Amazing pizza as long as you order it there. However...I ordered a XL pizza double meat. I had it delivered. Needless to say it wasn't double meat. In fact at least half of the slices had no meat on them. So I called to ask about what was going on and why I was charged for a double meat pizza and didn't receive it. " Well what do you want me to do about it?" was the response. I have noticed that if you order it there one topping is fine as they don't do it as sparingly.. read more

Pizza is good. Service is mediocre at best. Also they still dont have coupons available and it is high priced - 40 for a med pizza and breadsticks is a little high read more

This place is a winner. We've been here a few times now since they opened in downtown Geneva and have had a great experience each time. During Swedish Days they were packed but we still were able to get a nice seat on the patio. We love this pizza. Our favorite is the basic pepperoni thin crust. The wait staff have shirts that say it's in the sauce and I'd agree. The sauce is what makes this pizza. You gotta try it. Service has always been top notch and we'll continue to be regulars here. read more

Great rehearsal dinner, perfect private room and this pizza was delicious

Wow, no reviews until mine? Aurelio's is MK's favorite pizza place on Earth. I had never had it until we married. (11/20/08) We ordered up a "Fiesta" Cheese and Sausage (18"). The pizza has that sweet tomato sauce that several Chicago places have become famous for. Just the right cheese, sauce and sausage. It's pick-up/delivery only which is a shame because I'd like to sit down and order sandwiches off the menu at some point. Also they don't deliver to North Aurora which means I need to spend gas money to go get it, but you know what? I do. As I've said many times, "best pizza" could be debated from now until the end of this millenium, so you just need to find what you like and get it. Aurelios is mostly SouthSide but has been in this location for at LEAST 3 years now. They must be doing just fine. read more

The atmosphere was absolutely lovely. Service was good. Gluten free pizza were average read more

well....mixed review. Great margaritas, great service (awesome waiter). Not so keen on the pizza.

This is the quintessential family dinner place. It can be pricier for a family of 6 like us, but the food is awesome and we love being downtown Geneva! If you are not a fan of noisier, busy places then you might need to catch them on a slower night, but we love it! read more

We came here with a big group when we were in town for our wedding. The service was fantastic - we were not an easy crowd and our waiter did an excellent job accommodating all our whims, refilling our beers and was just generally great. The food was good. We ordered salads and pizza - there was plenty to go around and the price was reasonable. The best part of Aurelio's is the back patio. The ambiance is dynamite - a great place to dine with friends. read more

We had a wonderful time at Aurelio's last night. All thanks to our server, Matt. That young man can teach a thing or two about customer service. He was polite, smiled the entire time, did not push us out the door and was just so pleasant. When I didn't care for the wine, he brought me something else. He didn't make a big deal about it. So accommodating. I'm sure the owner will miss this young man when he leaves. I'll miss seeing him when I go back. The pizza was great, as was the antipasto. While we sat inside, they have a lovely outdoor space in the back that doesn't make you feel like your sitting behind a concrete parking lot. Very nicely covered. Great ambiance. The bar area also seemed friendly, and we did not spend any time sitting at the bar, the space looked great. Will definitely go back. Quick note - parking in a Thursday evening could be a bit tricky as the public parking the next block over is taken up by the car show. But we didn't mind walking the extra couple of blocks. read more

We go every Sunday for pizza our server her name is Sam she is the best. When we arrive our drinks are at her table she's always bubbly happy to help us whatever we may need. Thanks for taking care of Sam. read more

Went here tonight with a group of friends. The food was pretty good. Got the fried mushrooms and jalapeño poppers for our app. The fried mushrooms were great. Not a huge fan of the poppers. We ordered The Works pizza and everyone loved that especially the sauce. Why three stars? The service was just okay. Our waiter would come ask/answer a question and then disappear. It took awhile before we were able to order our meal and then leave at the end. Would try again, thanks to the pizza. read more

I visited Aurelio's yesterday with my family for a dinner. It had been a while since I dined at Aurelio's, so we were looking forward to it. We were waited on by Kaylie and had a busboy named Rylan and both were extremely pleasant and attentive. I can't say enough about them, and they are a credit to their employer. We had a couple of orders of garlic bread and a large, family style dinner salad for beginners and it really hit the spot. I really like their house dressing and their garlic bread is consistently good. The best part is the pizza. We went with a traditional sausage thin crust, and a small pizza with some olives and tomato slices for the wife, who likes to try healthier options. I remembered this time to ask for the pizzas to be "well done", because while Aurelio's has a really nice crust on their pizza, having them cook the pizza just a little longer ensures a truly crisp crust. Neglecting to ask for well done will sometimes result in the center pieces of the pizza having a softer crust. Their sauce is clearly their selling point. There's something about it. It's sweet or something, but it's great and it's almost addictive. Even when I was full from eating too much, I wanted more. No room for dessert after my dinner there. Overall, it was a great experience. Their outdoor patio dining area was really nice with a great atmosphere. The pizza was as good as I've had it there, and the service couldn't have been better. I've had three or four star visits there in the past, but they seem to have kicked it up a notch. Last night was truly an outstanding experience. read more

Aurelio's Pizza has been our "go-to" pizza since moving to the Geneva area. Their pizza is amazing. And I think most of the reviews will not argue with this. They moved from their "take out" storefront a couple years ago and the new location is a great restaurant. Friendly and accommodating staff. They have a outdoors patio in the back that is very cozy. Away from nearby traffic. read more

Got the chicken parm and the salads good, bread is decent, noodles and chicken decent Lotta food read more

SO DISAPPOINTED! The waitstaff was great - masks on and respectful of the state mandates but the management did NOT require guests to wear masks to their tables or while walking around the restaurant or outside. When questioned, the owner acted oblivious to this. Better pizza places will be getting our future business. We have a moral commitment to keep each other safe - Aurelio's doesn't appear to care about anything other than $. read more

I like pizza of all kinds but haven't quite been able to find pizza like Aurelio's anywhere else. The service at this location has always been friendly and helpful. It just makes me feel at home. read more

Just the facts. - Decided to give it another try. - Seated quickly. - Ants, yes ants start crawling all over the table and wall - Notified hostess and she reseats us across the room. Not even an apology. - They wipe off the table and seat another group at the table of ants! read more

It's been a while since I had been here so a few friends and I decided to give a shot. The moral of our story was that we had an enjoyable meal and drinks. We started out with a mixed appetizer plater filled w/ somewhat (not really) spicy boneless wings along w/mushroom poppers and fried ravioli. Throw in a few beers and we were on our way. We then had the deep dish pizza w/sausage that was packed with cheese and sauce. Add a few more drinks and we certainly were no longer in Kansas though Dorothy might have stopped by. Overall a great meal. The only complaint was it did get kind of noisy but maybe that's a good thing. People must like this place. read more

The appetizers as usual were very tasty. I was very happy with the service and we sat right away. The pizzas were awesome. My favorite was the traditional cheese but the roasted red pepper, onion and sausage was in the running also. The crust is outstanding, with a hint of oven baked taste. "I will be back" read more

See all

We walked into Aurelio's tonight, and even though it was a Friday it wasn't that busy. We were seated, and about 10-15 minutes later no server came to our table. We requested a server (at this point we should have left), and a server came by. We placed our entire order at once- including drinks, a salad and 2 pizzas. We got our drinks right away. After another approximately 20 minutes (maybe more) we still didn't even have a salad. At this point we just asked the server to cash out for our drinks so we can leave. I've read plenty of reviews about the service and it's never been great here, but wow. We just walked out with no food. I can't imagine ever returning. read more

Family went looking for a place to eat and drove thru Geneva and came across Aurelio's. Parking was easy to find on the street - got a booth right away and got comfortable. Food was very good and the young waitress very friendly. We'll be coming back to this place again. Family of 4 we spent $55 including tip. read more

Best beer garden around! Love this place! Great food, attentive and intuitive owners who are friendly and engage with their customers; a rarity nowadays...Check it out! read more

Great pizza. Carry out or eat in its always good. Great service.

We were excited to try the thin crust pizza. Unfortunately, the pizza was incredibly salty. Very disappointed! We spent $28 on a large two topping pizza and threw most of it away. read more

Horrible place. The pizza was disgusting and way over priced. I will never go there again!!

Every time my husband and I visit Geneva we eat at Aurelio's. The pizza is always delicious and on our last visit we ordered the wings which were exceptionally good. Our bartender/server Trish was amazing! She was so friendly and attentive. Our only complaint is that Trish wasn't able to pour draft beers. Not sure why because she was clearly over 21. As a result, we had to wait between rounds which was a bummer because we were on a getaway and weren't driving since our hotel was a block away. read more

My family tried this place for the first time and had a poor experience. Our server was nice but nearly non existent, my chicken for my Caesar salad was very over cooked and was difficult to chew, the pizza was more like a pizza bread, and my father's sausage was raw which he didn't realize until eating a good part of it. Our check was discounted but definitely not worth food poisoning. read more

This pizza is one of my all time favorites, next to Aggatucci's in Peoria, IL. Aurelios sauce has a hint of sweetness, not a typical pizza sauce. The mix of cheeses on top is perfect. It's cooked on a rack to give the crust a crunchiness. Overall, one of Chicago's best pizzas! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni pizza. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Visiting the area from CA. Found Aurelio's on Yelp so thought we would try it. We found it to be very nice, the staff was very accommodating and the service was good for being a very busy night As far as I am concerned the food was outstanding! I had their Italian beef sandwich, best I've ever had. My wife had a Spinach Salad and we shared a small pizza. Like I said the food was outstanding read more

Placed an order for delivery of gluten free pizza and fries. The fries were in a paper bag. Once I opened the bag I saw the fries were in a clear plastic container that was melted. This container did not appear to be suitable for hot items. Because of the toxins in plastic and potential for leaching in the food or just plain eating melted plastic, I tossed the fries. My children did not like the pizza and only took 1 bite each. The order was a waste. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Plastic warped from hot food. Not a container meant for hot items. Totally melted - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

Best pizza I've ever had anywhere!!! Only recommendation I have is if you like your Cheese on the pizza to be crispier, ask for it well done. Whenever we see an Aurelio's we have to stop! Great service at this location and we enjoyed our dinner read more

Poor service. Our waitress only came to the table to take our order, give us our food, and give us our check. We had to go and find someone to let them know they gave us the wrong pizza. They finally gave us what they thought was the right pizza but it turned out our waitress misheard our order. It is an extremely noisy restaurant so we were not surprised. We had been there a long time so we just ate whatever pizza they had for us. To top it off, they made us wait a long time to give us our check so we could leave. The pizza quality was ok but should have been a lot better for the price. There are so many places to get good pizza in this area....you shouldn't have to pay a lot and put up with lousy service. Overall a disappointing 1st and only visit we will make there. read more

The only reason this location gets 2 stars is because I LOVE the pizza. Grew up eating Aurelio's (in Homewood - the original location) and still crave it! However, after my family of 4 excitedly went to the new sit-down location in Geneva, IL we left so disappointed. While the pizza was as good as ever the service was awful. Also, we couldn't get over the fact that the prices were so high! I swear they must have raised their prices 20% compared to when they were just takeout across the street. It cost my family almost $80 for 2 pizzas, 4 sodas, and a small salad. I am still having sticker shock! Hate to say it, but even with gas prices so high, I would rather make the drive to the Addison location for fresh eat-in Aurelio's! At least there the wait staff seems happy to wait on you and the prices are not as expensive... read more

Have to say I was a little disappointed after our first visit. We ordered the stuffed pizza which was loaded with sauce that tasted like Ragu, very bland. The pizza in my opinion was the worst I have ever had. I'll have to try their thin pizza next time. My son ordered a sandwich and wanted mustard. Can you believe they don't have mustard? We thought it was very odd that a restaurant wouldn't have mustard. Even though I had a bad experience I will try them one more time. Hopefully the thin pizza will be a hit. read more

Great place for meeting up with family and friends! Love the beer garden outside with beautiful lights! Spectacular pizza, apps, salad, etc.!! Enjoy their famous thin crust pizza, or try their stuffed pizza. Everything is good! read more

We ordered an appetizer to start, they came out fast however they tasted like they were microwaved yet the insides of the poppers and cheese sticks were COLD. Halfway through our app we ordered 2 - 6 inch pizzas, 50 minutes later we finally received them, thankfully they were still warm! However during that 50 minutes we had absolutely zero communication from our waitress, and other people had already gotten their food, after being sat after us! The pizza was decent but not worth a 50 minute wait for a small 6 inch thin crust pizza. Will never return. Not worth the price either. We could have ordered delivery from some where else for faster, and cheaper! read more

Great service and awesome food! I prefer a traditional Chicago style thick pizza, but Aurelio's thin crust is amazing!!!

First, the best part: our server, Lora, was one of those rare servers that makes you want to come back to a place, just because of the service. The second best thing was the dessert: a chocolate chip cookie, served warm in a pan, topped with vanilla ice cream, a mountain of whipped cream, and topped with some mini chocolate chips. Nothing else was worthwhile. We had previously eaten at the Aurelios at 83rd St. and Rt. 59 in Aurora, and it was not bad. So, when we found ourselves in Geneva, at about 8 p.m. on a Thursday evening, without having eaten dinner, we saw Aurelios, and stopped for a bite. The Italian Submarine Sandwich was probably the worst I have ever had, anywhere. The large, wad of ham, at the base of the ingredients, so overwhelmed all of the other flavors, that it was like grabbing a 1/4 pound of sliced ham, rolling it up, and biting into it. There were no discernible condiments on sandwich. No mayo, no mustard, no italian dressing, no oil & vinegar. Just a smattering of some other meat, cheese, lettuce and tomato on a large wad of ham, on a toasted bun. The chopped salad and the Antipasto salad were very large, but mundane, the key to both being the dressing. The house dressing (Italian) did not make these salads. (The BEST chopped salad dressing, anywhere, is at Portillos.) The Antipasto salad looked good, until it became clear that the bowl was mostly lettuce, TOPPED with some antipasto ingredients. The worst thing: just before we left, our daughter went to use the restroom. While she was in there, someone started mopping the floor outside the door to the restroom. She came out, slipped on the wet floor, and slammed her knee into the floor. The swabby, said, "Oh, I didn't know anyone was in there. I should have put out a 'slippery when wet' sign," which he, then, did. Lora, our server, empathized, but no one offered to document the incident. This morning, our daughter's knee is badly bruised and very swollen. Bottom line: if this was the first Aurelios we had ever been to, it would have been the last. read more

The hostesses wear shirts that say "It's the Sauce" on the back. Yup, it is the sauce that make the pizza pretty nasty. Sorry, but we aren't fans of Aurelio's. We were in Geneva during the Festival of the Wine event. Not wanting to spend an arm and a leg on food at the fest, we decided to get a pizza. It was around dinner time on a Saturday and the wait was around 20 minutes. Once we were seated it was pretty evident that our server was frazzled and appeared to be taking care of half the dining room. When he finally took our drink order, we had already decided on what we wanted so we ordered everything at once. We got 2 drinks, salad to split and a pizza. Salad/drinks came out as expected as well as the pizza. When the pizza came I asked for additional ranch sauce which I didn't get for a while. At one point he stopped, looked at our table and exclaimed "Ranch" and went to go get it. The pizza though...ick. Sorry but the sauce is rank. The first slice you eat is fine but after a while it just gets to ya. It has a vinegeary taste. At some points we were just picking the toppings off and eating that, or as my bf did, he scrapped the sauce completely off. Maybe people like that? It was just weird. We had a lot of pizza left and we didn't even take it with us. Sorry Aurelio's but your sauce is not good. read more