Trying NY style pizza! Drink options are limited - water, Coke products, sparkling water and some alcoholic beverages. Service was great it's a sit yourself down type of place but the staff is super welcoming and get to your table right away. Both pizzas were delicious ! Will definitely be back read more

See all

Thoughtful service Delicious pizza with top ingredients Nice appetizers No wait to be seated read more

OMGGGG Nemecs is IT! Located in downtown Geneva, this small casual pizza joint has 1 of the best tavern style pizzas I've had. I love that they offer individual slices from 12pm-4pm. It's a great option if you want to try a variety. They also have daily happy hour specials from 2-4pm. I stopped in on a Saturday around 130pm and there were a few families dining in and a good number of people picking up orders for carry out. There's about 30ish-40 indoor seats. Service was quick since the slices are already made and just need a quick warm up before being served. I tried the mikes hot honey pepperoni, white pie, and the supreme. My favorite was the mikes hot honey pep pizza. The crust is crispy while all the ingredients go well together. You get the hot and the sweet. Going forward I'll probably get a whole pizza of this vs getting it by the slice. read more

See all

Best pizza outside of NY. Glad they have a location in Geneva to avoid the traffic (and possible boot/tow) going to zaza's. Reheated great as well. Super glad they offered beef pepperoni. Our server was also friendly. I'll be a monthly customer and live an hour south of here so if you're local, give it a shot. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - FIBONACCI PIE - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

The pizza was really good. We had the thin crust. First time in on a Thursday. Not crowded in the restaurant but lots of takeout pickups. House wine was good.service was just okay. We will be back. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Amazing food. When they got the female chef the quality got better. I go all the time with my daughter and she loves to see a girl working because she loves to cook. Went yesterday and even as the chef she was serving because they didn't have staff and was training she is always so collected and takes time at the tables. And always stops to help whoever is working with her. Never ignores questions despite being busy. That girl is the business in geneva. Her name is Kay I think only tatted one with red hair. I thought she was an owner the way she cares. She is single handily making sure that locations run. read more

Hands down one of the best pizza places in the suburbs and they're sister restaurant Zazas in the city is also one of the best in Chicago. This place is comparable if not better than most pizza in nyc. I would definitely recommend coming here for solid nyc style pizza and ask them to make it well done for the extra crunch! read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

GREAT customer service! I ordered 3 different pizzas and each were excellent. Loved the choices that were offered to customize your pizza . Will definitely will order again. read more

Best pizza in the area, hands down! Pricey, but so worth the quality of ingredients and the flavor. Nemec Bros and ZaZas is BETTER than Little Pops, Pie Life, and the Slice Spot, and tbh it's not even close. Their specialty pies are all So unique and well crafted, and as you can tell he by the pics a few slices didn't even make it home. Service is great, pizzas are great, and it's a fun spot to hang out in the downtown Geneva area. Def recommend. read more

See all

Closest thing to genuine New York style in the area. The hot honey pie is some of the best pizza i've ever had in my life. The workers are always very kind, I wish i could shake each and every cooks hand after i get done with my pizza every time i go. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - HOT HONEY PEPPERONI PIE - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

The excuse after driving 15 miles to get your "too good to go" bag offered on their site that "oh that's nothing to do with us so we cancelled the order as it keeps appearing their" isn't good enough to me. The person at the desk offered nothing else to us even though your store cancelled the order. A refund after a 30 mile round trip is not good enough. I'd suggest you get your house in order with the other company or at least offer 10-30% off for the inconvenience. Thus you get a 1 star when it could have been 5 with little effort and an upset customer. read more

I was looking forward to eat pizza for like forever since I can no her have gluten but Figured that this pizza place is popular on the social media and my son suggested to eat here since he likes it. As soon as I saw the pizza on display I knew I was not Going to like it My son order The pizza with sausage they added foam burratta I think with cheese on top of it And honey to it horrible the Saige is not Italian it Look like someone slide a hot dog and put few slices on each slice I was so mad I been saving my pizza break not to taste something like Fraser pizza which to my taste is more Italian genuine total disappointment the bread was so hard like I was eating a sub The only good was the salad The service was totally great the ambiance seeing how every one was loving the pizza was are you kidding me people don't have no more good taste buds or they don't Know how a pizza supposed to be made and the sauce should be flavor able and for heaven sakes get real Italian sauce not Something that look and Taste like a hot Dog read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

Previous visits in the last 2 years were excellent. Not today. This was the first time buying slices instead of a full pizza. Get the full pizza, it tastes a lot better. Ordered the slices and a salad as appetizer, got them at the same time which started the confusion. If there are two of you, don't sit at the square tables, as they are so small. We could not fit 2 plates and the pizza stand on a square table. My Pizza fell off the table and dumped onto the floor. My plate bounced on my chest. Table next to us opened up but waitress didn't think of moving us over to it. She never acknowledged that we were struggling. The table next to us stayed dirty till we left. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Adjacent Table Was Never Offered To Us. - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Their pizza is absolutely amazing. Best in the area. Pro tip. It's best if you eat it in the building and don't bring it home. Fresh out of the oven. AMAZING. Kids favorite too. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - This is the Mike hot pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

I've only recently heard of them from my uber eats app. I bookmarked them like 2 months ago and ordered a few days ago. Delivery was a little lengthy, and the pizza ended up being Luke warm. But I get it. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, no special requests. It was tasty. It had great potential for dine in or pick up. I decided I'm going to drop by 1 day and dine in to get a better understanding, LOL. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

My friends and I decided to stop into this location for a slice of pizza for lunch. We were able to sit anywhere we liked and greeted right away. Once you walk in, you can see all the pizzas being made and the different pies you can pick from. We opt for a slice each as we were just stopping in for a quick snack.l, but you can get a whole pizza if you'd like. All three slices were great! I had the hot honey, delicious! There is light music playing so you are able to have a conversation easily. They definitely make you feel welcomed. I will go back to try other slices for sure. They also have a happy hour, but we had just missed it! read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

Amazingggg pizza. We got the hot honey and it was absolutely delicious, comparable to El Lobo in Chicago. But very very expensive. Is it worth it to spend $44 on a 16in when you can get another pie for way less? Up to you, but I personally love specialty pizzas so I'll probably come back to try more. Salad however was very disappointing. For how much I'm spending I expect a bit more than 6 tiny croutons, but maybe I'm just picky. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - FUNKY CAESER - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

I love New York style pizza, and Nemec Brothers did not disappoint!! So so good. Everything I wanted and more. Highly recommend both of the pizzas we ordered. The classic cheese and white pies were delicious! Loved the added lemon juice for the white pie. We also ordered the thicc a*s chocolate chip cookies. Also amazing and would order again! Quick service. Was ready within 20 minutes of ordering on a Saturday night. Only con is that they are pricey! Almost $30 per pizza. Regardless, we are looking forward to trying more in the future. read more

See all

The food was excellent!! We got a classic cheese and a grandma hot honey pepperoni. Omg the crust, the fresh cheese, yum yum yum. The service was excellent, it is a little tight in there but it was totally manageable (we were there during dinner rush). Cute place, love that you can see into the kitchen. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Grandma hot honey pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Add this place to your must-visit list! I heard so many good things about Nemec's since they opened in November and was excited to give it a try! From pictures online, it looked pretty small inside so I was worried we wouldn't get a table on a Friday night. Unfortunately, they don't take reservations but you can order online to-go. We came around 5pm and had to wait 30 minutes for a table to open up (there was a big group celebrating a birthday that took up 5-6 tables though). We tried the fibonacci pie and the traditional grandma pie which was the perfect amount for 3 hungry people. I'm typically more of a New York style person but I actually preferred the grandma pie. The crust was so fluffy and the ingredients tasted so fresh. Both were good though! It is a bit on the pricier side and the tables are very cramped but overall a great addition to downtown Geneva! read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - TRADITIONAL GRANDMA and FIBONACCI PIE - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Weekday lunch slices are superb, and for what they are, a great deal. The pizzas feel a little pricy but they really are excellent. Definitely several notches above nearly anything else I've had in Fox Valley. read more

If you're looking for a solid local spot, Nemec Brothers Pizza is always a win. Great food, great staff, and just an all-around good atmosphere. The pizza is consistently awesome! Fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and you can tell they actually care about what they're putting out. The staff is friendly and welcoming without being over the top, which makes it an easy place to relax and enjoy your meal. It's one of those spots that just feels comfortable whether you're grabbing a quick bite or hanging out for a while. Definitely worth checking out if you haven't already. read more

My partner and I have travelled all across the Chicagoland area for pizza and this by far, is a top list choice. Nemec Brothers Pizzeria, sister restaurant to Zaza's Pizzeria in Chicago, is newer to downtown Geneva. While the Chicago location opened in 2022, this location just opened in the beginning of December of 2023 (this pizzeria is not to be confused with Geneva's La Zaza Trattoria restaurant). The smaller menu focuses on what they do best, new york style pizza. We tried the Signature Cheese Pie as well as the Garlic Twists to start. The prices are a bit high but you can ensure all ingredients are fresh. The Garlic Twists were perfectly doughy with garlic butter and parmesan on top. The two sauces were a fresh pesto and pureed tomato sauce. All pizzas only come in 16" sizes but they do offer slices for sale (while supplies last) till 4pm. Our pizza was cooked perfectly and we loved that the sauce was actually on top of the crust and cheese. This made it so the sauce was first to hit your palette. Also, all crusts are infused with rosemary garlic olive oil. Make a trip out to Geneva to try out Nemec Brothers; you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

It's in the same location as Osteria in Geneva. Small seating area for pizza place. They offer pizza by slice on the weekend between 12-4 pm. I went for this offering. But none of the pizza has a name in front of them, so we need to ask chefs about it. It was hard to hear them due to the kitchen sound. Once you make a decision, you need to place an order on the phone, and then the server will deliver it. Pizza sizes are big. The garlic twist was really good.. I also liked their white pizza, which is vegetarian. The mushroom truffle pizza was not that great. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

This pizza is out of this world!!! I've never eaten pizza or garlic knots like this! It was so good but also so heavy. Definitely recommend trying this place. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - GARLIC TWISTS - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Have been to Nemecs on multiple occasions for both dine in and carry out. The pizza is good and tastes just like New York in Geneva! We like the vodka sauce, the white pie and the truffle mushroom. Just beware that it does taste better at the restaurant because it gets cold fast. The dine in device is nice and the pizza is relatively quick to make! Also, they do slices if you want to stop by for a quick bite! read more

This pizza is phenomenal. It's thin, it's crunchy, it's cheesy! Just like me. Drizzle hot honey on it and perf . We got the garlic twists, they come with several dipping sauces, both are great, but my favorite was the basil. The twists itself are on the bigger size, and absolutely delicious. I wish my pillows could be garlic twists. I ordered a marg, and it was just right, good flavor. The service was quick and friendly, and the music choice was up my alley. Good rock music, good pizza, good vibes. Definitely coming back! read more

See all

A huge pizza upgrade for Geneva. I got to go as a first time. But saw how nice the dine in vibe was so I will have to be back. Pick up experience was efficient and the staff was courteous. I got the hot pepperoni pizza it was outstanding. Can't wait to try it again as a date night! read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Loved their thin-crust pizza. Crunchy bottom and a friendly atmosphere. I'll definitely be coming back--just wish the place had a bit more room... it's good enough to make you want to stay, not just eat and go! read more

Nemec Brothers definitely knows what they're doing when it comes to pizza. This place is so good, we've been in the area twice and have come here each time. It is absolutely incredible and exceeded any expectations. We were seated right away and our server answered all questions on the menu. Our first time we ordered a pepperoni pizza to share and the second time, opted for pizza by the slice. Each were equally as tasty, and make me want to try each pie they have to offer. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - PEPPERONI PIE - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

The pizza is decent. It's definitely better at the restaurant hot than for take out. But we visited for the first time today at the restaurant. It was busy and they had one server and one host with no manager on site to help. The server was doing the best he could but putting the staff in that position is bad management. Also know if there are four of you and you order two pizzas there is no table space. Instead of using two risers they stack both pizzas on one riser which takes up half the table. Overall just not a great experience. read more

We recently visited a peach fest in Geneva Il. We drove around and were surprised to find a Nemec brothers pizza(Zaza's pizza)!!!! We took our family who had never been to this type of pizza place. They were so surprised and happy with the delicious pizza and relaxing atmosphere of the restaurant. Thank you Nemec Brothers!!!! Will definitely return when in town! read more

We had tried their pizza just after they opened. It was burned, oily, over salted, and all you could taste was garlic! We each ate one slice of the pie and trashed the remainder of the $28 pizza. We said we would try them again after they had been open for a while for slices. Today, we went in for their happy hour (2-4 pm) slices at 2:10 pm. The woman just ahead of us asked about slices and they said they were out at the moment but would take about 15 minutes to make some. We sat down and were waiting to order. After sitting at a table for 10 minutes the waitress finally came over to us. We asked which slices were available and she said they were out of slices. She asked the manager about making more slices and came back to us saying they were done with slices for the day and we could only order a full pizza (just 10 minutes into their two hour happy hour). Needless to say, I don't like bait and switch and will never return to Nemec Brothers. read more

Absolutely Great Pizza! Outstanding Service! Well Priced! Local! So happy to have found Nemec's! We had a Greek salad with homemade dressing and sliced soppresata sausage (like GOOD salami). Plenty for 2 as a side! Had the Vodka Pepperoni Grandma Pie! Sicilian/Chicago style. One of the best USA pizzas I have eaten! 2.5 months into new pizzeria good luck! Yah got my business when I am in town! read more

I am giving this place 3 stars not because of the food but because of the experience. The pizza was excellent, it was thin crispy crust with the right amount of chew, it had great flavor and the lemons were a great touch, it obvious that they know what they're doing in the kitchen! The service however unfortunately wasn't great. We were seated at a dirty table, we ordered a salad that never came, and the pizza took about 45 min. A table that came in well after us received their food within about 15 min. And we had to flag down our server for plates and napkins as they didn't bring any when are food arrived. Overall we just felt a bit ignored and didn't have the best experience. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

They have the best pizza I think even better than Chicago! Another plus, the nicest people work there read more

I went there when they first opened -- the food and service were amazing. I went again today, and it was a completely different experience. The server never came to check on us once. When we asked for water, we waited 15 minutes, then had to ask again. We had to flag someone down just to get a box and the check. Even the pizza has changed -- it had barely any flavor, and both the pizza and garlic knots were overcooked. read more

We've dined here twice already. It's only been open for about a week, lol. Yes, we love pizza. This pizza is as advertised. NY style. Thin, light fluffy crust. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Great undercarriage with minimal flop. I ordered the sausage and was floored. Great taste. Spicy. I'm guessing it's made in house or procured from a local place like Josef's. NY style pizza is a bit different compared to traditional Chicago style pizza, but I like it. read more

Nemec Brothers Pizzeria - Pepperoni and cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

Went here for lunch this week and ordered the grandma vodka sauce pie and the bacon jam pie. Flavors were creative and delicious. But at $30+ per pie it's a bit overpriced for what you get. I'd love for this to be my go to place for pizza but am afraid it will be only for special occasions at those prices. They also pass along the credit card fee to customers so that's a bit much after paying what we did. It's a nice unique option for us in the western suburbs and I hope they are successful. read more

We stopped into this place when it opened just because we were walking by on our way to the car so just poked our nose in to see what this new place on State Street was. As we entered several very young servers bum rushed us at the door and said "we are closed" - we said that's ok we just wanted to see what this place is - can we see or take a menu? They told us to go on line. So we decided we were never going to come here. BUT we kept hearing from friends how good the pizza is so we swallowed our pride and ordered. WOW was it good!! It's on the expensive side but it was really good. Definitely will have again as a treat. read more