TL;DR: good pizza and fast service We have been to the one in Tyson's locations,, but we finally got a chance to try this location. There is plenty of indoor and outdoor season, with a full bars with TVs as well. There are two distinct lines, one for whole pies and one for by the slice. They also have a handful of combos which is the way we went. We got the pepperoni special (5/5) which was our favorite. The sausage and pepper (3/5) was solid but nothing special. Overall, the dough/crust was a perfect balance of crunch, chew, and substance. Already itching to go back and try other pizzas! read more

See all

Came in because teen said it was good pizza. Bought two pizza slices that they reheated with a cold coke. Seems their day old chicken buffalo pizza is a specialty, so that was a buck more. I should have just stayed with the pepperoni. To be honest, I was expecting better. This day old dried out thin crust was a sad excuse for a pizza slice. it should have been steamed then thrown through their reheat oven cycle. Because it was day old dry. The potential was there... but the execution after sitting out all day... I mourn that pizza. Thrown on a paper plate by a teenager, the service wasn't much more than a grunt for a credit card. And the garage like atmosphere wasn't off putting, but I could smell the used oil in the concrete floors. I'm told the location in Alexandria is a better store. But yeah, not a great first impression. read more

The pizza is definitely out of this world--not gonna lie, some of the best pizza I've ever had. But the portions and prices for the slices are insane. The slices are always uneven, yet you're paying the same premium price every time. Today, one slice was huge and the other was tiny. Paying $5-$6 for a slice, they should at least be somewhat consistent with the portions. Great pizza, but the pricing just doesn't make sense when the slice sizes vary this much. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Our go to pizza spot, love their crust and recommend eating it in! Glad they have a closer spot to our home! read more

We had the Andy's Tysons a few months ago and it lived up to all the hype, so wanted to try the Fairfax location to a) see how it compares for ourselves and b) to see if some of the negative reviews are warranted. They are not. We went on a weekend close to when they opened, so it wasn't very crowded. Ordered a large pepperoni and a couple of drinks. Pizza took maybe 20 minutes, during which a number of tables filled up. The pizza was consistent with what we had at Tysons. Very thin, very flavorful, and very hot. The pics speak for themselves. read more

See all

Now I get the hype. Wondered why there were so many locations and figured it was just a typical chain pizza place. Nope! Delicious, authentic NY style pizza. Very thin and crispy undercarriage. Wish there was a location closer to us in Loudoun. I only got Andy's because it was on my way home from work. read more

This review is for Andy's Bagels at Andy's Pizzq. Kudos to the staff for working so hard during the morning rush. The bagels were the perfect texture. We tried the salmon cc topping and the scallion.bThey don't mix them in, which is good and bad. Good bc the toppings taste very fresh. Bad bc the topping flavor doesn't get a chance to marinate into the cc. Tried a bacon, egg and cheese bagel another day. Eggs and cheese were perfect. Bacon was not crispy at all. Also, they should put out salt and pepper packets during breakfast. Try their bagels. They won't disappoint. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - 2 slices and a soda for $10! Great crust - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I ordered delivery from Andy's Pizza for dinner, and overall, it was a solid experience. The delivery was prompt, arriving in under 30 minutes, even during what seemed like a busy evening rush. I went with their burrata margarita pizza, and I have to say, the quality is there: fresh burrata that melts beautifully, vibrant tomato sauce, and a nice charred flavor on the crust that gives it that authentic wood-fired vibe. It's hearty and satisfying, especially if you're craving something with a bit of gourmet flair. That said, I think my enjoyment was tempered a bit because it was delivery--I bet it would have been even better fresh out of the oven at the location, where the heat and aromas could really shine. Still, if Neapolitan style pies are your thing, this place delivers reliably. I'd give it a 3.5 out of 5 and might dine in next time for the full experience. Decent spot for the area! read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Burrata Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Great deals on the combo meals. Full bar. Can be busy and limited parking. Has dine in and take out options. read more

See all

We come to this Andy's Pizza location in Fairfax quite a bit as it's very convenient being near the house, and it's also right next to Compass Coffee to grab a cold brew so it works out really well! And if someone wants to do their grocery shopping at Amazon Fresh. We're regulars there so we've tried essentially every topping and we really love the buffalo chicken one and the mushroom and onion. I'm not even a big fan of mushrooms in general but they make it right so it's tasty. I like the pizza crust, it's actually crispy, and you get a good amount of cheese and tomato sauce. I don't want a ton of tomato sauce on my pizza but this one has a balance of tang and sweetness. You can request little parmesan cheese containers to add, and the tables have shakers for pepper and oregano. I think ranch on the side is $1 from what I remember. Overall quick and friendly service, hot pizza, clean dining area that's now festive for the holidays. And they have their usual pizza slice combo deals with drink, I recommend trying the lemonade. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Still amazing!! I tried special pepperoni the other day and was blown away at how good it was. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Stopped by for lunch and we both got the two slice combo! Good as always and a quick wait, we got to sit outside as well. Ill have to remember this location next time im considering a slice read more

See all

The pepperoni special is probably my favorite slice of pizza in the dmv! Love the cupped pepperoni and burrata. The white pizza was good but it would feel a bit dry as I kept eating it. Fries would solid but the pizza is definitely what shines. This Fairfax location is a great ambiance and is big with indoor, outdoor, and bar seating. We had a big group and it was a great spot to meet with friends. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pepperoni Special Slice! White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Initially I thought of going to Andy's Foggy Bottom. Then I thought Ballston. Then I saw the DISASTER 66E was. So Fairfax it was. I parked on the other side of the stupid round a bout and walked over. I was thinking pepperoni. The pizza at Andy's is one size. Or grab slices from the case. I ordered a pepperoni and she gave me a number 18 order number. The place is all new, nice inside. The bar is complete with big screens for the game and a bunch of seats and an area where you can stand to drink and eat while watching the TV. Lots of folks enjoying the food, salads, slices and whole pies. The aroma is incredible with the pizza ovens in the same space as the dining area. My pizza is ready to go...In had something to drink in the car so i ate out of the trunk. The plates on the counter came in handy. It's hot in the box so I'm pulling a slice and waiting for it to cool off. The pepperoni curls up. I have seen this before but In can't remember where. The slices are huge, like a meal with two slices. I'm into the first slice and it's very good. Second slice is cooling off and gone before I know it. I remember going to Hooters on this strip in Fairfax, I guess gentrification is a reality here. If you're in the mood for fresh good pizza Andy's a is a lock. Dine in or take out is a good bet. read more

See all

Pizza was delicious! The crust was the perfect blend of crispy and soft. The fresh lemonades are a must!! We also had the old bay wings which were cooked perfectly - we loved that they offered an option of getting the wings fried extra crispy. The staff was all very friendly and helpful! Andy's was a total hit!! In an area saturated with specialty pizza places, Andy has moved into the top spot for me! read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Old Bay Wings - delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Ordered a combo box and pick out various slices to select from. My favorite slices from the selection was the hot honey pizza ( MUST TRY!!! So good) and the sausage and green pepper peppers pizza! Both very flavorful, fresh, and crispy. My least flavored one was the white pizza. There's also other sides to order such as Brussels sprouts. There's indoor and outdoor seating at this location, however be worn. It is packed on a Friday night! read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Andy's rocks. Whether it's at Nationals Park or Fairfax. Andy's never disappoints. Can't wait to check out the one in Tysons.

Andres helped us with picking the slices very appreciate it:)) Also slice we got was cheese and some fried love it!!! read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

It's true what everyone says... Andy's is legit. Dine-in is best and the only way to go; you're on your own if you do take out. I tried Tysons/ McLean branch recently and had to come again. I had the same great experience and then some. They have outdoor seating and are dog friendly. Outdoor seating on a summer day is everything. They even have big bulb string lights for vibes at dusk. Service was friendly and fast. I love how fast/ casual it is. We ordered at the counter, snagged a seat outside, and pizza was out almost immediately (they run precooked za through a broiler to reheat). Salads are preassembled and in the fridge under the drinks. Brussels sprouts came out in about 10 minutes. Before I get cooked for getting Brussels and a salad, a girl needs some greens alright. My friend and I downed an entire pizza, some greens wouldn't hurt. $9 is steep for a Caesar but it was pretty good (I love Caesar). Brussels were also delish! We got the 8 slices make a pie and tried: -pepperoni -pepperoni special -buffalo -margherita -mushroom and onion -sausage pepper My favorites were pepperoni, pepperoni special, and margherita. The crust is so perfectly thin and chewy. Tomato sauce is tangy sweet. Buffalo was kinda salty and basic, wouldn't get it again. It might be better with ranch. My friend loved the mushroom and onion. Sausage pepper was also kinda basic. I cannot wait to come here again. read more

See all

Really love this pizza joint! The sauce is what made it great and the crust is crispy and toothsome. Very enjoyable to eat by the slice. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Great pizzas by the slice- really hit the spot after a hike around Burke Lake - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Summary: told some guys I work out with I had a pizza cheat day. They ask "where did you go?" Andy's Pizza I replied. In unison they all agreed that it was a good choice and good pizza Let's jump in real quick. Had a craving for pizza and I live about 2 miles away. Stopped by and got 4 NYC style cheese pizzas and a couple of diet cokes (because I eat regular cake) Long story short - good pizza, authentic slice. "Forget about it". I recommend the different variety's. I'm just old school and like cheese pizza. read more

Went here on a Friday for pickup, and ordered online. Accidentally clicked for it to be ready for 7:30pm at 6pm, so called the restaurant and asked to move it up. Unfortunately they did not accommodate that and said they were too busy to move up the order, which I would have normally understood; but when I went to place another order to check if I could put it in for earlier, it worked and said I could pick the new order up at 6:45pm. So basically we had to wait an hour and a half for a pizza order to be made, which is kind of ridiculous even on a busy Friday night. We decided to wait anyway because I've been wanting to try Andy's for quite some time now. We picked up our order and our side was right but they made a mistake on one of the slices, so I'm glad that I checked. Thankfully the manager was accommodating and gave me another slice that I was missing. When we got home we had to reheat the pizza as it was cold (so much for we were too busy to make it earlier), and after waiting 1.5 hours already it was starting to get annoying. Nevertheless, we tried the food. I ordered the 8 slices make a pie pizza. I would say it is nice to be able to create your own pizza with multiple different pizza slices so everyone gets what they want and I think that's a great idea. I ordered 4 pepperoni for my husband, and I ordered 1 buffalo crispy chicken slice, 1 white pizza slice, 1 burrata margherita slice, and 1 pepperoni special. The buffalo crispy chicken slice was chewy and the chicken was unappetizing. There wasn't nearly enough buffalo sauce and it had dried out (this was before reheating it, I noticed it wasn't freshly poured on). Like other reviewers have said it's not flavorful enough and was honestly bland. I liked the burrata margherita slice as the burrata was fresh and delicious, but I feel like if it wasn't on there there wouldn't have been enough flavor for me to eat it, as there was a minimal amount of basil, hardly any sauce and it again, was chewy. The white pizza slice was ok, but there wasn't enough ricotta, and because I've had so much better elsewhere, I cannot say I cared for it. It just didn't have enough flavor. Lastly, their pepperoni special. I've never had hot honey before but I can say now that any kind of honey on a pizza is just unappetizing to me. I tried it because it was their special and what most people said they liked. The pepperoni special has pepperoni, burrata, and hot honey on top. It's basically their burrata margherita with pepperoni and hot honey. I didn't have the plain pepperoni, but my husband said it was just ok. He didn't like the fact that there was so much oil and I agree with that for all of the pizza. We also ordered their broccolini which has Parmesan breadcrumbs and lemon, which was surprisingly tasty. But I'm not going to a pizza place just for broccoli. Overall the pizza is just ok. There isn't nearly enough of each topping, thin layer of cheese, minuscule amount of sauce and hardly any flavor. Basically I would say it is Chuck E. Cheese pizza quality if they decided to throw some extra toppings on. Only reason for the 3 stars is the service was just OK. The restaurant is small, and there isn't enough parking as well, so prepare to fight for a spot on a busy day. I really wanted to like this spot but unfortunately I'm going to have to pass next time. read more

See all

Bagel review - finally! About time Andy! Got myself half a dozen and breakfast sandwich and delicious and we got some competition in the dmv. Kudos read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - bacon egg cheese on everything bagel - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Love their pizza. Been coming here almost every week or every other week. Service is great, minus couple front workers that weren't so customer friendly. Almost lost couple sales until a gentlemen stepped in, seemed like a supervisor or someone who's more invested into this establishment. Very professional and made a good impression. Service from him was very prompt and professional. Also came across friendly. Ambiance cute place. Chill bar/ sit down tables. Obsessed with their pizza read more

We've ordered here for a few years and gradually the quality of the pizza has gone down. This makes me sad. We ordered cheese pizza and decided to add our own basil when we picked it up. The pizza was very skimpy on the sauce and it was dotted with cheese. When I have cheese pizza I expect to see more cheese less sauce on the surface. Totally skimpy. We had a few slices and tossed the rest out. read more

This review is for the bagels themselves. My big gripe was I wanted a bagel with salmon spread and I told that to the guy taking orders and I made sure to clarify with the cashier that was my order which they both confirmed. Despite that they gave me the wrong order. At the end of the day I got the salmon sandwich on an everything bagel. The salmon and capers with cream cheese were really good. The bagel itself was delicious and chewy. I would say they are on the smaller side so maybe one would not be a filling breakfast. I cannot wait until all the locations have bagels then I would go there. I would say their bagels are easily in the top of the DMV. read more

Always busy, but for a good reason. Great flavor, thin and crispy crust, and the pepperoni special is 10/10 every time. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pepperoni Special. My favorite pizza in NoVA. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Insanely good, please visit this place. Freshest slice I've ever had in VA by a long shot read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Delicious all around. Can't go wrong with their pepperoni special with ricotta and hot honey. Tastes good reheated in the oven (and air fryer too I'm assuming) Their buffalo chicken pizza is also super yummy but eat that one fast as it tastes best fresh. We've gotten to-go and eaten at the restaurant and have never had a bad experience. I wish there was one closer to me! read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

I love Andy's pizza. But this location is not good. Maybe new staff are not trained well ? My margarita pie looked like cheese pie with basil. I'd rather go to the one in Tyson's. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Margarita ? - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Si wifey and I stopped in for a quick lunch. The two slices plus a lemonade for $14 was just right. I got the pepperoni/sausage. She got the sausage/green peppers. The slices were reheated on a conveyor belt oven that produced a perfect amount of reheating without further cooking. We both thought the slices were amazing. The crust was super thin and chewy without being a cracker. I don't know how they did it, but the crust was the thinnest crust I have ever had that wasn't a cracker. Nice chew. Good sauce. Plentiful cheese. Speaking of cheese, we got a couple of small containers with what I found out was finely ground parmesan. It looked like small balls of cheese. At first, I thought it might actually have been feta because the cheese was actually creamy in the bite/chew. I have had shredded parmesan and "sawdust" parmesan but never creamy parmesan. When I asked about it, they confirmed it was a premium parmesan that the ground in-house. There is plenty of seating for small groups and families with a long bar if teh tables are full. Yeah, I'm coming back. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Sausage and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Andy's Pizza is a superb option for high-quality pizza in northern Virginia. Our family enjoys the margherita pie (with basil) and their pepperoni pizza. For carry out service, it's usually ready within 15-20 minutes during off-peak hours. You may need to wait a little longer during evening peak times at dinner. It's best to eat as soon as you get home, but the slices can be frozen and reheated if you have extras for the week. I have not dined inside the restaurant, but it looks like an appealing place with a clean interior and TVs if you want to watch a Sunday football game. read more

They have really amazing pizza, the wings are really good too!! Highly Recommend! Either Carry out or Dine in, it's all good. read more

My favorite slice is the caramelized onions and mushrooms pizza. Customer service is great and everyone is always very friendly.

3.5. If I'm being picky, the music approaches night club level, a little loud for me. The drinks in the cooler may need to be rotated when restocked. They were barely cool the last couple of times we were here. On the plus side, the pizza is good, the place is clean and the staff is friendly. read more

Have gotten takeout from here a couple times, it's always been good but the timing can be off. Sometimes it is ready by the pick up time, sometimes it isn't. Overall the food quality is always good which is what matters! read more

Best tasting pizza and friendly staff! Also like that they have a lot of seating. Would come back!

The service was excellent, even during their busy hours. I wouldn't call myself a pizza snob, but having lived in Italy for a few years, I believe nothing beats Neapolitan-style pizza in my mind. That said, Andy's New York-style pizza is fantastic and incredibly tasty. The cheese was plentiful, toppings were abundant and flavorful. If you're craving good pizza in Fairfax, VA, you won't be disappointed. Many try to do it well and fall short, but Andy truly delivers. I happily give it four stars. read more

Another round of awesome pizza. Highly recommend Andy's pizza to everyone who loves pizza. If you haven't had Andy's pizza then you haven't had pizza. read more

FOOD I had the Pepperoni Special and Margherita slices, and both were a treat. The crust was perfectly crisp with a great bite, and the sauce added a sweet yet tangy flavor that complemented each slice. The burrata on the Pepperoni Special brought a creamy richness that made it stand out. While I felt the Margherita slice could use a little more mozzarella, it was still enjoyable. If you're looking for a spot to grab a satisfying slice for lunch, this place won't disappoint! SERVICE The staff are kind and friendly! There are two lines-- one to purchase by the slice and the other to buy by the pie. The staff keep the line moving so I was out with my order within five minutes. AMBIANCE Bar, booth, and table seats are available inside. Outdoor seating is also available though at a limited capacity. PARKING Ample parking is available in the lot before the store. read more

Andy's Pizza - Fairfax - Pepperoni Special (House Favorite) Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all