Love the crispy thin crust on these pies especially mikes hot honey, eggplant and meatball ricotta pies. Fast and friendly service. read more

See all

We went on a Sunday after picking my mom up at the airport across the street at 12:30pm. We weren't sure it was open as there was only one car in front and it was very dark inside. There was one other table of people. The food at Anthony's is always reliably good. We ordered the large salad, wings and a pizza with 1/2 mushrooms. The service and food were both good. The bathrooms however were horribly dirty. I'm assuming we were the second group of guests for the day and the sink was so grimy it looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a month and it smelled that way. When I mentioned it to the waitress she apologized and said she didn't notice because she never goes in there, and she would let someone know. There was no manager around, which surprised me because the manager at the Commack store is always there asking how everything was, and it's always clean. On the way out I noticed the door was so covered with hand prints you could barely see through the glass. We love the Commack location, but won't be going back to this one. read more

I ordered the eggplant marino. This is a simple dish...eggplant, tomato sauce with pecorino cheese on a pizza dough. It was inedible. Eggplant was burnt, very hard and indigestible. I complained at check-out that the meal was inedible. The cashier/waiter just sort of smiled. I was too annoyed to complain further. I will NEVER go back...nor should you! read more

You guys. I don't know if people think of this as a go to for wings, but seriously please do. The dry rub wings are the most delicious thing ever. I also go broccoli rabe and sausage which was yummy but standard, exactly as expected. Focaccia came with sauce that has BIG TIME improved since the last time I tried it, and the lovely server gave me some extra to take home :) The Italian Tuna sandwich is awesome, get it for lunch - it's probs the best sandwich on the menu. Not fishy, not smushy - it's perfect. I'm sorry I didn't review the coal fired pizza because duh, that seems like a real miss but all the other food was great! Also to note, the servers were so nice and attentive! Everyone is greeting you, thanking you, telling you have a great night - they're just so pleasant which isn't found everywhere these days. Minus one star because I think it could look cleaner. Nothing is overly dirty and I wouldn't eat there if it were, but the cleaning spray needs to be put away and not just left on a table waiting for the next use, and the floor could use a good sweep during the dinner service. Pepperoni on a dark floor makes me nervous of buggies. But - it's not that bad and the food and the people make up for it! read more

The pizza was delicious! I love the different combinations they presented in the menu. We've ordered half buffalo shrimp and half shrimp Alfredo. The strawberry lemonade was refreshing. There is abundant parking in the lot. It is shared with a Starbucks. read more

See all

We ordered out for work at a hotel. Delivery driver walked up to the door and was greeted friendly with tips ready to be passed for the pizza, but decided to place the pizza on top of trash on front of the hotel room door and walk away. I'm from Europe and being used to authentic Italian pizza I'm always skeptical when it comes to getting pizza expecting American pizza which I do not like at all. My colleagues were not too crazy about it and I ended up taking the leftovers home bc I was the only one who did. But I for one loved the pizza, primarily the crust. It was crispy, thin, charred on the bottom to the point it was black on some areas. Granted it might've been burnt on their side (we ordered a half and half pizza). My half was the Hawaiian (I know, pineapple right? But it can work when done right) The toppings were a tiny bit bland and they substituted the prosciutto for bacon so totally different experience and slightly disappointing. Also the pineapple chunks were nice and small but could've been spread out a little better as there were a few clusters and the rest was bare. All in all I liked the pizza more than any other pizza I've had in the past bc it was the closest to authentic Italian one had. It could've been better had it been prepared with the original toppings (prosciutto) and the tomatoes been seasoned. I can't speak for price, service or ambiance because our supervisor ordered dinner for us but the driver definitely needs to improve his people skills. read more

The pizza was perfectly cooked and tasty. The chicken ceaser salad was exceptional and the service was great

Nice happy hour options and good food. Great value also with the $5 deals offered. The service was good.

I've been past this place a number of times over the years but never visited until this weekend. It was later on a Saturday night and there was ample parking and seating. We were seated right away and were able to order drinks and appetizers within minutes of being seated. I ordered a lemonade off their menu that had Tito's in it. It was very good! We also ordered the shrimp scampi appetizer, a pizza with all the meat, and an order of meat balls. Everything came out in a decent amount of time. Nothing was really hot with the exception of the pizza. As our food came out we asked our server for plates so we could eat our pizza and she politely agreed however she proceeded to take the order of a large group, about 6 adults and 7-8 children, before going to get our plates. Anyone who has ever served or seen a large group served, this isn't a quick task. After 5 minutes of waiting we asked another employee for plates so our food wouldn't get cold. Other than that moment of neglect from the server, she was fine. If you're going to Anthony's, check out their lemonade (mixed with alcohol or not) and their pizza. stay away from the scampi unless you like spicy scampi. read more

See all

Love the wings, plenty of selection and the char that comes from the wings. Good pizza options as well

Stopped in at this Coal fired pizza Anthony's Italian restaurant in Bohemia out East. It's a chain that I don't recall being in. Seems they started out in Florida and have expanded to many areas including Nassau and Suffolk New York. 1st time there, I asked the waiter's suggestion. Spot on 10 inch pizza with ricotta cheese and meatballs along with my side of great garlic knots and gravy/ sauce. Delicious and to much at one sitting for me. Cardboard boxes to take home and much needed wet naps and napkins. Ah But, always room for dessert. Chocolate cake and cappuccino made by the waiter not at the bar. The latter didn't have much taste. So I go to their pretty bar tender and I ask if they make mimosas. She was unfamiliar with cava and nope they do not stock OJ. Seems years ago they did Sunday specials and all the chains follow suit stopping OJ use. No place to charge phone unless you have a plug adapter. There is room for handicap access including the bathrooms with cut pix on the doors. ( see pix of inside areas) some pictures of guest that appear hand signed board in back for Bohemias best!, and a view of the Pizza man at work at the oven. They take credit cards or have a QR to pay along with app and rewards plan. I'll go back again. read more

See all

Excellent thin crust pizza. Fresh ingredients. Good service Really the best pizza around . Once you go there, you'll be a regular read more

I have a great experience every time I visit. The bartenders are just awesome, friendly and always attentive. The service is outstanding, food is great and atmosphere is fun and relaxing. read more

Best gluten-free pizza I've ever had! And their wings are gluten-free and amazing! I found Anthony's in the Find Me Gluten-Free app and it was very close to my hotel, so I went with my girlfriend. The server, Sam, was super helpful and we ordered 10 wings as an appetizer: 5 original (caramelized onion) and 5 Garlic Romano, with the bread on the side for my partner. They are amazing, and the flavor from the coal-fired oven is unique. I ordered their 12" gluten-free pizza with prosciutto, black olives and artichoke hearts. All of their toppings are gluten-free except the sausage. It was amazing. We both had slices and agreed we couldn't tell it was gluten-free. I've had just about every pizza joint's gluten-free pies, and this one tops them all. I waited a day to leave this review so I could tell you that I had zero bad reactions or side effects. Can't wait to go back! read more

Drink specials are crazy here! Buy one get one free drinks... couldn't believe it. 2 beers for like $7 when I'd willing pay $7 for even one... Pizza was great. Happy hour is pretty good My minus star is just for the cleanliness of the restaurant. The bathroom wasn't stocked and there were bugs flying around the two times I went. It didn't stop me from going back since the deals were that great but I feel like that could be an easy thing to fix. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

We ordered in and had great wings! I loved their chopped salad! The coal fire pizza with hot honey was delicious! I highly recommend!

This was above and beyond. My first time ever at one of these locations and Tiff my server was as sweet as can be! Very charming! Enjoyed my food very much! Meatball appetizer and a caprese 'small' (6 slice) pizza! Delicious! Would definitely come back! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Carprese - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

The food is great and so is the inside it's right next to the crappy long island MacArthur airport which frontier is trash never go anyway you should go it is great so like always 5 STARS read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

The restaurant is fully seated most times. We had take out and although it was busy we were able to order our pizzas quickly. We ordered a chicken alfredo artichoke pie and sausage topped pizza. The restaurant has a lot of hard surfaces so it is rather noisy. There are several flat screens tuned to a sports channel. The restaurant is always clean and staff is attentive. read more

Great roasted cauliflower pizza - I've had other items here but this one item is why I go back-garlicky deliciousness!

You can't because it was my first and last time. I went last night, the service was HORRIBLE. First, the waitress never came over that the server had to keep calling her for my table. Then when we ordered, SHE asked ME, if she should bring the wings out as an appetizer and I said no, bring it all out together so we can eat together. She said perfect and not even 6 mins later, my wings are on the table and then my dinner. We weren't even served our drinks to enjoy before our food. My food was completely done, no drinks, my guests food wasn't even there. We never saw the waitress again until I stood up and was furious and then she brings us over a HUGE CRAPPY salad and said I gave you a large salad instead of a small. No charge. For more lettuce???? After all of that, the meatballs were So bland , the sauce taste worse then a jar and the pizza had zero taste. We took it all with us. I WILL NEVER GO BACK OR RECOMMEND THIS PLACE EVER!!! Service, food and timing.. 3 staples to a successful restaurant and they were horrible at all 3. read more

Paulies pie is a must!!! Delicious pizza just wish it was a little more crispy . Service was great read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Consistent for an Anthony's CFP, our server was very nice but the bartended who came from behind the bar to seat us was abrupt and rude. I was surprised and disappointed that they Anthony's, not just this location so no reflection on them) discontinued the ribs from their menu...it was, without a doubt, the best appetizer item in their menu. Anthony's were better years ago and maybe they would benefit from a fresh look ... but leave the menu alone, guys. read more

Food was great. Service was exceptional. Emma is far the best waitress anywhere. She is very personable. She takes the order perfectly. She Checks in periodically to make sure everything is good. read more

This Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza is located on Veterans Highway the entrance to Islip McArthur Airport. Years ago there was a diner here but apparently it just got old and tired and didn't survive. Step in Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. I've passed here hundreds of times and it usually looks closed and rarely do I ever see cars in the parking area. Well today I had to go to the airport to get my boarding pass for a flight to Indianapolis tomorrow. On the way home my wife says "why don't we give them a try. Sure, if they're open. Sure enough they are open. Although pizza in the name, this is not your typical pizzeria. There's a full bar and a number of tables for dining. A really lovely waitress seats us and brings menus. We ordered the "Pizza for Two ", and a couple of drinks. To be honest, the pizza for two is not enough for two adults, but we just wanted a quick bite to eat so it was enough for us. However, in looking over the menu I noticed several meals I would love to try, particularly their "Eggplant Marino ", and very reasonably priced. Overall I was surprisingly pleased and will definitely return, if not to this location, one of their other locations. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Make Anthonys Great Again! Ashley For Manager 2024! Great Location, Great Food, Great Service read more

While on the road traveling for work I stopped here to place a to-go order. There is a location near my home in PA and they are always consistent with quality food. Unfortunately this location didn't meet the expectations. The woman who took my order was friendly and helpful. It did not take long to wait for my meal and everything was accounted for. When I got to my hotel room down the street and took a bite of my Coal Oven chicken sandwich, the chicken was chewy/rubbery. Almost like it wasn't cooked enough but there was no pink. It takes me a lot to not eat something but I had to pull it out! The amount of chicken in both halves would not even fill one half of the sandwich bread. I'm just very disappointed as the location by my home has never disappointed me. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Over cooked chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

This Anthony's deserves another 4 from me. It's about 15 minutes away from my house and it's pretty good pizza. Now I know it isn't anywhere as close to being like Grimaldi's but for a chain... for what it's worth... it's pretty good. My chief and top complaint for this location is the parking. Let me just say this and I'm putting it very mildly! The parking situation is terrible!!! Granted this is really not Anthony's and Starbucks' fault but man! It stinks! It's so bad that you can give your car to valet and they can park your car for you! Other than that our waitress was quick and polite and we got our energy back and ready to run some errands! If you like crispy thin crust pizza and don't want to wait at Grimaldi's come to Anthony's. It's not as awesome as Grimaldi's but it'll fix some of your hankerings. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Regular Lunch Size Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

No better establishment all seasons for after dinner drinks, birthday party food, and definitely corporate events!!! Don't hesitate to stop by if you're traveling!!! Right by the airport they do an excellent job. Atmosphere, cleanliness, unbeatable bartenders who bring the place to life. Been coming here for years, but had one of there newbie bartenders tonight. Shout out to Front of House Kelly & Carla the bartender(Spanish speaking also :))!!! Special Thanks always to Ashley, Tara & Jess! True professionals and should never go unnoticed. read more

I had an amazing time at Anthony's coal fired pizza today! To start the happy hour is one of the best out there. 3-6 pm m-fri. Next comes the food. As a vegan items are obviously limited. I got the salad no cheese and garlic knots no cheese. Lastly I got a large pizza no cheese plus assorted veggies. I wish there was a veggie pizza so it wouldn't cost as much. Each item costed 2.50 more.... My pie alone came to 28.00... overall awesome spot but a little pricy for the pizza read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

See all

Had a 3 hour delay at airport, so we grabbed an Uber and drove the 4min over to Anthony's (it was below freezing w bags They sat us right away, and we split a salad (huge) and meatballs. Both were fresh tasty and meatballs were hot which helped given the temps outside. Got us in and out and back to airport in plenty of time for our flight! read more

I have been coming here for years and it's safe to say they never disappoint! The service is wonderful and the employees make you feel like family. I have met some great people over the years as a regular and always enjoy my time here. The food is consistently amazing and they are always adding new items! - 100% recommend Anthony's! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Personal Margherita pizza with meatball sauce. (Customized) - Pizza Near Me - Bohemia, New York

Had their food for the first time. The broccoli rabe sand-which was awesome. The garlic knots were very good because I love garlic. But over baked on the top and bottom. Looking forward to trying their wings in the future. read more

I was craving a crispy thin pizza and we found we past this location on our way home. We decided to do take out. Ally answered and was very friendly. We ordered a small Neapolitan pie. When we arrived the order came out very quickly and was hot. When we got home you could tell the pizza should have been cooked a little more. Besides that it had a Good amount of sauce and cheese. Sauce had a really nice flavor. read more

Great place! Would recommend. We have been there twice while staying in LI for baseball. Great food/pizza and beer menu. Wait staff was great! read more

I come here every Friday. The service is fantastic. Ashley is the best and makes it a joy to eat and relax after a long week.

Awesome garlic knots and wings! Ashley is the best! Pizza is great! Good spot for dinner and lunch

Great service. We come here as a crew from work every Friday. Ashley makes sure we get the best service.

I'm waiting to pick up my son at the airport. My wife said oooh! Lets get a table at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza! I walk in and my wife went crazy! She ordered a big salad, a platter of meatballs and three pizzas. I ordered a draft beer, let's get the party started! There's a big sign: our pizza is Well Done. Got it, it's coal fired. Charr is good. The meatballs come out, not too bad. Meatballs, mixed salad and a draft beer. It's not a culinary stretch so far. Now the pizzas comes out. Well done? Well done what?? The crust is like cardboard! Anthony's is a chain from Florida, how they're thriving in New York of all places boggles my mine. The crust on all three pizzas is weird, almost like a stale cracker. Now the bill comes, $100 bucks?! Folks, if you like this pizza then rock on. Second time visiting this chain, I hope to never return. read more

Not the only Antony's location I've been to. This one also didn't disappoint. Great hostess, service & food. Close to MacArthur airport, so if you are hungry upon returning from a flight or your heading out, it's a convenient location to airport. Restroom clean. read more