This is a place to avoid! Ordered at 5:20 and at 7:05 still no food. When did finally arrived it was cold. I had to reheat the shrimp fra Diablo, the salad packed on top of the fra Diablo was warm, I threw the salad out. The food itself was not very good. Overdone shrimp and linguine soaked in thick sauce. Even the bread was yuk. Wasn't really a nice piece of crunchy Italian but what appeared to be a pizza crust, maybe focaccia not sure but very dry and crumbly. Paid a lot for this dinner, waited a long long time, was hoping the wait was worth it, but NOT. read more

Solid 4, maybe more, in first visit. Selection was broad at many price points...all dishes we tried were delicious and nicely presented. Attentive service and good cocktails. We'll be back! read more

The food here is great. The service is great too. and the ambiance is quaint. This place reminds me so much of spots in Manhattan.

A little gem in Brewster/Southeast! We have catered food from them for many weeks for a few years of Alpha Marriage program at St Lawrence so we have eaten most of the items on their menu, The food was amazing week after week!! Chicken Florentine, Sorrentino, Adolina, Francese, Parmesan all fantastic!! Florentine was our favorite but all were delicious! Eggplant rollantini, pasta primavera, Sachetti pasta, and Orecchiette with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage all delicious!!! The salads are great as well! Aversano, Greek and Gorgonzola were the three we loved!! Thank you Aversano's for helping making our marriage program a hit !!! read more

Aversanos is that one local restaurant that you can always count on to have good consistent Italian food. Their catering services are excellent as well. This past summer, I had a pretty large outdoor party and ordered a few trays of food. Not only were the trays delivered on time but they were fresh, piping hot, and most importantly, delicious! The chicken Florentine was a huge hit. It is so nice when all of your party guests compliment the food. It was a no brainer that this past Christmas dinner was catered by Aversanos. The prices are reasonable and they always offer a coupon. The take out or dine in menu offers much variety and the food is of course delicious. They have a nice assortment of soups and specialty pizzas to choose from. Located in a shopping center is a plus for parking. Definitely the best Italian restaurant in the area. read more

The food I've ordered is consistently delicious. Service is good; orders are ready in a timely manner. The restaurant is clean.

No gloves. Worker was using bare hands to move chopped bacon from a pan to a large plastic bag. He then took my credit card, used the touch screen to ring up my order, and handed my card back. Without washing hands in-between Then continued to use dirty bare hands to touch the bacon. What happens in the back where we can't see food prep? The food is always good, so I hate to leave bad feedback, but this is unacceptable. read more

Best Sicilian pizza pie in the NY/ CT area... meals are always delicious... Chicken Parmigiana.. Baked Ziti.. Aranacini... etc... the real deal! read more

Authentic Italian cuisine in Brewster. The brothers John and Paul do a great job. It's like eating and your nonna's house. Highly recommended. Marc read more

We were here for a communion party recently for a family member over the weekend. The restaurant is located in a large parking lot with other businesses and was easy to find. Our gathering was in the back room just behind the pizzeria area. You can enter the establishment on either the pizzeria or restaurant side to get there. The back area is a decent size to accommodate a small party. The party had passed around apps, a pasta course, a choice for your main and desserts. Overall the food was very delicious. I thought the flavors were very good and balanced. The meatballs and eggplant rollatini were my favs of the appetizers. The vodka sauce used on the penne pasta was very creamy and coated the pasta well. The entree I had the chicken francese which was lightly coated and had a nice butter lemon sauce. Of course everyone loved the pastries. The cannolis were the best with a nice cannoli creme that was just at the right sweetness. Service was also very good and we all had a pleasant time with all the staff. read more

Good food. Just slow. Just be prepared when you order for takeout. They tell me one time and when I get there I always have to wait another 15-20 minutes. A pizza shouldn't take an hour. No apps or anything else. Good and slow read more

A hidden gem in a strip mall. Can't say enough about the food and the service. You have to try the Asian Calamari!!!!! We also ordered the broccoli rabe with sausage & beans delicious and the broccoli rabe was not bitter. For dinner the short ribs with gnocchi were outstanding as well as the pork chop with hot peppers. We have been here many times and have never been disappointed. The wait staff was friendly and attentive and so were the owners John & Paul. See you again soon. read more

I've been coming to Aversano's for years and I love that it is family run and how the staff always checks-in to make sure we're happy throughout our meal. You just feel taken care of. As to the eats, they have a great menu overall but my favs - the buffalo mozzarella is melt in your mouth, the penne ala vodka has the perfect sauce and the arugula prosciutto pizza is so unique and flavorful but still somehow feels light even though it's pizza. Truly, Aversano's never disappoints - always a great time had by all thanks to the delicious food, the attentive & friendly service, tasty drinks, and fun atmosphere. read more

Consistently excellent Italian food. I have been here several times with family and Aversano's has never disappointed. For an appetizer I would recommend the broccoli rabe, white bean & sweet sausage dish. The flavors are bold & fantastic. For an entree the chicken alla vodka over penne, the chicken francese or if they have the zuppa di pesce as a special, are all unbelievably delicious. And the after dinner Moscato is a nice sweet drink to finish off your meal. John & Paul do it right every time. read more

Been eating here for countless years now, the absolute best pizza in the world. The buffalo chicken pizza can not be topped, and I will drive an an endless amount of miles to get a pizza from here. Owners are the nicest people you will ever meet and the food is ALWAYS on point. Place is clean and has a great atmosphere. Nothing around can compare to Aversano's. read more

Aversano's - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Good food and service. Been going there for years. Have had and gone to several parties there. Have also used them for catering. Owners are very nice as well. read more

First time in Aversano's. Food was excellent. Our waitress Nina was efficient and courteous. She knew the menu inside and out. The entire staff was wonderful. read more

Was taking our COVID drive and came across this Resturant. Service and food was really good.

The waiter forgot to place some of our order with the kitchen. It took 30 minutes for a round of drinks for which we were charged twice. The chicken scarpiello was absolutely awful. The spaghetti and meatballs was also awful and the sauce tasted like Ragu. Even with all the issues a manager never came to the table. We will not be dining here again. read more

If an Italian family gives this place 5 stars you KNOW it has to be good!! From the appetizers to dessert EVERYTHING was amazing! The service .... WOW! From the moment we got there to the moment we left we wanted for nothing. Definitely a place that deserves 5 stars! Buon Appetito! read more

Best Italian food. Aversanos never disappoints. From pizza to pasta & so much more. Great staff, Owners kind and personable. Highly recommend!! read more

Good pizza but kinda disorganized at lunch time Kind of small in the front area No restroom sign Prices are reasonable read more

I liked that there was a few original slices on the menu and it was nice that there were also a few different calzones to pick from. There is seating in the front when you pick up your pizza, but there is also dining in the back and there is a bar. The pizza slices were huge for $3.50 that you paid and definitely filled you up. I had a slice with Tomato, Chicken, and bacon and my friend had a slice of white pizza with spinach and chicken. Service was speedy and you can watch TV. while you eat. I was even surprised that it was so full at 2pm because usually the lunch rush would be over. Must be more proof that this is a place to try. read more

Aversano's - Aversano's - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Good food and good service, this place is never a disappointment. I've ordered a variety of entrees and tried their pizza including their rolls. This place is always my go-to when I'm passing through . read more

My husband goes nuts over Aversano's. I just ate pizza from here for the first time the other night and it is pretty good, I cannot deny. I wish they offered specialty pizzas though because I love Buffalo chicken pizza! Otherwise, I appreciated how crispy the pizza was and would certainly recommend. read more

This stretch of 684 is a complete mystery to me, I trusted GPS to locate a place for a quick bite, Aversano's it was. Dead empty on my lunch visit, good authentic Italian food, and good fast service. read more

Aversano's - Pizza Near Me - Brewster, New York

Our dinner was excellent, particularly my white truffle sauce. Calamari and fried mozzarella appetizers were very nice. Pasta was freshly made and we enjoyed the shrimp ravioli as well. Decor was pleasant and totally unexpected for a restaurant in a strip mall. The chef visited tables which gave us the opportunity to pass on our appreciation. read more

We feel so fortunate to live near this great Italian restaurant! Every dish is oversized and tastes just like eating in an Italian home (I'm not Italian but have eaten in Italian homes!). Had an early dinner New Year's Eve, pleased to find it was the regular menu with holiday specials rather than a special menu which many restaurants do. The chef/owner spoke to everyone in the dining room, a welcoming touch. My husband and son both went for Nonna's meatballs (a favorite), we shared the calamari, had salads, entrees and even though we were so full, all ordered dessert (Chef made ricotta cheesecake, had to have it Yum!). Worth feeling stuffed! I commented how lucky we are to live in an area where you still find family owned restaurants. This is a great one! read more

Authentic Italian cuisine! Best pizza in the area. Try the eggplant rollatini, you won't be disappointed!

Best place !!! Owners are great. Food & prices excellent! Definitely try Aversanos. Never disappointed!

Three of us had a nice peaceful dinner at this restaurant. Valerie our waitress was extremely professional & polite. Her suggestions when asked were excellent. The food as always was delicious. We will be back for sure and will request Valerie! She knew every special by memory and there were 5 app specials, 2 salad specials, 6 entree specials and a couple dessert specials. read more

Good pizza. Their Italian food is really good. Had 2 wedding showers there. Portions were good.

Excellent food, nice service, LOUD, esp on a Sat NIght. NOT a place to go for a date or celebrate an intimate dinner with anyone unless you enjoy SCREAMING at each other (and that is normal for you two) ! You can always go to a RAVE and celebrate there instead of this Rest.--(the rave is probably a lower tone) read more

Food and service always good. Make sure to try the chicken franciase. Their lunch menu is great too and not just pizza which is also very good. Great staff also. Celebrated my wife's birthday there with family and friends and they still talk about the good food and service. Thanks Paul, John and staff. read more

I've gotten takeout pizza several times but last night we decided to try the sit down restaurant, great decision. I expected the food to be great as it was but it was enhanced by the excellent service we received. Jonathan out server was the best, it was like he was reading my mind, the entire staff were so efficient, professional, polite and really nice. We are looking forward to returning read more

Had such a disappointing situation recently. My husband and I were at one of the small tables in the bar. We ordered food to go, and each ordered an appetizer and a glass of wine while we waited... the tables are very tiny, and between the plates, wine, water, condiments... well, quite a crowed situation. I reached for the salt, knocking my wine glass over, and of course, the 'dominos effect' My glass knocked over my husband's, and both of our plates were full of wine and you can picture the rest. The waitress came over with towels to help us clean up. We ordered another glass of wine, and waited for our to-go order. They did not even offer to replenish the wine or the appetizers. Our bill was over $60 , I think they could have been a bit more accommodating... We will never go bac! read more

The food here is fantastic!!! Portions are huge!!!! Price is very low for all the food you are given!! The specialty pizzas are out of this world!! Both Paul and John go out of the way to make sure your meals are perfect!!! They also do fantastic catering as well! Enjoy the food and the service!! read more

I was employed in Putnam County for more than 30 years. Aversanos was always our pick for Christmas celebrations, birthdays with colleagues, & many business lunches. They never disappointed. My personal preference is chicken franchise & eggplant parm. Salads are excellent as well as shrimp dishes. Bread & dipping EVOO is also excellent. If you have room order a dessert. read more

Trying out some pizza places in the area, and usually start with the margherita as point of evaluation. This was the soggiest pizza I've ever had- due to the heavy use of very wet tomatoes. A good pizzeria should know very well how to avoid this on a fundamental pizza staple like the margherita. I hope they do better on the rest of the menu, but for pizza... i'll keep shopping around. read more

Food is terrible. Had to return 2 entrees for dinner selections. The broccoli rabe in the pasta with chicken sausage tasted like wood. All partially cooked stems and no flowery part of the plant. The chicken sausage was extremely sparse. The other dish was chicken scapariello The dish was terrible. All you could taste was LEMON. Sorry I didn't go to McDonald's Save your money. Very over rated read more