqua Lake area. The burgers are really good as well. I usually get take out but the dining room is nice as well.

Always a good meal. The pizza logs are a favorite appetizer. Great food and great service.

After a long drive from Ohio, we ordered 2 14 inch pizzas, one with mushrooms and spinach, the other with pepperoni to be delivered to our rental directly from the restaurant. It was delivered hot, and fresh, the delivery guy was friendly. Would definitely recommend! read more

Pizza was amazing. Chicken park calzone was outstanding. House was delicious. Great take out service,

Haven't been here in about 18mos. The first new impression was with the refurbishment of the entrance and patio seating. Very well done! Next was the wine list. We had the Albariño and the Nebbiolo. They were both great pairs to our salads and meals. In the spirit of my favorite movie, I got the special of night, crab and andouille ratatouille. Oh my! I got perspective in the same way the food critic, Ego, did in the movie:-) It wasn't as earth-moving as his, but I was very impressed at how Andriaccio's has stepped up its game. We were impressed! For European and American inspired dishes, don't miss this place. This will be one of our new go-to restaurants in the area. read more

Salads on two different days, mixed one day and Caesar another, we're both served room temperature and not chilled. Martini was $8.99 one day and $12 the next. . . Shrimp Portofino was tasty but skimpy on the sautéed spinach and mushrooms were diced very small - would have been great if sliced. Stick to pizzas and you won't be disappointed. Thanks to Ashley M. took her advice and stuck with the calzones, the sausage and pepper calzone was generous, filled with sausage crumbles and diced fresh red and green pepper. Always annoys me they charge 75 cents extra for bottled blue cheese salad dressing. Service is always friendly, efficient, and some nice wines on the list. read more

Andriaccio's Restaurant - Sausage and pepper calzone - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

This was our first time there and the food is way to expensive and I will not be going back. Lasagna for Lunch on Sunday was too expense and that is all you got no salad, no garlic bread and it was not good. chicken parmesan was too over cooked and you got a little spaghetti with it and nothing else no garlic bread or a salad and the cost was $23. I got a 10 inch pizza that was a ranch, bacon,& chicken tender. I asked for grilled chicken instead of chicken tenders and was charged $1.50 more plus the $17 charge for the pizza. My advice go some where else for better food or at least get better quality for the money. read more

One star for nostalgia. Another for the food which I actually believe is better than it was decades ago when I began consistently ordering Andriaccio's. That's where it ends, since, instead of a simple refund for an incorrect food order, Jake the manager decided to call me a liar. Poorest customer service imaginable. read more

This is quintessential Western NY Italian--I come here several times each summer. But for this visit I chose a burger that was prepared very well. Meat was fresh and tender. Accompanying salad, a substitution for fries, was crisp. My waitress was friendly and attentive. Another great experience at Andriaccio's! read more

Food and service was phenomenal. We had a party of 10 and everyone was very satisfied. We will definitely be back when we are visiting Chautauqua County. read more

Awesome family-owned and operated restaurant! They have the best pizza around, and they have done an awesome job expanding their menu and offering healthier options. Can't go wrong with this place! read more

Gluten free pasta and pizza that's actually good is hard to find but Andriaccio's has it!

bad service. meatball sandwich was dry as a bone. chicken sandwich out of a rubber factory. nothing was apparently home made. cackling old ladies were in seat bext to us drunk as skunks. will not come back. read more

I had a Godfather sub and some pizza logs... Man, the food was good. I'm definitely coming back and this was take out food!

As someone who needs to eat gluten free, I'm always a little hesitant when my family chooses an Italian place to eat. I was really excited and surprised that Andriaccos had gluten-friendly options. The first dish that came out to me was not gluten free, it was regular pasta. I sent it back, as I couldn't eat it and clarified that I would like the gluten free pasta. The second dish was definitely gluten-free, but it was ice cold and tasted of metal. I'm not sure if it was due to the type of pasta used or the fact it had likely been sitting in a metal container in the back for who knows how long. The server was kind, and I didn't want to send it back a second time so I ate the protein and left the majority of the really terrible dish. My family loved their dishes and had a great time. Unfortunately, if you need to dine gluten-free here I'd look elsewhere. (Or get a salad) read more

1. The lasagna was fine 2.Spaghetti has a different , but fairly good sauce 3. Meatballs are quite good 4. Grated parmesan cheese was flavorless.... how about some romano or asiago for a italian dinner that tastes much more authentic 5. Ordered a caesar salad and the croutons were great - the lettuce was fine and what should be a marvelous dressing tasted like mayonaise 6. Hey , we ordered an italian dinner , BREAD ? yes please , a nice crusty italian bread to compliment pasta ? heck no - just a cheap soft roll that most restaurants are serving these days . 7. Next time we want a good italian dinner I will buy a good crusty loaf at any decent bakery and make it at home from one of two outstanding family recipes . read more

After waiting twenty three minutes for a table, we finally get seated. The power goes out no more than four minutes later. Yes. The whole restaurant is lightless. Mind you, it's about 7pm, the sun is going down. No candles. No nothing. Just dim sunlight creeping in threw a nearby window. "Uhmnn... I can get you some water for now but that's about it. I'm not sure if we are going to be able to make any more food" "Is there a near by restaurant?" I ask. "Let me find out," she says as she heads off. By this point 411 is being called, we are asking about a restaurant we believe is a few miles down the road. The waitress comes back, "I know there is a restaurant nearby and I have a cell phone that works, but I don't have their phone number" .... Is this chick for real?? "It's ok, we are already calling" "Oh... Ahm, good good. let me know if they have power so I know either way" REALLY THOUGH. Come on. Get a clue. read more

Andriaccio's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

See all

Great food! Four of us came here at around 3pm, and although dine in wasn't open yet, they allowed us to sit on their gorgeous patio and they brought our takeout out for us. the staff was very kind! The prices were a bit high though, but pretty worth it. read more

See all

Ordered chicken piccata. Sauce was a little thicker than norm, and only one caper. Which explains why I didn't taste any capers. But still very good. In addition, the risotto was under cooked. NOTE to owners. When someone orders a pasta dish. Automatically, serve the parmesan cheese and red pepper. We asked for it and waited and waited. Two of our friend finished their meals before we got the waitress's attention. She was in such a hurry, we had two more request and she was practically running from us. Her service brought down the star rating. All in all - I would come back. read more

So one of the only sit downs I could find on a Monday at Lake Chautauqua. We sat down, 2 of us, inside. ...... there was 2 other tables occupied. It took 20 minutes to get a menu. It took 40 minutes to get my iced tea. It took 35 minutes before our waitress took our order. .... I ordered a cheeseburger... 25 minutes later the waitress informs me they don't have hamburgers. .... so I ordered a dinner salad and a sausage calzone. ... half hour later they bring my friends calzone, and a sausage smothered in sauce???? No salad, no calzone. By this time the manager comes out apologizing. Apologize? Just give me some food. I've now been here an hour and 15 minutes and I have an empty ice tea glass. My friend finished his calzone and they finally bring mine. With the dinner salad. ..... they didn't charge me for my tea... read more

This place is amazing - sadly it is not open year round, but it is right now and I suggest checking them out. Parking is easy, free and plentiful - it's also very easy to find. The staff are amazing - the selection incredible - pricing is out of this world great and it's clean and family friendly. I also must comment that the food tastes GREAT - they really knock it out of the park! Not quite sure why some folks rate this so low - but I travel all over the North America and this place isn't bad at all. read more

While staying at the St Elmo with a group, we ordered take out for dinner. The hot wings and the calzones (steak and ham & cheese) were good and the best things that we ordered. The chicken parm was just OK, however the chicken Marsala had the smallest pieces of chicken in a restaurant 'dinner' that I've ever seen (see picture). The taste was there, but I couldn't get over the portion size. The Pittsburg salad came with three French fries on it, so if you want more than that, order a side of fries! If you're ordering take out from here, stick with the pizzeria type options and not the dinners. read more

Andriaccio's Restaurant - Chicken Marsala to go. Very small portion. - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

Went to Andriaccio's a couple of weeks ago with my family. Had to sit inside due to the weather and to be honest, I think the tables were a little too close together. Our table ordered a variety of meals, prime rib, chicken parmigiana, chicken Alfredo, and spaghetti with sauce. The food was good but not outstanding. Prime rib was smoked but that wasn't identified in the description and that's just a style we didn't enjoy. Nothing wrong with it though. Chicken in the chicken parm was great. Chicken and broccoli alfredo was probably our favorite of what we ordered. Calzones looked SUPER and we all had food envy of the table next to us. There was some weirdness with the bill and we ended up overpaying and it wasn't really resolved. The food was the best part, service and the environment were just ok. I will definitely try a calzone to go next time I'm in the area. read more

Absolutely worst service ever. One of the managers, Jake, is super unhelpful and would rather argue with a customer than hear their needs to assist. He doesn't even know what service is. Whoever takes the orders doesn't know the menu, and would leave items off because she's lost. Overpriced and not even that good. Pasta was overcooked!! Wings were dry. Cannoli's were terrible!!! AVOID unless it's your last option and you have over $50 to throw away. read more

Pizza really good and lots of toppings. Good timing for take out. However the fried cauliflower was over cooked and completely inedible. How anyone could sell that to a customer is beyond me! Stick to the pizza and you are safe. read more

Andriaccio's Restaurant - Buffalo Cauliflower - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

Really enjoy Andriaccio's! High quality food at reasonable prices, and they made delivery contact free/safe during the pandemic. Try their margherita pizza! read more

Great atmosphere and wonderful waitress! We decided to have pizza but oh what a pizza. We tried the Neapolitan pizza and shared the Greek salad. The salad was huge, more than enough for two. Loaded with goodies, dressing was slightly bland. The pizza dough was phenomenal, and cooked with olive oil. So, so good! Loaded but not over loaded, I look forward to trying the others. read more

Andriaccio's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mayville, New York

Great restaurant. Fast and friendly service. Magnificent food. Chicken Parmesan is best I have ever had - melts in your mouth. I travel to western PA for business and make it a point to eat a meal here when I do! read more

Great wings. Ordered close to closing time but still had polite and fast service. They had a ton of different flavors, I got BBQ and Long Island. Only issue I had was that I stood at the carry out counter for a while before anyone knew I was there. Other than that no complaints. I've had their pizza before (not this trip) and it is OUTSTANDING. Being in there and smelling the kitchen made me miss it so I'll probably order one soon. read more

This place has monopoly on the Chautauqua Institution and the lack of Italian food competition in the region gives them the opportunity to treat customers poorly without consequences. Slow service. Pizza do be dank tho. This is an update- we have been waiting for preplanned food for an extra 30 mins. read more

My family and I were staying at the Fairway Suites at the Peak....It was my birthday and I was looking for a good Italian restaurant....The person in Fairway Suites reccomended Andriaccio's.... As I am picky on good Italian food...I can say this was excellent...I had the chicken parm/linguine.... They even brought out an awesome dessert for me and my famly.... The food, the staff the restaruant all excellent...Highly reccommend read more

Amazing taste - great food. Service was pretty bad - but they were way understaffed since it was out of season. I would have rated lower but the Food was so darn good.... read more

This place was honestly much better than I expected. Three of us ate in the lovely patio area and listened to live music. The service was friendly. The food was tasty. I had lasagna which came with bread (with both butter for spreading and olive oil for dipping) and a salad. The salad was a nice mixture of field greens with tomatoes and cucumbers and delicious croutons. The lasagna was a small-ish sized portion, but it was flavorful. Layers of perfectly cooked pasta with lots of beef and cheese and marinara sauce were baked until bubbly. It was a tasty meal in a fun place. read more

Ordered 2 large cheese pizzas, waited over an hour and our order was not even in the oven yet. Unfortunately not the first time this has happened. Our order often comes back incorrect but has never once been on time. read more