Bigger is not necessarily better. I love chicken calzones with spinach, but this one was too big to be great. It had lots of spinach, little chicken, and bland. The preparation time was adequate and about normal. The place is quaint with plenty of seating. See for yourself... read more

King's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Still the best pizza in Northern Virginia. Tonight its a medium to celebrate. I love this place because it's small, cozy, warm, and the pizza is GOOD. It just feels like a little pizzeria in Hells Kitchen. read more

See all

Pretty solid considering nova pizza sucks lol. Super cozy vibe and a bunch of old ppl come here to dine in. Very surprised and I'm glad I tried it. I'll be back read more

We tried this place three years ago and decided to give it another try. They served us completely burnt garlic knots. We definitely will not be coming back. If this is the quality of the food they serve, I'm not spending money on it read more

King's NY Pizza - Burnt garlic knots that should not have been served. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Pizza was good for Virginia. Service was good. Good value. Place was clean . My son goes to mason and it's his go to since his favorite place closed suddenly read more

My last several visits over the past few years have all been home runs. Excellent service, quality, and food. I'm bringing my family there tonight so I hope the streak continues read more

Pizza was good and pretty standard. We did takeout so it was pretty much ready when we got there. Area has plenty of parking! read more

King's NY Pizza - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Amazing staff, service, and of course food! Very cozy inside with immediate customer service and generally most things are made in-house. They also are very generous on portion sizes including toppings. I will be returning! read more

We used to be regulars here, ordering at least twice a month because the pizza was genuinely great. Delivery times were always a bit unpredictable -- sometimes early, sometimes up to an hour late -- but we were understanding. It's a small business, and we assumed they were doing their best, possibly with limited staff. Even when late, the pizza arrived hot and fresh, so we didn't mind. Unfortunately, our most recent order was a complete disaster and has turned us away for good. I placed an order with an ETA of 7:57 PM. The ETA came and went, but again, we were used to delays -- especially on a Friday night -- so we waited. Nearly an hour after the ETA, we finally called to check on the status. That's when we were told the driver had already delivered the pizza -- not to us, but allegedly to a random man standing by the bushes outside our house. The driver apparently asked this person if he ordered pizza, got a "yes," and just handed it over without confirming any details. We don't even have bushes in front of our house, and they refused to describe the person the pizza was given to, so I'm highly skeptical of their story. When I called the store, hoping to resolve things calmly, I was met with immediate hostility. The manager (or owner) scolded me for not calling sooner, saying if I had called within 5-10 minutes of the missed ETA, he might have considered a refund. I explained that, as loyal customers, we were just giving them the benefit of the doubt -- exactly because delays had been common in the past. Instead of understanding, he doubled down and told me I'd have to dispute the charge with my credit card company if I wanted my money back -- which I ultimately did. It's incredibly disappointing to be treated this way, especially as a frequent customer who always tried to be patient and understanding. Sadly, we won't be ordering from here again. read more

Thoroughly enjoyed King;s NY Pizza from the moment we entered. We were greeted very kindly and truly we were totally blown away by the quality of the presentation and the excellent service. Everything was so delicious and the prices were very reasonable. We will be returning for sure!! read more

See all

The best pizza in Fairfax, and it would have to be because their new ordering system is an absolute nightmare. I really hope they drop this system and find a new one. It's worth it to call in, but it shouldn't be this hard in 2026. read more

A colleague and I go there often for pizza, maybe once per week or so. Usually we get a slice plus a side salad and a soft drink. My fave is veggie, his is sausage or cheese. The crust is crunchy and well flavored. The cheese and tomato sauce are both excellent, and the toppings are good. The wait staff is attentive and pleasant. Only the ambiance is so-so, but it doesn't detract from the overall high quality of the food. I don't get why King's isn't written up more in lists of best local pizzas, but it should be, IMO. read more

Pizza review time. One bite everybody knows the rules... Amazing pizza! Great undercarriage, perfect amount of flop, outstanding flavor, and just the right amount of cheese. I have to say, it's the best New York style pizza I have ever had hand down! I highly recommend stopping by this little place ASAP! read more

August 2021 - COVID Review: When I used to work in the area, my coworkers that are originally from the NY/NJ metro area said that King's was as close to the pizza that they're used to from back home. After seeing them get whole pies for lunch often, I decided to try it for myself with my husband when we happened to be nearby. The pizza is thin but not too thin (which means it's not extra doughy) and I loved how crispy it was and how it holds up well with all the toppings. The times that I've been here, we've called ahead for pickup and there haven't been any issues. read more

We were a bit hesitant because of its location. But we're truly impressed with the food and service. The garlic knots were out of this world. I'm a plain Jane kinda person so I had spaghetti with marinara and my husband had Stromboli it was huge and both were awesome. I thought it was great the owner walked around and checked on people and food quality. Very pleasant experience. read more

Disappointing first visit. Friendly staff and minimal wait time, but the dark, dated decor was uninviting. The gyro was a major letdown, with overly salty meat resembling jerky. Won't be returning. read more

King's NY Pizza - Gyro On Pita - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I had lunch at King's NY Pizza. I am originally from NY and I can tell you this pizza is authentic! I had the Margherita pizza and it was yummy. I've been here a couple of times and will be back again. read more

Great "everything" pizza, and spagetti with meat sauce is nearly perfection! The Linguini Pescatore is really good if you lean towards seafood. Recommend 100% read more

Good solid ny pizza. I'm from NY, I'd know. It isn't as thin as I'd like but the flavors for sauce, bread and cheese are spot on. And then deliver!! More on IG @dmv_halaloholic read more

Great pizza! And a great deal. About $6 for two cheese slices. Folks here are nice. Dine in or take out. Nice thin crust pizza if you want a quick bite. read more

King's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

The pizza was good. The staff were okay, no one asked me how I was doing when I walked in. I loved the artwork on the walls. The craft beer selection could be better, there was not much variety. The drink options could be better as well, I would suggest possibly adding in some natural or even organic soda options as well. I would also suggest adding a recycling bin, because a lot of the pizza boxes and plastic bottles are recyclable, yet I had to trash mine (when they could have easily been recycled). Not a bad place overall, but there could be some room for improvement. The pizza did not taste very much like New York style pizza to me, and the crust was too chewy, but it was good otherwise. read more

See all

The pizza here is good....really good! It truly tastes like NY style pizza, and I have had really good NY style pizza. The cheese bread sticks were strange, basically like they rolled up some extra dough and covered it in cheese. The marinara sauce was like a very thin tomato soup. That being said it's not called King's NY breadsticks so this need not be a game changer. The price is pretty steep, close to $20 for a medium pizza with one topping but not super steep for the area. Another bonus, almost everything nearby closed at 8 PM, they were open until 10, a plus for sure. Ultimately, came for the pizza, loved the pizza, would eat the pizza again. read more

Kings pizza suck! They make Costco Pizza looks good. Pale crust that tastes like cardboard, purple pepperoni that tastes like stale grease. This is like Manny & Olga's and 7-11 pizzas had a child. I would not come back to this place if the pizza was free and they paid for the Uber. Andy's Pizza is where's at; flavorful pizza, lovely music, friendly staff. DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR HARD EARNED MONEY HERE! read more

When you order a put A New York pizza and you specifically say no green peppers can you imagine why they would put green peppers on the pizza. I must've said it three times. AND They do not take Apple Pay read more

King's NY Pizza - Green peppers that were put on the pizza that I ordered no green peppers. And they do not take Apple Pay!!! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Worst food ever. We tried three different things and all were terrible. Fried mushrooms with so much batter there were no actual mushrooms inside. Watered down sauce, way over cooked pasta and meatballs (if you can even call them that) were like balls of compressed rubber. read more

We've been getting takeout here for years. My husband loves the pizza, and I love their sandwiches and fries. And it's all inexpensive. But recently we've been really disappointed in their service. We sat waiting for our to-go order for 20 minutes, all for the employee to hand us the bag that had been sitting there ready the whole time. Today, we ordered a pizza and a sandwich. I called 15 minutes later to ask if I could add fried to the order, where they told me they forgot to put in the pizza on the order anyway. When we picked up the order, they forgot the fries and we had to again wait. I have worked in food service so I understand sometimes you miss things, but to not apologize for the mistake and simply act so blasé and unbothered about it like they do is such poor customer service. read more

King's NY Pizza - Medium cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I am not sure how they have so many stars, this place is as bad gets, bad ingredients, bad cooking, I just cant imagine why would anyone ever eat there. It was a complete waste of money, if you like to throw it away, this place is for you, good Lord!! read more

Do not order for their website it is insecure, it charged my card without placing a order and it looks like it was designed by a goth grader for a school project. The pizza at this place is decent, but the online ordering is truly the worst I have ever seen in my life. Call them, deliver, but do not EVER order online from Kings Pizza read more

Highly disappointed with the chicken Piccata. The noodles were over cooked there was only capers in caper juice and maybe a splash of lemon, the chicken was dry with no taste No sign of seasoning. And when I informed the waitress, then she proceeded to ask us if we wanted the check while laughing at the fact that it was nasty. She also left the chicken on the check. read more

King's NY Pizza - Chicken Piccata * NOT GOOD * noodles were overcooked, no seasoning (salt/pepper) only capers and caper juice. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

This pizza is amazing! My first time here and I would definitely come back if I were in the area. Just the right amount of sauce and the crust is perfect. The staff is friendly and were understanding that my kids were acting crazy. They had white milk which was also an added bonus! Thats all my toddlers drink. read more

It was a Saturday night and I was craving pizza as usual but I wanted something that offered slices so I wouldn't have to purchase a whole pie. I saw this place out of he corner of my eye as I drove by, called them up to ask about slices. They did offer them so I stopped by to get my grub on. I had a slice of meat lovers and a slice of supreme. Both were large with a good amount of toppings and tasted great. Had a good crust as well. My only knock is there should be more cheese but the toppings made up for it. Washed it down with a nice cold fat tire beer, a very satisfying and quick meal. This is a nice spot if you're looking for a quick bite or want to have a quiet family night out. There's a few tables and some high tops but the dining room is small so plan accordingly. Overall a solid pizza place. Passes my pizza test! read more

King's NY Pizza - Pizza and beer go hand in hand! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Ordered a pepperoni pizza extra sauce, extra cheese. But there's a point where extra is just over the top and since moving to this area have discovered pizza joints generally skimp on the sauce and from photos on the reviews looked like would be better to order that way. Obviously my mistake. Puddles of grease on the pizza and it was sloshed around. My 9 year old loves all pizza, his fave food and not picky about it...he wouldn't even finish a slice. Besides a goopy mess to try and eat, there was no flavor to the sauce or crust. We tossed it. Waste of $$. The steak and cheese was meh, bland and lots of lettuce. The onion rings were actually really good. Delivery driver was nice. read more

King's NY Pizza - How the pizza came delivered when opened the box. Sloshed over and puddles of grease. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

My wife called in an order for Spaghetti with meat sauce yesterday - and specified that she did not want marinara sauce. When the young man read the order to her he said; spaghetti with meat sauce and marinara sauce. She stated, very clearly, no, I do not want marinara sauce, only meat sauce. When I got home what was on the order" meat and marinara sauce? My wife and I have found in the past few years that trying to place an order with some young folks is almost impossible. For some reason they do not give full attention to the customer. This is not to slam all young people. Management needs to teach its staff how to listen to the customer and get the order correct. read more

Decided to support this local business during these crazy times, even though they also messed up my pizza order a year ago. Called on Easter Day, two simple veggie pizzas...by the time we started dinner I noticed little pieces of pepperoni all over one of the pies, which I had to throw out since we do not eat pork for religious reasons (kosher). I decided to call the next day (today) and let the Manager know of the problem. Once I connected with the "acting" manager and politely told him the issue, indicating I have a few pictures as well. He indicated to me that I should have called about the problem last night and brought the pizza in. When I told him it was a Sunday dinner and that they also closed at 9, he went on to tell me he could only give me a discount toward another pizza - and no money back or a complimentary pizza could be offered. I mentioned again that I had a few pictures that I could send him and that ordering another pizza again (knowing the past two experiences I've had) would not be something I'm comfortable doing at this time, he went on to tell me again that he can't do anything and then went on to say that "things like that happen". When I noticed he was not willing to respect me as a customer or work with me, I asked him what he would say if I posted to Yelp!. He hung up on me. Bad customer service and apparently little care or attention to dietary requests. Pizza is ok but there are definitely better options around, especially ones that want your business. read more

King's NY Pizza - Veggie pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Stopped by this pizza shop after seeing it several months ago. The place wasn't very busy when I walked in, but this meant I wouldn't have to wait long for an order. I saw on I could order pizza by the slice or order a whole pizza. Since I have never had their pizza before, I ordered only two slices. Ordering sausage and bacon pizza from a green haired lady. I don't remember her name so I will call her Verde. The pizza store had some nice pictures and a clean bathroom. I also saw the TV was playing some kind of TV show, but didn't pay attention to it. After several minutes the pizza was ready. The pizza smelled good and tasted good too. The only thing that I found bad about the pizza was it was to thin and the crust needs more flavor. read more

See all

Food is good but they keep putting wax paper under the pizza and after we get it home the pizza is undercooked, soggy, and the paper is melted and stuck to the underside. it's inedible. read more

Their pizza suck shit!!! not enough sauce and has a bitter taste. They use cheap shit beef for steak & cheese that drips grease all over the sub...not a lean rib eye in order to cut cost!!! Go fuck yourselves and go out of business soon!!! DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE PEOPLE!!! read more

These guys have a amazing meat sauce.... So willing to travel so hubby can get spaghetti. I have been trying various things.... I like their Stromboli and pizzas. They do have slices but so far have only done a whole custom. Like their bead so thumbs up Negative so far was the eggplant sub. This is a do not order... While it looked tasty it was mainly breaking and bread and hardly any eggplant. Plus their fries are the kind that have a coating on them... I don't understand why anyone needs to add a coating to fries.... Now I figured these items are brought in frozen..,, and I don't mind that but in this case it's a no no no.... In fact if this was all we had the rating would have been a 1.... But we come here for their meat sauce! At least for us it's a winner! A side plus is they are a couple doors from Sugar Momma's which is a great place for a soup of ice cream afterwards.... A great double header! read more

King's NY Pizza - Eggplant sub with fries - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

This is not NY Pizza I'll tell you that upfront and first most. This place is confused if it wants to be a sit down restaurant or a take out diner. With minimal seating available the "waitresses" attempt you to sit down a take an order just for them to get a tip. This a poor design when you could just have people order from a register. Now for the food. It's average and lacking real flavor. I had a steak and cheese which lacked any real flavor and couldn't hit the mark of being worth $8. The pizza is on the same boat, soggy and flavorless. The really need restructure their restaurant and fix the cooks who just seem like they have given up. read more

See all

Probably the best, or one of the best pizza delivery restaurants in the Fairfax area. While delivery pizza (even the better ones) tend to be relatively disappointing on the whole, this one really does taste quite good, even if they *didn't* offer delivery. The pizzas are really large (the largest is 18 inches) and use high quality cheese and toppings. The only thing that could use improvement is the bland and dry pizza crust, that is a let-down (costing my rating one star). Adding to the great pizza, the pricing on the pies is extremely fair (even if it was pick-up only). Oh yes, they even sell huge slices too! Highly recommended for both delivery and pickup alike. read more